
Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/2007
What this covers
This EconTalk conversation pairs Russ Roberts with Cornell's Robert Frank, who is promoting his book on the Economic Naturalist approach. The first half is about pedagogy. Frank describes his own failure to learn Spanish and German from grammar-heavy courses, in contrast to the Peace Corps method of drilling and improvised response. He applies that lesson to economics: repetition-driven learning, storytelling, and short writing assignments in which students pose and answer their own puzzles. He also offers an incentive explanation for why universities teach otherwise, since tuition covers only a small share of costs and professors answer to research funders more than to students.
The puzzles themselves cover a lot of ground. Apartment leases are explained through search costs and commitment. Brown eggs and aged scotch are used to show that a stable price difference needs both a cost story and a preference story, the supply-and-demand "two blades") idea, with opportunity cost doing the work for aged goods. Newspaper boxes and soda machines differ because publishers earn mainly from advertising. Frank also argues that New York's apparent rudeness reflects the high cost of a stranger's time, not a cultural trait.
The second half turns to positional competition. Frank uses hockey helmets, arms races, and overtime rules as examples of the prisoner's dilemma, and he contrasts goods judged by relative standing, such as house size, with those judged in absolute terms, such as leisure and life-threatening risk. Roberts draws in superstar markets through Sherwin Rosen's work, and he presses on whether such waste extends beyond zero-sum settings. The most contested stretch is Frank's reading of the marriage market, in which he treats love as a commitment device that makes children and joint investment possible. The conversation also touches on the tragedy of the commons.
Frank argues that economics is best taught as a small set of principles applied through repeated, narrative-driven examples that train students to see everyday phenomena, and that most puzzles resolve once both supply-side costs and demand-side preferences are considered. He also argues that competition over relative position can waste resources, though Roberts contests how far this extends beyond zero-sum settings.
- Traditional intro courses leave students no better on basic economics six months later than people who never took them
- Stories, repetition, and student-written puzzles build durable economic reasoning better than encyclopedic lectures and equations
- Many everyday puzzles resolve only when supply-side costs and demand-side preferences are considered together
- Relative-position competition creates arms-race-like waste, but Roberts argues most competitive failures trace to missing property rights
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Apartment leases exist because search is costly: a renter samples units and settles on one that clears a threshold, and a landlord who spent effort showing the apartment wants a tenant committed for a term, so without a lease either side can walk away and leave the other worse off.
“why the lease because there's bound to be some apartment out there that's better than the one you just found”
Competition for working hours is a prisoner's dilemma: as with hockey helmets, each worker who works longer to get ahead forces everyone to work longer, leaving relative standing unchanged while everyone loses leisure.
“it's essentially a prisoner's dilemma and so we do better by having a rule that requires it”
A military arms race is destructive when rivals each seek relative position, because arms and consumer goods like toasters trade off: if relative standing in armaments matters far more than in consumer goods, both sides build arms, fall behind in consumption, and would both benefit from a verified arms-limitation agreement.
“the only reason we say it's a problem that there's a military arms race is that falling behind in the toaster distribution is just less significant than falling behind in the armaments distribution”
Relative-ranking competitions produce winner-take-most outcomes: when Monica Seles was stabbed in 1993 and sidelined, Steffi Graf's earnings roughly doubled the following year, not because she played better but because her relative position improved, and such superstar dynamics are formalized by Sherwin Rosen in the economics of superstars.
“Steffi Graf earned twice as much in the next year as she'd had in the year before not because she was playing better but because relative to the competition she was playing better”
Language instruction failed Frank: after four years of Spanish and German courses he could not function in Spain or Germany because courses emphasized grammar such as the pluperfect subjunctive, while the Peace Corps method of repetition, drilling, and on-the-fly response produced functional speakers.
“we were learning the pluperfect subjunctive we were learning all this grammar that the professors thought important but we weren't really learning how to function in the language”
Hockey players skate without helmets when left to themselves, yet vote unanimously for helmet rules because removing a helmet confers a competitive advantage, so everyone removes theirs and the advantage cancels while safety is lost; this is a prisoner's dilemma that a rule can solve.
“it's essentially a prisoner's dilemma and so we do better by having a rule that requires it”
Older wine and aged single malt scotch cost more than younger ones not only because consumers prefer them, but because producers tie up capital and forgo interest for longer, and competition must compensate for that opportunity cost, so price differences reflect a real cost difference, not just demand.
