What this covers

Hanno Sauer, a philosopher, joins Russ Roberts on EconTalk to explore how humans evolved the capacity for large-scale cooperation and constructed morality without divine origin. The conversation traces a counterintuitive path: humans solved the evolutionary puzzle of cooperation through escalating enforcement mechanisms, beginning with self-domestication—the systematic removal of the most aggressive members across hundreds of thousands of years—which gradually selected for docility and norm-conformism. This biological foundation was then extended through cultural and institutional inventions, most notably religion, which allowed cooperation to scale from small bands of dozens to modern societies of billions. Sauer argues that moral intuitions, though appearing altruistic, rest ultimately on underlying strategic logics shaped by these enforcement needs.

The discussion ranges across surprising terrain. Sauer contends that the Big Gods Hypothesis—the emergence of omniscient, moralistic deities alongside urbanization—represents a cultural solution to the monitoring problem cities created. He examines whether humanity's capacity for cruelty constitutes a moral achievement, rooted in evolutionary hangover from when violence enforcement served cooperation. The pair spar over deterrence theory, with Sauer challenging Gary Becker's high-penalty model in favor of certainty of detection, and debate whether religion remains necessary for modern cooperation, with Steven Pinker-style optimism about secular societies like Scandinavia set against Sauer's emphasis on the collective action problem always threatening to unravel cooperation. Jared Diamond's claim that agriculture was humanity's worst mistake also surfaces as a point of friction about progress and cost.

Sharpest takeaway

Sauer argues that human large-scale cooperation and morality were not divinely given but evolved through escalating enforcement mechanisms—including self-domestication via the systematic killing of the most aggressive group members—and that institutional and cultural inventions (including religion) scaled cooperation from small bands to billions.

  • Cooperation is an evolutionary puzzle that humans solved uniquely by scaling group size through new enforcement mechanisms
  • Self-domestication via killing the most violent members reduced human aggression over hundreds of thousands of years
  • Religion and 'Big Gods' co-evolved with urbanization to monitor behavior and enforce norms at scale

The argument · threads6 threads · 33 claims
0.68

Cooperation unravels without enforcement; social sanctions stabilize and scale human cooperation across billions.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Experimental economics public-goods games show that cooperation begins in the first rounds but then unravels, yet when a punishment option is introduced, cooperation can be stabilized—demonstrating that social sanctions are a necessary mechanism for straightening out 'the crooked timber of humanity.'

    “people start with in the first couple of rounds, one or two rounds, with cooperation, and then cooperation unravels. And when you do these experiments with a punishment option, you see that cooperation can be stabilized.”

  • Humans are unique among animals in their malleability to live both in tiny hunter-gatherer bands and in societies of billions; unlike chimpanzees (who cap out at dozens) or eusocial insects (genetically fixed to one mode), humans expanded their institutional toolkit—norms, institutions, social practices—to scale cooperation to people they never meet across continents.

    “human beings have this malleability and plasticity and capability to live in all sorts of ways”

  • A solid answer to how cooperation arises in a Darwinian world only emerged in the second half of the 20th century, when evolutionary biologists equipped with game theory (sometimes working as or alongside economists) figured out the returns from cooperative behavior through concepts like inclusive fitness and reciprocity.

    “evolutionary biologists equipped with game theory, in tandem with economists indeed; sometimes these people were one and the same--figured out where do the returns from cooperative behavior come from?”

  • As cooperative groups grow in size, cooperation becomes increasingly fragile and 'entropic,' requiring progressively stronger enforcement mechanisms—ranging from soft sanctions like gossip and telling people off, up to capital punishment—to prevent cooperation from unraveling.

    “the larger these groups become, you need to introduce new mechanisms to stabilize cooperation, which becomes increasingly fragile, the more people you have. It becomes more entropic”

0.65

Humans self-domesticated by culling aggression while retaining capacity for coordinated violence against out-groups.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Delighting in cruelty was one of humanity's great moral developments because an evolved disposition to enjoy violence helped people enforce social norms when violence was needed—just as enjoying sex promotes reproduction—but once that enforcement problem was solved, the lust for cruelty became an impractical 'evolutionary hangover' that makes modern societies too punitive.

