
Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/2011
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Ryan Avent of the Economist about his book The Gated City. The conversation begins with a puzzle: coastal metros such as Boston, New York, and San Francisco have strong wage growth but little population growth, while the Sun Belt gains residents. Avent separates the reasons behind this net domestic migration and points to housing costs. He then asks why density has become more valuable to productivity, and ends on policy remedies.
The middle of the discussion covers a lot of ground. Avent grounds the case for density in tacit knowledge, citing research that interaction is lost even between floors of one building. He argues density doesn't require skyscrapers, and uses row houses, suburban Silicon Valley, and transit-oriented Arlington, Virginia as examples. Some claims are contested: that Silicon Valley's tight housing market pushed its entrepreneurship rate below the national average, that Sun Belt job growth is concentrated in non-tradable sectors, and that middle-skill workers are pushed into less productive labor markets. Avent also concedes that density has real costs, like congestion, while noting that New Yorkers emit less carbon per capita.
The final stretch is political. Roberts brings in the bootleggers-and-Baptists pattern, in which preservation and green-space arguments serve homeowners' property values. He also raises rent seeking under discretionary zoning. Avent frames Portland's growth limits as a NIMBY collective action problem. He describes a "rezoning budget" from Roderick Hills and David Schleicher and a developer density charge. Roberts doubts that incumbent voters would ever approve such reforms.
Avent argues that US land-use restrictions, driven by homeowner opposition to new construction, make housing supply in high-productivity coastal cities unresponsive to demand. This pushes workers and firms away from the agglomerations where they are most productive, which slows national growth.
- Coastal cities added housing stock at roughly 5% from 2001 to 2009, versus about 40% in Las Vegas and about 25% in Atlanta, Phoenix, and Charlotte, so prices rose faster than supply.
- Net domestic migration flowed from high-wage coastal metros to the Sun Belt, and the driver appears to be housing costs rather than amenities.
- Restricting density loses agglomeration benefits such as tacit knowledge sharing, specialization, and startup formation, and those losses are not visible in local price signals.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Tacit knowledge that cannot be transmitted by email is exchanged through face-to-face conversation, serendipitous encounters, and job-hopping between firms, and this happens far more within a city than across long distances; the effect is so strong that interaction loss is measurable even across floors of one building.
“there's a lot of kind of background conversation a lot of tacit knowledge as what economists call it that you really sort of miss out on when you're not there”
Density can be increased without skyscrapers: moving from single-family lots to row houses, or allowing large houses on small lots, adds density while preserving a small-town feel, but minimum lot sizes, setbacks, and footage minimums make such density hard to build and expensive for newcomers.
“there's minimum lot sizes there's minimum there's minimums for footage and you know setbacks other things all which have good attractive reasons for those things”
Ad hoc, discretionary zoning power gives politicians rent-seeking opportunities: when every development requires a vote, politicians can sell occasional approvals to developers and homeowners, which is extremely destructive even when it is not outright corruption.
“the entrepreneurial side of this for politicians is extremely destructive”
The research shows proximity matters even at very fine scales: productivity effects of interaction are lost across floors within a building, not just across the street or across the country.
“the research says that even across floors within a building you know there you lose something in terms of the importance of interaction”
Restrictions on new development are often justified altruistically, as historic preservation or green space, while serving the self-interest of homeowners who want to protect property values, which is the bootleggers-and-Baptists dynamic.
“a lot of regulation is justified is justified on altruistic rounds but often serve self-interested purposes”
Housing supply is far less elastic in coastal cities such as Boston, New York, and San Francisco than in Sun Belt cities built on flat land such as Phoenix, Charlotte, and Raleigh, so demand increases in coastal cities push prices up disproportionately while Sun Belt demand increases mainly produce quantity increases at small price increases.
