
Patri Friedman on Seasteading 10/13/2008
What this covers
This 2008 EconTalk conversation pairs host Russ Roberts with Patri Friedman, executive director of the Seasteading Institute. Roberts presses on the idea throughout. Friedman frames government as an industry with high lock-in and near-impossible entry: on land, you win an election, a war, or a revolution. He contrasts this with the Free State Project, which he rejects because it targets state legislatures while the federal government holds most of the burden. He also contrasts it with Ron Paul-style movement building, since seasteading needs only a few people with money to show it works, not millions of converts. Roberts brings in George Stigler and the Ralph Nader theory of regulation to argue that incentives, not the individual regulator, are the problem, and he asks whether the state is an unavoidable outgrowth of collective action.
The rest is practical. On law, the first steps are autonomy rather than sovereignty, using a flag of convenience and sitting just beyond territorial waters, with the long-run aim of leaving any state's EEZ. On engineering and cost, Friedman leans on breakwater scaling, in which protected area grows faster than perimeter cost, and on the offshore oil platform industry. Roberts counters that those platforms are viable only because they pump oil. Friedman's ocean tax versus government tax sets the threshold for scaling up. He denies that seasteads could be self-sufficient, since the ocean has no comparative advantage in agriculture. He proposes aquaculture as the leading early business, and the conversation also covers piracy, which he considers a minor risk.
The more contested passages concern Friedman's claim that a competitive market in small governments would be an empirical laboratory and would surface institutions nobody now anticipates. He offers 1960s European pirate radio as a precedent: governments improved their own stations until the offshore premium no longer paid, which he counts as a win. Roberts questions whether exit can work where earlier vote-with-your-feet efforts were undermined by attack and limited room.
Friedman argues that seasteading, building small autonomous communities on the ocean outside national jurisdiction, is the most practical route to freer societies because it lowers the cost of exit and creates a competitive market for government.
- Government is an industry with extreme barriers to entry and switching costs, which the ocean lowers by allowing new jurisdictions at small scale and modular mobility
- Flags of convenience already show that a competitive market in jurisdiction works, and the ocean extends that market to governance
- Incentive-based institutional competition can be tested empirically without converting a majority of people to libertarian ideas
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Roberts argues, following George Stigler, that the 'Ralph Nader theory of regulation' (regulation fails because regulators are captured, so the fix is better regulators) is wrong, since the real problem is the incentives the regulator faces; Alan Greenspan's regulatory failures would have occurred with any occupant of the job.
“it's not the person it's the incentives the person faces”
Breakwaters scale favorably: the length of a circular breakwater is its perimeter while the protected area is its interior, so protected area grows faster than cost as the structure gets bigger, and a large enough breakwater makes building on the water cheap.
“the length of the breakwater is the perimeter of a circle but the area it protects is is the area of a circle so you get a one over our economy of scale as it gets bigger”
Seasteads cannot be fully self-sustaining in any economically meaningful sense because the ocean lacks a comparative advantage in agriculture: fresh water and land are expensive, so imports will be necessary and self-sufficiency would mean being very poor.
“self-sustaining is another way of saying really poor we've got no comparative advantage in growing things we have expensive fresh water and expensive area”
A seastead would initially operate under a flag of convenience, registering with an existing country, because a flag of convenience registration is easy and has no real oversight; roughly half the world's tonnage is registered under such flags, so this is not a fringe arrangement.
“literally half of the world's tonnage is registered a flag of convenience so it's not like some little fly-by-night operation”
Friedman's approach is distinct from libertarian political reform because it changes the system's incentives rather than the people in power, and he argues that incentives, not good intentions, determine how people and institutions behave.
“it's the system matters the incentive matters the structure matters and people will respond differently given different incentives”
Sovereignty is too difficult to obtain for a seastead, so the realistic short-term goal is autonomy, achieved by flying the flag of an existing country that offers flags of convenience and so operates under that country's protection and rule.
“the mission specifically says autonomy not sovereignty because sovereignty is so difficult ... there's no formal legal way to get recognition of the country it's more of a de facto thing”
Piracy is not a major threat to seasteads: small-scale piracy mostly targets small boats and over two-thirds of attacks involve no guns, while organized crime seizing whole container ships is less attractive because a seastead's ratio of people to movable property is very different and its assets are concrete and generators, not gold.
