measurement problem
The unresolved foundational question of how and why quantum superpositions appear to collapse into definite outcomes upon measurement.
As defined in ms_130
Other definitions
In quantum mechanics, the conceptual difficulty that observation of a quantum system appears to affect the system's state (collapsing superposition to definite values), raising questions about the role of the observer and whether reality is determinate before measurement
Quantum Physicist Erwin Schrödinger Thoughts on Upanishadic philosophy | Eternal Talks |
Where it comes up · 19
- 59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics5 claims
- Sean Carroll: The many worlds of quantum mechanics4 claims
- 124 - In Search Of Reality3 claims
- 366 | Jim Al-Khalili on Time, Quantum, Biology, and Cosmology3 claims
- 55 | A Conversation with Rob Reid on Quantum Mechanics and Many Worlds3 claims
- 63 | Solo -- Finding Gravity Within Quantum Mechanics3 claims
- Adam Frank2 claims
- AMA | April 20252 claims
and 11 more
Most important claims · 10 of 38Search all claims for “measurement problem” →
- After the Civil War the North grew very rapidly, similar to Germany and Japan after World War Two, while the South's measured income fell at first, but this was largely a measurement problem because unpaid labor of enslaved people, formerly counted as property, was no longer captured in income.Engerman on Slavery 11/21/2006
- The measurement problem is that stuff is described by a quantum wave, but when you measure or observe it you see a particle instead, requiring separate rules for measurement that classical mechanics never needed, and the standard formalism never specifies why measurement needs separate rules, what qualifies as a measurement, or how and why the wave function changes.55 | A Conversation with Rob Reid on Quantum Mechanics and Many Worlds
- Historian David Kaiser's analysis of post-war physics curricula and textbooks found that the larger the classroom, the less time was spent on the meaning and foundations of quantum theory and the more on applications, because it is easier to teach solving differential equations than thorny philosophical issues.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- In Many-Worlds, a measurement is whenever a tiny quantum system in a superposition interacts with and becomes entangled with a big macroscopic system; the wave function of the universe then goes from describing one world to describing two worlds (e.g., one where you saw spin up and one where you saw spin down), so the universe has split or branched, which Everett claims answers the measurement problem.55 | A Conversation with Rob Reid on Quantum Mechanics and Many Worlds
- After the Manhattan Project, governments, industry and the military recognized the value of funding massive applied physics, and this influx of money and personnel redirected the field toward working out implications of quantum theory rather than its foundations, sweeping questions of meaning under the rug.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- Quantum mechanics has two contradictory rules for how wave functions behave: the deterministic Schrodinger equation when nothing is being measured, and the probabilistic collapse described by the Born rule when a measurement occurs; the unresolved question of which rule to apply when, and what counts as a measurement, is the measurement problem.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- Twentieth-century physics achieved the astonishing feat of figuring out how to use quantum mechanics as a black-box cookbook while tragically failing to try to understand what it says about reality, because a bad incentive structure systematically prevented those who wanted to work on the measurement problem and interpretation from becoming professional physicists, treating such work as disreputable rather than the highest priority.124 - In Search Of Reality
- The failure mode of a discipline is when it becomes insufficiently self-critical or disengaged from external reality—too inward-looking, judging its successes by criteria only it understands—because it's very hard to take seriously criticisms from people outside the discipline, even valid ones about the measurement problem in quantum mechanics or the foundations of macroeconomics.Holiday Message 2021 | On Disciplines & Cocktails
- Any version of quantum mechanics says we describe the world differently when we are and are not looking at it; before measurement an electron's spin is best described as a superposition of clockwise and counterclockwise (doing both with different admixtures), and only upon measurement do we ever see one definite outcome—and 'looking' requires no consciousness, since a video camera or a rock can perform a measurement.124 - In Search Of Reality
- A quantum measurement is fundamentally different from a classical disturbance like inserting a thermometer, because in the classical case the system has a definite pre-existing value that is merely perturbed, whereas in quantum mechanics the system is genuinely in a superposition with no definite value until measurement, so measurement involves entanglement and apparent collapse rather than mere physical disruption of a pre-existing state.AMA | April 2025