“the elasticity of supply is is much smaller in these coastal cities relative to the Sun Belt so that when there's an increase in demand price goes up a lot”
In the late 1990s Silicon Valley had unemployment of only 2 to 3 percent, and housing costs rose even faster than wages, so the tight housing market discouraged people from leaving to start businesses; the entrepreneurship rate in Silicon Valley fell below the national average even as it was a center of innovation.
“the rate of entrepreneurship in Silicon Valley at this point was much lower than the national average”
Dense places have real negative amenities such as congestion, competition for parking and public services, pollution, and overuse of public spaces, yet New Yorkers emit far less carbon per capita than residents of lower-density places because they share walls and heat efficiently, so density is not uniformly worse environmentally.
“New Yorkers emit far less carbon than people who live in unless center environments”
Voters already in place block reforms like rezoning budgets because insiders hold the votes while prospective residents cannot vote, so such policies are unlikely to pass without a level of enlightenment that may not exist.
“the insiders people already their vote and the people who'd like to live there can't vote against these these policies”
When many firms in one industry locate in the same place, the whole industry gets better, not just through competition but through cross-pollination of ideas, spin-off startups, and creative processes, which is why industries cluster in places like Silicon Valley and New York's finance sector.
“when a particular industry has a lot of participants in one geographical location the whole industry gets better it's not just that there's more competition”
Despite strong wage and employment growth in coastal high-productivity metros, these places have seen little population growth, and net domestic migration is a sustained flow of Americans from them to the Sun Belt.
“when you look at just that where Americans are moving focus on net domestic migration we basically see a giant sustained move from these high productivity high wage places to the Sun Belt”
Density is not only a feature of Manhattan-style skyscraper cores: suburban areas can be dense, as with Arlington County, Virginia, and Silicon Valley, which has low-rise office campuses yet quite high jobs per square mile, and this suburban density affects the effective size of the labor market and productivity.
“in terms of jobs per square mile this is really quite dense and and that matters in terms of the effectiveness at the town”
Housing-driven migration pushes mainly middle-skill workers out of high-productivity cities to places with cheaper, larger homes, and this lowers aggregate productivity because those workers move to labor markets where productivity is lower.
“the impact of that is that they're taking their family to a different labor market and productivity levels are lower”
Fast-growing Sun Belt cities add jobs mainly in non-tradable sectors such as health care and education, while Silicon Valley and Boston concentrate high-technology, exporting, high-value tradable industries, and the ongoing shift toward non-tradables reduces productive and innovative potential.
“the sort of distribution of jobs that we see in these fast-growing cities is different from what we see in places like Silicon Valley and Boston it's more oriented toward non-tradable sectors”
Restricting development in one neighborhood does not eliminate demand; it shifts development elsewhere, so the more NIMBY opposition succeeds in one neighborhood, the more pressure builds in others, a tragedy-of-the-commons dynamic within a city.
“when we limit development in one place within a city for which there's a high level of demand it doesn't go away it just shifts elsewhere”
Portland's strict growth limits can be understood as a collective action problem: homeowners buy the neighborhood but lack ownership rights over its character, so each neighborhood resists density even though the city as a whole would be better off with more density, and bargains across neighborhoods could make everyone better off.
“everyone is fighting density and even though they would be better off since the city as a whole allowed more density it's kind of a collective action problem”
New technologies increase the value of in-person conversation between firms and workers, because figuring out how to use new technologies depends on tacit knowledge that is transmitted through job-hopping, new business formation, and informal meetings that are hard to replicate by email.
“there's a lot of kind of background conversation a lot of Cassatt knowledge as what economists call it”
When the NIMBY efforts of many homeowners are aggregated, housing supply cannot adjust to rising demand: in the short run prices rise, and in the long run builders should respond, but homeowner restrictions block that final step, so high demand is absorbed in prices rather than new housing.
“what you get is a market where supply is unable to adjust”
Transit-oriented development around Washington-area Metro stations has allowed Arlington to grow much faster than typical close-in suburbs: Arlington grew almost 20 percent over the past decade, about twice the national population growth rate, because transit reduced fears that traffic would worsen and supported a walkable community.
