Carbon Removal
What this covers
This Business Breakdowns episode follows Ransohoff from climate framing to building Frontier, the buyer collective, and asks how a market for removing CO2 gets created from nothing. It opens with why climate resists action: a Tragedy of the Commons whose costs are diffuse and long-term, unlike the acute urgency behind Operation Warp Speed. Her own turning point was re-reading the 2018 IPCC report and seeing that the models rely on removal to make the math work. Along the way come the wider energy questions: electrifying cars and stoves, expanding a grid that must also become intermittent, and whether energy growth can come without emissions.
The technical and quantitative range is wide. Direct air capture pulls CO2 from air at about 412 parts per million and needs abundant clean power. Plants and rocks capture carbon for free, but biological storage is often impermanent and uses land. Land and soil sequestration would not meet the 1,000-year permanence bar. The contested numbers are the sharpest: roughly 5 billion tons a year needed by 2050, scenarios from 1 to 10 billion, and only about 10,000 tons permanently removed so far. Typical offsets, at $1 to $15 per ton, are criticized for quality and fires.
The last stretch covers Frontier's mechanics. Stripe Climate pools small revenue shares, and offtake agreements let a supplier like Charm Industrial take a committed customer to a bank for a loan. The early-buyer logic is the Tesla Roadster. Her main lessons are that buying is not enough, since verification and policy must carry the market once the initial $1 to 10 billion is spent. She also argues that incumbents with distribution are underused.
Ransohoff argues carbon removal cannot scale on voluntary buyers or future policy alone, so a pooled advance market commitment should give suppliers a guaranteed demand signal now, and the market must be built while the policy and compliance pieces are still missing.
- Early carbon removal firms cannot raise capital without a revenue stream, and no buyers existed historically
- The advance market commitment model was borrowed from the pneumococcal vaccine effort in the 2000s
- Voluntary corporate demand is far too small for the hundreds of billions of dollars per year needed, so compliance mechanisms like carbon pricing or federal procurement will eventually be required
Removal needs a built market, with offtake purchases supplying the demand signals financing requires.
- Frontier announced in April a $1 billion commitment from Stripe, Alphabet, Shopify, Meta and McKinsey to buy permanent carbon removal over nine years.
“a $1 billion commitment from Stripe, Alphabet, Shopify, Meta and McKinsey to buy permanent carbon removal”
- The $1 billion commitment is not enough to reach the scale the field needs, but it can start a flywheel where cheaper, further-along technologies sell at lower prices, so the next supplier can sell at $200 per ton instead of $500 per ton.
“The $1 billion isn't going to get to the scale that the entire field needs over the next couple of decades, but we can start to get that flywheel going.”
- Frontier's co-founding companies joined because they have ambitious climate commitments, want to create new supply rather than compete over existing supply, and understand cost curves: early buyers must pay price premiums so technologies get cheaper, like buying early Tesla Roadsters.
“We are all basically buying the Tesla Roadsters so that they can get cheaper overcoming iterations.”
- Frontier's core question is how to create a market for carbon removal absent policy, so it uses pooled voluntary demand as a bridge until policy catches up.
“How do you build a market for carbon removal for early-stage solutions, especially in the absence of policy.”
- Most offsets have wide quality variance, are often not permanent or additional, and many California offsets burned down, so the average offset price of $1 to $15 per ton cannot scale to solve climate change.
“If we were going to solve climate change for $1 to $15 a ton, we would have done it by now.”
- Unlike energy, which has intrinsic value because people derive value from producing it and can ride cost declines to market, carbon removal has no intrinsic value, so it cannot rely on a self-sustaining market and must be built through policy.
“With carbon removal, there's no value in it. So there is no intrinsic market for the thing.”
- Historically no one has paid for carbon removal, creating a chicken-and-egg problem: without customers, entrepreneurs and investors cannot justify building companies with revenue streams, so the core work is building a market for early-stage removal absent policy.
“With carbon removal, there's no value in it. So there is no intrinsic market for the thing.”
- An advance market commitment sends a credible demand signal to entrepreneurs and investors that a market will exist for their technology, giving them confidence to build; the concept was borrowed from a mid-2000s pneumococcal vaccine commitment that pulled pharma companies into developing a vaccine for low-income countries.
“the idea of an advanced market commitment is basically to send allowed demand signal to entrepreneurs and investors that there is going to be a market for your technologies”
- Phase 2, Stripe Climate, lets any Stripe business direct a fraction of its revenue to carbon removal, pooling the money to buy more removal down the cost curve, and it could not have worked as a standalone business due to customer acquisition costs.
