
Megan McArdle on Debt and Self-Restraint 12/07/2009
What this covers
Megan McArdle and Russ Roberts discuss debt's asymmetric power and the practical limits of willpower in this EconTalk conversation. McArdle draws on her experience at a Dave Ramsey personal finance seminar to argue that debt magnifies outcomes in both directions—enhancing prosperity in good times while turning catastrophic when conditions shift—but that most people forget this lesson because they live through mostly good times. The conversation moves from personal finance into government budgeting, extending her core claim: when a system requires willpower that most people cannot sustain, the problem lies not in individual failure but in the system's design. Workable solutions demand forcing mechanisms—the physical pain of handing over cash, the hard constraints of envelopes—not nudges.
The discussion covers behavioral economics and the psychology of self-restraint, examining why small tricks (smaller plates, credit cards masking expenditure) fail long-term. It pulls in historical perspective on how financial panics shape generational behavior, comparing Depression-era hoarding and flight to Treasuries with contemporary patterns. McArdle addresses the structural U.S. fiscal problem—not the cyclical deficit but the permanent gap between revenues and spending, and Congress's absence of any credible mechanism to enforce budget discipline the way cash envelopes force individuals to. The conversation touches on regime uncertainty, student loan bankruptcy law, Social Security and Medicare's unsustainability, the misuse of Keynes to justify permanent government expansion, and the Treasury's refinancing risks from short-term debt. Throughout, McArdle distinguishes between wanting a goal (weight loss, financial security) and wanting to pay the price that achieving it demands.
McArdle argues that debt magnifies fortunes in good times but becomes catastrophic in bad times, and that since most people cannot follow sensible rules through willpower alone, effective self-restraint requires brute-force forcing mechanisms (like Ramsey's cash envelopes) rather than nudges—an argument she extends to government, which lacks any credible commitment device to live within its budget.
- Debt magnifies outcomes asymmetrically: great in good times, catastrophic in bad times, which most people forget because they live through mostly good times.
- If most people can't follow a system, the problem is the system, not the people—so workable solutions must force the desired behavior (cash envelopes), not rely on willpower or small nudges.
- The same lack of a credible commitment mechanism that ruins personal finances afflicts Congress, producing an unsustainable structural deficit.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Debt magnifies our fortunes: when things go well it allows us to live even better, but when things go badly it can become catastrophic, and the behavioral challenge is that most people who live through mostly good times forget this lesson.
“debt sort of magnifies our fortunes when things are going well that allows us to live even better but when things are going badly that can become catastrophic and it's a great behavioral challenge for most of us who live through mostly good times to remember that lesson”
The lesson of the 1960s-70s is that while Keynesian short-term stimulus may work, governments wrongly concluded they could stimulate permanently; you cannot keep output above trend—attempting to do so ultimately yields inflation while output returns to trend.
“what we found out is that that doesn't work ultimately you get inflation and output returns to trend you cannot keep output permanently above above trend”
Financial panics shape the behavior of the generation that lives through them: the children of panics save more, hoard liquid assets, and distrust banks and the stock market, as seen in Depression-era people who hid cash and held only US Treasuries—and the same flight to Treasuries is visible again now.
“we've had panics and the children of those panics do behave differently”
Paying for variable expenses with physical cash from labeled envelopes works as a brute-force budgeting mechanism because handing over cash hurts—you physically see the money leaving and the budget dwindling—whereas a card masks the loss, so the cash constraint forces restraint without requiring receipt-tracking discipline.
“when you're actually paying cash it hurts because you're seeing the money leave your wallet and you can physically see your budget dwindling”
Regime uncertainty—constant fluctuation in the rules of the game—makes it hard to plan for the future, makes people anxious, and reduces willingness to take chances, producing a flight away from credit and toward cash that is itself an expression of lost confidence in the future.
“this is really Bob Biggs's story which is regime uncertainty the chained constant fluctuations and the rules the game make it very hard to plan for the future and make people very anxious and not so eager to take chances”
If the majority of people cannot follow a self-management system (time management, diets, home organization, budgeting), then the problem is the system, not the people, so workable solutions must use forcing mechanisms that make it easy to commit rather than relying on willpower.
“the problem if people can't stick to it the problem is the system not the people if the majority of people can't do it which is true all time management systems... so any system that starts with that premise is a failure and so you have to set up mechanisms that will force you to do what you want to do anyway”
Student loan debt is essentially non-dischargeable in bankruptcy except under very rare circumstances (e.g., permanent disability), similar to how tax debts cannot be discharged, which removes bankruptcy as an option for those burdened by it.
“student learned that is basically not dischargeable in bankruptcy unless you are permanently disabled they're like a very few rare circumstances under which you can discharge it in bankruptcy”
We often fail to do things we say we want (lose weight, get organized) not because we're irrational but because we want the goal without wanting the process or paying its price—e.g., wanting to be thinner is not the same as wanting to lose weight, which has an unpleasant downside.
