Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
What this covers
Vernon Smith and Jim Otteson sit down with Russ Roberts to examine Adam Smith's two major works as a unified intellectual project rather than contradictory texts. The conversation, recorded live at Ball State University, centers on how Smith applied Isaac Newton's method of discovering hidden rules to explain human behavior—beginning with moral development in The Theory of Moral Sentiments and extending to economic coordination in The Wealth of Nations. Both speakers contest the longstanding Adam Smith Problem, the 19th-century claim that Smith's emphasis on sympathy contradicts his celebration of self-interest, arguing instead that readers who know both books see them as complementary accounts of how order emerges without central design.
The discussion moves across several distinct territories. It examines how the impartial spectator—Smith's term for an internalized conscience—functions as a practical heuristic for moral judgment, and how Mutual Sympathy of Sentiments creates a feedback mechanism that holds people in social community. The speakers explore Smith's view that wealth serves as a tool to lift people from desperate poverty so they can pursue higher flourishing, not as an end in itself, alongside Smith's underappreciated warnings about businessmen's conspiracies and the mental effects of repetitive labor. A genuine tension surfaces: the moral skepticism toward wealth-seeking in The Theory of Moral Sentiments sits uneasily alongside the largely non-moral account of markets in The Wealth of Nations. Finally, the group considers how Smith's framework applies to contemporary concerns about labor conditions and public skepticism of markets, and whether the Extended Order of Exchange that connects strangers across continents depends more on rule-based systems than on trust.
Smith's two books are not in conflict but are unified attempts to apply a Newtonian, empirical method to human social institutions: The Theory of Moral Sentiments explains how shared moral rules emerge from social feedback, and The Wealth of Nations extends that same emergent-order logic to material betterment, with wealth understood as a tool rather than an end.
- Smith applied Newton's method of explaining observations via hidden rules to human sociability and moral development
- Moral rules and market rules both emerge spontaneously from individual approval/disapproval and exchange, not central design
- Wealth in Smith is a means to lift people out of desperate poverty so they can pursue higher human flourishing, not an end in itself
Human moral propriety and social order emerge naturally from inherent drives for mutual sympathy and impartial judgment through ongoing developmental feedback.
- Smith identifies a fact of human nature he calls the desire for mutual sympathy of sentiments — we like to see our own sentiments echoed in others, which gives pleasure and feedback that reinforces behavior and acts as a centripetal force holding people in social community, whereas discovering others don't share our sentiments is unpleasant and corrective.
“We all desire what he calls mutual sympathy of sentiments. What that means is we all like to see our own sentiments echoed in other people”
- Smith's impartial spectator is like a conscience and functions as a practical heuristic: when deciding what to do, ask what a disinterested observer who knows everything about the situation would approve of — this term represents the culmination of a lifetime of inductive experiments in which we receive feedback and internalize a sense of propriety as the voice of an impartial spectator.
“ask yourself what a disinterested observer of your conduct who knows everything about the situation--what would that person think? Would that person approve or not?”
- Smith treated morality as an empirical, developmental process: infants have no sense of moral propriety and simply demand what they want, but over their lives they become moral adults with sophisticated morality — and the puzzle that intrigued Smith was explaining how this maturation actually happens.
“an infant has no sense of moral propriety. They just scream out and demand whatever they want. But at some point over the course of their lives they become moral adults”
- The two books are not in conflict but deeply connected: in The Theory of Moral Sentiments Smith developed a marketplace-like model in which people exchange judgments and sentiments to give rise to rules of propriety, and with few modifications this same model transfers to the larger-scale market economy where rules of property and exchange procedures also emerge unintended from the exchanges themselves.
“this model, which is something like a marketplace model where people exchange their judgments and sentiments with one another...with not too many modifications this can be transferred to this much larger scale model of...a market economy”
Smith's economic theory was fundamentally driven by moral concern for alleviating desperate poverty and human suffering.
- The Wealth of Nations was driven by a moral concern, not mere empirical curiosity: Smith saw desperate poverty in the Scottish highlands where mothers had to decide which child would eat and clans turned out elderly members they could not sustain, so figuring out the institutions that lift people out of such poverty was, for Smith, job number one — and only after passing those thresholds can people turn to questions of justice and a flourishing life.
“mothers, he says, often find themselves in the horrifying position of trying to decide which of my children will get to eat today. Because they can't all eat”
- If alive today, Smith would almost undoubtedly say there have been qualitative improvements in human life over the last two centuries, even though he held a particular view of happiness in The Theory of Moral Sentiments under which material acquisition like an iPhone does not necessarily produce true happiness.
“I think he would almost undoubtedly say that there have been qualitative improvements”
Wealth functions as a necessary tool enabling people to rise above survival to pursue higher things, but mistaking it for life's ultimate end produces pathology.
- Treating wealth as an end in itself rather than a tool leads to pathologies and difficulties in life; for Smith wealth is a powerful tool that lets humans raise their attention above pressing material survival needs to higher things, but mistaking wealth for the ultimate thing that matters is a separate kind of mistake worth reminding ourselves and our children to avoid.
“If people make the mistake...of thinking of wealth as being an end in itself, well that can lead to various kinds of pathologies and difficulties in people's lives”
- Smith was not entirely silent about wealth's downsides in the Wealth of Nations: he warned that businessmen conspire against the public to fix prices and seek subsidies, and in Book V he feared that increasingly specialized workers doing the same repetitive tasks could suffer deleterious effects on their minds.
“you can't get a few businessmen together over drinks before immediately the conversation turns to conspiring against the public. They want to fix prices and get special subsidies”
- For Smith, self-interest is broader than selfishness because the flourishing of one's family, friends, and country counts as part of one's own interests, so actions serving those people are simultaneously self-interested and serving others.
“he seems to think that my interests, what's in my interest, includes the interest of people I love and care about”
Smith's analytical imprecision and focus on dynamic human unpredictability established sociology as the study of emergent social institutions.
- The imprecision of Smith's analysis is a strength, because Smith saw that human beings are unpredictable — possibly reflecting his religious view of free will — so that human societies are dynamic and go in directions that cannot be predicted, which means the science of sociology must recognize that human beings are not exactly like inanimate objects.
“it's impossible to predict what kinds of clothing people will be wearing in 20 years. No matter how much you know about the facts today”
- Adam Smith should be classified as the founder of sociology, or the study of human social institutions, as a discipline.
“I would classify him as the founder of sociology as a discipline, or the study of human social institutions as a discipline”
- Smith was unhappy with his studies at Oxford because he believed the professors, having tenure and an endowment, were lazy and did not do their jobs.
“he thought that his professors at Oxford, because they had tenure and they had an endowment...he thought that that made them all lazy and they didn't actually do their job”
- Modern authors quote their own earlier books in every new work they write.
“Every book I write I quote the other books that I already wrote. Just in case.”