America At 250
What this covers
Three historians, Frank Cogliano, Patrick Griffin and Brendan McConville, talk with the host Paul as the country nears its 250th anniversary. They keep returning to how little people in 1774 knew about what they were living through. Through most of that year the dispute was called a civil war within the empire, and most people still expected a way out until Lexington and Concord. The shift came when town committees began requesting gunpowder and organizing militias. Griffin argues that the story of inevitability, strung from the Stamp Act onward, was built afterward, an instance of Retrospective Teleology. He also describes the early Congress as a meeting rather than a sovereign body, quasi-sovereign only because of a power vacuum.
Slavery gets sustained attention. Cogliano treats Lord Dunmore's 1775 proclamation as a wartime act of desperation, not an abolitionist one, yet it drew enslaved people to the British side and appeared among Jefferson's grievances. McConville calls the war the largest disruption of slavery before the Civil War, producing mass flight, Black evangelical churches, Maroon communities, and settlements in Canada and West Africa. Cogliano reads Jefferson's excised slave-trade passage as a sign the Declaration's rights were meant to be universal.
The contested turns come on ideas and memory. McConville credits the founders' mix of Enlightenment optimism and Calvinist pessimism with keeping the revolution from consuming itself. Cogliano notes Jefferson's rejection of originalism and the amendable design of the Constitution. Griffin defends founding myth as national glue, citing Frederick Douglass on holding the country to its principles. Cogliano says the political right has claimed a simplified revolution, while Patrick predicts commemorations will reveal more about the present than the past.
The American Revolution's enduring value lies in an improvised, imperfect founding that paired Enlightenment optimism with a realistic view of human nature, and the civic myths built on it must be kept alongside honest historical critique.
- Founders built a system meant to refine itself, not to reach a final perfect form
- The revolution was contingent and improvised; inevitability was a later construction
- Civic myth is necessary social glue, but it has to coexist with demythologizing history
The founding creed belongs to all, so its hypocrisies must be confronted, not discarded.
- Nativism and a Puritan streak of drawing in-groups and out-groups are recurring threads in American history, unrelated to the historical Puritans themselves, and they stand in tension with the 1776 creed.
“nativism has been a prominent thread in American history... the notion of who's on the inside and who's on the out”
- Descendants of immigrants, including Catholic ethnics from working-class waterfront families, felt 1776 belonged to them as much as anyone, because America was an open door for anyone who embraced its principles.
“1776 was as much ours as anybody else's. There was no question about that.”
- The United States was born in a sort of sin but has always had a case for redemption: Frederick Douglass argued that Americans should expose hypocrisy in failing to live up to the founding principles without rejecting those principles, and that more people should be able to enjoy them.
“he basically says, shame on you, but he doesn't reject those principles”
- The Declaration of Independence was a wartime document whose life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness language was boilerplate British thought at the time, and African American abolitionists later turned it into a sacred civic creed.
“These were boilerplate British kinds of ideas that were used to actually justify all the important stuff”
- Throwing away the mythic ideals, including the life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness standard of belonging, would dishonor people excluded in the past who struggled to claim that membership for themselves and their people.
“if we somehow throw away some of these mythic ideals... then we can potentially dishonor those people who have been excluded in the past”
- The American past was built partly on the expulsion of Native Americans and the land acquired at their expense, along with slavery, traumatic histories that generations continue to carry and must be confronted rather than ignored.
“it was always acquired at the expense of other human beings. So that's a traumatic history.”
Founding myths are necessary national glue, and commemorations reveal the people doing them.
- Founding myths are necessary because a revolution must be settled by building a state and a nation; the Constitution solved the problem of state, but a mythic national identity provides the glue that prevents return to anarchy.
“State is one thing, nation is the other. And I think many of the myths that we still subscribe to”
- The 1976 bicentennial was a more consensual moment in which Americans, after Vietnam and Watergate, wanted to get back up off the canvas, a nostalgic sentiment captured by the film Rocky.
“1976 was a bit more of a consensual moment... we can get ourselves up off the canvas again”
- Because historians are mortal, they tend to see their own time as uniquely critical; future historians will look back on today's fractures and judge them, which Patrick finds grounds for hope that the country will get through this moment.
“we tend to think about the period of time in which we live as being the most distinctive, the most important”
- When societies enter commemoration, the event being commemorated matters less than what the commemoration reveals about the people doing it.
“When we get into the commemoration business, it's not about what happened in the past, it's what it says about us.”
The Revolution was contingent, quasi-sovereign in its governance, and globally significant.
- Nothing was inevitable; a switch flipped in the early 1770s when certain people turned an imperial crisis into a secession crisis, and only later did a myth of inevitability develop as Americans strung together the Stamp Act and subsequent acts.
“certain people then turn what was an imperial crisis into a secession crisis. And that is the moment when that switch flips.”
- The American Revolution was a seismic global event that touched off the French Revolution and inspired liberation movements through the 19th and 20th centuries, and historians now grasp its global significance better than before.
“the seismic event, not only for American nationhood... but also in many ways globally”
- Congress in its early phase was a meeting and not a sovereign body like Parliament, and it was quasi-sovereign because of a power vacuum; the colonies behaved more like the early European Union, each doing different things.
“it's better to think almost about the European Union at first, and they're all doing different things.”