Robert Whaples on the Economics of Pope Francis
What this covers
Robert Whaples of Wake Forest University and host Russ Roberts examine Pope Francis's encyclical Laudato Si', which addresses capitalism, poverty, and environmental stewardship. The conversation centers on a fundamental disagreement: whether the Pope correctly diagnoses the root causes of the world's ecological and economic crises. Both speakers grant that Pope Francis identifies excessive consumption as a genuine moral and spiritual problem, but they argue he misplaces the blame. Rather than reading capitalism as an institutional failure, they contend that capitalism simply delivers what people want—and that reform therefore requires changing human desires, not the market system itself. The Pope's error, they suggest, lies in applying public choice theory-style skepticism to markets while naively trusting governments and NGOs, which face the same human selfishness and corruption.
The discussion ranges across three main territories. First, it contests the empirical claims: Whaples points to the environmental Kuznets curve and documented improvements in air quality and living standards under market-oriented policies, arguing the encyclical ignores this evidence. Second, it examines the Pope's theological reasoning—particularly his framing of the Earth as sentient and his invocation of St. Francis of Assisi's spirituality—alongside his skepticism of genetically modified crops and large-scale agriculture, which reflects sympathy for peasant farmers that economists typically overlook. Third, it explores alternative solutions: the speakers emphasize property rights, market mechanisms, and work by Elinor Ostrom on commons governance as paths the encyclical missed. Throughout, Roberts argues that moral exhortation from religious figures suits the problem better than state coercion, while both speakers register that the Pope's Argentine experience with crony capitalism shaped his wariness of markets in ways Pope John Paul II's anti-communism did not.
Whaples and Roberts argue that Pope Francis's encyclical Laudato Si' rightly diagnoses excessive consumption as a moral and spiritual problem, but errs by treating it as an institutional failure of capitalism rather than a failure of human desire, and overlooks market-based and property-rights solutions to the very environmental and poverty problems it laments.
- Capitalism delivers what people want, so to improve outcomes you must change human desires, not the market system
- The encyclical lacks empirical evidence and ignores documented progress like the environmental Kuznets curve
- The Pope applies a public-choice-style skepticism to markets but naively trusts governments and NGOs which are equally fallen
Moral exhortation and attitude change, not state coercion, should shape economic choices and human behavior.
- Capitalism is not the problem—we are; what capitalism does well is give us what we want, so if you want to make capitalism better you must change what we want rather than indict the institution, which is why moral exhortation by figures like the Pope is the right lever and the encyclical errs by reading as an institutional indictment instead of an indictment of human frailty.
“capitalism is not the problem. It's us. Capitalism is, what it's really good at, is giving us what we want--more or less.”
- Channeling Saint Francis of Assisi, the Pope argues that our attitudes affect our behavior toward the earth: if we see ourselves in a different relationship with the Earth, we will behave better, be less wasteful, and pollute less, making self-transformation through emotion and attitude rather than only external incentives a route to better environmental conduct.
“argues that our attitudes affect our behavior. Particularly, toward the earth--is the way I read it--is by, if we can see ourselves in a different relationship with the Earth, we would then behave better. We would be less wasteful. We would pollute less.”
- Roberts wants moral persuaders like the Pope and preachers, not governments with guns, to influence humanity's economic choices; people should be free to ignore the Pope, but no one should be able to impose those choices on others through the coercive power of the state over the economic system.
“I want the Pope and the other preachers of the world to be the ones who influence humanity; and not the governments with the guns.”
Empirical evidence shows poverty has dramatically declined and capitalism has succeeded, contrary to the encyclical's claims.
- The encyclical is strikingly short on empirical evidence: rather than cherry-picking data to make its case, it contains very little data at all, while the available data on environmental destruction and poverty largely cuts the other way against the Pope's claims.
“it's not so much that the document cherry-picks data to make the Pope's case. There's very little data in it. And the data that comes to my mind is on the other side.”
- Over the last century and especially the last 20 years, hundreds of millions of people have left poverty in what is an incredible success story, though debate remains over which aspects of capitalism and how much government were responsible, and large pockets of miserable poverty—perhaps the bottom 800 million—still persist.
“many, many millions, hundreds of millions of people have left poverty in the last century, in the last 20 years. It's been, I think, an incredible success story.”
Free-marketers and papal critics both dismiss inconvenient versions of their preferred systems while capitalism genuinely enables regulatory capture.
- There is nothing inherently good about a bigger economy: if people genuinely want to give fewer gifts, be less material, and spend more time with family, then a smaller economy is fine, and economists who insist on a big holiday season to 'keep the economy going' display an unattractive bias toward growth for its own sake.
“There's nothing inherently good about a bigger economy, if we don't want it.”
- There is a distinction between resume virtues—career accomplishments in the material world—and eulogy virtues—what kind of human being, spouse, parent, friend, and colleague you were; people commonly forget the latter and over-focus on the former, a challenge for religious and secular people alike.
“a distinction between your resumé and your eulogy. Your resumé is your career accomplishments... but your eulogy is why kind of human being you were”
- Free-marketers dismiss failed socialism as 'not real socialism' yet inconsistently dismiss crony capitalism as 'not what we meant'; both moves are symmetric, and the Pope may have witnessed the real kind of capitalism, since the growth of capitalism genuinely empowers businesses to capture the political process for their own ends.
“when we have capitalism gone wrong, which is what crony capitalism is, we say, 'Oh, that's not--that's not we meant. We mean the other kind.'”
Economic science conflates descriptive human behavior with normative goodness, misleading students about what markets achieve.
- Economics teaches that 'more is better' and that people maximize utility, which is a reasonable starting description of how people actually behave; but economists deliberately or not confuse students into thinking that because that is how the world is, it is therefore good—the descriptive fact of behavior and its normative goodness do not necessarily go together, an error compounded when the market equilibrium is labeled the efficient social optimum.
“we often, I think, deliberately or not, confuse our students into thinking that how the world is is necessarily good. And it's not necessarily true.”