
Engerman on Slavery 11/21/2006
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Stanley Engerman, co-author with Robert Fogel of Time on the Cross, about slavery across world history and in the United States. Engerman describes the book's contribution as a systematic use of existing records rather than new data: sixty years of New Orleans sale records, estate inventories, and plantation ledgers tracking daily output, rations, and families. The conversation also places American slavery in a global frame. It ran late in Cuba, Brazil, China, Thailand, and Korea, and by 1888 Africa and Asia probably held more slaves than the Americas ever had. Some historical slavery was also voluntary, with starving families selling themselves.
The middle of the talk turns to incentives and to how slavery ended. Engerman cites Xenophon on ancient masters rewarding productive slaves with better clothing, and he applies piece-wage logic and the principal-agent problem to slave and free labor alike. He reads manumission as often self-purchase rather than generosity. He uses the post-1350 English labor shortage as a case of cartel breakdown.
On the Civil War, he stresses that only 25 to 30 percent of southern households owned slaves, yet slaves' value in 1860 roughly equaled gross national product. He notes that nearly every other abolition paid owners, that Abraham Lincoln proposed compensated emancipation in 1862, and that the Haitian indemnity went to owners, not the enslaved. A postwar income puzzle is explained as a measurement artifact. The last stretch is Roberts on trade deficits, capital surpluses, and protectionism.
Engerman argues that American slavery was a profitable, adaptable, and incentive-managed system rather than an unproductive one, and that the Civil War was not primarily a moral crusade against it, so conventional views of slavery's economics and of the war's causes are misleading.
- Slave owners used differential rewards and incentive schemes, and slave prices and lending were at peak levels in the 1850s
- Northern states restricted Black rights, and most Confederate soldiers did not own slaves, so moral-crusade and property-defense explanations fit poorly
- Compensated emancipation was the norm elsewhere, and the US failure to compensate owners shaped how slavery ended
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
After the Civil War the North grew very rapidly, similar to Germany and Japan after World War Two, while the South's measured income fell at first, but this was largely a measurement problem because unpaid labor of enslaved people, formerly counted as property, was no longer captured in income.
“the South actually curiously suff is a large suffers a decline in income but that's because you've ended slavery and you lose a plantation system it's a measurement problem”
The US and a few other countries were nearly alone in never compensating slave owners for emancipation, while in almost all serfdom and slavery abolitions owners were paid in cash or continued labor; a federal purchase of slaves at market prices would have raised the federal budget about 50-fold.
“the US and one or two other countries are among the very few places in which the slave owners were never compensated for the freeing of the slaves”
After the Black Death in England around 1350, labor shortages broke landowners' cartel: they bid against each other for serfs by offering pay, rewards, and eventually freedom, a case where the cartel collapsed and the government did not enforce coercion.
“the owners of the land however broke their cartel what they started to do was to bid against each other for slaves offer of serfs”
In 1862 Lincoln proposed compensated emancipation and argued that compensating slaveholders would cost less than the war, which he estimated at about 87 days of warfare in cost.
“he compared the cost the financial cost of the war here in bringing bodies with how much would be to compensate slaves in certain places and his argument in effect was that if we compensated the people that will save the cost of 87 days of warfare”
Xenophon, a Greek writer, countered the idea that slavery lacks incentives by describing a reward scheme in which a master bought better clothing for productive slaves and worse clothing for unproductive ones, showing that ancient masters already thought about incentives.
“the most intriguing one because it's a counter to Adam Smith's argument that slavery is inefficient because there's no incentive was a Greek philosopher Xenophon who commented”
Most manumissions were not granted by owners as acts of generosity; instead, slaves were often allowed to purchase their own freedom with money earned by working elsewhere or overtime, so the practice was less benevolent than it appears.
“most of the manumissions were not given by the owner the slave was given the right to purchase himself with money here and working elsewhere”
The South seceded because the value of enslaved people in 1860 was about equal to the entire gross national product, so the economic stake in slavery was enormous, and independence was seen as the best way to protect that property.
