
Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Defoe, Robinson Crusoe
What this covers
This is a single-lecturer survey of Daniel Defoe's 1719 novel, delivered by Michael Sugrue. It reads the book as a document of its moment: an England growing rich through commercial capitalism, where new wealth raised new questions about how people relate to one another and to nature. The lecturer argues Crusoe is a new kind of hero, neither Homeric warrior nor medieval saint, defined by prudence, diligence and practical acquisitive habits. He also defends the book against the charge that it is only an adolescent adventure story, and notes that Jean-Jacques Rousseau made it the one book recommended in Emile.
The range is wide. The economic reading draws on Karl Marx, who disliked the book, and on the Labor Theory of Value, which the lecturer sees in Crusoe's ledger of time spent on each task. He also finds the cycle of money, commodity and more money in Crusoe's trading voyages. The political reading sets Crusoe as Natural Man / State of Nature against Thomas Hobbes and John Locke, both of whom defended enslaving captives. It takes the absence of women as a sign that the atomized individual has replaced the family as the basic social unit, a claim Aristotle would have rejected.
The most contentious material concerns race and empire. Crusoe sells the boy Xury into slavery while softening it to himself as ten years of indenture. Friday, who kneels and declares himself Crusoe's slave, is set against the cannibals who must be killed, a division the lecturer says justifies colonial domination. Charles Dickens is cited on how coldly Friday's death is handled in the sequel. The theological strand is also notable: providence arrives through sprouting barley and rice, Friday asks a question about the devil that Crusoe cannot answer, and the lecturer presents the book as an uneasy union of Athens and Jerusalem, reason and faith.
Robinson Crusoe is the first great English novel and a literary epitome of Enlightenment thought, depicting how Western culture came to dominate nature and other societies through the character of Crusoe, whose isolation on an island recapitulates the entire history of Western cultural development.
- Crusoe's technological and cultural progression on the island mirrors ontogeny recapitulating phylogeny—he moves from natural man through hunting, agriculture, domestication, and rational exploitation of resources
- The character embodies the fundamental Enlightenment project: domination of nature through reason and science, combined with a materialistic, practical theology that rewards diligence and productivity
- Crusoe's relationship to savages and other peoples—distinguishing between 'good savages' (those who accept enslavement) and 'bad savages' (cannibals to be killed)—encapsulates the justification for Western colonialism and imperialism
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The two fundamental themes of the Enlightenment (roughly 1600-1800) are: (1) the domination of nature through Newtonian mechanics and modern natural science, and (2) the relationship with non-Western cultures, particularly the problem of how Western man should think about 'savages' and peoples with different worldviews
“there are at least two fundamental themes to the enlightenment to the age of reason which happens roughly speaking between 1600 and 1800 in western culture the first of the main themes of the enlightenment is the domination of nature newtonian mechanics the development of modern natural science”
England in 1719 (when Robinson Crusoe was published) was becoming extremely wealthy through commercial capitalism, and this wealth was changing social relations and raising new questions about how humans should relate to each other, to nature, and think about their condition
“he was published in 1719 and at that time english commercial capitalism was perhaps the most important economic force in the world england was becoming extremely wealthy this wealth had the quality of changing social relations changing society and in particular it raised new questions about how human beings are going to relate to each other how they're going to relate to nature”
Crusoe is enslaved by Muslim pirates and forced to work, but then cleverly escapes by taking a slave named Xury with him; he later sells Xury into slavery but experiences some qualms about this, telling himself it's just indentureship for 10 years, showing his capacity for self-deception and instrumental rationalization of slavery
“they enslave him naturally enough that being what pirates do...well after doing that he happens to have a slave boy in the boat with him and his name is zuri and he says hey zuri you know we're out of here i mean here we are they let us out and we're going into deep water we're gone”
