
History of the Peloponnesian War: Bibliotheca Webinar
What this covers
This hour-long webinar is a single-speaker lecture by Michael Sugrue on Thucydides' account of the Peloponnesian War. Sugrue begins with the historian's method: no poetic or divine causation, numbers that are often inflated but not invented, and speeches reconstructed from the stock rhetorical training that all Greek elites shared. He admits Thucydides' loyalty to Athens colored the work, but points to the fair treatment of the Spartan commander Brasidas as evidence of rigor. The lecture then follows the war's causes and course, using the narrative to ask what it shows about political order and human nature.
On causes, Sugrue sets the quarrel over Corinth aside as a pretext. He puts the real cause in a rising Athens and an established Sparta frightened of it, a pattern often called the Thucydides Trap. He traces how the Delian League turned from shared defense into a tribute system and a kind of protection racket. He also covers the alignment of Athenian democrats and Spartan oligarchs, the Spartan refusal to wall their city out of pride, and the collapse of Corcyra as an example of how fragile shared trust is. He adds a vignette of barbarian raiders massacring schoolboys, offered as war's meaningless brutality.
The more contentious material comes later. Sugrue reads the Melian Dialogue as the point where Athens openly discards moral argument in favor of force. He blames the demagogues who followed Pericles for the Sicilian Expedition, citing the violation of the rule against dividing one's forces and the Athenians' poor sense of Sicily's scale. Much of the colorful detail concerns Alcibiades: the mutilation of the Hermae, his flight to Sparta and then Persia, and the honors he took from Socrates. Sugrue closes on broader claims. Technical power has outrun moral understanding, Hubris undid a civilization too clever for its own good, and the abolition of slavery and the emancipation of women are the West's two real moral advances.
Thucydides presents the Peloponnesian War as a rational, non-mythological account of power politics driven by human nature and force rather than morality or divine intervention, offering enduring lessons about political order, hubris, and the tragic consequences of miscalculation.
- Thucydides was the first genuine social scientist who rejected mythological explanations and analyzed human affairs through observable causes and effects
- The war resulted from rising Athenian power threatening established Spartan dominance, leading to inherent instability that no moral framework could prevent
- Human nature remains unchanging across time, making the Peloponnesian War a cyclical pattern that recurs when similar circumstances align
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Thucydides was the first genuine social scientist in the western tradition because he rejected poetic and mythological references, eliminated divine explanations from historical causation, and analyzed human affairs through observable facts and rational causes.
“vicinities can be thought of as the first genuine uh social scientist in the western tradition and what that means is he's going to leave out as much of the poetic references as he can in other words he doesn't believe in magic or in the uh miraculous religious traditions that have been sold by the poets over the centuries he wants facts and he doesn't allow for divine uh influence on human affairs”
Our technical abilities have greatly outstripped our moral understanding; we can destroy entire cities but our capacity to restrain our aggressive impulses remains dodgy and uncertain.
“one of the great problems of our age is the fact that our technical abilities have greatly outstripped our moral understanding we can do a tremendous number of things that we couldn't do before like destroy entire cities um but our capacity to restrain our aggressive impulses while thank god we haven't used nukes since the second world war but our capacity is always dodgy and always uncertain”
Thucydides illustrates the meaningless brutality of war through a vignette in which non-Greek barbarians, arriving at a Greek city-state looking for combat, found only a schoolhouse with teachers and boys, whom they impaled and slashed to death—an event that achieved nothing militarily yet devastated lives.
“celebrations who the greeks would have regarded as barbarians tried to join in the peloponnesian fight...they landed at uh a greek city-state but there was no one there to fight they had not gotten the right information but they had come with the intention of killing things so they looked around and what they found first was a schoolhouse full of teachers and school boys and they masturbated and then the city just goes on with the story the main point of the main story of the war um that little vignette meant nothing militarily it made no sense it was achieved nothing and yet what it meant is that a bunch of children and a couple of teachers got impale and slash the death welcome to war”
Civilization is rare and fragile; the Athenians were so civilized that they outsmarted themselves through hubris and arrogance, proving their own undoing rather than being defeated by superior force.
