regime uncertainty
The idea (associated with economist Bob Higgs) that pervasive uncertainty about future government policy, property rights, and rules discourages private investment and prolongs economic downturns.
As defined in Amity Shlaes on the Great Depression
Other definitions
Investor apprehension caused by unpredictable, rapid, or threatening government policy changes, including uncertainty about property rights and the rules of the game, which discourages long-term investment.
Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
Where it comes up · 8
- Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/20089 claims
- George Selgin3 claims
- Amity Shlaes on the Great Depression2 claims
- Steve Fazzari on Stimulus and Keynes 01/24/20112 claims
- Peter Boettke on Hurricane Katrina and the Economics of Disaster 12/18/20062 claims
- Larry White on Hayek and Money 02/01/20101 claim
- John Taylor on the State of the Economy 07/19/20101 claim
- Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/20091 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 21Search all claims for “regime uncertainty” →
- A 1941 Fortune magazine poll of about 1,000 business executives found that 40 percent expected a semi-socialized society or complete economic dictatorship after the war, with 52 percent expecting government to take over many public services, and only 7 percent expecting a restored free enterprise system.Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
- Property owners, not experts, should decide whether and how to rebuild because they have the strongest incentive to determine the best use of their land—but unreleased flood maps and unresolved insurance and levee decisions created regime uncertainty that shortened time horizons and suppressed risk-taking and long-term investment.Peter Boettke on Hurricane Katrina and the Economics of Disaster 12/18/2006
- Regime uncertainty, the atmosphere of apprehension created by erratic government policy, explains why long-term investment did not recover after the mid-1930s, and it is a better explanation than a simple ex post rationalization of dislike for Roosevelt.Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
- Regime uncertainty, created by Roosevelt's administration from about 1935, made investors apprehensive about property rights and the future, so long-term private investment never recovered to late-1920s levels, when private investment had been about 16 percent of GDP, until after World War II.Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
- In 1940-41, businessmen refused to accept government munitions contracts because they did not trust the Roosevelt administration, a 'strike of capital' that Higgs says ended quickly once Roosevelt brought businessmen into government to run the buildup.Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
- The salient question is not whether the war ended the Depression but why it lasted so long; following Bob Higgs, the atmosphere of uncertainty Roosevelt created through relentless reform and tinkering made it much harder for the economy to recover, and GDP did not return to prior levels until late in the 1930s while the market did not recover until the 1950s.Amity Shlaes on the Great Depression
- Roosevelt had no fixed course but engaged in 'bold, persistent experimentation' that was unpredictable; because the ruler's unpredictability about what he would do next made investors and employers freeze, capital effectively went on strike, and this cost the economy significantly—an aspect generally left out of standard Depression histories.Amity Shlaes on the Great Depression
- Regime uncertainty—constant fluctuation in the rules of the game—makes it hard to plan for the future, makes people anxious, and reduces willingness to take chances, producing a flight away from credit and toward cash that is itself an expression of lost confidence in the future.Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/2009
- Regime uncertainty, the idea that government intervention discourages risk-taking, is used by non-interventionists as an explanation for bad times, but no one has a theory of its magnitude, so it is easy to invoke and hard to test, and the correlation with bad times may be confused with causation.Steve Fazzari on Stimulus and Keynes 01/24/2011
- The length and depth of the Great Depression is not explained by Hayek's theory alone; it requires adding Bob Higgs's regime uncertainty and Milton Friedman's money-supply collapse, plus the actual interventions of the National Industrial Recovery Act and Agricultural Adjustment Act, which organized industry and agriculture to restrict output to raise prices—a non-sequitur because cartelizing one industry yields monopoly profit but cannot work for all industries simultaneously, since universal output restriction shrinks total output and reduces hiring.Larry White on Hayek and Money 02/01/2010