“over two-thirds of pirate attacks don't even involve guns”
Oil platforms are only financially viable because they pump oil ('black gold'), so they demonstrate engineering feasibility of standing in waves but not financial viability for a seastead; the offshore oil and gas platform industry is worth about $120 billion a year, so seasteads can leverage its designs and expertise.
“building floating platforms for oil and gas is like a hundred and twenty billion dollar a year industry”
Government is an industry that produces poor service because it has an extremely high barrier to entry: to try a new government on land you must win an election, win a war, or lead a revolution, which Friedman says is harder than competing with Microsoft.
“in order to try out a new government you basically have to win an election or a war or revolution I'd rather compete with Microsoft and then try to start a new government on land”
Government as an industry has high customer lock-in and switching costs, since changing governments on land means leaving your house, job, and friends; floating, modular seasteads that can be moved or rearranged reduce these switching costs and lower the cost of secession.
“to change government you have to leave your house usually leave your job leave your friends and far away so it's really complex”
A seastead is a natural laboratory for generating empirical data: if each community's failures stay with its own members, societies can try different rule sets and learn which institutions work, which are bad, and which are matters of taste.
“as long as the system is structured so that their failures only bring down them you know what's the problem and I think we can all we can all learn from what happened”
Pirate radio in 1960s Europe was killed not by making offshore stations illegal but by governments improving their own radio stations, which made the extra cost of offshore operation (the 'ocean tax') exceed the benefit; competition can push governments to improve, which Friedman counts as a win.
“what killed pirate radio in the end was that the government got better radio stations so the extra cost is doing the pirate radio wasn't enough”
Aquaculture is the most promising seastead business: wild fish stocks are declining from the tragedy of the commons while demand rises from health awareness and growth in China and India, and inland and coastal aquaculture, which supplies about 20% of fish production, is constrained by environmental sensitivity, so deep-ocean aquaculture could become a huge industry in the medium term.
“the supply of fish is dwindling worldwide the tragedy of the Commons people are just taking it out of the common pool but the demand for fish is going up”
Seasteads will initially pursue autonomy rather than sovereignty, because there is no formal legal path to recognition as a country, so sovereignty is a de facto matter for the long term.
“the mission specifically says autonomy not sovereignty because sovereignty is so difficult in such a long way off I mean there's no there's no formal legal way to get recognition of the country”
The state may be a natural outgrowth of humans' desire to act collectively, so coercive collective action may be unavoidable in any community, including seasteads, if they grow large enough.
“the state is a natural outgrowth of people's desires to act collectively and it's has its own organic nature to it and it can't be avoided”
The first seasteads would sit just outside US territorial waters, 12 to 24 miles off the coast, with the long-run goal of being outside any state's 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ), where the state has limited rights over economic activity such as harvesting wind or wave power.
“we're thinking about something just outside US territorial waters so depending it with a lawyer say that's something like 12 to 24 miles off the coast and eventually we want them to be outside the EEZ of any state”
Flagging is a competitive market in a way governing is not: a ship can fly the flag of any country anywhere in the world, so seasteads can negotiate with every country to see who offers the best flag, whereas a land government holds a local geographic monopoly.
“flagging is a competitive market the government isn't because it has a local geographic monopoly but with flagging you can no matter where your ship is in the world”
Friedman rejects the idea of moving to a single state to gain political influence (the Free State Project in New Hampshire) because it has limited reach: the federal government and most burdensome regulation operate at the national level, so the state-level project addresses the least-broken part of government.
“the Free State Project is basically trying to address the part of government which is the least bad namely at the at a small level of the state level”
The vote-with-your-feet method has historically had problems due to attacks and limited opportunities; the ocean may be large enough to avoid those limits and make exit a credible route to liberty.
“this is the vote with your feet method which historically has had problems because of attacks and limited opportunities the ocean might be sufficiently large to let us avoid that”
The Free State Project's fundamental weakness is that it attempts to influence a state legislature while the federal government, which holds most burdensome regulation and tax burden, remains unchanged, and the higher the level of government the more people are involved and the worse it performs.
“the higher the level the more people that are involved the worst government works”
Seasteading does not depend on converting people to libertarian goals; it changes the incentive structure of the system, so people who want state intervention can have it on their own platforms, while others who do not want it can leave, making coercion hard to impose because the fluid ocean lets people take their town and go.