“the value of slaves in 1860 was equal to about the whole value of the gross national product”
Only about 25 to 30 percent of southern households owned slaves, and most Confederate soldiers did not own slaves, so the common view that southerners fought to protect their own slave property is mistaken.
“only about 25 to 30 percent owned slaves most of the slave owners were you had some very large plantations”
Piece wages, paying by output, give workers stronger incentives than time wages, so a principal-agent problem appears in both slave and free labor: the logic that favors piece pay applies to free workers as well.
“the optimum payment scheme should be peace wages not time wages time wages don't give people enough incentive peace wages do”
Only about 25 to 30 percent of Southern white families owned slaves, and slave ownership was seen as upward mobility, which tied many non-owners to the system.
“only about 25 to 30 percent owned slaves most of the slave owners were you had some very large plantations”
Slavery persisted late in many places: it lasted in Cuba until 1886 and in Brazil until about 1888, ended in China around 1910, Thailand in 1905, and Korea in 1894, and by 1888 there were probably still more slaves in Africa and Asia than had ever existed in the Americas.
“slavery existed in Cuba to 1886 and to Brazil which had a large number of slaves to about 1888”
Haiti, after its revolution, was pressed by France to pay compensation for property losses, and Haiti did pay, but the money did not go to the formerly enslaved people, illustrating how strongly property rights were held in the 19th century even against enslaved people's claims.
“Haiti did pay compensation to the French where they got to the flavin is we don't know but it did not go to the slaves”
Manumission, the owner's granting of freedom, was a long-standing practice but was never a direct attack on slavery: it was accepted as part of keeping the system going, and real assaults on slavery as a system began only in the late 18th century.
“manumission was always accepted but that was actually part of keeping the system going”
Almost all other abolitions of slavery and serfdom paid compensation to owners, but the US was among very few places that did not, so the South held out for compensation that was never offered.
“the US and one or two other countries are among the very few places in which the slave owners were never compensated for the freeing of the slaves in almost all cases of serfdom and slavery”
Slave owners who bought or coerced people into slavery rationalized it by believing that buying a slave kept that person alive, and that providing living standards and following religious codes of kindness was a public good, so they could accept the practice.
“these people were feeling number one that if they didn't purchase a slave that slave might die and therefore what they were doing is helping the people survive number two they were providing living standards for these people”
Most white southerners were small landowning farmers with high literacy and substantial income and wealth, so they were not a downtrodden group and had their own stake in defending their farms against a Northern conquest.
“most of the southern population was basically small farmers who owned their own land in fact you have many more landowners in the south among the white population”
The book's central empirical contribution was not new data but systematic use of existing sources: New Orleans slave sale records over 60 years, estate inventories, and detailed plantation records showing daily output, rations, and slave families, allowing estimates of how well people were fed and how prices changed over time.
“so it wasn't at the data itself may have been particularly new or novel this was really just much broader and much more in-depth study of these various sources”
Any way a country gets cheaper goods, whether through domestic innovation or through foreign trade, raises living standards by freeing resources for other uses, so the main effect of imports on the US is the same as that of a domestic innovation that lowers car prices.
“it allows America to use fewer resources making cars and more resources making something else and it's going to ultimately make us richer”
Agricultural productivity shows that job losses from efficiency do not produce mass unemployment: the share of American workers in farming fell from a large share in 1900 to under 2 percent today, and new jobs replaced those lost while food became cheaper.
“think about agriculture over the last hundred years as farmers have become more innovative we get more food at lower prices using fewer workers”
Trade deficits do not destroy total employment: even if imports replaced domestic production, job losses in one industry would be offset by expansion elsewhere because consumers would have more money to spend, and the living standard would rise.