“Arlington over the past ten years has grown almost twenty percent which is about twice in terms of population which is a twice the national growth rate in population”
A rule-based system would reduce politicians' discretion, and a 'rezoning budget' proposed by Roderick Hills and David Schleicher, which caps annual new development, lets politicians blame the budget rather than constituents for saying no.
“one suggestion has been been made by a couple scholars Roderick hills and David Schlenker is a rezoning budget”
A rezoning budget, proposed by Roderick Hills and David Schleicher, would set a fixed amount of new development each year, tying council members' hands and giving them an external reason to refuse particular projects, though it will likely be set below the optimal level.
“one suggestion has been made by a couple scholars Roderick hills and David Schlenker is a rezoning budget”
A density charge, which taxes or charges developers for building more densely and channels the revenue into local amenities such as parks or transit, could align local political interests with new building in places where political opposition blocks any new development.
“if you had a sort of density charge which I hate to tax density in that way but it's you know in terms of being realistic about the distribution of cost you can charge developers for building more densely”
Over the past decade Americans have sustained a large net domestic migration from high-productivity, high-wage coastal places to the Sun Belt, and when the reasons are separated out, the main driver is dramatic differences in housing cost associated with the difficulty of building in coastal cities.
“we basically see a giant sustained move from these high productivity high wage places to the Sun Belt”
Existing homeowners in most cities, and especially in ten cities, strongly favor limiting new construction not only on their own properties but on adjacent ones, through zoning, historic designations, and pressure on councilmembers, which is the NIMBY effect.
“existing homeowners strongly favored efforts to to limit new construction not just on their properties but on adjacent properties and this is what we would call the NIMBY effect”
Innovation spillovers are much easier to capture when a firm is close to the location of the innovation, because tacit knowledge and labor-market flows are local, so high-cost centers of innovation are underused relative to their potential.
“spill overs from new new innovations are much easier to take advantage of them when you're in a place that's close to the the location of the innovation”
Local land-use restrictions that impose negative externalities on the wider metropolitan area or society justify a check on local decisions, just as pollution is taxed or regulated; Portland's residents can make their own choices but not at the cost of people who would like to live there or benefit from higher productivity.
“it's appropriate to have some check on on the actions of people in places like Portland simply because their decisions don't take into account the many other people who would like to to live in Portland”
The puzzle is that coastal cities with high housing demand and high prices should be building more, not less, than Phoenix, but they are not, which contradicts the standard economic prediction that high prices induce supply.
“you probably should see more building in a high demand area like San Francisco than you would in Phoenix and that's just not what you've seen”
High housing and salary costs lead high-tech firms to locate elsewhere, so the market partially routes around expensive cities, but Avent argues that the most innovative hubs remain important and that other cities do not fully substitute for them.
“it's not that there's nothing good coming out of places like Austin or Raleigh”
In recent decades density has become increasingly important for productivity, and this is tied to the growing importance of face-to-face personal interaction in the economy, especially for high-skill and even some high-school-level jobs; the returns to very talented individuals have soared, which Avent links to the importance of face-to-face interaction in big cities.
“especially in recent decades density has become quite important for improving productivity”
Silicon Valley entrepreneurs struggle to hire people with cloud computing platform skills because social media and large search firms pay far more, and this talent shortage would be less severe if a middle-class lifestyle were affordable in Silicon Valley, since high housing costs deter workers from relocating to where demand is high.
“they're struggling to find people with the skills to develop the cloud computing platforms that it's just not attractive to people because they can make so much more money doing social media”
From 2001 to 2009 the housing stock grew only about 5 percent in Boston, New York, and the Silicon Valley area, while Las Vegas grew almost 40 percent and Atlanta, Phoenix, and Charlotte grew about 25 percent, a difference Avent says has to do with the ease of building rather than demand alone.