“the cost difference in the case of wine and aged scotch and many things is that it takes longer to make it you tie up your money in there and the opportunity cost of forgoing the money by selling the wine earlier has to be compensated”
Brown eggs cost more than white eggs because both sides of the market matter: consumers associate brown eggs with healthful or organic food and will pay more, and hens laying white eggs are smaller and eat less per egg, so white eggs cost less to produce, and a stable price difference requires both a demand difference and a supply difference.
“if it were just the demand side difference then the question would ring out well why are they bothering this white eggs of people like brown eggs better why not sell only brown eggs”
The narrow cost-benefit model of the marriage market, in which every trait trades off against every other and a faster gun always might arrive, implies no commitment, but in real life people search where objective criteria are met and then value the specific person they are with, so love functions as a commitment mechanism.
“we have as a result love which is their natural explanation of love”
Requiring short writing assignments across upper-division courses works because writing about an idea is one of the most effective ways to make it part of one's understanding; Frank's program was funded by a Cornell writing-in-the-majors initiative that paid for a TA to grade papers.
“the theory is that if you if you want to learn about an idea there's really almost no better way to get your brain around the idea than to write about it”
In a pure free-agent marriage market where every stage allows a better match, no one would dare have children or buy a house together, because a better partner could always appear, so the economist's ruthless marriage market model misses how relationships deepen once people commit.
“if that person comes along and if it's just a free agent market at every stage then there's no commitment you don't dare have children or buy a house together”
Overtime pay rules that bar a worker from trading time-and-a-half for extra hours may look like a welfare loss, but Frank argues they resemble Schelling's hockey-helmet case: when competitors race for an edge (here, hours), everyone ends up in the same relative position while expending effort, so a rule can make everyone better off.
“it's essentially a prisoner's dilemma and so we do better by having a rule that requires it so you can just push that same argument over into the domain of safety regulations”
The same logic applies to work hours: working ten extra hours to buy a bigger house means less time with family and friends, and if one's evaluations of housing and status goods are more context-sensitive than evaluations of leisure, the same distortion appears as in the arms race.
“if I worked the extra ten hours I'm going to be able to spend more on a house and I'm going to have less time with family and friends”
The same logic that justifies helmet rules applies to safety regulations: people take riskier jobs for higher pay to afford better school districts, bidding up house prices in good districts with no net gain, so regulation can offset the futility of competing on these dimensions.
“I might be tempted to take a riskier job to get higher pay fully voluntarily then I could take the money in bid for house in a better school district”
In surveys, people choose a job with a lower absolute risk of death even if their relative standing is worse, implying absolute safety dominates relative safety for life-threatening risk, whereas for interview suits people prefer the relatively better-dressed position, implying relative standing dominates for status goods.
“everybody I've ever seen confront that question says I'll go where it's only 200 rather than move to where it's 400,000”
People care about absolute levels of some goods and relative standing in others: a house matters largely through its size relative to neighbors, whereas leisure is valued in absolute terms, and people would not trade half their leisure for a higher relative standing, but many would accept a smaller house in a more advantaged neighborhood.
“once your house has gone beyond a certain size the main thing that predicts whether you'll be pleased with it is its relative size”
Context shapes evaluation of consumption: a fast mile time or a fast car is judged by its era, but a house's satisfaction is largely driven by its relative size among neighbors, while leisure is judged in absolute terms, so distortions arise where context matters more in some domains than others.
“the main thing that predicts whether you'll be pleased with it is its relative size”
The standard cultural explanation that New Yorkers are rude and Kansans are nice is unsatisfying, because it does not explain why cultures differ; differences in opportunities and income levels usually explain them, and New York's high hourly earnings make a five-minute conversation with a stranger costly.
“it wouldn't explain why they're rude you know I think that's always the dissatisfying we think about cultural explanations is that it you don't really come to grips with why the cultures are different”
Love functions as a natural commitment device: once people are in a relationship they care about that specific person rather than trait trade-offs, which provides the security needed for children and joint investment, so love is an evolved explanation for durable commitment.
“we have as a result love which is their natural explanation of love”
Academic incentives reward professors for catering to multiple customers because tuition covers only a small share of university costs, with the rest coming from endowments, research grants, government and foundation grants, so professors are not primarily accountable to students for teaching quality.
“tuition only covers a small portion of total costs rest comes from endowment and research grants government grants foundation grants”
Learning requires repetition and active use: the brain carves out durable pathways only through repeated exposure, so one-time exposure to a principle rarely lets a person recognize it when observing the world, unless the material is paired with a vivid emotional stimulus.