“the decrease in the demand for labor in the our industry is going to be offset by an increase in demand for labor in industries outside the car market”
The only way a country raises its standard of living is to produce more stuff with fewer resources, either through technological innovation or through trade that lets others produce things more cheaply.
“the only way to do it is to find a way to make more stuff with fewer resources there are two ways to do that one is to innovate through technological change”
Historically, much slavery was voluntary in the sense that desperately poor people or families on the verge of starvation sold themselves into slavery to survive, whereas American slavery and most other slavery was clearly involuntary, consisting mainly of war captives and kidnapped people.
“you have a lot of what is called voluntary slavery its voluntary in the sense of people at very low levels of income who who they were their families are on the verge of starvation”
A trade deficit is exactly matched by a capital surplus, because foreigners use the dollars they earn from US purchases to invest in US assets, so the trade deficit and the capital surplus are the same thing and both let America consume more than it produces.
“so a trade deficit and a capital surplus are exactly the same thing they both let America consume more than we produce”
Banning all imports would not raise total employment: domestic workers would shift to making goods that were imported, consumers would pay more, and the result would be a poorer, self-sufficient America, so self-sufficiency is the road to poverty and trade is a form of cooperation.
“self-sufficiency is the road to poverty trade lets us cooperate and allows others to make things for us that we could only make for ourselves a greater expense”
Adam Smith was internally inconsistent: in 1770 (published 1776) he argued French slave owners in Haiti (Saint-Domingue) were more productive than British owners because their management was superior, a view possibly based on Haiti's great wealth at the time.
“Smith writing in 1770 you know published in 1776 argues that actually the French slavery and French slave owners are more productive than other British”
Plantation food and height data support the view that the nutrition provided over a lifetime was adequate for growth: southern enslaved people were considerably taller than West Indian slaves and African men were almost as tall as white Americans, indicating the work did not consume all their calories.
“the slaves the southern slave was quite a bit taller than the West Indian slave and then the Africans almost as tall as white Americans”
Slavery was clearly highly profitable, and it was probably at its all-time profitability peak in the 1850s, depending on foreign demand for cotton, and this profitability was recognized across the political spectrum, including by Marxists, liberals, and conservatives.
“clearly slavery was very doctor very highly profitable and the fact was probably at its all-time peak profitability in the 1850s”
Adam Smith argued that slavery was inefficient because enslaved workers lack incentives; Engerman responds that Smith never studied how plantations actually operated, since slave owners knew that slaves respond to incentives and used rewards alongside whipping.
“what the Smith had never done is said that never see a plantation in operation never really study how to plantation operated because all the slave owners knew that you have a gift slaves incentives”
The trade in enslaved people to North Africa and the Middle East, starting around 800 CE, may have totaled as many people as the roughly 12 million moved across the Atlantic, and one of the major slave revolts in history occurred among Black slaves in Iraq in the 10th century.
“it was also a very extensive trade which over time may have been even more going to North Africa in the Middle East from after from southern Africa that this trade started about 800 kept going”
Slavery was economically adaptable: it shifted from rice and tobacco on the eastern seaboard to cotton, and by 1860 about half the enslaved population lived in states that did not exist in 1800, so the westward movement reflected high productivity, not failure.
“the westward movement was not because you had problems westward movement was because it's highly productive”
The North was not fighting primarily to end slavery: many northern states had abolished slavery only gradually while excluding Black people from schools, voting, and in some Midwestern states from relocating within the state, and Illinois-style black exclusion laws existed even during the war.
“many of the northern states which had abolished slavery very gradually today in many of the northern states did not let blacks go to school did not like blacks vote”
Economic motivation in slavery was not only the stick of starvation: masters also used carrots, and Engerman and Fogel argued that slave owners were concerned with keeping slaves alive, incentivizing them, and feeding them relatively well, so the harsh plantation mechanism did not fully describe the system.
