tragedy of the commons
The tendency for shared, unowned resources to be overused and degraded because no individual bears the full cost of their depletion.
As defined in et_814
Other definitions
The tendency for a shared, openly accessible resource to be overused and depleted because individual users bear none of the full social cost of their use
Terry Anderson on the Environment and Property RightsAn economic problem where individuals acting in their own self-interest deplete or degrade a shared resource, resulting in a worse outcome for everyone
Luke Gromen: "Peak Cheap Oil and the Global Reserve Currency" | The Great Simplification #91
Where it comes up · 28
- Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/20113 claims
- Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/20092 claims
- Luke Gromen: "Peak Cheap Oil and the Global Reserve Currency" | The Great Simplification #912 claims
- Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism2 claims
- Robert Whaples on the Economics of Pope Francis2 claims
- Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/20072 claims
- Patri Friedman on Seasteading 10/13/20081 claim
- Decoding Media1 claim
and 20 more
Most important claims · 10 of 35Search all claims for “tragedy of the commons” →
- The colleagues who opposed the equity proposals stayed silent because they were responding to their narrow short-term interests—correctly perceiving they would be stigmatized and driven out if they stood up—but failed to realize the danger would come for them anyway; this 'activist dilemma' is a version of the tragedy of the commons or free-rider problem where everyone wants the problem solved but the best individual deal is to let someone else bear the cost, which ultimately undoes the coalitions that should form.109 - Biology And Culture
- Both the tragedy of the commons and the tragedy of the anticommons are different versions of transaction cost failures—it is difficult to negotiate with everyone to forbear (commons) or to get everyone to contribute their piece (anticommons)—and James Buchanan and Yoon proved their mathematical symmetry.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- Unlike a common pasture, which suffers the tragedy of the commons through overuse and congestion when shared freely, there is no tragedy of the intellectual commons—an idea like oral rehydration therapy can be used by everyone simultaneously with no overuse, congestion or degradation, because ideas are non-rival.Paul Romer on Growth 8/27/2007
- Before barbed wire, Montana cattlemen recognized the potential tragedy of the commons and voluntarily formed Cattlemen's Associations that carved up and wrote down customary grazing territories, enforcing them with 'line camps' where cowboys rode the boundaries—an institutional property-rights solution arising without government.Terry Anderson on the Environment and Property Rights
- Just as a tragedy of the commons (too few owners) leads to overuse of a resource, a tragedy of the anticommons (too many owners) leads to underuse, because each owner can block the others from putting the resource to any productive use.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- Many environmental problems can be solved by securing property rights, as shown by the Haiti–Dominican Republic border where trees stand on the side with enforced property rights and mud on the side without; harnessing such market techniques, along with Elinor Ostrom's research on commons governance, offers solutions that make lives both better and more virtuous, which the encyclical missed.Robert Whaples on the Economics of Pope Francis
- The euro crisis is a classic tragedy of the commons and free-rider problem: each healthy nation would prefer not to pay for irresponsible ones, but the shared currency means the whole group goes over a cliff together.Tyler Cowen on the European Crisis 12/05/2011
- Communities lacking third-party enforcement do settle on norms (like not taking baby lobsters or not overgrazing) to avoid the Tragedy of the Commons, but these norms are nonetheless enforced—by gossip that damages reputation and by occasional anonymous threats or symbolic vandalism such as cutting loose an overfishing lobsterman's trap floats.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Dense places have real negative amenities such as congestion, competition for parking and public services, pollution, and overuse of public spaces, yet New Yorkers emit far less carbon per capita than residents of lower-density places because they share walls and heat efficiently, so density is not uniformly worse environmentally.Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/2011
- Climate has been hard to act on because it is the canonical tragedy of the commons: negative externalities are diffuse, long-term, and hard to attribute to specific causes, unlike acute crises such as the Manhattan Project or Operation Warp Speed.Carbon Removal