“I don't think that Stripe Climate would have worked as a stand-alone business because it would have gotten killed by customer acquisition costs.”
- Frontier signs offtake agreements promising to buy tons from supplier facilities, which lets a supplier like Charm take a promise to a bank and secure a loan, because the bank will lend once there is a committed customer at a set price.
“So we will write promises to buy the tons coming off of these suppliers' facilities such that Peter can then go back to the bank”
- Frontier's first phase in 2019 was a $1 million purchase of permanent carbon removal at any available price, and the carbon removal community reacted surprisingly positively, showing how starved the field was for customers.
“to buy $1 million of permanent carbon removal at any available price”
- Frontier provides $1 billion of revenue to companies building carbon removal, and the profit motive is important because suppliers need revenue to get loans, so the market structure should use profit incentives to drive supply.
“I think it's really important. And what we're trying to do with Frontier, it's $1 billion of revenue for companies that are building carbon removal.”
Carbon removal must scale from near zero quickly to meet net-zero targets.
- The world emits about 50 gigatons of CO2 equivalent per year, and reaching net zero by 2050 requires both stopping emissions and pulling existing CO2 out of the atmosphere and ocean for permanent storage, with roughly 90 percent of focus belonging on emissions reduction.
“The world emits out 50 gigatons of CO2 equivalents every year and to stay within reasonable warming targets, we need to get that down to net zero by 2050 or before.”
- Carbon removal is underdeveloped largely because the field did not realize how much removal would be needed until the 2018 IPCC report, and the models now depend on removal to make the climate math work.
“it's very underdeveloped in large part because we didn't really realize we are going to need as much of it as we now do until the 2018 IPCC report came out.”
- Cumulatively, only about 10,000 tons of carbon have been permanently removed to date, so the industry is functionally at the starting line and must go from near zero to scale extremely quickly.
“Today, cumulatively about 10,000 tons of carbon removal has been permanently removed, which is crazy.”
- Under the carbon budget framing, roughly 5 billion tons per year of removal will be needed by 2050 depending on the model, ramping up over time and continuing after, which is massive relative to the U.S. annual emissions of about 6 billion tons.
“roughly 5 billion tons of removal is going to be needed every single year and it ramps up between now and then”
- Ransohoff's interest in climate began in fourth-grade science when she learned about greenhouse gases and was surprised people were not alarmed, and she later moved from emissions work at Opower, Nest, and Uber Pool to carbon removal after reading the 2018 IPCC report.
“I've been interested in climate since a fourth-grade science class”
- The 2030s are the critical decade to get the best removal solutions to the starting line and remove roadblocks so they can scale, and by 2030 the field should narrow its confidence about how much removal will occur.
“The 2030s are a very important decade to get the best solutions to the starting line”
Removal is essential, but emissions reduction should take most of climate effort.
- The IPCC is the canonical resource for climate science, and Carbon Brief does an excellent job summarizing it, so these are the two resources to point people toward.
“I would point people to the IPCC, which is the canonical resource for much of the science. Carbon Brief also does an amazing job”
- The base case IPCC scenario is about 6 billion tons per year of removal, the worst case is around 1 billion or less, and the upper range might reach 10 billion tons per year, so the field does not yet know where removal will land.
“The base case that the IPCC has modeled is around 6 billion tons per year.”
- Ransohoff argues that roughly 90 percent of climate effort should go to reducing emissions rather than carbon removal, though removal remains an essential part of the solution set.
“carbon removal and I would say, roughly 90%-ish of focus should go towards the emissions reduction piece of the equation”
- Because emissions reductions were slow, carbon removal has become a larger part of the climate story than it would have been had emissions been reduced when scientists first warned.
“Because we've been rather slow to reduce emissions, carbon removal has become a larger part of the story”
- Climate models rely on carbon removal to make their math work, which Ransohoff discovered when re-reading the 2018 IPCC report and which motivated her to focus on removal.
“how the models are also relying on carbon removal to make the math work”
- Carbon removal is a really important part of the suite of climate solutions.
“But carbon removal is a really important part of our suite of climate solutions”
Buyers alone cannot scale removal; verification and compliance policy must also be solved.
- A key bottleneck for removal is verification: measuring a ton of biomass sequestration differs from confirming bio-oil injection, and buyers need a way to know when purchased tons have actually been delivered.
“it's unclear how verification is going to scale for the field.”
- Demand for removal will move from today's voluntary corporate and individual purchases toward compliance markets created by government, since the bulk of funding will come from companies and governments.
“We are moving from what I would characterize now as voluntary markets to more of a compliance market in the future.”