Robinson Crusoe represents a new kind of hero for a new historical moment—the Enlightenment man—distinct from the Homeric hero of ancient Greece or the otherworldly medieval saint, embodying instead the virtues of productivity, prudence, diligence, and practical acquisitiveness
“i'd like to say that robinson crusoe represents the enlightenment man and i would use the term man specifically it's meant to sp to refer directly to males and i'll try and explain why it's specifically enlightenment man that's talked about here”
Karl Marx hated Robinson Crusoe because it so thoroughly epitomizes English commercial capitalism—its unrelenting acquisitiveness, its materialism disguised as piety, and its purely economic view of human motivation—making it a devastating portrait of bourgeois man
“one of the reasons why karl marx hated this book so much is that it is such an english book particularly it epitomizes english society at the time of commercial capitalism robinson crusoe is unrelentingly acquisitive”
Rousseau, writing in the 18th century, believed Robinson Crusoe was one of the very few great works of Western literature that does not corrupt youth, and he made it the only book recommended for the education of a young man in his work Emile
“rousseau thought i mean i don't know if any of you know rousseau's novel the emil well in the emile he is writing about the topic of education and how it is possible to educate a young man in such a way that society doesn't corrupt him and above all it's very important that we keep him away from books except one book robinson crusoe”
Friday's death in the sequel is treated with shocking coldness by Defoe—occupying only about a paragraph where Friday gets sick and dies—which Charles Dickens contrasted with his own approach, saying if he had written it, the passage would be ten times longer and would move readers to tears
“charles dickens the english novelist uh was appalled by this novel...dickens read this novel and he said...about that death of friday in book two it occupies about a paragraph friday gets sick and then it dies let's move on let's go make some more money”
In the 18th century context of Enlightenment thought, the concept of the 'natural man' in the 'state of nature' (drawn from Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau) is crucial—Crusoe embodies natural man forced to manipulate nature to satisfy his needs after being stripped of all social support
“think of that as being natural man which is perhaps the most important concept in the political theory of the enlightenment natural man thrust into the state of nature forced to manipulate nature in order to satisfy his needs that's exactly characteristic of robinson crusoe”
Crusoe rescues Friday from cannibals and kills those pursuing him; Friday immediately kneels and worships Crusoe, declaring himself Crusoe's eternal slave, exemplifying the 'good savage' who voluntarily desires to be enslaved and subordinated because of gratitude for rescue.
“he rescues friday friday runs away people pursue him and he kills him and manages to spirit friday away and of course what does friday do gets down on his knees worships him says i'll forever be your slave he's a good savage a good savior somebody immediately says well you're the best thing in the world”
Robinson Crusoe is sometimes denigrated as an insubstantial adventure story suitable only for adolescence, but this dismissal misses its profound literary and intellectual substance as an epitome of the Enlightenment project
“robinson crusoe is a novel which is sometimes nowadays denigrated as uh being rather insubstantial it's sometimes treated as a rather plural adventure story suitable for adolescence perhaps but not having much in the way of literary substance and i'd like to try and argue against that proposition today”
John Locke and Thomas Hobbes both defended slavery, arguing that people captured in war can legitimately be enslaved as an alternative to execution—a view that reflects and justifies Enlightenment practice of enslaving conquered peoples
“those of you who know john locke's second discourse on government about i don't know 17 1690 or so he makes a defense of slavery said look slaves taken in war as an alternative to killing them immediately can legitimate people taking what can legitimately be enslaved...say it's a kind of hobby in relationship uh hobbs likes the idea of slavery too that you give to captains in war”
Robinson Crusoe embodies the labor theory of value—the Enlightenment idea (developed by Locke) that the amount of labor invested in an activity determines its worth—by keeping a detailed ledger of how much time each of his activities takes, quantifying his work as economic value