“from 2001 to 2009 the housing stock in in Boston New York and and the Silicon Valley area each of those it grew by a little over five percent and then you look at a city like like Las Vegas and the housing stock grew by almost 40%”
The median owner-occupied home in Boston was about $130,000 in 2009 while in San Jose it was over $600,000, a gap that dwarfs the wage differences between the two places and is not explained by construction cost differences, which are small relative to the premium from the difficulty of building.
“the median home owner occupied home in Easton in 2009 was just about a hundred and thirty thousand dollars in value and in San Jose it was over six hundred thousand and that just Dwarfs the difference in wages”
Silicon Valley's high cost of living is inevitable because it contains scarce amenities, but the magnitude of its expense is much greater than it would be if supply were not artificially restricted.
“we always would expect it to be expensive it's just how expensive it is it's much more expensive than it would be if we didn't artificially restrict the supply response”
The United States has distorted and under-consumed density through public policy, so a denser urban and suburban America would be substantially more productive than the current pattern.
“we have distorted the amount of density that we consume”
Places that are more open to newcomers tend to have smaller and less generous state apparatuses, since residents accept inflows more readily when there are fewer public benefits to be shared; Texas, which is open to immigration and development, has large housing growth in Houston and Dallas with fewer public services.
“people are more willing to accept Outsiders when there's less than the way of state spoils to be shared”
Coastal high-housing-cost cities impose a cost on national growth: by restricting who can afford to live near innovation centers, they under-exploit the potential of innovative places and reduce the national growth rate.
“we're just we're under exploiting our innovative opportunities and that has an impact not just for you know the economies Silicon Valley but for the national growth rate”
Public financing policy distorted the housing market over two decades: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were liberated from restrictions and could buy loans from originators, mortgage-backed securities widened the pool of buyers, and Federal Reserve low interest rates in the early 2000s pushed buyers toward bigger houses, so policy subsidized debt and pushed up prices in constrained places.
“we distorted through public policy financing costs a great deal over the last two decades we made it a lot easier to borrow money”
Exclusion through housing costs in coastal cities creates political pressure for interventions such as affordable housing and school reforms aimed at lower-income residents, when the underlying problem is that many people cannot afford to take advantage of local opportunities; Scandinavian countries sustain high-quality public services only because they are not welcoming to outsiders.
“you see that I think in Europe as well you have Scandinavian countries that have rich economies really high-quality public services but they're really only able to maintain those things because they are not welcoming”
Dual-career households make moving costly: when both partners work, relocating to a better opportunity for both is very difficult, and this rise in two-earner households has supported large cities by reducing mobility.
“if you have both members of a couple working one of them is their job it's very problematic to try to locate and find a better opportunity for both people”
Large cities support greater specialization and trade because they have enough diverse demand: a small city may have zero Vietnamese restaurants, while a large city has enough customers with diverse tastes to support many specialized producers, which drives innovation and better satisfaction of preferences.
“in a small city there might have one you might have one exactly zero you're not going to have enough people with the diversity of taste to support high levels of specialization in a large city will”
Minimum lot sizes, footage minimums, and setback rules, though they serve aesthetic purposes, make it much more expensive for newcomers to enter a city because they block lower-cost forms of housing.
“there's minimum lot sizes there's minimum there's minimums for footage and you know setbacks other things all which have good attractive reasons for those things”
Thick urban labor markets allow workers who lose jobs to find another good job more easily, which matters most in downturns, because a large city contains many different employers.
“if you lose your job in a large city with a lot of different producers you're better able to find another good job”
Part of urban concentration reflects amenity-driven sorting rather than productivity: people with particular preferences choose cities like Manhattan for urban amenities or Bozeman for non-urban ones, so concentration is partly a result of choices.
“some of the concentration we're talking about is just a result of the choices people make”
NIMBY restrictions operate through zoning rules, historic district designations that make new development difficult, and explicit political pressure on councilmen when a developer seeks to build, and these tools are often a means to control what others do with their land.