“it doesn't depend on the goals of the people who participate in it it depends on changing the intent of the system”
Because the ocean is essentially unclaimed, it allows new countries to be started at much smaller scale than on land, and a competitive market of small governments would produce ideas that people would not currently anticipate but that work well, as a well-functioning market does.
“since the ocean is essentially unclaimed you can go start new countries on a much smaller scale”
Friedman's long-run framework is the 'ocean tax' versus 'government tax': the ocean tax is the extra cost of living in a harsh, corrosive, resource-poor environment, while the government tax is the cost of regulation and taxes on land. If the ocean tax falls below the government tax, seasteading can scale enormously.
“the ocean tax is the extra cost of living in this harsh corrosive resource-poor environment and the government the government tax is is pretty high too”
Seasteading's main advantage over Ron Paul-style politics or building a mass movement is that it only needs to be taken seriously by a few people with money, who can build the platform and demonstrate it works, rather than converting millions.
“all we need is to be taken seriously by a few people with money and we can go build it and show that it works”
Oil platforms have a decent safety record: a few disasters occur every few years, usually with evacuation by helicopter beforehand, so the platform design approach is historically sound, though seasteads would aim to avoid storms by migrating on an annual pattern rather than outrunning them.
“oil platforms have have been done pretty well every now and then you know one gets evacuated and knocked over by storm but not not very often”
Roberts reads Friedman's Free State critique as aligned with a view that the problem is not bad policy but a system that fails to generate good policy, so the question is how to change the system in a feasible, sustainable way rather than electing different leaders like Ron Paul.
“the problem is not the policy the problem is not that nobody has come up with efficient policies people are constantly coming up with efficient policies but we have a system that doesn't generate them”
Seastead governance would form a hierarchy: local platform rules, groups of platforms contracting for shared power, internet and utilities, and collective defense at the top; but collective defense creates classic public-goods problems in which power given for defense can be used for coercion.
“there you get all the problems of Defense's of public good and you know you give them power in order to send they use it to coercion”
Initially a seastead would be a private business owned by a company that profits from it, like the proprietary community model, because an owner who leases or rents space has an incentive to maximize its value and serve residents well, even without giving residents a direct vote; over the long term residents will demand a say, a constitution, and elections.
“over the long term people are going to want to have a say and how things work”
Even if 20,000 hardcore libertarians lived in New Hampshire, their state senators would not be anarcho-capitalists, because most residents would still find state involvement attractive; a seastead faces the same problem if it grows large.
“even if there were 20,000 hardcore libertarians living in New Hampshire I don't think their their Senators would be anarcho-capitalists”
Defense for seasteads faces a dilemma: it needs enough military capability to make attack expensive, but must avoid appearing offensive to other countries, which care greatly about weapons technology.
“walking the line between having enough defense that it's expensive to attack us and well trying to not seem like an offensive threat to other countries”
The world has run out of frontiers, and the lack of a place to experiment impoverishes the whole world; the ocean is the next frontier where pioneers can try new governance, as democracy was first tried on the American frontier, and successful experiments can then be copied by everyone.
“the world has run out of frontiers and the ocean is the next frontier”
Competition from seasteads may cause governments on land either to improve service to retain citizens or to crack down; Friedman expects some of each, and considers improvement a win since his goal is more liberty in the world rather than on the ocean specifically.
“to the extent to which governments on land get better because of the competition that's a win I mean my goal is to bring more liberty of the world”
Seasteading aims to build new city-states on the ocean, and Friedman believes this is the most practical route to bringing libertarian ideas into practice, even though it sounds crazy.
“our idea is to basically build new city-states on the ocean and even though it seems kind of crazy that building new countries on the ocean is the best way to achieve a freer society”
The biggest risk to seasteading is government response: once the project is effective, governments may notice and act, and the question is whether they can still suppress it when there are many offshore sites, and how violently they would be willing to act to keep their monopoly.
“the biggest worry and the biggest wild card is government you know at some point government will notice and try to do something about it”
A cruise ship offers a feasibility precedent: some estimates suggest living on a cruise ship costs less than a nursing home, and millions of people already spend time at sea, so a seastead could provide basic life needs like food, water, and electricity at sea.
“some estimates that suggested that the cost of living on a cruise ship is less than the cost of living at a nursing home”
Seasteads have a competitive advantage in regulation: businesses that are heavily regulated on land, such as medical tourism, euthanasia, and psychedelic treatments like MDMA for PTSD, could be located 12 to 24 miles offshore to escape US rules, and the savings could justify the trip.
