Impartial spectator
Adam Smith's concept of an internalized, imagined observer whose disinterested judgment we use to evaluate our own conduct as a moral reference point.
As defined in et_1053
Other definitions
Smith's construct of an internalized, disinterested observer who has a sense of the whole situation and whose imagined approval or disapproval guides our moral judgments; in Part I it appears first merely as a person who happens to be impartial, with the full construct developed in Part III.
Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009
Where it comes up · 26
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V10 claims
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 4--A Discussion of Part III 04/29/20098 claims
- Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem7 claims
- Adam Smith's Warning About Wealth, Fame, and Status (with Ross Levine)6 claims
- Russ Roberts and Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Can Change Your Life6 claims
- James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/20116 claims
- Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith4 claims
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/20094 claims
and 18 more
Most important claims · 10 of 77Search all claims for “Impartial spectator” →
- Adam Smith's idea that humans want to be 'loved and to be lovely' means being cognizant of and wanting to conform to the social rules around you so others will want to interact with you in the future; the desire to be lovely—to be seen as a person of propriety—acts as an internal brake on behavior even when one cannot be caught.Shampoo, Property Rights, and Civilization (with Anthony Gill)
- Drawing on Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments, the impartial spectator sitting in the background wags its finger when we violate social etiquette, which is why people tip even at a roadside diner they'll never revisit—they saw the server's face, recognized the mutual expectation, and feel obligated to live up to their side of the bargain.Anthony Gill on Tipping
- There are two easily confused desires: the love of praise, which seeks the opinions of others and is fleeting and hollow, and the love of praiseworthiness, which seeks inner integrity through the impartial spectator and is steady and deeply satisfying; much human dissatisfaction comes from pursuing the first while neglecting the second.Adam Smith's Warning About Wealth, Fame, and Status (with Ross Levine)
- Smith's impartial spectator operates on two levels: in some passages it is a literal disinterested bystander observing a bilateral interaction, but Smith elaborates this into an allegory of an internalized spectator—conscience—who is privy to all our personal knowledge and whose imagined assessment of our conduct shapes our sense of right and wrong, with the relationship between this internal spectator and a possible singular God left deliberately mysterious.Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 1--An Overview 4/6/2009
- Even when alone and unobserved, a person restrains themselves because they imagine an impartial spectator—a watcher who is not a friend, gives no benefit of the doubt, and judges the act plainly as wrong; for the religious this can be God, but for everyone it is at minimum oneself, and this internal judge is a stronger deterrent than adding more police to a city.Shampoo, Property Rights, and Civilization (with Anthony Gill)
- Smith's impartial spectator is like a conscience and functions as a practical heuristic: when deciding what to do, ask what a disinterested observer who knows everything about the situation would approve of — this term represents the culmination of a lifetime of inductive experiments in which we receive feedback and internalize a sense of propriety as the voice of an impartial spectator.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- Through Smith's system of propriety, humans internalize the reactions of others to such an extent that they act as if an impartial spectator (the 'man in the breast') were watching—doing the right thing not because someone is present but because they seek the approval of that internalized observer.Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable
- Adam Smith's idea of the impartial spectator can be deliberately constructed as an external vantage point that lets you see yourself more clearly and objectively and guide your own behavior, so you avoid doing things you would otherwise be ashamed of.Ryan Holiday on Ego is the Enemy
- Throughout history, the local impartial spectator has endorsed cruelty toward out-groups. A white planter in the 1840s South earned peers' respect by viewing African slaves as subhuman, and in 1930s Germany or Poland people viewed Jews similarly. The current egalitarian disrepute of 'othering' could change, and slavery falls nowhere near the familiarity principle.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- Attempting a crime is generally punished far less than completing it (premeditated attempted murder draws lesser punishment than murder), but treason is the exception: because the sovereign judges in his own case and indulges his own resentment rather than entering by sympathy into others' resentment, he punishes treason more violently and 'sanguinary' than the impartial spectator can approve, often before any attempt is even made.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/2009