“in theory what I would like is to be thinner I don't actually want to lose weight necessarily right because losing weight has an unpleasant down”
Keynesian theory only prescribes counter-cyclical government spending (spend heavily in deep recessions), not a high average level of government spending, so invoking Keynes to justify a permanent rise in government's share of GDP from ~20% to ~30% is illegitimate and unrelated to whether stimulus works.
“what it tells you cyclically that the government should be operating counter-cyclical... it doesn't say the average level of government spending should be high”
Congress's fiscal problem is fundamentally a lack of a credible commitment mechanism: they write a budget but don't stick to it and won't say 'if I don't have the money it doesn't go out the door'—exactly the discipline that cash-envelope budgeting forces on individuals.
“they don't have a credible commitment mechanism to stick to the budget that they write down and they aren't willing to say if I don't have the money it doesn't go out the door”
Because people plan their lives around Social Security and Medicare, delaying reform makes the eventual changes more damaging: those who counted on it and paid in will end up worse off than if there had been no program at all, and the longer reform is left, the more such people there are.
“people plan their lives around it and when you have to change it as we will... those people will be worse off than they would be if there were no program and the longer you leave it the more people you have who will be worse off”
Libertarian-paternalist nudging and coercion rely too heavily on time inconsistency and hyperbolic discounting—privileging future-you's preferences over current-you's—but this is not always a valid distinction, since current-you's enjoyment (pumpkin pie) is genuinely valuable and the idea that one should always postpone gratification is an anti-human idea.
“they rely too much on hyperbolic discounting which is just a way of privilege a future you the desires of future you over the desires of current you because pumpkin pie is super delicious”
The real fiscal danger is not the cyclical deficit but the structural deficit: even in 2019 there is a projected ~$750 billion gap (about 6% of GDP) that keeps compounding, and with trend growth of only 3% the debt cannot be outgrown, so creditors will eventually stop lending at attractive rates.
“the libertarian and conservative pundits including me are talking about the structural deficit which is that when you look out in 2019 there's still seven hundred and fifty billion dollars sitting there gap its 6% of GDP”
Social Security and Medicare are not true liabilities but campaign promises the government cannot keep as written; the law is unsustainable and will be changed, so the real issue is the political fight over the mix of benefit cuts, means testing, and raised retirement ages.
“those aren't liabilities those are campaign promises they're not gonna keep they can change the law... the law is written is not sustainable so they're gonna change it”
Contrary to the common narrative of a 'bygone era of thrift,' America has historically had a more open relationship to debt than Europe—being settled in part by people escaping debts—as shown by unusually debtor-friendly US bankruptcy laws (e.g., Chapter 7 available to 90% of filers), which other countries find astonishing.
“America was filled with people who came here to escape their debts and in Europe like we've always had actually much more sort of open relationship to debt than most people and it shows like in our bankruptcy laws which are just unbelievably debtor friendly”
Paternalistic nudges aimed at saving are more justified than those aimed at minor health goals because of the free-rider temptation: if society will keep the destitute alive anyway, individuals have an incentive to spend everything now and rely on the minimum standard of living others will provide.
“with things like saving it's arguably more justified because there's always the temptation to free rise well if I'm really destitute people are going to keep me alive anyway so I might as well spend it all now”
Ramsey's debt-snowball method has you pay minimums on everything except the smallest debt, attack that smallest debt fastest, then roll those payments into the next debt and so on—a sequencing that prioritizes psychological momentum over mathematical interest-cost minimization.
“a very common technique called a snowball where you pay the minimums on everything except your smallest debt and you pay that down as fast as possible and then you take all of the payments from that you roll it over into the next step”
Small calorie-based weight-loss tricks (smaller plates, refilled soup bowls) don't actually work long-term because a surplus or deficit of only 50 calories a day compounds to several pounds a year, meaning appetite must already calibrate intake to metabolism closely; you can fool people in the short term but they compensate later.
“a deficit or a surplus of 50 calories a day is enough to make you gain several pounds a year and if our appetites have to be calibrating our metabolisms pretty closely... otherwise we would all be grotesquely obese”
The Treasury has issued a lot of short-term debt to capture lower interest rates, which means an enormous rollover burden—potentially needing to borrow around three trillion dollars in a year (two trillion to refinance maturing short-term debt plus a trillion of new deficit)—and there may not be enough lending appetite at current rates, mirroring the 1930s residential balloon-mortgage collapse when borrowers could no longer roll over.
“we might end up having to borrow three trillion dollars this year two trillion to pay off the short-term debt that's coming due at another trillion of expenditures above in income receipts”
Dave Ramsey's core message, derived from the Biblical verse 'the borrower is a slave to the lender,' is that as long as you owe money you are in bondage to the lender, who can always push you into bankruptcy, so you should never borrow money for anything.