“anything that suffers from regulation and is the ocean things that specifically happened on the ocean”
The early resort model is the right starting point because extended living at sea would be difficult at first; people would visit as tourists, and as the community grows to small-town size it would attract residents who tolerate isolation.
“I think it would be difficult at first that's one reason why I think the resort model is a good way to start”
Seasteading's worth is not that it is a fun or pleasant place to live but that it is a geopolitical and liberty-expanding experiment, starting with small offshore ventures that make money, prove the platform, and achieve economies of scale.
“these small ones off the coast are just a way to get started a way to make some money prove the platform and get economies of scale”
The Hayekian emergent order means that seasteads cannot predict how they will turn out or what people will ultimately choose, so institutions must emerge through experimentation rather than be designed in advance.
“there's a certain Hayekian emergent aspect to you're not as you said you don't know how it'll turn out or what people will ultimately choose”
Fixed-tower seastead designs are an inferior starting point, since mobile seasteads need to avoid storms by migrating on an annual pattern to avoid hurricane season, and locating in the doldrums near the equator could reduce big-wave risk.
“we're looking at doing is being mobile in the sense of not being able to outrun a storm but migrating and an annual pattern so that we avoid hurricane season”
Preliminary engineering estimates put platform construction at about $500 per square foot, comparable to expensive houses in the San Francisco Bay Area, though this is only a starting point because costs should fall with factory-based mass production after the first platform.
“the very very preliminary estimate are a cost of something like $500 a square foot so it's comparable to expensive houses in the u.s. say in a San Frisco Bay Area”
Aquaculture is analogous to ranching relative to fishing as farming is to gathering, and the shift from wild catch to managed production is a major transition like the agricultural revolution.
“aquaculture is the fishing as as ranching is the hunting and you know as we saw and whereas farming as the gathering”
Breakwaters can be designed as inclined planes that compress wave length and raise wave height until waves break, dissipating their energy without hitting the structure, so the breakwater could be surfed and the wave break becomes a recreational amenity.
“you could actually surf this wave break you could have this enormous circular wave break in the middle of the ocean”
The equatorial doldrums have few large waves, which makes them a potentially safer site for a seastead, though Friedman jokes he would like to be there permanently.
“locate in the doldrums the area by the equator right doesn't have a lot of big-wave”
Freshwater for seasteads can come from reverse osmosis or evaporation desalination; large volumes are expensive for growing plants, but water for showers and drinking is affordable, and power would start with diesel, with solar and wind tested for later and wave or thermal (OTEC) power still costing tens of millions to 100 million dollars.
“at the beginning mainly diesel it's pretty cheap to burn diesel we're gonna want to have a little bit of solar and wind”
Friedman and his collaborator Wayne Gramlich wrote the original engineering paper and book describing how a small group could build seasteads step by step, and this incremental, small-group path is what makes the project feasible.
“this guy Wayne Gramlich who wrote the original paper about kind of the engineering and how this would work”
If governments work much better on the ocean because they can be rearranged, the logical extreme is a world where most people live at sea and use the continents as farms and nature preserves.
“everybody moves to the ocean and they just use the continents as farms and Nature Preserve”
Cruise ships already bring in workers from the developing world who earn much more at sea than they could at home, and a seastead could use the same labor model.
“they bring in a lot of workers from the third world and the workers you know they're in this small place they're working a lot but they're making a lot of money”
The danger in seasteading is that collective-action communities could create socialist or strongly coercive arrangements, though Roberts questions how many people would actually want that, and Friedman answers that competition lets such communities exist without binding others.
“there would be an opportunity for ... socialist communal powerful state powerfully coercive arrangements at least in theory”
Large seasteads can use hollow concrete foundations that provide buoyancy at relatively low cost, and with breakwaters in place building on water becomes cheap enough to lower the ocean tax substantially in the long run.
“instead of having this big solid full concrete foundation you have this big solid hollow concrete foundation which provides your buoyancy but it's actually fairly cheap”
Peter Thiel calls the ocean the 'penultimate frontier', and because the ocean shares similarities with space and serves as a stepping stone, seasteading is part of humanity's eventual expansion beyond Earth.
