
How a stronger USD pushes the US further into fiscal dominance, and vice versa
What this covers
In this 34-minute talk, Luke Growman works through how the US arrived at its current fiscal position and what the exits look like. He defines fiscal dominance as the point where true interest expense, meaning gross interest plus entitlements, reaches about 95% of tax receipts. The Fed then has three options: let Treasury auctions fail, cut entitlements permanently, or create dollars. He argues the third is the only one that will actually be chosen. Supporting figures include a $10–30 trillion effective eurodollar short, about $8 trillion of foreign-held Treasuries, and the 2015 episode when China sold Treasuries to defend its currency.
The range is wide. Historical analogies include the 1968 foreign demand for gold that closed the gold window, Weimar Germany's hyperinflation, and the 1929 crash restated in gold terms. The talk also covers the Q3 2022 Treasury selloff, the claim that federal outlays alone prevent a nominal recession, and the idea of "dollar Dutch disease," in which financial strength hollowed out manufacturing and the defense industrial base. Unrest in Kenya over an IMF-linked tax bill is offered as an early sign of a broader sovereign-debt and resource-scarcity squeeze. He also gives screening criteria for which emerging economies might face currency crises next.
The more contested material is forward-looking. He expects the $130 trillion bond market to move eventually into stocks, gold, Bitcoin and commodities. He expects rates to be managed rather than left to rise, and gold to become a neutral settlement asset without any return to a gold standard. He suggests gold could rise from roughly 30 barrels of oil per ounce toward 100 or more. His practical advice is to avoid long-dated Western sovereign debt, since those governments need negative real rates to function.
Growman argues that fiscal dominance in the US is mechanically driven by dollar strength, which triggers a debt spiral: strong dollar → foreign selling of treasuries → rising rates → weaker US growth → declining tax receipts, forcing the Fed to eventually print money; therefore, the dollar's level is the critical transmission mechanism for whether the US can sustain current spending or faces a fiscal crisis.
- Strong dollar creates short squeeze on the $10-30 trillion eurodollar short position, forcing foreign treasury sales to defend currencies
- Once true interest expense exceeds 95% of tax receipts, the debt spiral self-reinforces and pushes the US into fiscal dominance requiring either entitlement cuts, treasury auction failures, or monetary injection
- The US cannot afford sustained stock price declines (which feed tax receipts) so the Fed will always choose to print rather than tighten into fiscal dominance
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
In 1968, foreign creditors of the United States, primarily centered in Europe, began demanding gold in exchange for their dollars in response to US guns and butter deficits, and these foreign policy actions forced the US to close the gold window and wind down escalations in Vietnam.
“a little bit further back in 1968 you saw foreign creditors of the United States primarily centered in Europe at that time begin to say here's our dollars we want gold in response to us guns and butter deficits uh and ultimately there is a view that those actions forced the US to close the gold window forced the us out of Vietnam or to begin winding down the escalations certainly uh to Bas basically as a result of the pressures those things were putting those uh foreign policy uh moves were putting on the US fiscal position”
In the Weimar hyperinflation, people in Vicar Germany dumped gold multiple times to buy reichsmarks because they believed the German government would cut spending, reduce war reparations, the Reichsbank would do quantitative tightening, or fight inflation—showing that political and fiscal expectations can override fundamental logic even in currency collapses.
“these are political situations four or five different times people in viar Germany as the currency was going to zero against gold dumped gold to buy reich's marks because they believed the equivalent of the German government's going to cut spending or the latest War reparations under the Daw plan is is is going to reduce the burden or the reich's bank going to do qt or they're going to fight inflation blah blah blah blah blah and blah blah blah blah blah”
Recent unrest in Kenya sparked by a finance bill intended to raise taxes to repay IMF loans, with casualties on the street, is a sign of the toxic political and geopolitical combination emerging globally: a mix of sovereign debt, scarcer/dearer resources, peak cheap oil, a rising power vs. incumbent dynamic (Thucydides Trap), and major policy mistakes by Western governments.