“it's repetition that's that's really the key it's drill it's it's active using of the material you know the brain doesn't learn something those ears only once”
The human brain is adapted to absorb information packaged as narrative rather than abstract formalism, because human communication evolved through storytelling, so economics taught through stories and puzzles fits the brain better than graphs and equations drawn in the sand.
“the impulse wasn't to grab a twig and start sketching equations and graphs in the sand you know we told stories and and the brains just marvelously adapted”
Newspaper publishers make most of their revenue from advertising, so a stolen or given-away paper that boosts circulation actually helps them sell ads, which is why they are less upset about theft than soda vendors are about a second soda.
“the owner of the newspaper isn't quite as upset when you steal the newspaper and resell it or give it away or just put it somewhere because they make a large portion of their revenue from advertising”
Why do Americans with more purchasing power seemingly ignore leisure? Frank argues that formal education requiring memorized exam-oriented formalism persists because the incentives of universities are tied to tuition covering only a small portion of cost, with endowment, research, and government and foundation grants paying the rest, so professors cater to research funders rather than students.
“the source of the money tuition only covers a small portion of total costs rest comes from endowment and research grants government grants foundation grants”
Students who take a traditional introductory economics course score no better on a basic economics test six months after finishing than people who never took the course at all.
“if you give introductory students once you've taken this traditional course a test that probes their knowledge of basic economics six months after they're done they don't score any better than people who never took the course at all”
Roberts disputes Frank's overtime argument, claiming that competition produces bad outcomes mainly when property rights are absent, as in the tragedy of the commons (pollution, overfishing), and that zero-sum competition is rare and artificial, as in hockey where entry is limited.
“my claim is that in most situations when competition produces bad results it's because there are no property rights”
Roberts doubts the case that relative standing matters for happiness, citing the happiness literature that people are no happier than they were decades ago, and argues absolute income matters greatly, though Frank agrees relative holdings matter in some domains and calls it an area needing empirical work.
“I'm just reacting to the happiness literature which argues often that you know we're no happier than we were 50 years ago or a hundred years ago”
Steroid use in baseball is a classic arms race: individual players gain an edge when some take steroids, but when everyone does, no one gains an edge while health suffers, though fans may still value the spectacle of 600-foot home runs, so there is a benefit to acknowledge.
“everybody looks for an edge fails to get one and in just in dangers their health but you do have to take into account that the game is more exhilarating”
Most cases where competition produces bad results stem from the absence of property rights, as with the air and oceans, which generate pollution and overfishing; the invisible hand breaks down mainly where property rights are missing.
“my claim is that in most situations when competition produces bad results it's because there are no property rights”
Brides buy wedding gowns but grooms rent tuxedos because gowns must suit many body shapes and be sized precisely, so a rental company must hold a very large inventory that is rented only every eight to ten years, forcing rental fees of 110 to 115 percent of the purchase price, while men accept standard styles that rent eight to twelve times a year at about a quarter of purchase price.
“so to carry such a large idol inventory they've got to charge one hundred and ten hundred fifteen percent of the purchase price of the gown as the rental fee”
Economics education lacks the vivid performance feedback that language and other training programs have, because when economics students fail to learn principles, employers and the public do not know it, so no one complains and the course has no corrective pressure.
“if we send economic students out into the world who didn't learn principles well nobody else knows principles either out there so there's really no feedback”
Newspaper vending machines have open doors while soda machines dispense one item per payment because the owner of a soda sells every unit, while a second newspaper has little value to a thief who already has one, so a theft-proof newspaper machine is not worth its extra cost.
“it'd be a lot more expensive to build a machine like that then one whose door just opens and then locks shut when you shut it and since most people wouldn't stand to benefit by having a second newspaper if they already had one”
New Yorkers are less likely to stop and give directions because the opportunity cost of a few minutes of time is high in a city with the highest hourly earnings and the richest menu of activities, while Topeka residents face a lower opportunity cost.
“it's just a difference in the opportunity cost of time was the suggested answer”
Economics teaches a repeatable way of seeing: once a student recognizes a puzzle's underlying economic principle, they can recognize the same template in new settings, which is the book's central aim, so the economic way of thinking is more an art than a science.
“once you see this puzzle explained by this economic principle then when you see the puzzle in a different form somewhere else you'll recognize the template”
Economics faces an arms race in formalism: the field adopts heavy mathematics and jargon partly to appear more scientific, and the question is why incentives in modern universities keep rewarding dull, exam-oriented textbooks and mediocre teaching.