“he came upon a Bible verse the borrower is a slave to the lender and he decided at that moment never borrowing money again and that's his core message is that as long as you've borrowed money you are in slavery to the person you borrowed money from”
The Great Depression was sui generis because government and the Fed actively prolonged it—contractionary money supply, staying on the gold standard (which forced perverse moves like raising rates in a recession)—while FDR did some necessary things (FDIC, ending bank panics) alongside genuinely insane things (price controls, threats to seize profits) that deterred investment.
“the Fed egged it on with contractionary money supply with staying on the gold standard which required all sorts of bizarre things... like raising interest rates”
The paradox of thrift only bites when savings fail to be channeled into investment; from roughly November to March the mechanisms translating savings into investment (IPOs, new bond issues) were broken, so savings became money pulled out of the economy—but such traps don't last forever because investment goods are the missing piece.
“what it leaves out is investment goods exactly right so it really depends on where the savings go”
Roughly 3 out of 10 Americans who make more than $100,000 a year report living paycheck to paycheck, with no buffer if something bad happens, and a majority of people below that income level do so.
“how many people live paycheck to paycheck even among people who make more than $100,000 a year 3 out of 10 of them say that they live paycheck to paycheck”
Keynesian and monetarist views are not mirror images, so disproving Friedman would not vindicate Keynes—both can be (and were) partly right and partly wrong; people who concluded 'Friedman was wrong, Keynes was right' from the crisis committed a logical error.
“it's not like there's some sort of mirror image of each other where like if Milton Friedman turned out to be wrong then therefore Keynes would be right they could both be wrong and I think they were both wrong about a bunch of things and right about a bunch of things”
MBA students grossly abused the permanent income hypothesis and consumption-smoothing theory to justify lavish spending and debt, illustrating that in the hands of someone who already wants to do something, a little bit of knowledge is an incredibly dangerous thing.
“we were grossly abusing theory of the permanent income hypothesis and the theory of consumption smoothing this is not to say that we were taking good advice from economists rather it's to say that in the hands of someone who already wants to do something a little bit of knowledge is an incredibly dangerous thing”
Budgeting every dollar in advance ('giving every dollar a name') produces a serene, freeing feeling because you can spend whatever is allocated without guilt, knowing every dollar you spend is one you can afford and every dollar you don't spend is already where it should be—being intentional about money is the key benefit.
“that serene feeling of knowing that every dollar that you're spending is a dollar you can afford to spend that it's okay to spend and all of the money that you're not spending is where it should be it's in your bank and it's doing its thing to be intentional”
Pleasure from consumption like ice cream is short-lived and does not create lasting memories, whereas an extravagant experience like a vacation produces a lifetime of photographs and memories, so there is a real difference between forms of present gratification.
“the pleasure from the ice cream is fairly short-lived it does not create a lifetime of memories like the Cancun experience... the extravagant vacation does produce a lifetime of photographs and memories”
Her grandmother used the same cash-envelope budgeting method during the early years of marriage in the Depression era, showing Ramsey did not invent the technique.
“Dave Ramsey did not invent this my grandmother used it... so she has a little envelopes and she was telling me all about it”
The one mortgage Ramsey permits is a 15-year fixed-rate mortgage whose payment is no more than 25% of income, which by normal home-buying standards is very conservative, to be paid off as fast as possible.
“a mortgage but only a mortgage that is a 15-year fixed-rate mortgage where the payment is only twenty five percent of your income”
Measured savings rates are an awful, very misleading measure of saving in absolute level terms, though the trend clearly shows people saving more than before.
“measured savings rates an awful measure savings and is very is very the absolute level measure is very misleading but but the trend is clearly people are saving more than they did before”
America has a 'permanent income hypothesis in our bones'—a national character that assumes the standard of living will always rise (which Roberts believes is basically true), encouraging a live-for-today attitude that wars against an opposing Puritan, self-sacrificing streak.
“it's sort of a permanent income hypothesis in our bones I think maybe our national character that since our standard of living is always going to be rising which I believe is basically true”
Debt is a good thing because it allows businesses to thrive and lets people own houses.
“that's what allows businesses to thrive it lets us own houses”
It is no longer unimaginable—as it was two years ago—that the US could default on its sovereign debt.
“it's not as unimaginable as it was two years ago that the US would default on its nationally would a sovereign debt to fall for the u.s. government is imaginable now at least to me”
Megan McArdle has substantial personal debt, including a roughly $100,000 MBA from the University of Chicago (1999-2001), and currently carries a car loan and a student loan but no credit card debt.
“I got an MBA from the University of Chicago in between 1999 and 2001 which cost about a hundred thousand dollars when you factor in living expenses and forgone income”