Thucydides trap
The theory that war becomes likely when a rising power threatens to displace an established power, named for Thucydides' account of Sparta and Athens
As defined in Shadi Bartsch
Other definitions
The theory that war becomes inevitable when a rising power threatens to displace a declining ruling power; Ramaswamy rejects it as a theory, not a law of physics.
Vivek RamaswamyThe dangerous dynamic in which a rising power threatens to displace an incumbent power, increasing the likelihood of war—named for Thucydides' account of Athens and Sparta.
117 - Networks Power And Chaos
Where it comes up · 18
- Steve Bannon's Warning On China's Trade War4 claims
- Apocalypse Now? Peter Thiel on Ancient Prophecies and Modern Tech2 claims
- History of the Peloponnesian War: Bibliotheca Webinar2 claims
- The Geopolitics Of a Changing World by Professor Jeffrey Sachs1 claim
- Is the U.S. Destined For War with China?1 claim
- Ray Dalio on Career, Market Cycles, China Debt1 claim
- Shadi Bartsch1 claim
- The Truth About China That The West Gets Wrong1 claim
and 10 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “Thucydides trap” →
- Avoiding major conflict with China starts with clear red lines on both sides: the US must hold a hard red line that China will not annex Taiwan by force for the foreseeable future, while prudently maintaining its decades-old quiet deference to the one China policy (since formally recognizing Taiwan as independent would be China's red line); the Thucydides trap is a theory, not a law of physics, and conflict is not inevitable.Vivek Ramaswamy
- The security dilemma (Thucydides Trap) between rising China and declining US is not inevitable—China recognized it decades ago and built resiliency accordingly, while the US only recently began to view China as a threat; the outcome depends on whether US develops embedded optionalityThe Truth About China That The West Gets Wrong
- The foundation of war is economics, and since the US has been the dominant economic power since ~1890 while China's economy may become two to three times larger, the situation parallels the Thucydides Trap of Athens and Sparta, where both sides saw the clash coming yet could not avoid it.Elon Musk #4
- Recent unrest in Kenya sparked by a finance bill intended to raise taxes to repay IMF loans, with casualties on the street, is a sign of the toxic political and geopolitical combination emerging globally: a mix of sovereign debt, scarcer/dearer resources, peak cheap oil, a rising power vs. incumbent dynamic (Thucydides Trap), and major policy mistakes by Western governments.How a stronger USD pushes the US further into fiscal dominance, and vice versa
- The Thucydides trap—when a rising power confronts an established power, war results—is presented as a timeless, eternal pattern, exemplified by Athens vs. Sparta, or Wilhelmine Germany vs. Britain, or contemporary China vs. the US. This timelessness reflects a cyclical view of history where particulars don't matterApocalypse Now? Peter Thiel on Ancient Prophecies and Modern Tech
- The Thucydides Trap is a concept describing historical tensions when a rising power challenges an existing dominant power; Graham Allison's book 'Destined for War' examines this relationship with China and the U.S., drawing from historical precedent.Ray Dalio on Career, Market Cycles, China Debt
- Regarding the Thucydides Trap, the Chinese intellectuals Bartsch studies see themselves as the aggressed-against—casting China as the rising Athens and the US as an anxious Sparta seeking to squash it—reflecting a belief that the West is invested in preventing China from becoming a global power on par with it, which Bartsch regards as an inevitable development.Shadi Bartsch
- Technological convergence—where poor countries narrow the capability and income gap with rich countries—paradoxically increases the risk of great power wars because rising powers compete more aggressively to achieve dominance, triggering the Thucydides Trap where incumbent powers fear being overtaken while rising powers fear being contained.The Geopolitics Of a Changing World by Professor Jeffrey Sachs
- The Thucydides trap—where a rising power (China) leads an incumbent power (US) into conflict as Athens and Sparta did—is a real danger given China's growing self-confidence, economic expansion, one-belt-one-road strategy, and the more combative US national security strategy; though history also shows rising and incumbent powers sometimes avoid war, so the danger is not destiny.117 - Networks Power And Chaos
- The great challenge for the United States in response to China's rise is how to live in a world where China is a peer competitor, determining what forms of cooperation and rivalry will exist, as framed by Graham Allison's 'Thucydides Trap,' rather than responding through military buildup or becoming more defensive."What China Will Be Like As A Great Power" : Martin Jacques Keynote (32nd Annual Camden Conference)