Questions

Should we abolish nuclear weapons?

Confidence · 50%
What moved

Nothing new since your last review.

Compiled positions
  • Nuclear disarmament through diplomatic communication is the only viable path to survival, because defense systems cannot reliably stop ICBMs, deterrence depends on rational actors, and reframing adversaries as negotiating partners—not enemies to be killed—is the sole psychological escape from annihilation.

    28 arguments
    • The U.S. government comprises many distinct agencies including 17 or 18 intelligence services, of which the CIA is only one and some like the NRO are extraordinarily classified.
    • Systems like Iron Dome, THAAD, and Aegis can intercept short- and medium-range missiles but cannot intercept intercontinental ballistic missiles traveling 500 miles above Earth; conflating the two is incorrect science.
    • Disarmament makes everyone safer by drastically reducing the chance that a dangerous six-minute nuclear launch-decision scenario will ever occur.
    +25 more
  • Human distinctiveness lies in the capacity for large-scale cooperation around shared ideas, which enables civilization-building but can equally be turned toward destruction.

    1 argument
    • Humans' ability to cooperate at mass scale around shared ideas distinguishes them from chimps and enables construction of complex societies like the Roman Empire and protective legal systems, though this same capacity can be weaponized destructively.
  • Creating superintelligent AI is strategically unwinnable because control is theoretically impossible, safety cannot match capability growth, and the resulting risks span extinction, suffering, and permanent loss of human agency.

    15 arguments
    • AGI control is theoretically impossible due to self-modification, containment escape, and the impossibility of maintaining zero bugs across centuries.
    • Safety research cannot outpace capabilities because safety remains an infinite problem generating new unsolvable challenges with each solution.
    • Superintelligent systems pose three distinct existential harms: death, extreme suffering at scale, and permanent loss of meaning that make creation strategically unwinnable.
    +12 more
  • Major economic restructuring happens through crisis rather than foresight, and the US debt burden will eventually force painful adjustments despite the nation's substantial underlying wealth.

    3 arguments
    • Economic restructuring occurs through crisis-driven necessity rather than coordinated advance planning.
    • US spending beyond its means will eventually create serious economic problems requiring tax increases and reduced consumption.
    • The US possesses vast wealth but cannot liquidate it quickly to resolve debt because assets are actively in productive use.
Open bet
No state conducts an explosive nuclear test before 2029closes 8/14/2026
Open the full question →
20 open · 3 settledacts this session · 00 disputes unreviewedpipeline • synced