“recent unrest in Kenya sparked by a finance bill that would have raise taxes to payback IMF loans is this sign of things to come is the global sovereign debt bubble finally coming home to roost with Innocent Canyons dead on the street some of the first real casualties of too much debt who or what is next uh possibly sadly you've got a mix of lots of sovereign debt you've got scar SL scarcer SL dearer resources Peak cheap oil uh you've got a situation that is historically uh rare of a rising power versus an incumbent the the the thusi Trap uh Dynamic uh you've got very major mistakes made by very powerful people and policy makers in the incumbent places anglo-american and and Western governments in particular when you blend all those things up together you have a very toxic political and geopolitical combination”
Since 2014, when global central banks stopped growing holdings of treasuries and began buying gold, the Fed and US banking system have expanded their balance sheet from $4 trillion to $8-9 trillion at peak to finance US deficits by taking up the slack that foreign central banks left.
“if we go back to 2014 when Global central banks stopped growing Holdings of treasuries uh and began buying gold in theory that's that's very similar to what happened in 1968 back then we had to get off the gold standard and we inflated um after we went off the gold standard this time we can see the fed's balance sheet 2014 versus 2024 uh it's it went from 4 trillion forign change trillion in 2014 uh to what 89 trillion at Peak so fed and the US banking system uh have taken up a lot of the slack in terms of financing us deficits once Global central banks stopped doing so on net in the third quarter of 2014”
Dollar weakness has the opposite effect: it reduces pressure on foreign currencies, foreigners no longer need to sell treasuries to defend currencies, global growth accelerates, US asset prices rise, tax receipts accelerate, and treasury issuance falls.
“the flip side is also true you weaken the dollar you increase room you know foreigners that are short if the dollar goes down they have more room Global growth acceler Ates us receipts accelerate us asset prices accelerate uh us issuance Falls foreign selling of treasuries Falls”
The United States will not return to a gold standard because there is zero chance of that happening, but gold is becoming a new neutral reserve asset for settling net energy and commodity-related deficits globally regardless of what the US wants to do.
“in my opinion the United States will not go back to a gold standard I think there's zero chance of that uh I do think gold is becoming a new neutral Reserve asset for settling net energy and commodity related deficits globally regardless of what the United States thinks or wants to do”
Fiscal dominance occurs when true interest expense (gross interest expense plus entitlement payouts) reaches 95% of tax receipts and rises toward 100%, at which point the Fed faces a choice: stand aside and let treasury auctions fail, slash entitlements immediately and permanently, or inject dollar liquidity (print money) to finance treasuries and entitlements.
“the easiest way to think about fiscal dominance is that is in the context of this uh true interest expense as a percent of tax receipts that we have this number we've cited over and over and over which is gross interest expense of the United States plus entitlement pay goes of the United States as a percent of tax receipts once that ratio gets to 95% on its way to 100% the dollar starts Rising as us deficits crowd out Global markets and that touches off this debt spiral that then feeds back into the us as rates go up and receipts go down you go over 100% it puts the us into a fiscal dominance position where the FED has a choice stand aside and let treasury auctions fail or the US has to slash entitlement spending immediately and permanently to make room for interest or the FED Andor treasury need to inject dollar liquidity print money however you want to do it”
Nobody knows what the trigger will be to spook the bond market (could be a fiscal report, election outcome, etc.), but the key insight is that the $130 trillion bond market, full of very smart people, will not sit still and watch its purchasing power destroyed year after year, so capital flight from bonds is inevitable, it just hasn't happened yet.
“nobody knows what the trigger is to Spook the bond market it could be a fiscal report it could be an election outcome who knows you just don't know the math everybody knows the math and everybody's looking around waiting for somebody else to panic first the one thing I feel very strongly about though and this will be very difficult if you're trying to trade a month a book month to month because you can't care about this until it's right there but slow inflation forever implies that $130 trillion bond market managed by very smart people are going to sit around and let their wealth collapse slowly on a real basis over time in my view that's simply not going to happen”
I don't foresee a realistic scenario of a sustained US market crash or financial crisis unless the United States is willing to stand aside and let treasury markets dysfunction to the point of sustained treasury auction failures that drive interest rates up and force the US government to slash defense and entitlement spending, which has zero chance of happening.