“robinson crusoe is because he doesn't want him he doesn't want to squander anything or waste any of his uh of his effort and his activity he keeps a ledger now since you can't have an economy with just one person you can't buy and sell from yourself he keeps a ledger of what he does and how long how much time it takes to do it in other words the amount of labor that goes into a given activity is what the activity is worth that's what the labor theory of value is”
Crusoe's trading expeditions to the African coast involve exchanging European trinkets and beads for gold dust and slaves from 'ignorant savages,' exemplifying acquisitive economic exploitation and his role as an early commercial capitalist
“so he goes out and makes several trips to africa makes a ton of money makes a great deal of money...he decides that he's going to trade on the coast of africa why because he wants to accumulate things he'd like to take advantage of the ignorant savages and give them trinkets and you know go beads and things like that and get back gold dust”
Robinson Crusoe's progression on the island recapitulates the entire technological and cultural development of Western civilization, moving from natural man through hunting and gathering, to agriculture, domestication of animals, and rational exploitation of resources—a process that mirrors the biological principle that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny
“if you think about what robinson crusoe does in the uh when he's on the island what you'll find is that he goes through all the stages of technological and cultural development and he does it as an individual rather than as a society”
Robinson Crusoe distinguishes between two types of savages: the 'good savage' who wants to become enslaved and accept Western civilization and Christianity, and the 'bad savage' who is a cannibal and must be killed—a dichotomy that encapsulates and justifies Western genocide, slavery, colonial oppression, and imperialism
“there's us and there's the savages but fortunately for us there are two different kinds of savage there's savage number one who's in this case named friday and savage number one is the good savage capital g capital s and the good savage is the kind of savage that wants to become your butler in other words a good savage is somebody that wants to be economically exploited wants to learn christianity and wants to follow you around”
Robinson Crusoe marries together two foundational intellectual traditions of Western culture—the tradition from Athens (reason, empiricism, rationality) and the tradition from Jerusalem (religious faith, ethics, divine providence)—in an uneasy alliance that is central to the novel's philosophical significance.
“robinson crusoe not only exemplifies and epitomizes enlightenment man you might want to say that he brings together and marries two intellectual traditions which are foundational to western culture the tradition that comes out of athens and the traditions which comes out of jerusalem and these two traditions are married together in a rather uneasy alliance”
Women are absent or superfluous in Robinson Crusoe because Defoe is arguing that the minimal unit of society is no longer the family (as Aristotle had claimed) but rather the atomized individual—a specifically Enlightenment idea that contrasts with ancient and medieval political theory
“the reason why there are no women in this novel is because he's trying to suggest the minimal unit of society is the atomized individual that's why women are more or less superfluous you don't have to reproduce you by yourself are sufficient to be a whole society whereas anyone in the ancient and medieval political tradition would not have accepted that idea that is a particular an idea characteristic of the enlightenment”
Robinson Crusoe follows the economic logic of Marx's formula MCM (money → commodity → more money), constantly accumulating wealth through repeated cycles of trade in order to produce capital rather than to achieve any final material satisfaction.
“he is caught up with the idea uh if you know karl marx's book capital mcm he starts out with money he turns it into a commodity sells the commodity and then he has more money well he keeps on doing that he lives in order to produce money to accumulate wealth”
God reveals himself in Robinson Crusoe not through visions of Jesus on the cross or information from angels, but through the sprouting of barley and rice, demonstrating a thoroughly materialistic interpretation of divine providence characteristic of commercial capitalism.