“he says look civilization is a rare and fragile plant we are lucky to have created the great thing that we have and the problem is that our we were so civilized we outgoing ourselves we fooled ourselves our hubris and our arrogance proved our undoing”
Thucydides' constructed speeches for historical actors he did not witness were not arbitrary fabrication but rather reasonable reconstructions based on Greek rhetorical training shared by all elites, who learned identical stock forms and could be expected to argue using common templates.
“vicinities was educated by sardis and so were the elites throughout the greek world and that meant that they all learned rhetoric in the same way and so when given a situation trying to work out some diplomatic do or create a troops or something they had a set of stock forms that they were just filling with the details and so the cities wasn't actually stretching the truth too far when he just constructed speeches for both sides arguing their point”
The Delian League was established by Athens and Greek islands for common defense; initially islands contributed sailors and ships, but over time this became a financial tribute system where the Athenians took the money and hired mercenaries, which evolved into a protection racket.
“what athens did was create what cult was called the delian league named after the island of delos and a whole bunch of islands got together with athens greek islands and they said look we're going to unite for common defense and we're all going to kick in a pro-rated amount of sailors and ships...well that sounds good to begin with but over time it turns into a shakedown it's a protection racket they're not really in danger of being invaded but when these city-states say well we'd like to end this now we don't think we should send any more money to you the athenians say um we have a very big navy and we can help you change your mind”
The West has made two genuine achievements: the abolition of slavery and the emancipation of women, which could not have been done in the ancient world and are only possible in modernity.
“i think that the progress of the last couple of hundred years has been genuine look at what the west has done these are two they're two great achievements one is the abolition of slavery and the other is the is the emancipation of women and those are genuine achievements that couldn't have been done in the ancient world that's only possible in modernity once we get to the age of the machine”
Thucydides argues that all societies have either overt or covert separation and chasm between rich and poor, and every society wanting to sustain itself must work to bridge this chasm.
“thucydides says that all societies are either overtly or covertly they have a separation of uh a chasm between rich and poor and every society that wants to sustain itself is gonna have to do what it can to bridge that chasm”
Alcibiades was given military honors that belonged to Socrates; Socrates refused them and gave them to Alcibiades, and years later Alcibiades used those honors to claim he was a decorated war hero when proposing the Sicilian invasion.
“alcibiades was given military honors that actually belonged to socrates uh they were both fighting uh on the athenian side in an earlier engagement socrates says i'm not interested in metals you can keep them give them to the sydneys he really likes them so they gave him to the vicinities the city some years later comes up and proposes the sicilian expedition says that he's a decorated war hero which he sort of is but he didn't do anything to deserve it”
Alcibiades and his friends defaced and destroyed the Hermae (household gods) in Athens the night before the Sicilian expedition, committing sacrilege; he was indicted for this capital offense and fled, eventually running to Sparta.
“before they go he and his friends go on a wild drunk the night before they set sail for sicily and they destroyed the herme herme are household gods...alcibiades at the head of a whole bunch of drunken revelers they defaced and destroyed these household gods...they were singing and vandalizing and generally acting stupid...the next morning...people came out and looked around and saw that the household gods had been destroyed...it eventually comes out that alcibiades is the ringleader...the city gets together they indict alcibiades for sacrilege which is a capital offense”
Alcibiades subsequently turned on Sparta as well, fleeing to Persia and offering to make the Persians masters of Greece if they made him warlord; eventually someone killed him, and he 'really had it coming.'
“when the spartans realized that he had turned on them too he split again this time he went to persia and offered a chance for the persians to invade greece if they made him war lord of all of greece no one knows what happened to him then we only hear that somebody killed him and no doubt he really had it coming”
Power politics and Realpolitik are not modern inventions beginning with Bismarck; they are at least 5,000 years old and Thucydides provides the first solid rational account of these dynamics.