“in short no I don't uh I don't foresee a realistic scenario unless unless the United States is willing to stand aside and let treasury markets dysfunction to the point of con sustained treasury auction failures that drive interest rates up and force the US government to slash defense and entitlement spending to make room for interest payments I see Zero chance of that happening”
The US is not intentionally trying to move away from reserve currency status, but parts of the US establishment have been trying to change the primary global reserve asset from treasuries to other assets by discrediting treasuries as a safe haven.
“I do not believe the US is trying to and the reserve currency status of the dollar in my opinion I do think parts of the US establishment have been trying to change the primary Global Reserve asset of treasuries uh essentially uh by discrediting them as a safe haven asset for foreigners”
The United States has 'dollar Dutch disease': it has become very good at producing dollars through the financial system but very poor at producing manufactured goods, and this has hollowed out the defense industrial base, making it a national security issue to restore manufacturing capacity.
“the United States has US dollar Dutch disease you can find an article about this in the Ft in 2019 we are the Saudi Arabia of dollars which means we have gotten very good at producing dollars but we're not uh very good at producing much else anymore that is all fun in games early on but then when you have to fight a war in Europe against Russia who's on10th your size of GDP and all of a sudden you find the Russians are out producing you you can't make shells and missiles enough”
Markets are starting to realize that in a world with 120% debt-to-GDP and 7% structural deficits at full employment, the traditional bond market cannot own long-term sovereign debt because the real return will be negative, so capital will shift into harder assets like stocks, gold, Bitcoin, and commodities.
“you can't own long-term Bonds in that world you can't how can you possibly own long-term Bonds in that world so you're going to start to see the $130 trillion bond market come to the realization oh my gosh the rules are different 120% debt to GDP in the world's Reserve currency with 7% structural deficits at full employment in the world's Reserve currency I can't own long-term sovereign debt I need to get into assets that better hold purchasing power stocks gold Bitcoin Commodities”
The 1929 crash saw the Dow fall 85% from 1929 to 1933, but because the dollar was pegged to gold at $20 per ounce, the Dow didn't fall against the dollar—it fell against gold; similarly, the Dow is down 20% since summer 2019 in gold terms, down 60% since 2000's peak in gold terms, and down 50% since 1966 in gold terms, while being up massively in dollar terms.
“it highlights a really important point which is a lot of people say hey the 29 crash the Dow fell whatever 85% from 29 to 33 but the dollar was pegged to gold at 20 bucks an ounce so the Dow didn't fall against the dollar the Dow F Dow fell against gold 85% the Dow's down 20 % since summer 2019 in Gold terms up in dollar terms uh it's down the Dow is down 60% since 2000's peak in Gold terms obviously it's up massively in dollar terms uh the Dow is down 50% since 1966 in Gold terms obviously up massively in dollar terms”
In 2015, China sold a lot of treasuries to defend its currency when the dollar was strong, and this example is still very relevant to current fiscal dominance dynamics because foreigners own $8 trillion in treasuries and will sell them to defend their currencies when the dollar strengthens.
“we've seen when it's been forced recently 2015 you saw China selling uh in particular a lot of treasuries to defend their currency”
Gold is up 4x since 2008 in oil terms, rising from about 8 barrels per ounce to about 30-32 barrels per ounce, and that number will ultimately move toward 100 barrels per ounce, possibly more or even 200 barrels per ounce over time.
“gold as a result is up 4X since 2008 in oil terms it's gone from about 8 barrels an ounce to about 30 32 barrels an ounce and I think that number will ultimately move towards 100 barrels an ounce maybe more over time 200 barrels an ounce possible certainly”
Foreigners globally have borrowed approximately $13 trillion in US dollar-denominated debt according to the BIS, and the eurodollar system overall has an estimated effective dollar short position somewhere between $10-30 trillion, creating a massive short squeeze risk if the dollar strengthens.