“their idea of economic motivation is you with people and starve them that's the stick but you guys talked as much about the carrot”
Buying the enslaved population at market prices would have raised the federal budget about 50 times, which made compensated emancipation unrealistic and left peaceful options off the table, so the war ended slavery as an unintended consequence.
“if the north try to purchase the sleighs at market prices the federal budget would have increased about 50 times”
Slavery as an institution required three characteristics together: people could be bought and sold, the status was lifelong or nearly so, and the status was inherited through the mother.
“you know it seems sort of three major characteristics of slavery which have to come together one is that people can be bought and sold number two that basically the status is lifetime or close to it”
In most societies the state enforced slavery and helped maintain it, because the state was largely controlled by rich slave owners, so states rarely opposed the system for long periods.
“the state was basically the rich slave owners so they maintained the system and you find very little in the way of states coming out against the system”
Northern lenders continued to lend to southern planters throughout the 1850s, which Engerman treats as evidence that they expected slavery to remain profitable and to be repaid.
“many the northerners were lending to the southerners and they kept going they kept lending throughout the 1850s so they obviously expected to get the payment back”
Lincoln's commitment to preserving the Union, rooted in his nationalism, played a major role in the war, and it is hard to present the war as a moral crusade given the North's treatment of Black people and Lincoln's own efforts to remove freed slaves to Haiti or the Caribbean.
“Lincoln believed in nationalism and nationality and that he didn't want to let anyone secede”
Whipping was less common than the popular view assumed: the book's evidence came from one detailed planter's listing of whippings, slave narratives, and British anti-slavery societies' counts from the West Indies, and the claim survived criticism, though the threat of violence was always present.
“we found only one very detailed listing of whippings by a planter and the argument we made there was that the amount of whippings was much less than people used to think”
Enslaved people were often paid cash, got days off, and worked overtime for others, and some accumulated money, so the slave economy was partly a cash economy.
“there was quite often days off payments and cash remember all these manumissions which people talk about the meant that people had to have had money to purchase themselves”
Free labor was argued by some 18th-century writers to be more efficient than slave labor because starvation wages made workers work harder, and Engerman notes that this argument cuts both ways, since masters could also get productivity by keeping people near starvation.
“his legs are too well taken care of free workers are at the verge of starvation and have to work you got much more work from those people”
Slavery in the American South was highly profitable and at its all-time profitability peak in the 1850s, and the book's main claim is that slavery was productive and profitable for owners rather than an unprofitable and sadistic institution as the traditional view held.
“the fact was probably at its all-time peak profitability in the 1850s”
In the 1858 Lincoln-Douglas debates, Lincoln argued that slavery would end, without interference where it already existed, once slave numbers outgrew available land and slave prices fell; Douglas asked how long this would take, and Lincoln estimated about a hundred years.
“Lincoln's anson this is in 1858 is it will take about a hundred years to end slavery unless anything happens”
The claim that imports destroy jobs and exports create jobs is a mercantilist mistake, because it ignores how the job market adjusts dynamically: the gift of a free car would destroy auto jobs but free up about 25,000 dollars per car for spending that creates jobs elsewhere.
“the argument of these folks which i think is wrong but the argument is is that imports destroy jobs and exports create jobs this is really a form of mercantilism”
Parallel expansion occurred in Brazil, which shifted from sugar to coffee, and in Cuba, which shifted from tobacco to sugar, and slave prices were at all-time highs across these slave societies in the 1850s, which indicates heavy investment in the system.
“the cube is shifting from reducing tobacco to producing sugar so the point is wherever you look at this period of time that this certainly the prices of slaves are rising there at all-time Peaks”
Slave traders published newsletters every couple of weeks describing expectations of continued good activity, showing that the market expected slavery to keep expanding and not to be moribund, so slavery was not going to end soon without a civil war.