- Frontier learned that because removal is so early, it cannot just be the demand side; it must address bottlenecks in verification, policy after the $1 billion runs out, and supplier financing, growing supply and ecosystem rigor simultaneously.
“because carbon removal is so early, you can't just play the role of demand.”
- Frontier learned that being a buyer is insufficient, because the field needs solutions to verification of delivered tons, which differ across biomass and bio-oil approaches, and policy mechanisms to carry the market after the initial 1 to 10 billion dollars runs out.
“as a buyer, how do we know when the tons that we paid for have actually been delivered? That's a gap that needs to get spun up.”
- Voluntary corporate purchasing will not reach the hundreds of billions of dollars per year needed for removal, since at 5 billion tons per year and even 10 dollars per ton the demand is enormous and voluntary altruism cannot scale that far, so compliance mechanisms like a carbon tax or federal procurement are needed.
“We are moving from what I would characterize now as voluntary markets to more of a compliance market in the future.”
Climate is a hard collective problem whose harms are diffuse, slow, and require moving atoms.
- Climate has been hard to act on because it is the canonical tragedy of the commons: negative externalities are diffuse, long-term, and hard to attribute to specific causes, unlike acute crises such as the Manhattan Project or Operation Warp Speed.
“This is the canonical tragedy of the commons problem. The negative externalities are diffuse and they're long term and they're hard to pin down to what their causes are.”
- Climate is hard because it requires moving atoms rather than bits, so it cannot be solved with purely software-style development and requires long-horizon, capital-intensive hardware investment.
“at the end of the day, you have to move atoms. It is bits and service of atoms.”
- Ransohoff joined Stripe because its theory of change, creating a market for removal without policy, resonated with her, and she chose removal work because she judged herself not a scientist, engineer, or policymaker.
“The question I really became obsessed with was, how do you create a market for carbon removal in the absence of policy?”
- Climate was a niche topic around 2012, when Ransohoff worked at Opower and Nest, but it has shifted dramatically into the general conversation, with more individuals and companies asking what assets they can contribute.
“That has shifted a huge amount in the past couple of years.”
- Governments mobilize well for acute visible crises like the Manhattan Project and Operation Warp Speed but struggle with slow problems, and Ransohoff doubts there will be a single watershed moment that turns climate into a crash program, instead expecting many incremental efforts.
“I'm not sure there's going to be like a single watershed moment where everyone comes to realize that we're going to turn this into Operation Warp Speed.”
Decoupling growth from emissions is feasible, and subsidies are accelerating climate solutions.
- Climate outcomes should be framed both as avoiding human suffering and biodiversity loss and as the opportunities that abundant free clean energy could open up for humanity.
“it's worth thinking not only just what are the bad things that we can avoid, but what are the exciting new opportunities”
- The Inflation Reduction Act, a $380 billion U.S. bill, is a large subsidy that will accelerate climate solutions, and national security framing of energy control is helping governments step up.
“with IRA, that the $380 billion bill that passed in the U.S. this summer, this is a huge amount of money that is going to subsidize and accelerate climate solutions.”
- Several countries have already shown they can decouple economic growth and energy use from carbon intensity, which suggests the decoupling goal is feasible.
“we can decouple economic growth and energy use from carbon intensity”
Individual removal pathways each face permanence, energy, or land constraints.
- Charm Industrial takes waste biomass such as corn stover, heats it into bio-oil, and injects that bio-oil underground, capturing the carbon the plant already absorbed and making its storage permanent.
“There's another company called Charm Industrial that is taking waste biomass like corn stover”
- Running Tide grows kelp on ropes over six to nine months, and when biomass is heavy enough it sinks below the thermocline to the ocean floor, a hybrid nature-engineered approach that meets Frontier's criteria.
“They drop it into the ocean, and that kelp grows over six to nine months.”
- Plants and rocks already capture carbon using solar energy for free, but biological storage is often not permanent and consumes arable land, so the aim is to harness nature's capture while making storage durable.
“Nature does the capture piece for free. It has its own source of energy, but it's often not permanent, and it takes up a lot of arable land”
- Direct air capture pulls CO2 from air, where it makes up about 412 particles per million air particles, and then condenses and injects it underground; the capture step is very energy intensive and depends on abundant low-carbon power.
“That is energy-intensive, finding and separating those 412 particles of CO2 from the other million air particles, that capture piece is very energy intensive.”
- Frontier published a roadmap identifying about 100 gaps across altitudes, from high-level ideas to specific knowledge gaps, with substantial focus on synthetic biology to make biological storage more permanent.