    “if you have an increasing need to enforce social norms--and sometimes you need violence--it just helps to install a disposition for people to enjoy violence”

  • Self-domestication applies mainly to the in-group, while humans' capacity for coordinated violence—forming ad hoc coalitions, cooperative hunting, and nightly raids on rival tribes to seize resources and women—remained directed at the out-group, leaving us with strong inherited us-versus-them cognition.

    “this self-domestication dynamic would be something that applies more to the in-group... And, these violent tendencies would largely remain directed at the out-group.”

  • Humans self-domesticated over hundreds of thousands of years by systematically killing the most aggressive ~10% of their tribes each generation, removing wannabe bullies and tyrants before they could reproduce, which selected for docility, low impulsive aggression, and norm-conformism—making humans the 'golden retrievers of the primate kingdom' relative to chimpanzees and gorillas.

    “we just killed the most aggressive members of our tribes and bands for hundreds of thousands of years”

0.57

Modern erosion of decorum norms and ethno-nationalist backlash are growing pains in scaling cooperation globally.

9 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Jared Diamond's claim that agriculture was 'the worst mistake of all time' rests on the view that, while it created storable caloric surplus and amplified military capability (allowing agriculturalists to absorb or kill remaining hunter-gatherers), it was a terrible deal for the majority: it brought oppression, hard labor, slavery, huge inequality, warfare, and zoonotic pandemics from living among animals.

    “The worst mistake of humanity was the invention of agriculture.”

  • Even after the emergence of urban civilization, it took a couple thousand years until the real escape from the Malthusian trap began, and that escape started only about 300 years ago—a very recent development in human history.

    “it still took a couple of thousand years until the real escape from the Malthusian trap started to work out. And, that's just 300 years ago when that started. That's very recent.”

  • The contrast between the 2012 Obama-Romney presidential debate—where the candidates praised and embraced each other warmly—and current political discourse reveals a cultural normative shift involving the erosion or destruction of norms of decorum in how people treat each other, a change that may be gone forever and is unlikely to be good.

    “people share this video of the Presidential debate between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney, and it's a different country.”

  • Recent thinking holds that nomadic hunter-gatherer life, despite high child mortality from large infant head size, was relatively good for those who survived past four or five: people often lived to 60 or 70, had few diseases (including no cancer and few animal-derived viruses), told stories, and did not work unusually long days.

    “once people made it past four or five years old, life was apparently pretty good. Right? People--they were 60, 70 years old in many cases.”

  • There is a negativity bias in news headlines—for example, suicide numbers tend to get reported only when they tick up even if the long-term trend is improving—which, combined with the work of optimists like Deaton, Pinker, and Rosling, supports a useful corrective against reflexive nostalgia and doomerism that everything is going to hell.

    “there's negativity bias in headlines. Suicide numbers only get reported when they tick up, even when they're long-term trend is--whatever, that kind of example.”

  • Despite the recent ethno-nationalist backlash and erosion of norms of decorum, the long-term forces still push toward scaling up cooperation further, because put-your-own-country-first homogeneity strategies are not functional in our interconnected world; current upheavals are best read as growing pains rather than a reversal—though there remains a real risk, as in 1930s Germany, that growing pains become catastrophic if exploited by opportunists.

    “I do think the trend still goes towards scaling up cooporation even more, and these I'm inclined to think are growing pains of that.”

  • Population size, not intelligence, determines the level of sustainable technology and cooperation: genetically identical Australian and New Zealand populations diverged because the smaller, isolated New Zealand group of ~20,000 lost bows, arrows, and complex boats—demonstrating that civilization, complex technology, and modern economies require large numbers of people, which only sedentary agricultural living made possible.

    “in New Zealand, the populations, they couldn't sustain bows and arrows... Not because they were stupid; not because they were genetically inferior... It's just that they got stuck on this island, and it was too few people”

  • Brexit was the first major event ushering in an atmosphere of returning ethno-nationalist thinking about politics, culture, and the economy—a cultural-vibe movement (not a rational economic one, since an isolated British economy could not function better) paralleled by right-wing backlash movements across the Netherlands, Hungary, Germany, Austria, and France reacting against the global integration of institutions and the economy.