“in a lot of times it's just a means to to control what other people can do with their land”
Measuring the cost of high-cost cities is hard because comparing San Francisco with Phoenix conflates housing costs with differences in skill composition and other city features, though the market itself partly corrects this by making firms relocate.
“of course it's very hard to measure what you're talking about you can compare jobs in Phoenix to jobs in in San Francisco but of course you never know whether you're controlling for the things that are different”
Density carries real negative costs such as congestion, competition for parking and public services, pollution, and overuse of public spaces, so the benefits of density do not come without trade-offs.
“congestion is one of the first ones people think about it's one of the big complaints people have when you talk about new development”
Underpricing of roads and public parks in America produces serious congestion costs, a tragedy-of-the-commons problem, though some people value the stimulating crowds of places like the Manhattan sidewalk.
“many of the public the tragedy of the Commons problems come from underpricing and I guess the fact that you know the roads are typically unpriced in America”
Cities exist because transporting goods and moving people are costly; even with better transportation and communications technology, distance still matters, so activities that depend on close interaction cluster together in cities.
“cities exist basically because there are limits to how easy it is to ship goods and how easy it is to move people”
Allowing density in some neighborhoods reduces pressure on historic and other neighborhoods: Ed Glaeser argued that building in a Manhattan midtown site would lower apartment costs and reduce pressure to develop Central Park or historic districts, so a market that satisfies demand in some places does not force change everywhere.
“Glaser made it an excellent point which was that when you allow the market to satisfy demand on as he's fit on you know some places in the city there's less pressure on other other places”
It is surprising but true that face-to-face agglomeration is becoming more important even as communication technology makes distance cheaper and back-office work is outsourced to distant low-cost locations; the outsourcing is partly a response to expensive cities.
“it's a little bit surprising because at the same time so much more communication is taking place not face-to-face right so much stuff's being outsourced”
Density matters on the consumer side as well as production: a large market can support niche businesses and experience goods, such as avant-garde theater and big museums and sporting events, that cannot be replicated in smaller markets, which is driving the rising popularity of dense cities.
“you have enough people there to support things that require very huge audiences to really work”
Roberts' view that high housing prices represent natural signals in which people sort themselves by preferences and everything is working out fine, which Avent rejects in favor of the claim that homeowner restrictions distort those prices.
“there's these natural signals sometimes literally prices sometimes implicit prices of congestion and that's what determines where people want to live”
Government should not take land by eminent domain and mandate density in order to steamroll local interests; density should be achieved through buy-in, and transit infrastructure, which is needed anyway as population grows, can change local equilibria in a cost-conscious way.
“I don't think the way to achieve density is to have government come in and take over the land and mandate it”
Portland, Oregon has adopted some of the most restrictive growth limits, making development much harder than in most other cities, and residents defend this as preserving a specific livable character.
“Portland has really taken many of the ideas that we're talking about here”
Rising prices in constrained cities also reflect a compositional shift: wealthier buyers are filtering in and buying larger or higher-quality units, so within a market new housing is weighted toward expensive houses, and some purchases may be speculative bets on future development.
“you're probably filtering for people with greater levels of wealth and that could be affecting the size of the units that they're buying”
Development costs such as historic preservation and environmental regulation are substantial in American cities, and the historic-preservation cost in particular has no positive justification, since it serves mainly to control what others do with their land.
“that kind has no positive justification it's basically so there's many there's many of these obvious”
Arlington County in Northern Virginia is one of the denser places in the country, yet it looks nothing like Manhattan, with single-family homes and few skyscrapers.
“I live in one of the denser places in the country and that's Arlington County in Northern Virginia just outside Washington but it looks very very different from Manhattan”
Coastal price premiums partly reflect scarce amenities (weather, vistas, urban amenities, productivity from clustering) that are hard to duplicate, so higher prices there are expected, but the size of the premium is far beyond what amenities justify.
