What this covers

Cass Sunstein, a Harvard legal scholar, joins Sean Carroll to defend liberalism as a coherent philosophical tradition worth preserving despite mounting pressure from opposing flanks. The conversation spans the philosophical foundations of liberalism—its commitment to individual freedom, pluralism, and rule of law—and traces how figures ranging from Ronald Reagan to Franklin Delano Roosevelt inhabit the same broad tent. Sunstein distinguishes between political liberalism, which makes space for diverse ways of life without enforcing any single vision of the good, and perfectionist liberalism, which treats personal autonomy as itself the highest good. Much of the discussion concerns what liberalism is not: neither a guarantee of neutrality nor a license for unlimited choice, but a framework that respects others' dignity and embraces humility about one's own judgments.

The episode traces two major critiques. The right-wing case, rooted in Tocqueville, holds that liberal societies erode the virtues—faith, tradition, community—on which they depend; Sunstein argues this rests on empirical claims that are likely false. The left-wing critique identifies liberalism with free markets and inequality, treating Reagan as liberalism "working itself pure" while blaming it for climate change and social hierarchy. Sunstein counters that both critiques share a distrust of individual agency itself. The conversation then turns to structural threats: group polarization amplified by social media algorithms, the erosion of general interest intermediaries that once provided shared cultural experience, and how economic inequality translates into political inequality, corrupting the ideal speech situation. Throughout, Sunstein defends experiments in living—the freedom to try new ways of working, loving, and living—as central to why liberalism matters.

Sharpest takeaway

Sunstein argues that liberalism is a broad tradition unified by individual freedom, pluralism, rule of law, and humility about the good life, encompassing figures from Reagan to FDR, and that it is worth defending against intensifying critiques from both the right and the left.

  • Liberals across the political spectrum share core commitments to freedom of speech, pluralism, individual agency, and the rule of law
  • Critiques from the right (liberalism erodes virtue/authority) and left (liberalism enables inequality and hierarchy) both distrust individual autonomy
  • Technology-driven group polarization and the loss of shared culture threaten liberal democracy's stability

The argument · threads6 threads · 22 claims
0.71

Rule of law, restraint by officials, and respect-based pluralism are liberalism's practical moorings and moral foundations.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Both the Reagan and Obama administrations were firmly committed to the rule of law, with officials declining to pursue policies the Justice Department deemed unlawful even when they could have technically gotten away with them, treating lawful conduct as a moral obligation rather than merely avoiding getting caught.

    “under President Reagan, the Justice Department said frequently in the first eight months or so of his presidency, you want to do this, but the law doesn't allow you to... 'The law is against it. We're not going to do it.'”

  • Despite China's impressive achievements, the rule of law is not flourishing there, and as a result people are genuinely scared—illustrating that stable, clear, prospective rules are an insufficiently appreciated safeguard of freedom.

    “I taught in China a number of years ago, and I saw there, for all the amazingness of what China's done, the rule of law isn't flourishing there. And so people are really scared.”

  • Although liberalism is not doing better today than a few months ago, there is rising appreciation for it among extremely diverse people worldwide—because, as the Joni Mitchell line goes, 'you don't know what you've got till it's gone'—and the fact that liberalism is gone or at risk in some places is making people newly recognize it as something to cherish.

    “we are seeing sprouting appreciation of liberalism on the part of extremely diverse people all over the world. And it's partly because you don't know what you've got till it's gone”

  • A liberal society does not insist on any particular conception of the good life, making space for the astronomer, the construction worker, the animal-welfare devotee, or the religious devotee alike; the risk is that heartfelt competing conceptions of the good (as with abortion) can produce severe conflict that liberal ground rules struggle to contain.

    “in a liberal society, we don't insist on any particular conception of the good... a liberal society says, there's space for all of that. But you're right that there's a risk that if there are heartfelt competing conceptions of the good, people will end up fighting”

  • There are two distinct forms of liberalism: political liberalism, which is a political ideal guaranteeing liberties and making space for diverse (even illiberal) sub-cultures so long as they don't harm others; and perfectionist liberalism (associated with Mill and Joseph Raz), which is a claim about the good life holding that everyone should be autonomous and author their own life's narrative.