“you can appear more scientific if you start couching your arguments and fancy words and jargon and equations and there's again a sort of an arms race argument”
Intermediate courses are often built on dull basic-theory prerequisites like marginal productivity and fixed-cost theory that students forget and review anyway, and many students who might have enjoyed economics never take the intermediate course because the principles course was dull, so departments never see them again.
“the argument that the theory builds on the previous series is is over overrated”
Being a good teacher is a sound career strategy for assistant professors who are motivated by non-monetary reward, because the institutions that honor teaching are rare, but at places like George Mason good teaching is rewarded, while elsewhere it can be sneered at by colleagues.
“George Mason I'm proud and ashamed to say is one of the only places maybe the only place where good teaching was honored and and rewarded”
A good intro economics course can be distilled to about seven basic principles, a short list that covers an alarmingly high proportion of what economics can explain, and the test of a syllabus is whether it strips away everything non-essential.
“I managed to get the list of basic economic principles down to seven by doing that”
Roberts argues that extra work gives people more absolute consumption that they value, so overtime laws should not be justified as preventing competition, and that the laws, like many laws against competition, protect one group from working hard rather than serving a social benefit.
“maybe those laws against overtime just like lots of other laws that limit competition aren't there for socially beneficial reasons but to prevent one group from having to work too hard”
As Frank cut the required paper length from about 20 pages to 10, then 5, then a 500-word maximum, the best submissions became shorter, and he thinks 200 words might work even better, because brevity forces students to pose an interesting question and apply basic principles.
“the shorter they got the better they were and as you say maybe I should set the limit of 200 words”
Roberts counters that the gown-rental explanation misses that women's bodies vary more than men's, so brides need more styles and alterations, making a rental inventory much harder to run; he also cites that tears at weddings occur more often on seeing the bride than the groom as anecdotal evidence the bride's attire matters more.
“since women's bodies are less uniform than men's you need more choices in shapes and styles which as you point out is also part of the alteration cost”
When students are asked to produce a second paper, many return with three good questions and ask to submit a medley, which Frank takes as evidence that their brains were rewired so they now see economic principles organizing real-world observations.
“that to me is just a clear signal that during the course of this exercise their brains got rewired”
Female fashion models earn more than male models because women spend at least twice as much as men on clothing and give more thought to what they buy, so a model who captures the look of the moment generates large sales, and top female model Gisele Bundchen earned about 30 million dollars modeling last year, while no male model's salary reached seven figures.
“his Elle bündchen is the highest paid female model and last year she ran 30 million bucks modeling I couldn't find a single male model whose salary went into seven figures last year”
Roberts counters that absolute living standards have risen steadily since 25, 50, and 100 years ago, so relative competition is not obviously harmful, since people value both absolute and relative consumption.
“aren't we all getting ahead of where we were 25 30 and 40 and a hundred and two hundred years ago we have more absolute stuff”
Writing assignments grow out of the realization that writing about an idea is one of the best ways to master it, and assignments work best when TA grading makes feedback feasible.
“if you want to learn about an idea there's really almost no better way to get your brain around the idea than to write about it”
Happiness research claiming people are no happier than fifty or a hundred years ago misses how much absolute income matters: people would not choose to return to an era where three of five children died before age ten.
“if somebody could actually experience what it would be like to have three of your five kids die before the age of 10 they wouldn't want to go move back to that environment”
The Washington Post reviewer who faulted the book for not saying whether supply or demand explains the egg price difference missed the point, since a stable price difference requires both sides; this is the Marshall scissors point.
“the reviewer complained bitterly that Frank doesn't tell us whether it's supply or demand that explains the difference in the price of these eggs when that was precisely the point of the example”
The economic way of thinking is more an art than a science, and before the internet it was absorbed mainly by arguing over puzzles with other economists at lunch rather than in formal classrooms full of graphs and equations.
“the way you'd absorb it would be by hanging out with economists at lunch that's the way a lot of us never did as grad students when we would argue over puzzles”
Steroid use may not raise home-run totals as much as commonly assumed, as Arthur Devaney argues, since Barry Bonds and Mark McGwire may be statistical outliers, though the claim that steroids are harmless to health is not established.
“there's an interesting paper by Arthur Devaney where he actually suggests that he makes the claim that there's no there's no real evidence”
Overtime laws that require time-and-a-half pay ban voluntary arrangements in which workers would accept regular pay for extra hours, which on its face makes both workers and employers worse off.
