What this covers

Richard Gunderman, a physician and reader from Indiana University, joins Russ Roberts to examine how Adam Smith and Leo Tolstoy understood greed and the misdirection it causes. The conversation centers on Tolstoy's short story "Master and Man," using its protagonist Vasili as a case study in how the pursuit of wealth can blind a person to what actually matters. Gunderman argues that Vasili's life—measuring himself by money accumulated, using deception to gain advantage, regarding his own family as objects rather than persons—exemplifies a fundamental impoverishment masked as success. The discussion moves between literary analysis and moral philosophy, tracing how Thomas Hobbes, Smith, and Tolstoy each imagined human nature, and what follows from those visions about how we ought to live.

The core disagreement concerns whether humans are naturally isolated egoists (as Hobbes held) or naturally embedded in networks of sympathy and dependence (as both Smith and Tolstoy argue). From there, Gunderman develops the claim that morality is fundamentally a matter of attention—what we notice, what we choose to see in others—rather than rule-following. Vasili's catastrophe, when stripped of his wealth and facing death, shows that his entire framework for understanding reality collapses. The conversation examines the Hierarchy of Desires: whether humans are meant to transcend lower, animal desires for higher fulfillment in relationships and art, or whether Psychological Egoism traps us in perpetual self-interest. Roberts and Gunderman also consider how cultural artifacts—novels, films—almost never depict someone choosing greed over goodness, suggesting a persistent moral intuition about which life is actually worth living.

Sharpest takeaway

Gunderman argues that a life consumed by greed and wealth-accumulation is impoverished and self-deceived, and that the moral life lies less in following rules than in 'attending'—paying attention to what truly matters, especially our embeddedness in family and human relationships.

  • Tolstoy's Vasili shows that measuring life by wealth blinds a person to their own humanity and even their own safety
  • Hobbes sees humans as fearful egoists, while Smith and Tolstoy see us as born into networks of cooperation and sympathy
  • Morality is fundamentally about noticing and attending, not merely about obeying rules

The argument · threads4 threads · 31 claims
0.75

Paying attention to others' subtle distress is a learnable moral skill we systematically fail to teach.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • There are two distinct things in the morality of attention: first, paying any kind of attention at all (being alert rather than absorbed in oneself), and second, choosing what to attend to; noticing the subtle distress or heartache of another person—not just obvious crying or bleeding—is a skill that must be worked on, and we do not educate children in this at all.

    “there's two things going on here. And, the first is just to pay any kind of attention. To be alert. And then the second one would be, what do you pay attention to?”

  • Earlier in the story Vasili soothes his panic about dying by mentally going through his investments, a form of distraction; the second time he cannot soothe himself and panic rises—this illustrates how minds racing with worry, fear, or self-soothing daydreams make it hard to pay attention to others, so that paying attention is what redeems the lesser side of ourselves.

    “So, many times our minds are racing with our worries and our fears and our excitement... But it makes it harder to pay attention.”

0.75

The pursuit of wealth and status is seductive and easy to mistake for genuine paths to being worthy of esteem.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Most great works of art on this topic depict a character who realizes there's more to life than money, and almost never the reverse—you cannot find a great novel, film, or story where a character who was good to others wakes up and decides to forget them and focus on making money—reflecting a cultural force pushing us away from a life like Vasili's.

    “it is interesting that most great works of art on this topic are about a character who realizes that there's more to life than money. Usually, it doesn't go the other way.”

  • Smith argues we desire both to be loved (praised, admired, respected) and to be lovely (worthy of praise); there are two paths to being loved—the 'glittering' path of being rich, powerful, and famous, which attracts the 'great mob' of humanity, and the less shiny wise-and-virtuous path appreciated by only a 'small party'—and the first path's brightness is seductive and easy to be blinded by.

    “If you want to be loved, you want people to pay attention to you. One way to do that is to be rich, powerful, and famous. And, the other way is to be wise and virtuous.”

0.61

True virtue means doing right even when it brings no pleasure or personal benefit to oneself.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Echoing John Stuart Mill's line 'Better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied,' Roberts confesses a deep attraction to the parts of his existence that are less animal-like, feeling virtuous when exercising distinctly human faculties—the desire for the transcendent and creatively human—even while acknowledging much of human experience resembles an animal's.

    “"Better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied."”

  • Beyond self-interest, thoughtful people care about doing the right thing even when it doesn't benefit them; the example of returning a found wallet—giving up money you wanted because keeping it is wrong, and not being happy about the sacrifice—cannot be honestly reduced to 'doing the right thing gives you pleasure.'

    “a lot of times we do things that aren't fun, don't give us pleasure. We wish we could keep the wallet we find in the street and buy something with the money. But, we think it's the wrong thing to do, so we give it back; and we're not really happy about it”

0.57

Tolstoy's narrative technique reveals a character's self-deception and inattention through artistic method rather than explicit judgment.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The effectiveness of Tolstoy's storytelling comes from the disconnect between how the main character sees himself and how the reader is able to see him; Tolstoy never labels the character a hypocrite but slowly reveals his inner thoughts so the reader sees the man more fully than he sees himself.

    “the effectiveness of the story, I would say, comes from the disconnect between how the main character sees himself and how we, as the reader, are able to see him. The brilliance of Tolstoy is he doesn't say, 'Look at this hypocrite.'”

  • The repeated recurrences in the story—getting lost, the worn-out horse, passing through the town multiple times—are Tolstoy's way of saying that for some of us at some stretches of life we make the same mistakes over and over because we are not paying attention, blinded by the pull of the deal or simply failing to notice.

    “Tolstoy is saying something about the nature of life. That for some of us and at some stretches in our life, we just make the same mistakes over and over again, because we're not paying attention.”

  • Listeners should read Tolstoy's 'Master and Man' before listening because it can only be read once without knowing the ending, and should also read George Saunders's A Swim in a Pond in the Rain.

    “if you haven't read the story yet, please do before you go any longer on this episode.”