    “there are two forms of liberalism in political philosophy... That's political liberalism, and it makes space for manospheres... Then there's another idea... let's call that perfectionist liberalism... it says everyone should be autonomous. It's not just about a political ideal. It's an idea about what a good life is”

  • Political liberalism can be understood either as a modus vivendi—an honorable peace treaty allowing diverse people to live together—but is better grounded in respect and humility: a person lives by their own conception of the good without forcing it on others, out of respect for others' dignity and humility about their own capacities; this respect-based account captures the core of political liberalism better and is more inspiring than the peace-treaty view.

    “I think another view is more about respect and humility than about peace treaties... 'I'm humble about my conception of the good... but it's not something I'm going to force you to do because I respect your dignity. And I also am humble about my capacities.'”

  • In government regulation, value disagreements can often be quieted by being rationalistic about data—asking what a rule's costs and benefits are rather than whether one is 'pro-safety' or 'pro-market'—so that a $4 billion rule saving one life a year is hard to defend while a $100 million rule saving 1,000 lives is easy, enabling civilized, evidence-based debate even among politically diverse people; however, on issues like capital punishment, abortion, and immigration, the dispute resolves by votes, not data.

    “if you're a regulation that costs $4 billion and would save one life a year, that would be very hard to defend if you had a regulation that would cost $100 million and save 1,000 lives a year, that would be really easy to defend. And it was all based on that, not values.”

  • Contrary to Montesquieu's view that a republic must be small and homogeneous to survive, Hamilton argued that a large republic with pluralism is preferable because the clashing of opinions and deliberation among diverse people promotes circumspection—a distinctively liberal thought, even though it is not always true.

    “Hamilton said, 'This is exactly wrong, that it's in a large republic where there's pluralism, that the clashing of opinions and deliberation will promote circumspection.'”

0.70

Liberalism rests fundamentally on respect for individual agency and autonomy as core commitments.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Liberalism is best understood as a broad political tradition, defined by John Stuart Mill and others, that is freedom-friendly, treats freedom of speech and religion as central, values pluralism and individual agency, and has communism and fascism as its antonyms—a tent broad enough to include both Ronald Reagan and FDR.

    “I mean the liberal political tradition that John Stuart Mill helps define, that includes Ronald Reagan and Franklin Delano Roosevelt, that helped fuel the birth of the United of America, that helps define Western Europe, that has as its antonym communism and fascism”

  • The shared root of both right-wing and left-wing critiques of liberalism is distrust of individual agency—seeing individual autonomy as a problem rather than something to be placed at the foundation of social order; liberals counter that agency and autonomy are core commitments but are not unlimited, since liberals readily constrain choices that harm others or impose senseless self-risk, and pluralism is autonomy's necessary twin.

    “It's that individual agency is seen as something like a problem or not appropriately put at the foundation of what we order our society on the basis of”

  • Drawing on Mill, liberalism cherishes 'experiments in living'—the freedom to try new ways of living, working, loving, or playing (from pickleball to a new bookstore to an unconventional marriage) because we cannot know in advance what works without the freedom to try; this reflects Learned Hand's idea that the spirit of liberty is 'that spirit which is not too sure that it is right.'

    “in science, or social science, astronomy, in life, there are lots of things to try and you don't know really what works unless there's a lot of freedom to try it... And liberalism cherishes experiments in living.”

  • Tribalism and identity politics on the left make liberals uneasy: while membership in a group can confer some knowledge, the fact that one is, say, a white male does not commit one to favoring whatever white men have historically benefited from, because liberalism assumes a degree of universality in the human condition.

    “identity politics on the left make liberals nervous. When people say, as a whatever. I think this. Liberals kind of roll their eyes a bit... the fact that you're, let's say a white male doesn't mean you have to be in favor of whatever white men have historically benefited from”

0.53

Both right-wing and left-wing critiques challenge liberalism's foundations and values in distinctive ways.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The most formidable right-wing critique, traceable to Tocqueville, holds that liberal societies depend for their stability on non-liberal virtues—faith, community commitment, tradition, family—yet liberalism tends to erode or 'swallow' the very forms of character on which it depends; Sunstein argues this rests on impressionistic empirical claims that are likely false, since such virtues often prosper under liberalism.