“we have several market newsletters from slave traders which are quite interesting because the system was you know Howard as it was it worked in a way which the owners were wanted”
Total US employment has grown steadily even as imports surged and trade deficits ballooned over the last thirty years, and manufacturing employment is also largely unaffected by trade deficits; manufacturing output is at all-time highs even though the absolute number of manufacturing workers is smaller than 45 years ago.
“even manufacturing employment is relatively unaffected by the trade deficit it's overwhelmingly been affected by productivity”
Engerman argues that popular depictions exaggerated the horror of slavery in day-to-day violence, though he also says that the master's legal power to punish was itself the core of slavery and that this should not be minimized.
“my sense is I in general would go with the conclusion that the people have exaggerated the horror”
A trade deficit is sustainable as long as foreigners want to buy more American assets than Americans want to buy foreign assets, which depends on the US remaining an attractive, stable place to invest and take risk.
“as long as the amount of American assets that foreigners want to buy exceeds the amount of foreign assets that Americans want to buy this situation can and will persist”
The literature that emerged after Time on the Cross emphasizes the agency of enslaved people, a shift Engerman sees as a left-wing reframing, and he argues that this framing can understate the master's power because enslaved people's agency existed only within a system the master controlled.
“it's interesting it is a quite an interesting tactic or it sort of as I say seems to forget that if this were true as it is true to the that is true it's basically at the master sufferance anyhow he had all the power”
Despite about 500,000 to 600,000 casualties, the Civil War's effect on the post-war American economy was less dramatic than one might anticipate, and the South grew reasonably rapidly from 1865 to about 1890 while catching up from its shortfall.
“starting from 65 to about 1890 the South is also growing reasonably rapidly though South has to catch up from it shortfall so in terms of a major effect it seems less dramatic”
Under floating exchange rates, a trade deficit does not signal an impending balance-of-payments crisis, and countries no longer need to hold stocks of foreign reserves to pay for imports, so the Turkish-style crisis scenario from fixed rates does not apply.
“with floating exchange rates you don't have to keep a stock of reserves and a trade deficit no longer is a sign of an impending crisis”
Post-emancipation output declines in slave societies can reflect ex-slaves choosing more leisure and lower work intensity rather than a failure of the economy, and the measured decline overlooks what the freed people wanted.
“the ex-slaves don't want to work on the conditions they had before and they can avoid it and so it's a measured decline and taken in full of leisure or intensity”
The Founders expected slavery to end within 50 to 60 years, but the cotton gin changed that expectation, so the invention of the cotton gin made slavery more durable.
“he argued also that the founding fathers had expected slavery to end in 5060 years but then the cotton gin came along”
The Roman writer Cicero noted that slave workers posed the same incentive problem as free workers, which means the problem of motivating labor was recognized long before modern economics, and Smith's argument does not follow from the historical evidence.
“the ancient Rome the Roman Cicero when he was discussing this problem commented that you have the same trouble with slave workers”
Slavery is the most ubiquitous of all human institutions: it has existed in nearly every country and era, and in the Arabian peninsula the UN recognized an end to it only as late as 1970, with forms of it persisting afterward.
“slavery is the most ubiquitous of all human institutions slavery is discussed in the Bible there at various times slavery existed in just about every country at every time”
Slave codes and legal codes across the Arabic world, the Americas, and Europe always included specific rules that masters should not be harsh, though these rules were often not followed in practice.
“the cause are always very specific that you don't be harsh and of course those are not always very quite quite often that followed”
Before Time on the Cross, the traditional view among historians and many economists was that American slavery was unprofitable, sadistic, and that slaves were lazy and brutalized by violence; Engerman and Fogel's book challenged that view.
“the traditional view among historians and many economists was that American slavery was an unprofitable and sadistic institution slaves were lazy and productive and brutalized by violence”
Most of the book's factual findings have been accepted by critics; the dispute is mainly over interpretation, such as how to read feeding, work routines, breeding, and violence, rather than over the underlying facts.