“real politics did not begin with bismarck it has been around since war and politics had existed at all certainly it's 5 000 years old the first good solid uh rational account of power politics comes from thucydides”
Thucydides did not look at matters in terms of right and wrong in politics but rather in terms of winners and losers, understanding nature as amoral predation where some societies become predatory and consume others.
“the simple facts of of life in other words he uh the citizens doesn't think about politics in terms of right and wrong he thinks of it in terms of winners and losers big fish and little fish hawks and sparrows and he says look in the same way that nature doesn't feel bad about creating predatory animals human life means that some societies will end up being predatory and consuming the others uh it's all one it's all part of the same nature”
Political order is fragile and evanescent; it requires shared trust and a sense of community, and without these, destructive patterns easily emerge and grow, as demonstrated by the collapse of Corcyra.
“the danger here is that we take political order for granted it is fragile it is evanescent it requires that we have trust in other people if you don't have a shared sense of community um it's easy for a destructive uh pattern to emerge and grow”
The Peloponnesian War was not caused by the ostensible conflict over Corinth but rather by the rising power of Athens and the established power of Sparta fearing a dangerous up-and-coming rival, making the Spartan ultimatum the true cause.
“thucydides says the the ostensible cause of the war was a conflict surrounding corinth that both of the big powers got involved but he says that's not the real reason...the spartans decided that athens was getting too big and too strong it was getting more dangerous by the day and they were going to have to fight them sooner or later so the spartans decided to issue an ultimatum to the athenians and that caused the war to commence”
Thucydides' allegiance to Athens inevitably biased his work, but his effort not to demonize the other side and his fair treatment of Spartan leaders like Brasidas demonstrates professional historical rigor.
“do you believe that thucydides allegiance to athens biased his work um it couldn't help but bias it and yet i think that that one of the things that makes this such an impressive work is that he's doing his best not to demonize the other side in other words they're just people engaged in uh conflict like his side and so he treats uh spartan leaders like brassitus very well and he treat and he shows them to be more than capable military men”
The Athenians did not realize the massive scale of Sicily because cartography was still primitive and most voting citizens were illiterate, so they could not comprehend that Sicily was far larger than Athens and they were in no position to invade it while fighting the Spartans.
“you have to remember back then the art of cartography is still in its infancy if you look back up behind me i have a an old map and the greeks had even nothing like that okay um they didn't realize because gotta remember that everybody that's doing the voting the citizens they're illiterate um they don't realize how big sicily is all right so if you can i mean if you look at the size of athens and you look at a map of the med and you see how big sicily is um they are in no position to do that”
Athens thought itself exceptional and believed the rules did not apply to it, while Sparta became exceptional by organizing its entire society around war, with all men trained for combat and all other work done by enslaved peoples.
“athens certainly thinks it's exceptional right whether it deserved that or not um they they didn't believe that the rules applied to them sparta on the other hand um decided to become exceptional exceptional exceptional by focusing their entire society on war they didn't have literature they didn't have philosophy they didn't have much in the way of architecture or sculpture what they had was an extraordinarily powerful war machine because all young men were trained for war and nothing else women were expected to to give birth to warriors and all of their farming all of the craftsmanship everything else was done by slaves that they had conquered so uh spartans didn't work at the arts and crafts did not farm all they did was war”
Thucydides thinks human nature doesn't change and time is cyclical; when similar circumstances recur, people do the same things because human nature is unchanging.
“since visiting vicinities thinks that human nature doesn't change and he also thinks that time is cyclical what he says in book one is that when similar circumstances come around when the cycle continues um when people find themselves under the same circumstances they're going to do the same things because human nature is more or less unchanging”
Numbers in ancient sources are typically exaggerated, but deviations from fact are usually in the direction of exaggeration rather than invented non-events; Thucydides avoided including supernatural elements from gods and goddesses.
