state of nature
In Locke's theory, the hypothetical condition of human beings prior to or apart from political society, used to reason about natural freedom, equality, and the basis of legitimate government.
As defined in Peter Berkowitz on Locke, Liberty, and Liberalism
Other definitions
Hobbes's hypothetical pre-political condition in which humans live without government, used to justify the creation of the state through social contract.
Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Ada Palmer – Machiavelli is the most misunderstood thinker of all time
Where it comes up · 11
- Kant's Moral Philosophy3 claims
- Peter Berkowitz on Locke, Liberty, and Liberalism2 claims
- Richard Gunderman on Greed, Adam Smith, and Leo Tolstoy2 claims
- Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Defoe, Robinson Crusoe1 claim
- America At 2501 claim
- Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield1 claim
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Ada Palmer – Machiavelli is the most misunderstood thinker of all time1 claim
- Michael Lind on Libertarianism1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “state of nature” →
- After Hobbes's Leviathan, Western philosophy spent about forty years refuting Hobbes, and critics turned to Machiavelli, whose utilitarian and consequentialist analysis of politics without divine foundation Hobbes seemed to echo, making Machiavelli useful as the 'daddy monster' to attack.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Ada Palmer – Machiavelli is the most misunderstood thinker of all time
- Unlike Confucius, who treated the Western Zhou culture as a perfect, possibly heaven-revealed system, Xunzi was a fallibilist who held that humans invented the Confucian way over time through a series of cultural geniuses, for functional purposes — to restrain limitless human desires against limited resources (a Hobbesian state of nature) — leaving openness for new sage-kings to innovate as conditions change.160 | Edward Slingerland on Confucianism, Daoism, and Wu Wei
- Moral agency and moral personhood adhere not just to individual persons but also to nations as collective rational agents, obligating all nations to eliminate the state of nature between them by creating international law, just as individuals must create civil law.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- Autonomy (from Greek autonomous, 'making laws for oneself') is freedom conceived as regulated freedom under rational law, not as arbitrary liberty; freedom is the activity of creating a moral law that one obeys.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- The state of nature can be understood metaphorically as the state of pure heteronomy, pure animality, and pure passion before human beings discover their potential for rational, free, autonomous behavior.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- The Continental Congress descended from earlier diplomatic congresses like the 1754 Albany Congress and 1765 Stamp Act Congress, but it took on governing responsibility gradually out of necessity, because the colonies never entered a state of nature and existing governmental bodies continued.America At 250
- Locke marks a seminal moment because, while not the first to discuss limited government or consent, he gave classical expression to a new way of thinking about politics: that the most important fact about human beings is that they are by nature free and equal, and that a legitimate political society must respect this freedom and equality—a basis distinct from the Bible's grounding of equality in being created in God's image, and from Greek thought's focus on virtue and human excellence.Peter Berkowitz on Locke, Liberty, and Liberalism
- Hume rejects natural law ethics and Locke's claim that property rights exist prior to civil society, arguing that the idea of a state of nature is a myth and fiction that is both historically false and logically incoherent, because property rights are necessarily products of organized society rather than natural facts.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- The environments where honor-based norms function—prison, gang, war, extreme scarcity with no social safety net or Leviathan to restore order—are akin to a state of nature or moral emergency; the further society gets from such conditions, the more it discovers the wisdom of outsourcing the use of force and coercion to a third party.126 - In Defense Of Honor
- In the 18th century context of Enlightenment thought, the concept of the 'natural man' in the 'state of nature' (drawn from Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau) is crucial—Crusoe embodies natural man forced to manipulate nature to satisfy his needs after being stripped of all social supportGreat Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Defoe, Robinson Crusoe