“what you have is most of the findings we have our points are factually accepted it's just the interpretations people don't like”
Sherman's march and wartime destruction of property and buildings created a need to rebuild capital stock, though Engerman notes this rebuilding would not necessarily stimulate the economy in a simple way.
“you have a much greater need to rebuild the capital stocks and so forth in here but that should stimulate the economy”
Under New York law, Black men had to own property worth at least $250 to vote while white men could vote without property, showing systematic treatment differences in the North.
“if you were a free black you could vote as could a white except the white could vote without paying a free black had to have property worth at least two two dollars to vote”
Adam Smith argued slavery was inefficient because enslaved workers have no incentive to work productively, and this was a common view for a long time.
“the Smith said that slavery was inefficient because presumably because a person working against their will would not be as productive”
Smith's explanation for why slavery persisted despite its inefficiency was the 'will to domineer', a phrase Engerman glosses as sadism; Engerman's point is that the owners' pursuit of control, not just cost, sustained the institution.
“Smith use the phrase the will to domineer for sadism”
Biblical slavery distinguished Jewish from non-Jewish slaves: a Jewish slave was freed every seventh year, while a non-Jewish slave was freed only after about 50 years, so the length of enslavement varied by the enslaved person's group.
“if you enslave if you had sort of acquired a slave who was Jewish they will be freed every seventh year if the slave was none if the person was none Jewish they would be freed only every 50 years”
Enslaved soldiers who fought for their masters were freed afterward, and this was never regarded as a real attack on the system.
“one of the major forms of manumissions was if you needed soldiers to fight for you and you slave soldiers they would be freed afterwards”
The end of slavery in the American South did not cause a sharp long-term economic collapse, and war losses, though severe, produced a smaller economic effect than one would anticipate, possibly because the South's measured decline reflects changes in how labor was counted.
“in terms of a major effect it seems less dramatic than one would anticipate”
Few people in the 1840s and 1850s argued that slavery was about to end immediately; most anti-slavery voices agreed it was on its way out but expected a long timeline.
“very few people are arguing that slavery is on the way out what they're arguing well they are on the way out but it's going to take a long time”
Near the end of the Civil War, the Confederacy considered enlisting enslaved men as soldiers with a promise of freedom, but Engerman does not recall that the promise was ever implemented; the Confederacy was more anxious to defend itself than to preserve slavery as such.
“they probably would have been because I was sort of the standard terms but you know they never got around to doing it”
Since 1976, the United States has run a merchandise trade deficit every year, importing about six trillion dollars more in goods than it exported over 1976 to 2005, and the US had a small services trade surplus since 1971.
“every year since 1976 the value of the goods that the US has imported from the rest of the world is greater than the value of the goods that the world imports from the United States”
The bulk of foreign capital inflow to the US is private investment in equities, corporate bonds, and other private assets rather than US Treasury debt, which means foreign investment is largely financing private US investment.
“the bulk of foreign investment is purchases of US equity corporate bonds and other private assets”
GDP is not the goal of life: leisure, time with family, reading, and thinking are valuable even though they are not counted as productive output.
“people seem to think that the goal of life is to make GDP as big as possible it's not the goal of life”
Property rights generally produce prosperity and freedom, but the institution of property in human beings was a way to degrade and dehumanize people, and the compensation of owners in emancipation shows a troubling chapter in the history of property rights.
“it's a really embarrassing chapter in the history of property rights which in general produce great prosperity and freedom”
Analogies to slavery persist in other settings: baseball and sports unions, and old studio-system movie stars bound to studios and rented out, have used the slave analogy, while academics rarely use a 'reverse slave analogy' for tenure.
“the baseball union in sports unions use a slave analogy for quite a long time movie stars in the old days were bound in the studio system”
Engerman suggests the history of slavery damaged respect for property rights in general, because the moral revulsion at owning people weakened the legitimacy of other property rights, but he is uncertain about this.
“maybe that weakened our respect for other types of property rights understandably perhaps I don't know”