“usually among the angels the numbers are the first thing to get dodgy okay in other words uh a thousand means a lot and ten thousand means are a whole bunch it's not like they actually counted these guys out right so uh my sense is is that when there's a deviation from fact it's usually in the direction of exaggeration but i don't think that any non-factual things have been put into the history in other words i don't think that uh well the cities never has any of the gods and goddesses come down and help people out”
In the Melian Dialogue, the Athenians explicitly reject moral and ethical arguments, claiming only military power matters: the Melians' ethical appeals about justice and divine favor are worthless because the Athenians have a larger army and will kill everyone if not surrendered to unconditionally.
“the dialogue which vicinities didn't see buddy which he understood was between the city elders arguing about ethics and religion and morality and virtue and the athenians pointing out that none of that mattered because they had a much bigger army and that if any such nonsense prevailed uh everybody in milos was going to be killed”
After Pericles died, demagogues who were bad rulers persuaded the Athenian people to do foolish things, most notably the Sicilian invasion—the most foolish decision because it violated the military principle of never dividing your forces unless absolutely necessary.
“pericles died and he was a good a good ruler after him came demagogues that were very bad rulers that persuaded the people to do foolish things the most foolish thing they did was while fighting a war against the spartans who are a formidable force they decided that they were so much ahead and they succumbed to hubris that alcibiades the athenian persuaded the population that this would be an opportune time to invade sicily now if you know anything about military matters you never divide your forces unless it's an absolute necessity”
After the Peloponnesian War ended, Sparta emerged victorious but was unable to provide cultural leadership to Greece; the vast destruction meant an enormous loss of manpower and goods, ending the balance of power that had previously existed.
“there was no longer a balance of power once the war was over the spartans had emerged victorious but on the other hand the amount of destruction that had been done was enormous there was a loss of manpower and a loss of goods uh also there's the fact that the spartans could take political leadership in greece but they were in no position to take cultural leadership in greece”
The Spartans refused to build a wall around their city even though they had the ability to do so, as a mark of pride; they believed that if anyone wanted to invade, Spartans would kill the invaders without needing fortifications.
“one of the remarkable things about sparta is that although i had plenty of time to do so and plenty of enemies they thought about it and then decided not to build a wall around their city they said if there's anybody that wants to invade our city we don't need a wall come with us and let's dance we'll kill every mother son of you so not having a wall was a mark of pride for the spartans”
Pericles' Funeral Oration, as recorded by Thucydides, is an encomium (speech of praise) that justifies Athenian rule, culture, and greatness, and Pericles functions as a wise ruler and king in all but name despite Athens being a democracy because he can persuade crowds in wise directions
“the things that he talks about the topics are of very great importance in understanding athens uh which is of course the center of greek culture pericles funeral oration for example is a kind of encomium on athens an encoding is a speech of praise and it's early in the war a lot of young men have lost their lives their bodies have been brought back and this and thucydides puts in pericles mound because he's an admirable speaker and politician uh a justification for athenian rule and for athenian culture and for athenian greatness”
The Athenians supported democrats because the poor wanted power, while the Spartans supported oligarchs; it made sense that Athens would support the democrats and that Sparta would support whoever Athens opposed.
“thucydides says that the poor were democrats because they wanted their they wanted power the rich were oligarchs they wanted a more aristocratic form of government and uh it made sense that the athenians would support the democrats and it also made sense that the spartans would support anybody that was not supported by the athenians”
A generation earlier, at Thermopylae (480 BC) and the naval battle of Salamis, the Persians had attempted to invade Greece but were stopped by the Spartans and Athenians respectively, which led all Greeks to maintain standing armies and especially navies for common defense.