“foreigners globally have borrowed around $13 trillion in US dollar denominated debt per the bis and the euro dollar system overall has what is estimated uh a an effective dollar short position if you will of somewhere between 10230 trillion nobody knows for sure but it's safe to say you have a very large effective dollar short position out there”
Entitlements are growing 8-12% per year from a base of $3.3 trillion, which is almost 1.5% of GDP just from that category alone, and interest expense is repricing the entire debt stack from front to back as rates rise, potentially adding another 1% of GDP growth from interest payments if rates move to 10%.
“entitlements are 3.3 trillion and they're growing 8 to 12% a year that right there is almost what one and a half per of GDP all by itself uh interest expense we're we came into the year at 3.1% interest rates on average uh I think we're at 3.4 now maybe but we're moving to the front end you're repricing the entire debt stack from front to back uh it's entirely possible that 35 trillion of debt interest at whatever it is now a trillion trillion one probably keeps growing at a two you know 20% clip for the next year um as you reprice all that debt $1.1 trillion is about 4% if you grow 20% there's another percent of GDP growth right there”
There won't be a nominal recession because US federal spending is 23% of GDP, and in April and May federal outlays were up 23% and 22% year-over-year respectively, which equals 5.1% nominal GDP growth just from the federal government, and the private sector (77% of the economy) would have to fall 6-7% just to achieve flat headline nominal GDP.
“US federal spending is 23% of GDP in April and May Federal outlays were up 23 and 22% % respectively year-over-year 22% time 23% that's 5.1% nominal GDP growth annualized just driven by the federal government the other 77% of the US economy that is the private sector that everybody's watching and that is absolutely slowing would have to fall by about 6 to 7% just to have flat headline nominal GDP”
The treasury market crashed approximately 20% in one quarter (Q3 2022) when fiscal dominance dynamics triggered, as an example of the debt spiral mechanism in action.
“it begins to feed on itself... when we saw the treasury market crash 20% in one quarter uh it begins to feed on itself”
The transition from treasuries to gold as the primary reserve asset is positive for gold prices, good for the US (reduces Dutch disease), and good for inflation, but very bad for long-duration bonds on a real basis.
“I think that's going to continue I think it's very good for the price of gold I think it's very good for the United States I think it's very good for inflation I think it's very bad for long Bonds on a real basis”
Rates cannot simply rise unchecked because the US cannot afford rising rates given the fiscal situation; rates will be managed (probably by the central bank or proxies via regulation) in an inflationary manner over time.
“the United States cannot afford for rates to just go up and up and up they will be managed probably by the central bank or its proxies via regulation Etc that is inflationary overtime”
Given the toxic political/geopolitical situation, the key recommendation is to avoid long-term Western sovereign debt, as those governments need negative real rates to keep systems functioning and lending to them for long periods is high-risk.
“ultimately when you have these situations when you have that toxic combination maybe the strongest conviction way to play that is avoid long-term Western Sovereign debt with that toxic combination the last thing you want to do is loan money to those governments for long periods of time when they need negative real rates just to keep the situation together”
For identifying which tier-2 countries might face FX crises, look for energy importers, those with twin deficits (current account and fiscal), and those with relatively low positive net international investment position or reserve position as a percent of GDP; countries that match these criteria are the most likely candidates for FX trouble.
“what I would do is I would look at the energy importers I would look at those with twin deficits and then I would look at those that have a relatively low positive net International Investment position or Reserve position as a percent of their GDP um and whatever you get by running a search or a sort on that list at the top of that those would be your candidates”
The historical reference points for US official gold as a percentage of foreign-held treasuries are: long-term average 40%, 1989 low of 20%, 1979-80 crisis high of 135%, and today's level of only 7%.
“US foreign official gold as a percent of foreign held treasuries outstanding uh long-term average is 40% 1989 it was 20% uh at the highs when there was an honest to goodness dollar crisis in 7980 it was 135% today it's 7%”
Gold could be used as a 'sweetener' for long-term US Treasury bonds: issuing longer-term treasuries at attractive interest rates with the inflation risk assuaged by a small gold kicker at a floating price, allowing investors to buy low-yielding bonds if they receive compensation for inflation risk via gold appreciation.