    “the idea is that liberalism kind of carves up or destroys or swallows the forms of character on which it depends”

  • A left-wing critique identifies liberalism with neoliberalism—free markets, hostility to equality, and an engine of acute deprivation for those at the bottom—treating Reaganism as the core of liberalism 'working itself pure,' and blaming liberalism for climate change and the worst features of current society; a related strand (echoing Marx and Catherine MacKinnon) faults liberalism for sustaining racism, sexism, and unjust hierarchy under a too-thin conception of equality.

    “there are left wing critiques that identify liberalism with neoliberalism and say that liberalism is associated with free markets, is hostile to equality, is an engine for acute deprivation on the part of people at the bottom”

  • Some people hold a deep, almost erotic emotional commitment to authority, and the appeal of authoritarianism resonates in every human heart—as dramatized by the ending of Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four—but this attraction is deeply illiberal because, per Lincoln, no one can rightfully rule another without that person's consent.

    “There's some part of the human heart that reads Orwell's 'Nineteen Eighty-Four.' And I think that's why it's such a great book that the attraction of Big Brother. Every human heart gets that”

0.53

Group deliberation and social media polarization threaten liberal democracy by amplifying extremism and eroding shared experience.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • On average, groups of like-minded people who deliberate together become more extreme, more confident, and more unified, shifting further in the direction of their pre-deliberation tendencies—a robustly replicated finding (originating with the MIT student named Stoner) that, when supercharged by social media algorithms and voluntary self-sorting, creates 'information cocoons' that threaten the stability of liberal democracies.

    “on average groups of like-minded people engaged in conversation with one another and are more extreme, more confident, more unified”

  • Many democracies are struggling partly because of social-media-bred polarization and the destruction of general-interest intermediaries; democracies need some 'monoculture'—shared experiences like national holidays or common media outlets that aren't strongly left or right—and it is unclear whether modern societies still have enough of it.

    “One causal factor is polarization of the kind we're discussing bred through the use of social media and the destruction of general interest intermediaries”

  • In a study of juries (with Daniel Kahneman and David Schkade), groups of people ended up much more outraged after engaging with one another than the average individual member was beforehand, with this amplification appearing on every scale used to measure the magnitude of outrage.

    “we found that groups of people ended up much more outraged after they engaged with one another than individual who are outraged... And we saw that with every scale we use to measure the magnitude of outrage.”

0.45

Free speech and diverse experiments in living protect liberty by keeping beliefs vital and enabling discovery.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • The liberal case for free speech, following Mill, holds that even false or harmful speech is valuable because hearing other views keeps one's own beliefs fresh rather than dead and calcified and lets the error of false views emerge through discussion; suppressing speech, per Justice Robert Jackson, achieves only 'the unanimity of the graveyard.'

    “Mill thought that even if there's false or harmful speech, it's really important to learn what other people think. That to keep your own views fresh and alive rather than dead and calcified is a good thing.”

0.39

Economic inequality poses a grave liberal risk by converting wealth into political power and distorting genuine discourse.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Liberals oppose monopolies of both kinds: government monopolies (a key reason liberals reject socialism understood as public ownership of the means of production) and private monopolies (as even the pro-market Hayek opposed); so Elizabeth Warren's concern about big-tech monopolies speaks within the liberal tradition, even though whether breaking up specific companies like Apple, Google, or Meta would improve things is not determined by liberalism itself.

    “it's clear that monopolies are something that liberals don't like either government monopolies. That's one reason liberals don't like socialism... Liberals are also opposed to private monopolies. So, Warren is speaking for that part of the liberal tradition.”

  • While the liberal tent includes a strand (Reagan, Thatcher) comfortable with vast inequality, Sunstein argues the best conception of liberalism endorses FDR's Second Bill of Rights—a right to a job, a decent minimum, good education, and protection against disability and old age—and is more concerned about the very poor than the super rich, seeking to engineer opportunities for people to rise above a decent minimum rather than guaranteeing a fixed level of wealth.

    “Franklin Delano Roosevelt believed in a second Bill of Rights in accordance with which everyone would have a right to a job, everyone would have a right to a decent minimum... in my view, the best conception of liberalism endorses the second Bill of Rights”

  • A fair liberal concern is that economic inequality turns into political inequality, as people with vast resources can shape public opinion to a shocking degree, distorting the ideal speech situation; the campaign finance debate is an attempt to address this, but not nearly enough has been done.

    “there's the concern that economic inequality turns into political inequality. And I think that's a very fair concern... it's shocking the extent to which people with a ton of money can get, can form public opinion because of all the resources they have.”