cost-benefit analysis
An economic decision method that weighs aggregate benefits against aggregate costs, treated as if utility across different people could be summed.
As defined in et_911
Other definitions
A decision-making framework that weighs the benefits of an action against its costs, including alternatives and opportunity costs, to determine whether it is worthwhile.
David Leonhardt on the Media
Where it comes up · 17
- Robert Frank on Coase4 claims
- Binyamin Appelbaum on the Economists' Hour2 claims
- Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics2 claims
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20102 claims
- Tariffs, Decline, and the Promise of AI | A Conversation with Larry Summers and Niall Ferguson2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler 2024 Retrospective1 claim
- Sheilagh Ogilvie1 claim
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)1 claim
and 9 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “cost-benefit analysis” →
- Economists are too powerful because they privilege what can be measured over what cannot; most of the most important things in life—meaning, purpose, dignity, agency, responsibility—cannot be captured in a dataset, and because economists win debates by having data, they drown out other disciplines, which is a problem regardless of political orientation.Binyamin Appelbaum on the Economists' Hour
- Variolation carried about a 1.6 percent death risk versus a 10-20 percent risk of dying from naturally caught smallpox, so on cost-benefit grounds it was rational to do it, and 18th-century doctors and ordinary people explicitly used 'the calculus of capitalism' to make this decision.Sheilagh Ogilvie
- In government regulation, value disagreements can often be quieted by being rationalistic about data—asking what a rule's costs and benefits are rather than whether one is 'pro-safety' or 'pro-market'—so that a $4 billion rule saving one life a year is hard to defend while a $100 million rule saving 1,000 lives is easy, enabling civilized, evidence-based debate even among politically diverse people; however, on issues like capital punishment, abortion, and immigration, the dispute resolves by votes, not data.327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
- White-collar crimes such as FTX, Enron, and Madoff are typically not the result of careful cost-benefit analysis but of mindless irrationality and failures of intuition, because the perpetrators are often already wealthy and successful with little to gain and everything to lose.361 - Sam Bankman-fried Effective Altruism
- Moving Stonehenge to a transport-connected exhibition center would score better on conventional economic value and even on visitor access, yet the lesson for students is that economics isn't always the answer—people value things being in their authentic place even if they will never visit.Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics
- Economists are trained as utilitarians, using a single money metric to pile everything into one number for go/no-go decisions, but this reductionism feels alien to many people who hold that aesthetic, spiritual, and identity values are genuinely multidimensional and cannot be collapsed into one scale—creating a core dilemma since policy still requires a decision-making framework.Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics
- The rise of cost-benefit analysis was one of the most profound revolutions of this era, with real benefits, but it makes explicit that anything you can put a dollar figure on gets privileged over things that cannot be priced, producing almost frantic efforts to monetize things like an unimpeded view or a wilderness no one experiences—an approach that is misguided as the only or best way to weigh such values.Binyamin Appelbaum on the Economists' Hour
- Frank argues cost-benefit analysis is unfair to the poor because wealthy people can pay more for preferred policies even when their intensity of preference is no greater, so a general transfer to low-income workers, such as an increase in the EITC, can compensate for that bias.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- The influence of economists has expanded dramatically since 1970: they now dominate cost-benefit analysis at EPA, antitrust analysis at Justice Department, and central bank leadership globally, which indicates the discipline is not in decline but has become more successful.Tariffs, Decline, and the Promise of AI | A Conversation with Larry Summers and Niall Ferguson
- The nightmare case of utilitarianism is that if 90 percent of a culture votes to murder 10 percent, or 51 percent votes to kill 49 percent, utilitarian cost-benefit analysis could justify this if the happiness units for the majority are sufficiently high; Kant would reject this entirely because you cannot universalize murder and torture violates reason itself.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar