The nightmare case of utilitarianism is that if 90 percent of a culture votes to murder 10 percent, or 51 percent votes to kill 49 percent, utilitarian cost-benefit analysis could justify this if the happiness units for the majority are sufficiently high; Kant would reject this entirely because you cannot universalize murder and torture violates reason itself.

causalpending

Speaker

Michael Sugrue

Evidence Quote

“suppose 90 of a culture wants to murder 10...if you have some enough british happiness units maybe you could justify that but god is going to leave out things like torture and violence reason doesn't allow for that kind of behavior all right why because you can't universalize the maxim”

Source

Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar— Michael Sugrue
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:05:53 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...