“I think gold could also be used as a sweetener if you will for long-term US Treasury bonds uh Judy Shelton has talked about this in the past we talked about it in our last video essentially um you would issue longer term treasuries at a very attractive interest rates with the inflation risk of those bonds assuaged by uh a little gold sweetener at a floating price in other words you can buy treasuries at a low rate if you've got a gold kicker that compensates you for the inflation risk since the bond itself only has inflation risk no credit risk”
S&P 500 relative to TLT (long Bond ETF), NASDAQ relative to TLT, gold relative to TLT, and Bitcoin relative to TLT are all hockey-sticking (sharply outperforming), which is exactly what would be expected in the fiscal dominance / unsustainable debt environment Growman describes.
“you can call up a chart call up S&P over TLT the long Bond uh the long Bond ETF call up NASDAQ over TLT call up gold over TLT call up Bitcoin over TLT it's all the same chart they're all hockey sticking which is exactly what you'd expect to see in the environment that I just laid out is happening”
Market participants have been underestimating the impact of US government spending on growth, and this has been a blind spot that Warren Mosler helped Growman recognize.
“I don't think people have been paying nearly enough attention to US government spendings impact on growth uh Visa via recession I certainly wasn't early on uh Warren Mosler really uh turned my head to that reality”
Do not borrow in fiat against gold with leverage because of the extreme volatility risk shown in the Weimar Republic hyperinflation, where the price of gold in reichsmarks rose from zero to a trillion marks in 4-5 years with such violent volatility that levered long positions were liquidated multiple times as people panicked and sold gold to buy reichsmarks.
“I once thought that and then my friend Dan Oliver had that brilliant chart shared uh a few years back I've shared it a number of times with clients which shows the price of gold in viar German Reich marks over time and it basically went from zero to a trillion reiches marks uh over a span of four or five years overlaid with the month-over-month price change in German viar reichs marks as the currency hyperinflated to zero against gold and what that chart showed was that if you were levered long gold in one of the great hyperinflations of all time you lost all your money four or five different times in four years because the volatility was so face peeling”
Given current stock valuations, a portfolio of gold plus Treasury bills (T-bills) would likely perform better over the next decade than stock-only portfolios because the total return difference between stocks and gold+T-bills is primarily the dividend yield, which is not compelling at current valuations.
“with that said yes it's not a total return index but in that case especially with valuations where they are wouldn't it make more sense to own Gold Plus T bills uh because really the total return difference is the dividend yield right so um you know given these valuations Gold Plus T bills probably uh these valuations on stocks Gold Plus T bills probably will do pretty well uh over the next call it decade”
The dysfunction in the treasury market from the strong dollar push eventually got bad enough in 3Q 2022 that Yellen needed to weaken the dollar to avoid treasury dysfunction and debt spiral issues, showing that the ultra-strong dollar strategy cannot succeed unless the US government is willing to accept treasury auction failures and widespread bank failures.
“the dysfunction in the treasury market eventually got bad enough in 3 q22 Yellen needed to weaken the dollar to avoid precisely what we just discussed in terms of the treasury dysfunction Deb spiral uh fiscal dominance issue uh and so when you think about it that way the try to break the rest of the world with the ultra strong dollar game plan cannot succeed unless the United States government is willing to stand aside and let treasury auctions fail”
In regions where bonds don't yield more than inflation (negative real rates), real estate can act as a bond proxy because rental income plus capital appreciation can provide returns better than savings accounts, and this is particularly common in East Asia where people save in overpriced real estate rather than banks.