“a generation earlier uh in 490 and 480 the persians had attempted to invade greece they had been stopped at thermopylae by the spartans and the great naval battle solomons in 480 they were stopped by the athenians and ultimately that rolled back the spartan danger now the reason why that was important is that thereafter the greeks all thought it would be a good idea to maintain a standing army but especially especially a standing navy”
The Ionian scientists of the sixth century created the world's first scientific revolution by developing non-mythological accounts of nature; Thales, Anaximander, Anaxiomenes, Empedocles, and Democritus led this revolution.
“here i'm talking about the sixth century in ionia the ionia is the little islands between turkey and greece okay what they put together there was the world's first scientific revolution it was uh led by a man named thales he had some uh some uh followers named anaximander an aneximonies and then there was a whole bunch that came after that like empedocles and democritus”
In the Corcyra civil war, words changed their ordinary meanings, communication broke down, trust disintegrated, and the political order collapsed as rich oligarchs backed by Sparta and poor democrats backed by Athens destroyed the city until nearly everyone was dead.
“thucydides also talks about civil war and the civil war corsair is one of the most frightening uh events that these entities narrates and what he says is words change their ordinary meanings and as a result people could no longer communicate trust broke down and two factions the rich and the poor which were backed by athens and sparta...at the end of the civil war the entire city had been destroyed almost everyone was dead”
Thucydides died before finishing the History of the Peloponnesian War, but the last two books show his compositional process: he first wrote the narrative events and only later inserted speeches, leaving those final books without the reconstructed speeches.
“you can see the process by which he composes because in the last two books which are the ones that are that he did last the speeches haven't been put in yet so what he did was write his history and then he'd go and put and write speeches to put into the mouths of the people that he was talking about the last two books don't have the speeches yet and the war hadn't ended when he died but the writing was on the wall it was very clear what was going to happen”
Alcibiades catalyzed the Sicilian expedition through his catastrophic proposal; although he did not stay for the catastrophe, the soldiers he sent were destroyed—either killed or captured and enslaved in an open-air pit—leaving Athens defenseless.
“he catalyzes the war because he comes up with this great idea right it's a catastrophic idea um he doesn't stay for the catastrophe but all of his uh all of the soldiers that had landed in sicily they were either killed and those that were captured were put in an open-air pit mine and from there um they were eventually destroyed they either killed themselves or were killed by the uh sicilians”
Graduate students in international relations typically begin their studies with the Melian Dialogue from Thucydides as an introduction to power politics and Realpolitik.
“generally speaking if you go to graduate school in ir one of the first readings you're going to get is the million dialogue from vicinities and this will be your introduction to power politics real politics”
The Thucydides Trap—the inevitability or strong likelihood of war between an established hegemonic power and a rising power demanding equal treatment and respect—is now far more dangerous due to technological amplification of military destruction than in ancient times.
“something called the thucydides trap has been discussed in both washington and beijing of late it's the inevitability or strong likelihood at least of war between an established hegemonic power like the us and a rising power that wishes to be treated as an equal and demands respect in the case of china it could the situation itself could produce a war that nobody wants and that neither side would actually benefit from our technological amplification of military destruction makes the vicinity strap far more dangerous now than it ever has been”
After Athens destroyed its own army and navy in Sicily, rebellions among formerly tributary states became possible because Athens could no longer use force to suppress them, as demonstrated with Melos and other cities
“this is a big problem and this causes many of the clients of athens to want to side with the spartans but they're afraid to do so on the other hand once once athens destroys its own army and navy you'll see a whole bunch of rebellions and they won't be able to support to uh crush it the way they did with the island of milos”
World War II produced 60 million casualties, a number unthinkable in the ancient world, demonstrating how technological advancement amplifies capacity for destruction.
“if you look at the second world war there's 60 million casualties um that's a number unthinkable in the ancient world”
The Athenians completely destroyed Melos: they killed every Melian male, raped and enslaved all the women and children, and replaced the population with 500 Athenian colonists, so that Melos no longer exists and has no desk at the United Nations.