    “Brexit was the first real big event that ushered in this atmosphere of returning to a ethno-nationalist thinking about politics, groups, culture, and the economy”

  • Morality can be grounded in human-level considerations without requiring a transcendent or divine foundation; even if a divine entity existed, one could still ask why its verdicts should be accepted, so 'without God, everything is allowed' is false.

    “I do not think that without God, everything is allowed. I think we can ground morality in human level considerations, and we don't need transcendent justification”

0.51

Cultural institutions like religion and ritual enforce cooperation by monitoring behavior and inculcating conformity.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Theories of cultural evolution show that early urbanization and empires co-evolved with 'Big Gods'—the shift from many goofy nature gods toward a single omniscient, moralistic deity—because as cities grew to tens of thousands of inhabitants, behavior could no longer be monitored, so an all-seeing God who knows your thoughts and punishes wickedness even after death became a powerful cultural invention for enforcing norms at scale.

    “you almost always see the co-evolution of early urbanization and empires together with what these people call 'Big Gods.'”

  • Sociologically, religion's primary function is to practice ritual, awe, and respect for authority and group cohesion—as seen in the highly regimented, synchronized, symbolic role-affirming structure of Catholic mass and synchronized prayer—which inculcates a sense of awe and conformity that can then be harnessed for cooperation, making religion a form of 'cheesecake' for our moral instincts.

    “what it does is that it practices ritual and respect for authority and the cohesion of a group”

  • Even if it turned out that most people in a society need religion to be cooperative, cohesive, and compliant, this would not show that religion is true—since untrue opinions can be more socially beneficial than true ones—and some people may not need it, while certain high-trust, low-religion societies like Scandinavia appear cohesive without it.

    “it wouldn't show that it's therefore true. Sometimes untrue opinions or theories can be more socially beneficial.”

0.48

Effective deterrence relies on high detection certainty and mild punishment, not harsh rare penalties.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to the high-penalty/low-detection model, the evidence suggests deterrence is most effective when people are quite certain they will be caught even if the punishment is mild, because people facing harsh but rare punishment believe they'll get away with it—and those who self-select into criminal careers tend to be imprudent and unresponsive to the cost-benefit calculation that would persuade a high-IQ economist.

    “it seems to be motivationally the most effective when people are quite certain that they get caught, even when the punishment is not as harsh”

  • We should engage in explicit cost-benefit analysis of how punitive to be, because human psychology is not naturally cost-benefit psychology—the public tends to see only benefits or only costs of an action and ignore one side of the equation—yet some mix of incentives and sanctions, ideally more incentives and fewer, gentler sanctions, remains necessary because collective action problems always threaten cooperation.

    “we should engage in cost-benefit thinking when it comes to punishment and our punitive instincts and social sanctions”

0.38

Human cooperation paradoxically emerges from selfish genetic logic expressed through authentic prosocial virtue.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Just as theism faces the theodicy problem of explaining evil under an all-good, all-powerful deity, a naturalistic Darwinian framework faces the reverse problem: if nature is fundamentally selfish and 'red in tooth and claw,' it becomes puzzling where friendship, heroism, love, altruism, and sacrifice come from.

    “now you get the opposite problem when you move to a naturalistic Darwinian framework. All of a sudden, the default assumption seems to be that it's 'nature, red in tooth and claw.'”

  • Authentic prosocial behavior is a far more effective social signal than faked behavior because humans are extremely sensitive to deception and manipulation, illustrated by Herb Kelleher genuinely enjoying working baggage claim with his workers versus the off-putting story of a celebrity chef faking kitchen presence by walking through restaurants in chef's clothes.

    “we are very, very sensitive towards deception and people trying to manipulate us with the signals that they send. And when they do it so strategically, people absolutely hate that.”

  • There is a paradox of being moral analogous to the paradox of hedonism: if you aim directly at seeming moral, you come off as calculative and manipulative, whereas if you authentically care about people you will seem moral and be appreciated far more—so evolution equipped us with genuinely felt, authentic dispositions of virtue that nonetheless rest on an underlying strategic, selfish-gene rationale.

    “if you aim at seeming moral directly--there's also going to be--you're going to come off as calculative and manipulative”