“it sounds on its face like you're making the worker and the employer worse off by preventing them from engaging in that voluntary transaction”
Whether context distorts consumption in a given domain is an empirical question that economics has not studied much, and Frank regards this as an important area for empirical work.
“that's an empirical question yeah explain that again”
Professors and departments often cover as much material as possible to appear cutting edge, when they should ask how much students can absorb; the problem extends beyond economics to physics and engineering.
“they ought to be asking how much can my students absorb today really but yeah I think it is a widespread problem it's not just economics”
Information is valuable and social alliances matter: people who could acquire information from others through fluid exchange had advantages in almost any environment, and people who are boring cannot form bonds or solve the cooperation problems the species faces.
“if you're boring and if you don't have anything at all interesting to say then people won't want to spend time with you you won't be able to forge bonds”
Teachers underestimate the need for repetition and blame students for forgetting material they said once, forgetting that saying something in class is not the same as students learning it.
“teachers underestimate the value of it they get mad when their students forget stuff that they told them right”
Learning Frank's French in a year abroad, he was the weakest speaker in conversations until he began translating shaggy-dog jokes, which earned him airtime, showing that being interesting is what gets you a turn to speak.
“I finally started translating jokes shaggy dog stories in the French and it turned I mean maybe it's their their preference to listen to people like Jerry Lewis”
The game can become more entertaining even when competitive balance is unchanged: 1950s basketball players were scrawny and did not lift weights, while today's players lift weights and perhaps use steroids, producing a more exciting game without altering the relative competitive balance.
“just like you look at 1950s basketball players are all scrawny none of them lifted weights they didn't use steroids today's basketball players I suspect some of them are using steroids”
The standard introductory economics course is an encyclopedic survey crammed with every idea, delivered through equations and graphs that students dislike, and students take it mainly as a stepping stone to well-paying careers.
“there's a big encyclopedic text with every idea that's ever been written about crammed into it”
Whether relative-position concerns distort outcomes across domains is an empirical question about the magnitude of relative versus absolute motives, and economists have paid too little attention to it.
“and I'll accept the fact that we haven't paid much attention that in economics I think it's an interesting area and as you point out I think it's an area where empirical work is would be useful”
Economic puzzles are valuable when the answer is not obvious, because the counterintuitive question itself draws readers in; the best examples ask why something seems ass-backwards.
“the good questions have that nice element in common there they just seem ass-backwards”
Good teaching is costly because it demands extra office hours and fresh preparation, whereas a chatty, narrative style lets an instructor avoid repeating the same dull notes and graphs, and students' liking the course is itself a reward.
“the beauty of this way of teaching is you know it's not so hard just chatty if you do it well you don't have to work up your notes now”
A single careful reading of the book's puzzles can leave a reader with more lasting knowledge of basic economic ideas than most students retain from a principles course.
“in a single reading of this book walk away with more permanent knowledge of basic economic ideas than most students carry out of a principles course”
Consumer utility theory as usually taught is mostly good for exam questions; Vernon Smith's account of his Harvard teacher Leontief (transcribed as Leon tf) captured that most of it fills time in class, and Frank says most of it is only useful for exam questions.
“Leon tf's answer was teaching what's good for fills up the time”
Incomplete or even erroneous answers in an economics book can be a feature rather than a flaw, because they invite readers to argue and engage; Frank says he would ideally publish questions online for readers to debate.
“it would be an improvement to go through and make the answers incomplete or erroneous at least a handful of cases which I'm sure is the case in the book as it stands just because it gets people arguing”
A child's explanation that Topeka is simpler to navigate, so a stranger giving directions is more likely to know the route, is an insight Roberts and Frank discount because Manhattan is grid-simple and Boston, which is smaller, is harder to navigate.
“Boston for example smaller than Manhattan it's layout is much worse in terms of giving directions more people get lost there”
Roberts doubts that the reasoning about relative versus absolute concerns is empirically settled, arguing that some advantages of absolute returns are not obvious in survey questions, and that the magnitudes and cross-domain differences are open empirical questions.
“one part of my skepticism about the emphasis on relative returns is that some of the return some of the advantages of absolute returns are not so obvious”
Frank concedes that overtime laws would be clearly wrong only if they capped work at an hour a week, because the law prevents workers from exerting a little extra effort for a large gain in goods, which Frank views as a sound reason to accept the restriction.
“if the overtime laws said you could only work an hour a week then I think there would be no question at all but that law is preventing people from putting out a little bit of effort”