“when god reveals himself you don't get a vision of jesus on the cross you don't get a direct direct information from angels when god reveals himself to robinson crusoe he does so in the form of barley rice is the way god reveals himself in this novel”
The image of Crusoe's wrecked ship—grounded on a reef and never to sail again—is suggestive of how modern culture relates to biblical religion: unable to revive it, but still able to strip away valuable things that have accumulated over centuries and represent the wisdom of the Western tradition
“it's often seemed to me that the image of crusoe's wrecked ship tells us or at least hints to us certain things about our relationship to biblical religion...we live now in an age in which we some respects have been cast amidst a desolate nature in which it's harder and harder for biblical religion to be taken seriously by the professoria or the kind of the intellectuals of our culture and yet we relate to this tradition of biblical religion in some respects the way crusoe related to the hulk of his ship even though the ship is grounded on a reef and will never sail again there are many things of enormous value here that might well be stripped off before we let it go”
Crusoe occasionally has 'fearful dreams' but generally does not experience the emotional despair or loneliness that might be expected from someone spending 20+ years alone on an island
“he doesn't have much in the way of ecstatic visions he occasionally has the fearful dream but he lives in a very natural world and he is a very practical man”
Friday's question about why God, being all-powerful, doesn't kill the devil is a legitimate theological problem that Crusoe cannot answer; Crusoe evasively refuses to engage with the question and tells Friday to trust him, revealing the limitations of Crusoe's theology
“friday is having christianity explain to him and he says in his usual kind of garbled version of english so uh since god is all-powerful and the devil is really bad how come god just doesn't kill him why hasn't he killed him a long time ago and crusoe first asked first is puzzled and doesn't want to seem puzzled because he's european so he acts like he doesn't hear it right which is kind of evasive unpleasant response and so friday repeats the question”
Crusoe demonstrates extreme prudence and conservation, rationing his powder and liquor over 28 years at rates that suggest he would preserve most supplies until rescue; this reflects the mentality of rational economic calculation where maximizing present resources for future contingencies becomes the organizing principle of life.
“he's constantly being prudent and wondering wow i only have 20 years worth of powder here i want to make sure that i conserve it i only have about 40 gallons of liquor i want to make sure that i only have a half an ounce every year in other words if i were there i would certainly pour myself a stiff drink and have to think the problem over when he is rescued 28 years later most of the booze is still there why because he's a good prudent diligent kind of a guy”
God is the most important character in Robinson Crusoe despite never appearing or speaking, functioning as 'the strong silent type' who is always present and running the world in providential ways, with Crusoe's relationship to God evolving to become something like Job's faithful servant.
“the most important character in this novel is god i know that may sound very strange since he never appears and never says anything but it turns out that from the perspective of defoe god is the strong silent type in other words god is always present and he is always running the world in his providential way”
Crusoe's theodicy—his attempt to justify God's existence and action given the existence of evil—is resolved through a utilitarian cost-benefit calculation using double-entry bookkeeping, where he lists the evils that have befallen him and the goods God has granted him and mathematically determines that God is 'in the black'
“crusoe's idea of theodicy involves double entry bookkeeping...he actually makes up a list he says here's the good things about being here and here's the bad things let's see how god comes out point number one evil i'm cast upon a horrible desolate island void of all hope of recovery on the other hand good but i am alive and not drowned as all my ship's company was”
Robinson Crusoe goes to sea against his father's advice, which he later calls his 'original sin,' and God providentially sends a storm to warn him—establishing the novel's allegorical structure where Crusoe's disobedience recapitulates the Fall of Man
“dad says stay home son stay home live the middling sort of life...best thing you can do is stay home here i'll give you a comfortable existence and we're here in the garden of eden unless i'm mistaken which turns out to be england...so there we get the fall of man and he later on the novel says that was my original fall that was my original sin”
Robinson Crusoe himself is an extraordinarily unemotional and cold figure—perhaps the least emotional character central to any novel in the Western literary tradition—characterized by a purely instrumental relationship to other human beings and an unrelenting acquisitiveness rooted in economic rationality
“crusoe is a very unattractive person...he seems to have almost nothing in the way of personality in the first place he is a good instantiation of what the economists like adam smith later on in the century would call homo economicus he lives in order to consume stuff and he lives in order to acquire things”
Robinson Crusoe settles in Brazil and becomes a plantation owner, accumulating enormous wealth through diligent labor; he shows no moral concern about slavery or its cruelty, only regret that he doesn't have enough enslaved labor to maximize productivity and profit.