“is real estate in the Nations where bonds don't pay more than inflation acting somewhat as a bond proxy duration you know durable won't go bankrupt plus coupon is the rent plus non-fixed face value uh unlike bonds it's pretty common in East Asia where people save an overpriced real estate rather than putting money in a bank yielding unattractive returns uh in my opinion yes that's exactly what's happen happen in particularly in luxury or sort of finite type real estate um that have lower carrying costs”
When a strong dollar triggers the debt spiral and rates rise while receipts fall, stocks decline, and stocks are critical drivers of US consumer spending and therefore tax receipts, creating a feedback loop where stock declines further reduce receipts and worsen the fiscal problem.
“once the dollar gets too strong it touches off this debt spiral it pushes true interest expense above 100% of receipts because oh by the way as foreigners sell stocks stocks go down stocks are critical drivers of us consumer spending and therefore tax receipts which we saw in 2021 22 23 on the upside and the downside and it feeds on itself”
People with close ties to Washington told Growman in mid-2022 that the plan was to take the dollar (measured by DXY) to 110-115, believing this would spur outflows of other assets into US stocks and bonds, driving prices up; however, Growman warned this was incorrect and predicted instead that the dollar would rise, the treasury market would dysfunction, and stocks would tank—which is precisely what happened.
“I definitely remember being told by um people with close ties with Washington that that was the plan in the middle of 2022 they were going to take the dollar as measured by dxy to 110 to 115 they being yelling in the treasury and that don't worry this will spur and out of other assets into US Stock Market and bonds to drive those prices up I warned those people close to Washington that that was absolutely 100% not going to be what happened rather the dollar would go up the treasury market would dysfunction and stocks would tank which is precisely what happened”
If S&P 500 reaches 50,000 (in nominal terms), gold would reach 80,000 (the 2009 ratio) and Bitcoin would reach a half million to a million dollars, illustrating that nominal price levels are meaningless without understanding the currency's purchasing power.
“S&P 50,000 one day sure but per my prior point in that world you're tough S&P 50,000 in the world you're describing that's gold 80,000 right that's a point that's that's the ratio of gold to S&P in 2009 uh bitcoin's probably a million in that world half million dollars or a million in that world”
Avoid debt like the plague; focus on understanding the fiscal balance sheet, and if you want to know what's happening now, look at the income statement; if you want to know the future, look at the balance sheet.
“the fiscal situation is a fiscal situation the balance sheet is the balance sheet you want to know what's going on now look at the income statement you want to know the future look at the balance sheet so no don't I don't want to be levered long that's why I want to avoid the plague”
John posed a scenario showing that the 1929 crash took 25 years for the S&P to recover, 1970s stagflation took 8 years, tech bubble took 16 years nominally, 2008 GFC took 6 years, but 2022 (fastest rate hikes in history with a banking crisis) recovered in just 2 years, suggesting markets are recovering faster than in prior cycles.
“John shared a really interesting table showing the 1929 crash it took the S&P 25 years to come back 70 stagflation 8 years to come back tech bubble in 2007 years to come back nominally uh 08 GFC 6 years to come back nominally 2022 fastest rate hikes in history in a banking crisis two years only”
The Jacob Fugger investment philosophy involves allocating 25% to physical gold bullion (in different locations), 25% to cash or US Treasury T-bills, 25% to stocks (with focus on positive free cash flow, good balance sheets, good franchises), and 25% to real estate (focusing on cash-flowing properties, luxury real estate in attractive locations).
“look I think you want to own 25% physical gold bullion um different locals um I think cash or essentially US Treasury T bills uh along with uh cash in the bank uh in terms of 25% stocks uh I think you want positive free cash flow good balance sheets good franchises that's what I am looking at uh I I think in terms of the gold allocation I think it's fair to say hey 25% gold 5% Bitcoin 20% gold 5% Bitcoin within that uh absolutely and uh in terms of real estate I think ultimately cash flowing is better uh luxury real estate um in areas that have some sort of um uh attractiveness to them right Lakefront houses certain areas um location location location with real estate right”
Within the portfolio, Bitcoin could be substituted for some gold allocation (5% Bitcoin, 20% gold) as an alternative hard asset with similar properties.
“I think in terms of the gold allocation I think it's fair to say hey 25% gold 5% Bitcoin 20% gold 5% Bitcoin within that uh absolutely”