“the athenians broke through they killed every athenian man but ever every million male the women were raped and sold into slavery along with the children and then when the city was completely empty 500 new athenian uh colonists came and then there were no more millions so if you go to the u.n now and you look around at the desks of various countries there's no desk for milos because they're all dead”
While humans have not stockpiled nuclear weapons with the intention of not using them, the major nuclear powers (Russia, China, US) are likely to be responsible in deployment, but small actors like Iran or North Korea could be the unpredictable variable that breaks the threshold.
“i don't stockpile nuclear any kind of weapon with the intention of not using it and so while i think the russians of the chinese and the americans are likely to be responsible in the deployment of nukes it's the small actors like iran or north korea that could be the fly in the ointment they could break that and uh who knows what happens once we break that through that threshold”
Pericles' funeral oration and Lincoln's Gettysburg Address are structurally similar: both are heads of state of democratic regimes justifying the bloodshed and sacrifice required to maintain their society to the honored dead and future generations.
“very similar and so uh in situation in the content to lincoln's gettysburg address in both cases you had heads of state of democratic regimes trying to justify the bloodshed and sacrifice that was inevitably a part of fighting to maintain their society so both lincoln and pericles had to create uh a justification for the honored dead before them and a justification for the future sacrifices which inevitably were going to be made”
Alcibiades was raised in a moral vacuum and exemplifies what happens when people are educated by sophists who teach that winning matters, not being right.
“alcibiades is a good example of what happens if you raise people with uh in a moral vacuum all right and that's one of the possible outcomes that we see with the education provided by sophists it's all about winning not about being right”
If politics is an attempt to create social order and advantage, the destruction of Melos—killing all males, enslaving women and children—is not acceptable and shows the limitations of morality when applied to power politics.
“if politics is an attempt to create social order and social advantage if you look at what happened to the millions when they all get killed and all the women and children are sold into slavery well um whatever we're trying to do in politics that's not it right so this is what we're not to do and the fact that this is not a moral conflict but rather a conflict simply of one power against another tells you the limit gives you a sense of the limitations of morality when it's applied to politics”
Plato's Republic is an attempt to rejoin the connection between politics and ethics that was lost during the Peloponnesian War, which created a disjunction between moral reasoning and political action.
“there's a good argument to make that plato's republic is an attempt to rejoin that connection between politics and ethics that we had lost during the peloponnesian war”
It is not accidental that Thucydides was educated by sophists; this education shaped his amoral, realist approach to analyzing politics as pure power dynamics.
“it's not an accident that thucydides was educated by sophists that's really i didn't know his history so that that adds on to that thank you for that”
Anaxagoras replaced the mythological account that the sun is Apollo's golden chariot with the scientific account that the sun is a hot rock, which had profound implications for truth-telling and oath-swearing in court.
“a scientist named annex sagaris came up with the idea that the sun is not apollo's golden chariot but rather that it's a hot rock now you may wonder what the difference is why that makes any difference well here's the thing if the sun is apollo's golden chariot when you get sworn in to give testimony at a greek court you'll be sworn in not on the bible because that doesn't exist yet you'll be sworn in on apollo's golden chariot now apollo sees all and knows all and at the end of every day he goes back to mount olympus and tells zeus who's been naughty and who's been nice particularly those that have perjured themselves and if you believe in that myth you will tell the truth when you give testimony now once you get educated by annex sagaras and he tells you that the sun is a hot rock what what that means is that the hot rock doesn't care whether you tell the truth or not”
The Thucydides Trap is a matter of concern in both Washington and Beijing because policymakers educated in classical literature understand the Peloponnesian War pattern and perceive it as instructive for contemporary US-China relations.
“this is part of the reason why um the thucydides trap has been a such concern in both washington and beijing i assume that in washington many of the people there have gotten a classical education so they know who the cities is so they don't have a problem understanding what the the issue is i'm also confident that there are people working for the chinese government who are trying to figure out the mindset of washington policymakers who came upon thucydides and were impressed at how much there was to learn from this”
Thucydides rejects the poetic tradition that imagined a golden age followed by decline through silver and bronze/iron ages, arguing instead that in ancient times life was primitive and dangerous, and civilization is a rare and fragile plant.