“We published a roadmap a couple of weeks ago that basically there are 100 gaps in there”
- Treating land or soil carbon sequestration would not meet the 1,000-year permanence criterion, and tree planting is constrained because there is only so much land available.
“Part of the challenge with trees, we love trees, but there are only so many trees you can plant before running out of land.”
- Frontier's criteria require removing an additional ton of atmospheric CO2 permanently for at least 1,000 years, a path to under $100 per ton, a path to more than 0.5 gigatons per year at scale, and no competition for arable land.
“namely it removes the source carbon permanently for at least 1,000 years.”
Decarbonizing energy requires electrification and grid expansion matched to intermittent supply.
- Emissions have tracked energy use and rising quality of life since the industrial era, and have only recently started to flatten, so the curve now has to be bent all the way down.
“this has been going up since the industrial era and recently has started to flatten out.”
- Matching intermittent wind and solar supply to rising demand is a pronounced supply-demand problem that will require substantial new hardware and software to connect them.
“there's a pretty interesting supply-demand matching problem here for how do you match intermittent supply with a lot more demand.”
- The core climate challenge is decoupling energy use and quality of life from carbon intensity, through electrifying devices so they draw clean power and switching oil, coal, and gas to solar, wind, and nuclear.
“a big chunk at the heart of climate is how do we decouple energy use from carbon intensity.”
- Moving cars, stoves, and other end uses from fossil fuels to electricity adds a large new load to the grid, so the grid must expand capacity dramatically while shifting to intermittent sources.
“We're going to be adding a ton of demand to the electric grid.”
- Both per capita and absolute energy use are likely to keep rising as population grows and living standards rise, so the real question is whether that growth can occur without increasing emissions.
“I think that both on a per capita basis and an absolute basis, this is likely going to keep going up as population grows and as we raise that floor.”
Patient capital and incumbent firms are better suited to scale climate solutions than startups.
- Venture capital has historically shied away from early hard-tech R&D, but this is changing with investors like Breakthrough Energy Ventures and Lower Carbon Energy Impact Partners, and long development horizons call for patient capital and new financing models.
“Historically, VC has generally shied away from hard tech early R&D as science-y efforts.”
- Large incumbent companies have distribution and expertise that make them better suited than new startups to scale climate solutions, and leveraging existing firms is underused compared with founders instinctively starting new companies.
“leveraging existing companies, assets and talent and distribution is underleveraged.”
- Frontier is not profit-seeking and spends heavily on removal without return, which lets it think climate first or ecosystem first, an advantage it would lose as a standalone organization outside Stripe.
“In a sense, I think we're actually really lucky to not have profit as a motive for the work that we're doing.”
Progress will come from many diverse, uncoordinated efforts rather than one watershed moment.
- Because the removal field is so early, the next few years should yield heterogeneous approaches and creativity, and the goal is to mature a cohort of companies ready to scale a different set of approaches.
“I think we're just starting to see the kinds of heterogeneity that we want to see and creativity and approaches over the next couple of years.”
- Ransohoff does not expect a single watershed moment on climate; instead many efforts from governments, private companies, and individuals will sizzle away from different angles, and she has seen climate move from niche to general conversation over the past five years.
“I'm not sure there's going to be like a single watershed moment where everyone comes to realize that we're going to turn this into Operation Warp Speed.”
Localized technological and regional advances spread benefits far beyond their origin.
- Australia could become a carbon removal hub because it has abundant renewable energy and good geologic storage, and each country should identify its unique geophysical advantages.
“they have huge access to a lot of renewable energy. They've got really good storage solutions and potentially could be a hub”
- Tesla's largest climate impact was not its own direct emissions reductions but compelling other car companies to take EVs seriously, illustrating how localized technology advances can have second and third-order effects globally.
“I would argue that Tesla's biggest impact was compelling all of the other car companies to actually start taking EV seriously.”
- Large companies should use their own assets to accelerate transitions, for example an appliance maker developing a compelling induction stove for mass deployment or a rideshare company accelerating electric vehicle adoption among its own drivers.
“how can Viking or Wolf come up with an incredible induction stove that they then make that sexy and get that scaled everywhere as soon as humanly possible”
- Every part of the world must determine its unique strengths, since regions differ in sun, wind, storage and water.
“Every part of the world has access to different amounts of sun or wind or geologic storage or water.”
- Technology advances in one place, such as cheap renewable energy, spread benefits to other countries and geographies through trickle effects, so localized progress can have second and third-order effects far beyond its origin.
“But technologies, new technologies tend to have trickle effects.”