Adam Smith's Warning About Wealth, Fame, and Status (with Ross Levine)
What this covers
Russ Roberts and Ross Levine examine Adam Smith's The Theory of Moral Sentiments as a work of psychology rather than economic theory, drawing out Smith's analysis of why humans work so hard and what actually satisfies them. The conversation centers on a distinction Smith makes between two desires easily confused as one: the love of praise, which chases the fleeting opinions of others, and the love of praiseworthiness, which seeks the steady approval of the impartial spectator—an internal moral voice that judges whether one's actions are genuinely worthy. Roberts and Levine argue this matters because modern economics typically models human behavior around consumption and self-interest divorced from social context, missing what Smith saw clearly: that the hunger for esteem, not for goods, drives most human striving. The question becomes where that hunger directs itself.
The discussion moves outward from personal ambition to social and political consequences. When a society admires wealth and power regardless of virtue, Levine argues, it corrupts moral sentiments and produces servility, fraud, and the undermining of justice—the bedrock that markets and freedom require. The conversation traces this corruption through contemporary examples: entertainers celebrated for fame rather than character, highly successful people grinding long after material needs are met, and the erosion of stories that once taught virtue. Roberts and Levine also examine imposter syndrome, childhood loyalty, and how self-help culture's focus on self-improvement can paradoxically breed unhappiness. Throughout, they treat Smith as a thinker whose insights into human nature—anticipating behavioral economics by centuries—remain vivid because the human heart has barely changed since 1759, even if chemistry has.
Roberts and Levine argue that Adam Smith's deepest insight in The Theory of Moral Sentiments is that humans are driven not by consumption but by a desire for esteem, and that the healthy life and the free society both depend on directing that desire toward being praiseworthy rather than merely praised.
- Smith holds that our motivation to work is largely the desire to be admired and approved of by others, contrary to standard economic models of consumption-based utility.
- True contentment comes from the internal 'impartial spectator' approving one's actions, not from external praise.
- When a society admires wealth and power for their own sake rather than virtue, it corrupts moral sentiments, breeds servility and fraud, and undermines justice and freedom.
Admiring the rich and powerful for reasons other than virtue distorts moral sentiments and enables fraud, coercion, and the erosion of free society.
- Admiring the wrong people is not a harmless social habit but threatens the foundation of a free society, because if a society admires wealth and power regardless of how they were achieved, people seeking admiration will engage in fraud, coercion, and monopoly-seeking, undermining the justice system on which freedom and the market depend.
“if what we do is we admire the wrong people or we admire the wrong activities--simply if we just admire wealth--then this can give rise to fraud and the seeking of various types of monopoly privileges and the undermining of the judicial system”
- Smith identified the admiration of the rich and powerful as the major source of the corruption of our moral sentiments—the chief way our sense of right and wrong is distorted.
“he calls this admiration of the rich and the powerful 'the major threat,'--the major source of the corruption of our moral sentiment”
- Smith does not claim the rich and powerful are unvirtuous because they are rich and powerful, but rather that they are not necessarily virtuous simply because they are rich and powerful, so admiring wealth and power rather than virtue is the error.
“he's not saying that the rich and the power are, because they are rich and powerful, unvirtuous. But, he's saying that they're not necessarily virtuous because they're rich and they're powerful”
- When people admire the rich and powerful for reasons other than virtue, they become deferential and servile toward those in power—failing to speak up when things are wrong—and negligent toward those near them, eroding both integrity and accountability.
“rather than calling out or speaking up when they view things as wrong, they will defer. And, that's part of this admiration of the rich and the powerful.”
Human motivation centers on gaining esteem and admiration from others, not merely on individual consumption as economics assumes.
- Smith argues the key motivation behind why we work so hard is to be seen, admired, praised, and held in esteem by others, which contrasts with standard economics modeling utility as based solely on what the individual consumes independent of social context.
“Smith argues that the key reason, the key motivation is that we work to be seen, we work to be admired, we work to be praised, we work to be held in esteem.”
- Smith's notion of virtue and praiseworthiness, governing how one deals with society as a whole, does not mean forgoing self-interest but does mean not being greedy.
“This did not mean forgoing self-interest, but it did mean not being greedy.”
- Smith effectively anticipated behavioral economics, observing human behavior in ways mainstream pre-behavioral economics ignored, and wrote a century or more before psychology became its own discipline.
“if you go to economics before the movement in Behavioral Economics, I mean, Smith would have looked at the profession like, 'What are you guys doing?'”
Chasing external esteem through wealth leaves people empty and regretful, while virtue and relationships deliver genuine contentment.
- Working hard to gain the admiration and esteem of others ultimately leads to emptiness and dissatisfaction rather than happiness or tranquility, because external approval is fleeting and hollow.
“he's concerned about that as a motivation because he ultimately views it as leading to an emptiness and a dissatisfaction”
- Smith's Parable of the Poor Man's Son depicts a young man who sacrifices family and self-care to chase wealth believing it will bring the esteem and tranquility he craves, only to reach old age full of regret because external esteem never delivered the contentment that virtue and good relationships would have.
“it's about this person who works his life and neglects his family and neglects caring for himself in many ways. And then, as old age hits, he realizes how much he has missed, how empty his life is”
- Even where national and international politics breed constant anger and admiration not based on virtue, the trust, mutual aid, and virtuous traits people show at small, local levels persist, offering hope that those traits could be reclaimed at larger scales.
“at very local levels, those types of traits, I think are still very much valued”
Smith's actual position is sophisticated and often caricatured; reading him carefully on his own terms reveals nuance missed by misinterpretation.
- Smith is frequently caricatured—such as in the film Wall Street's 'greed is good'—but he is emphatically not saying greed is good; his view is a sophisticated, nuanced one in which not all wealth and power are bad.
“it can be annoying when Smith gets caricatured--like in the movie Wall Street with Michael Douglas: greed is good. And it's, like, that guy is not saying greed is good.”
- Contrary to philosophers and economists who assume a sense of right and wrong simply emerges, Smith argues that even our moral sentiments are shaped from birth through social interactions with parents and community rather than arising independently.
“your sense of right and wrong is based on your social interactions. It doesn't just emerge.”
- Both Levine and his Marxist father initially read Smith looking only for what they wanted to find, and only by rereading without that bias—taking a deep breath and appreciating him on his own terms—could Levine avoid caricaturing Smith, ending with the whole book highlighted.
“I felt that he had read Smith simply trying to find in Smith what he wanted to read. And then I realized that I had read Smith simply wanting to find in Smith what I wanted to read.”