“he's only going to include facts in his history and his the first thing he wants to do is get rid of the poet tradition which suggested that in the beginning there was a golden age and then we declined to a silver age and then to a an iron or bronze age and the city says that's nonsense it's straightforwardly backwards in other words in ancient times life was really primitive and dangerous uh his description of life is very much like bob's state of nature so he says look civilization is a rare and fragile plant”
Thucydides is best read slowly and carefully; he is not appropriate for young readers focused on exams but rewards patient, mature engagement, revealing him as a straight-ahead genius in political science aware of uncertainty, force, and the connection between politics and ethics.
“thucydides is not for young people i read it when i was 18 or 19 in college and you know all i wanted to know was is this going to be on the exam i read it again when i was actually i was on a a yacht cruising the aegean from island island for three weeks and all i did was i brought the cities with me and i read it slowly and carefully the guy's a straight straight ahead genius uh he's a political scientist who is very very aware of the uncertainty of human affairs and of the importance of force and uh of the connection between politics and ethics”
Historians cannot predict the future any better than anyone else, and those claiming predictive expertise should be ignored unless they are willing to bet money on their predictions (since investing in stock market requires true predictive ability).
“it's very dangerous to ask historians what they think is going to happen because they don't know any better than anybody else if i actually did i'd be investing in the stock market but as it turns out”
Thucydides was an Athenian general who wrote the History of the Peloponnesian War, which lasted from 431 to 404 BC and resulted in Athenian defeat despite their wealth, culture, and capability.
“thucydides was an athenian general and the peloponnesian war which he writes about went from 431 to 404 bc and the athenians lost”
The antagonism and backbiting in the contemporary United States has become so shrill and counterproductive that the next administration's job one must be to find reconciliation; without it, potential exists for real danger, including upsurges in political violence.
“i am very concerned about the state of the us um i think that the antagonism and the uh backbiting has become so shrill and so uh counterproductive that job one for the next administration when they come in in january is gonna have to be to find some kind of reconciliation if uh the conflict if the racial conflict or the ideological conflicts that we have in america continue um the potential is there for real danger i don't think that civil war is a likely possibility we tried that once and i don't think anybody wants to go back to that but an upsurge in political violence is entirely possible like we saw in the 60s”
Following Pericles' idealized vision of Athens in the Funeral Oration, Thucydides describes the devastating plague that struck Athens and Greece, killing many and disrupting both military operations and civil order.
“it's very interesting that right after the funeral oration pericles or rather pericles idealized city becomes only too real thucydides they were accounts the plague in athens and the plague was devastating not just athens but to all of greece”
Thucydides' Plato Symposium is the second greatest dialogue ever written and it ends with Alcibiades giving an encomium (speech of praise) about Socrates.
“plato's symposium is a dialogue because that's what plato writes it's the second greatest dialogue ever written and it ends with alcibiades giving an encomium a speech of praise about socrates”
In the fifth century, Athens experienced a flowering of drama with great tragic and comic writers, historians, architects, sculptors, and painters—a golden age of culture.
“periclean athens this is fourth century athens okay or actually fifth century fifth century again essentially right periclean has this fifth century um they have uh a flowering of drama so we get the great tragic writers we get the great comic writers we're going to get some great historians we're also going to get great architecture like we're also going to get great statues and painting in other words every kind of culture flourishes in athens”
The plague in Athens came and went without permanent effect on the war, but it forced Athens to minimize military operations and required them to hold their society together via the protective wall around the city.
“it came and it went so it didn't have a permanent effect on the war but the year that it arrived uh the athenians had to minimize their operations and try and hold their society together they had built a wall around their city and that was a big uh that was a big element in keeping the spartans out”