“he starts a plantation and because he's a diligent hard-working prudent kind of a guy he makes a ton of money... he has some qualms and he says you know i really wish that i hadn't sold zuri not as you might guess because it's a cruel thing to sell someone into slavery that you don't even own but rather you know i could do i get a lot more work done here and i could make a tremendous amount more money if i had somebody that would be willing to work for that would be coerced to work for me”
Crusoe encounters a naked footprint on the sand which terrifies him because he assumes all savages are bad cannibals who will kill him, so he hides and banks his fires, but eventually makes contact with savages who have captives they plan to eat
“he encounters the other capital o and in the form of a very famous passage where he finds a naked footprint right on the say now it turns out not to be friday's footprint it's just some anonymous savage but for now i mean the safe thing to assume is that all savages are bad savages and of course you know what that means they have to be killed or they'll kill you they'll eat you”
Crusoe teaches Friday Christianity and makes him a Protestant Christian; the novel suggests that on Crusoe's island, there will be toleration of all Christian religions, though Friday's father (a pagan cannibal) remains an implicit outsider
“since friday by now is not only a christian but a protestant christian crusoe decides that his society is going to have toleration of all christian religion of all religions not just all christian religions because friday's dad is naturally a pagan and a savage and believes in idols and all that sort of business”
When Crusoe returns to England after 28 years, all his property has grown enormously through compound interest, and everyone who inherited his property willingly returns it because they are honest Europeans, making him hugely successful and wealthy
“amazingly enough here's the big break every all his property the property that is in brazil the property they had back in england all that has multiplied enormously i i love the idea of interest isn't it great and when you're away for 28 years and you can't touch the principle compound interest kicks in he's a capitalistic kind of a guy so he comes home and he's hugely successful in everything he's undertaken”
The 'heavy-handed' symbolism and repetition in Robinson Crusoe—symbols laid on multiple times and themes reiterated throughout—is characteristic of the novel as a literary form in its infancy in 1719, before writers had fully developed the sophistication of the form
“the kind of heavy-handed symbols well he goes to c and the first thing happens god warns him...remember the novel is kind of a new thing in 1719 they haven't worked out all the the kind of kind of finesses and this is not a lava a novel loaded with finesse if he says anything once he says it 20 times if he symbolizes anything once he symbolizes it again and again and again and the kind of heavy-handed symbols”
Mutineers arrive on Crusoe's island and he strategically befriends the loyal captain, pretending to be someone shipwrecked on the island, then secretly captures the mutineers and releases the captain and his crew, ultimately regaining control of a ship to return home
“right now this is about the only plot twist in the whole novel fortunately and again one of those coincidences happens there's a shipwreck or not a shipwreck but a a band of mutineers comes to the island and they're going to dispose of the captain and the ones who are loyal to the to the mate uh to the captain...carefully cleverly rationally crucial outfoxes them he captures them when they come on shore looking for water he eventually manages to get in contact with the captain release the captain and the loyal crew members from bondage bring them on secretly quietly onto the boat take control of the boat and amazingly enough he's rescued”
There is a digressive passage about wolves and bears and European dangers in the novel that doesn't belong and 'should have been chucked out,' reflecting problems with editing and structure
“and as a kind of afterthought or and then there's a there's a kind of digressive part of the novel which doesn't really belong there where they talk about wolves and bears and the natural dangers that are in that are still in europe at the time but that should have been chucked out i mean the book needs an editor”
Crusoe has a dream that prefigures his relationship with Friday and the savages—an example of literary foreshadowing that is 'a little dicey' as a narrative technique but fits the allegorical pattern
“there's a part in which uh he has uh crusoe has a dream which prefigures his relationship with friday and the savages that's a little dicey too but don't ask too much of the literary form remember it's infancy at this point”
Crusoe chooses to leave the mutineers on the island after showing Christian mercy, telling them they can stay and deal with the savages themselves, allowing them the option to remain rather than be hanged in England as punishment for mutiny
“he leaves the captives or the uh the mutineers on the island he said look we can take you home to england and they're all going to ha you're all going to hang right because that's what we do with mutineers on the other hand since i was sent here for providential reasons i can't see why god's providence wouldn't work in your case there must be a reason why you're here we'll give you a choice you want to stay here i got a couple of nice houses i you know i have tilled fields i have domesticated goats i got all this great stuff so we'll leave you guys here”