“we would expect given the differences and amenities that there's going to be a premium to live in San Francisco relative to Phoenix but you know you wouldn't necessarily expect to see a huge gap”
Real costs of living are higher in expensive coastal cities than in places like Houston, and wages do not fully compensate for that difference, which is why the cost gap signals an inefficient allocation rather than a simple amenity premium.
“how little they compensate given given the differences”
Las Vegas's 40 percent housing stock increase was largely a mistake that left many houses unoccupied, showing that some cities overbuilt in the boom even as coastal cities were restricted.
“much of that was a mistake next post ex ante it might have seemed like a good idea”
Generous public goods such as high-quality public education and healthcare may increase the desire to exclude outsiders, because residents fear that outsiders will exploit those goods, so policies that expand public goods may need to be weighed against their effect on openness.
“maybe when we have a high level of public education that's going to increase the desire to exclude Outsiders out of fear that those public goods are going to be exploited”
Russ Roberts asserts that the concept of 'supply responding' in the discussion should be understood as movements along the supply curve, which are technically a quantity supply response rather than a shift.
“we're talking of core about movements along the supply curve and we technically should have called a quantity supply”
Locating a corporate headquarters in Silicon Valley is expensive because of land and salary costs, which may lead firms to locate elsewhere, though software startups may work just as well in Austin, Texas, and the agglomeration argument may be overstated.
“don't software startups work just as well in Austin Texas or other places than Silicon so is it really that important”
Coastal cities such as Boston, New York, the Bay Area, Washington, Portland, and Seattle have a more interventionist average political outlook than Sun Belt metros such as Charlotte, Raleigh, Phoenix, Tucson, Houston, and Dallas, which favor smaller government, and this worldview difference shapes zoning policy and reinforces migration toward the Sun Belt.
“the coastal cities Boston New York the Bay Area Washington DC Portland Seattle these are places where the average worldview of the people who live there tends to be more interventionist”
Historically the industries that attracted millions of workers to American cities were high-value exporting industries, so the current pattern of those industries repelling workers rather than attracting them is an anomaly that signals a problem.
“these were the industries that really were attracting millions and millions of workers now it's curious that they're repelling them”
Population in the restrictive coastal cities has been flat to slightly increasing once immigration is counted, with net domestic out-migration of existing residents, in sharp contrast to Phoenix-type cities with enormous population growth.
“they're losing existing residents on a net basis you know much more many more current residents are moving out than are moving in”
Cities that struggled in the 1960s and 1970s, including New York, Boston, Washington, and the Bay Area, have become highly productive and economically successful over the past decade, driven by new technology and high human capital.
“cities that had been struggling in the 60s and 70s have really enjoyed a turnaround and they have I places like like New York Boston Washington the Bay Area”
Montgomery County, Maryland requires a special permit for very large stores, letting the City Council grant or deny big-box retailers like Walmart and Wegmans, and grocery incumbents donating to council members keeps competitors out, making the system extremely destructive even if no one goes to jail.
“there is no super Walmart and no Wegmans grocery store in my County right there's a special provision that if you have a really large store you have to get a special permit”
Some shift toward healthcare employment is a natural result of an aging population and should not be a low-productivity field, but much of the current growth in low-productivity industries is a symptom of people being unable to afford high-productivity cities.
“we're going to be putting more employing more people in healthcare which shouldn't be a low productivity field but I think much more of it as occurring that needs to be the case”
Roberts asks whether parks and green spaces in Palo Alto should be turned into housing, and whether relaxing zoning would produce noticeably cheaper housing, which Avent declines to prescribe as a design policy.
“are you suggesting that that those parks should be turned into housing tracts”
The discussion of trade-offs between Sun Belt and coastal approaches is mostly a matter of different political tastes rather than an empirical settlement, and the consequences of population movement over the next decade remain open.
“that's going to be I think something that continues to be debated as we watch this play out over the next ten years”
A joke that sourdough bread might really be better in San Francisco because the air is special, used to illustrate whether the Bay Area's advantages can be replicated elsewhere.
“there's really sourdough bread might really be better in San Francisco because the Aires is special”