“as Peter Thiel says the ocean is the penultimate frontier eventually it's going to be cost effective to reach space”
Ocean platforms can be made large enough to be 'skyscraper-sized' and move around, so a city could be placed a thousand miles from Russia, which fundamentally changes how governance works and lowers the cost of secession.
“on the ocean instead of just being a boat it can actually be an entire building if you look at the size of a cruise ship or container ship we're talking about things as big as skyscrapers”
The Free State Project has struggled: after about five or six years it had roughly 9,000 signups of its target 20,000, and its main benefit so far is showing people they can move to a lower-tax, lower-regulation state and immediately benefit.
“they had their signups has been pretty slow I think there maybe 9,000 it's been going for you know five or six years”
Seasteading was initially funded through a $500,000 seed investment from Peter Thiel and Clarium Capital after an earlier Google-employed founder side project; Friedman quit his Google job in July to work on the Seasteading Institute full-time.
“he gave us $500,000 and seed funding to start the seasteading Institute just in July I quit my job at Google”
Offshore life can be made pleasant like Las Vegas, where artificial greenery and fountains such as the Bellagio's exist because people will pay for them, so seastead amenities can be supplied by spending on them.
“there is greenery in fountains there is the fountains in front of the Bellagio because people like it enough that it's worth spending the money to have them”
Seasteads would use mobile platforms so they can move to avoid storms or threats and to reduce exposure to attacks, yet this mobility could also make the community a valuable target for hijacking or hiding, which Friedman concedes is a real problem.
“that you could move around that that would be a very valuable thing to hijack the kind of a hard thing defense or to hide that's true a good point”
A seastead could be designed as a giant aquarium with underwater viewing, which would generate tourism and aesthetic value, and the pillars could be converted into viewing spaces.
“if you think about a sea stead as a giant aquarium where you know going the tourism possibilities and the aesthetic possibilities for the residents could be quite large”
Seasteads will be designed to meet their own needs rather than the heavy load requirements of oil platforms, so they can save money by designing differently while leveraging existing oil and gas engineering skill.
“our requirements are much different we don't need to be six in one place we don't need to take these heavy heavy loads”
A libertarian-leaning state would be unlikely to be allowed to secede from the federal government, which would still constrain it.
“I don't think the federal government would let a libertarian minded state secede”
Seasteading will attract a broad range of people, including libertarians who see it as the most plausible option and people with other political goals who expect that a successful seastead will provide government for many different kinds of people.
“some of them are people who are libertarian whose fetuses is the most plausible option others have other political goals”
Oil platform workers report unhappiness with long isolated stays, so psychological tolerance for life on a remote platform is an open question for seasteads, and Friedman responds that Las Vegas, with its artificial fountains and greenery, offers a model of making a desert environment appealing.
“talk to people who work on oil platforms for long periods of time I don't think they're very happy”
Roberts argues that the seastead's main liberty aim, though framed as a resort, requires ocean living to feel acceptable, and that the lack of landscape may be a psychological barrier that tends to make people bored or unhappy on oil platforms.
“I don't think they're very happy”
Seasteading structures are built like oil platforms on tall pillars to avoid waves; the initial coastal platform is about 50,000 square feet, and the first deep-ocean design is about 250,000 square feet housing roughly 200 guests and 70 staff, not a hotel-resort headcount.
“we're looking at about 200 people and 250,000 square feet and that's not a design for a hotel resort so it's actually it's 200 guests and 70 staff”
Friedman's timeline for the first seastead is an optimistic three to five years, and he has not yet raised funds; the first deep-ocean platform timeline remains uncertain because existing oil-platform designs differ from seastead requirements.
“the optimistic timeline is three to five years”
Friedman's stated primary aim is ensuring that the long-term political vision is realized, while he is content for people with business expertise to run the operational side of the venture.
“I want to make sure that the long term political vision happens so I'm happy happy if people who know more about business handle the business aspect”
Seastead sushi and underwater viewpoints would be needed to attract residents, since visitors to a far-offshore platform will expect good sushi, and aquaculture could make a sushi-oriented sea resort a tourist draw.
“anybody who who comes to a floating platform far offshore is going to expect good sushi so we're gonna have to provide that”
Friedman quit his Google job to work on seasteading full-time, and the Institute plans to hire people with business expertise because Friedman himself has never run an organization and is more focused on keeping the long-term political vision on track.
“I ever run anything nope but we can bring in people who know more about the business aspect than I do”