What this covers

David Leonhardt of The New York Times speaks with economist Russ Roberts about how mainstream news organizations resist partisan drift while subtler biases persist in less visible ways. The conversation ranges across media structure, healthcare performance, and the role of published data in creating accountability. Leonhardt argues that the news sections of major outlets like the Wall Street Journal and The New York Times converge on similar coverage despite serving different ideological audiences, suggesting that reporting aimed at objectivity operates as a distinct product from opinion pages. Yet bias proves harder to police in the subjective choice of which stories matter than in overt slant within a story itself. He contends that published rankings and performance data, however imperfect, force transparency and drive measurable improvement—exemplified by UCSF Hospital's dramatic improvements in heart attack care once their data exposed gaps compared to peers.

The discussion traces how transparency as an incentive works in healthcare, economics education, and news production. Leonhardt explores tensions in economic writing between rigor and narrative accessibility, argues that the journalistic equal-time norm falters when scientific consensus exists (as with climate change), and examines how the internet has shifted newspapers away from breaking news toward analysis—a shift that necessarily introduces more subjective judgment. He notes a simultaneity problem at The New York Times: whether liberal readers shaped its editorial voice or the editorial voice attracted liberal readers remains unclear. Throughout, the conversation treats media bias not as conspiracy but as the product of institutional incentives, editorial choices, and the demands modern readers place on reporting.

Sharpest takeaway

Leonhardt argues that mainstream news organizations like the NYTimes deliberately try to resist the broad partisan narrowing of media, but that subtler bias persists through the subjective choice of subjects, and that public release of performance data creates powerful incentives for improvement in fields like healthcare.

  • The news sections of the WSJ and NYTimes are far more similar to each other than to their own editorial pages
  • Bias is harder to police in the choice of subjects than in overt reporting
  • Published rankings and data, however flawed, force transparency and accountability

The argument · threads4 threads · 15 claims
0.73

Published rankings and performance data, despite their limitations, create incentives that push institutions toward measurable improvement.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Door-to-balloon time—the time from a heart attack patient walking in the door until their arteries are expanded by balloon—has standards of 90 minutes or 2 hours, and while the national average is that 67% of patients get treated within 2 hours, hospitals vary enormously, with some performing much better or worse.

    “National average is that 67% of patients get treated within 2 hrs., but some hospitals do much better or worse.”

  • Hospitals like UCSF only improved their heart attack care—from an average closer to 3 hours down toward the standards—when they actually examined their own data and discovered they weren't doing the best job, and they were pushed to study their performance by the threat of public exposure and public release of the data; published rankings and data, despite their bluntness and failings, create incentives that drive improvement.

    “They only got better when they actually looked at the data and discovered they weren't doing the best job. They were pushed to study their performance by the threat of public exposure, public release of the data.”

  • Rankings of MBA programs, colleges, and graduate programs by Business Week, U.S. News and others, though flawed, create transparency, even if it remains hard to sort out customer satisfaction with education from other issues.

    “Rankings of MBA programs, colleges, graduate programs by Business Week, U.S. News, etc. flawed but create transparency.”

0.65

Media bias operates primarily through subject selection and framing rather than overt slant within individual stories.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Because the New York Times is located in New York City, its readers skew more liberal than the country as a whole, which is intertwined with the character of its Op Ed page in a simultaneity problem where it is hard to tell cause from effect.

    “its readers "skew more liberal than the country as a whole"”

  • The news sections of the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times, in terms of their outlook, are far more similar to each other than either is to its own editorial page, indicating that reporting that attempts to set aside bias is a distinct product from partisan opinion.

    “the news section of the WSJ and the NYTimes, in terms of what you might describe as their outlook, are actually really quite similar. They are far, far more similar than either of them is to their respective editorial pages.”

  • A deeper and subtler form of media bias than overt reporting is the choice of subjects, which remains more subjective than objective and is shaped by incentives, making it harder to police than slant within a given story.

    “Choice of subjects is still affected by incentives, more subjective than objective.”

  • Newspaper readers today demand more analysis than dry reporting of the news, which naturally leads coverage to a closer approach to bias because analysis requires subjective judgment.

    “Newspaper clientele today demands more analysis than dry reporting of the news, which naturally leads to a closer approach to bias.”

0.59

Blending rigorous analysis with interdisciplinary storytelling and attention to real-world incentives produces better research and policy outcomes.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Economists are sometimes too clever for their own sake, and rigor has to be balanced with artful use of stories, interdisciplinary work, more case studies, and talking to non-academics.

    “"Sometimes economists are too clever for their own sake." Interdisciplinary work; more case studies and talking to non-academics. Rigor has to be balanced with artful use of stories.”

  • Some economists actively blend scientific research with ideology to differing degrees, with the downside that they come to be seen as having an agenda, and the upside that they can use research to make better policy decisions and improve the world.

    “Downside is that you come to be seen as having an agenda. Upside is that you can make the world a better place. Use research to make better policy decisions.”

  • Economists' approach to problems—using cost-benefit analysis, asking whether something works and what the alternatives are, and considering incentives, opportunity costs, and efficiency—is an intriguing and rigorous way to think about things.

    “Economists' approach to problems is intriguing, rigorous, "the way to think about things".”

0.57

Objective reporting and partisan opinion serve distinct roles in informing public debate, though structural changes to news economics are reshaping journalism.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • What happened yesterday now takes up less space in newspapers, in part because the Internet has become the main medium for immediate information in society, shifting the role of print away from breaking news.

    “What happened yesterday now takes up less space in newspapers, in part because of the Internet.”

  • When there is a scientific consensus, such as on climate change, the journalistic norm of giving equal time to both sides becomes questionable; skeptics excluding cranks may not deserve half the coverage but should still be mentioned from time to time, and the truth about what has happened differs from claims about what will happen.

    “Should a newspaper continue to give equal time to both sides if there is a scientific concensus?”

  • Objective-aiming news reporting and partisan opinion are a joint product, where news sources that attempt to set aside their biases provide the 'oxygen that the political debates live on,' while the blogosphere offers only the opinion aspect and not original reporting.

    “The news sources are the "oxygen that the political debates live on". Blogosphere only offers the opinion aspect.”

  • The front page of the NYTimes is decided through a competitive process in which articles are offered and pitched at two daily team meetings, after which top editors decide, occasionally holding features for the next day to get them onto the front page.

    “Articles are offered for front page display, and pitched: Here's why this is a front page story.”

  • Claiming that a task 'is really hard' is often an excuse for avoiding accountability rather than a genuine reason for poor performance.

    “"This is really hard" is often an excuse for avoiding accountability.”