What this covers

This is a solo talk by Sean Carroll, who builds the case in stages. He starts with what the wave function is: in quantum mechanics there is no definite position or velocity, only an amplitude assigned to every place a particle might be found. He then sets the Copenhagen interpretation against the plain Schrödinger equation. Copenhagen adds a discontinuous collapse on observation without saying what counts as a measurement, who can make one, or how fast it happens. Carroll argues that without these extra rules, everything, observer and environment included, simply evolves deterministically. He also notes that early speculation about conscious perception causing collapse is no longer needed.

The middle of the talk covers the mechanics of branching. Decoherence is the irreversible entanglement of a superposed system with its surroundings, and it happens far faster than a conscious observer could register a result. Carroll says branching is therefore frequent, and that Hilbert space is large enough to hold all the branches. He tells the story of using a Universe Splitter app, which on his account produced two equally real versions of himself. The hardest conceptual question he takes on is probability. His answer rests on self-locating uncertainty, with the Born rule fixing the weights. He also says many-worlds is testable in principle, since a collapse that did not come from decoherence would falsify it, and he admits the theory is not finished.

A good part of the talk is historical and sociological. Hugh Everett, a student of John Wheeler, whose own mentor was Niels Bohr, was discouraged from presenting his idea as a break with Copenhagen, and he later left physics. Carroll's most contested claims concern the field's culture. He describes a journal memo advising rejection of foundations papers unread, and says physicists who work on the measurement problem are marginalized. He also reads Schrödinger's cat as a reductio against quantum theory, and takes Richard Feynman's remark that nobody understands quantum mechanics as a license for complacency. The talk closes briefly on the suggestion that gravity might emerge from entanglement patterns.

Sharpest takeaway

The many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics is the simplest and most natural reading of quantum theory: if you take the Schrödinger equation seriously as the complete description of reality without adding special rules for measurement or observation, the universe branches into multiple non-interacting worlds, and this interpretation resolves the measurement problem more elegantly than the Copenhagen interpretation.

  • The Copenhagen interpretation requires ad-hoc rules about measurement and wave function collapse that have no clear physical basis and create paradoxes (the measurement problem)
  • Many-worlds derives from pure quantum mechanics (wave functions + Schrödinger equation) without additional postulates, making it more parsimonious
  • Decoherence naturally explains why we observe definite outcomes: quantum entanglement with the environment irreversibly branches the wave function into separate worlds

The claims · ranked37 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Hugh Everett, a graduate student of John Wheeler at Princeton in the 1950s, originally proposed the many-worlds interpretation, but Wheeler's mentor was Niels Bohr (the Copenhagen interpretation's founder), so Wheeler discouraged Everett from presenting many-worlds as incompatible with Copenhagen, though Everett knew it was fundamentally different.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“This was invented by a graduate student Hugh Everett, a graduate student of John Wheelers in the 1950s. Uh he fought very hard against his adviser John Wheeler in writing the PhD thesis because Wheeler's mentor was Neils Boore, the boss of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics. And Wheeler didn't really want to admit that his student had a better theory than Boore did.”

0.74

The development of quantum mechanics was driven by need to account for experimental data and observations, not by a priori philosophical preferences, meaning the crazy ideas quantum mechanics requires are forced on us by nature rather than invented.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“They're not things that we sat around in our room late at night with a few pints going, man, what if there were like a lot of universes out there. Okay? We are driven to the crazy ideas I'm going to be talking about today by trying to account for what we see in nature.”

0.74

In quantum mechanics, there is no such thing as a definite position or velocity of a particle; instead, there is a wave function spread out over space that assigns a number (amplitude) to every position the particle could possibly be found in, and this is what physical reality is according to quantum mechanics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“I'm not saying that we don't know what the velocity is or what the position is. I'm saying there is no such thing as the actual position or velocity of the particle. There is a wave function that is spread out all over the place.”

0.74

The Schrödinger equation by itself, without any additional rules about measurement or collapse, predicts that a system evolves deterministically and smoothly, so if you remove the special rules about measurement and let everything—the quantum system, the measuring apparatus, the observer, and the environment—all obey the Schrödinger equation, you get a purely deterministic theory without wave function collapse.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Before we added all these weird rules about measurements and observation, if we just had the wave function in Schrodinger's equation, quantum mechanics looked a lot like classical mechanics. There was a state of the system, it evolved according to an equation and it would evolve deterministically forever. It was only when we added in the weird rules about measurements and observation that things got hairy.”

0.74

In the early days of quantum mechanics, some physicists (including the founders) speculated that maybe conscious human perception had a special role in collapsing the wave function, but we now have much better explanations that don't require consciousness to play any special physical role.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“people have been driven in the early days of quantum mechanics to suggest maybe there really was something special about conscious perceptions. Maybe the human mind really changed reality by interacting with it. We don't have to think that anymore. This is an old outof-date way of thinking.”

0.74

Everett left physics after receiving his PhD because he received poor treatment from the physics community for proposing many-worlds, despite having a well-reasoned alternative interpretation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Hugh Everett, who also, by the way, left physics after he got his PhD because he didn't want to take the guff that he was getting. I mean, Wheeler actually sent him to Copenhagen to try to talk to Neils Bohr and the other Copenhagen people and it was a disaster.”

0.73

Decoherence is the irreversible process in which a quantum system in superposition becomes entangled with the environment (photons, air molecules, etc.), and once this entanglement occurs, the different parts of the superposition can never interact again because the environment states entangled with them are completely different.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“This process called decoherence is simply the fact that for all intents and purposes, the environment has been interacting with the cat all along. Right? If the cat is asleep on the floor of the box or awake and climbing around, the photons and the atoms in the air will interact differently with the cat.”

0.73

Decoherence happens very fast (on timescales of 10^-20 seconds or faster), so by the time a conscious observer opens a box to measure a system, the system has already become entangled with the environment; therefore, the branching into multiple worlds has already occurred before the observer's conscious mind can process the measurement outcome.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“The process of decoherence in which the cat or the quantum system interacts with this environment is incredibly fast numbers like 10 the minus 20 seconds get thrown around. Okay. So no matter how quickly you open the box and look at it decoherence has happened much before your conscious mind can process the outcome of that particular experiment.”

0.72

Schrödinger invented his famous cat thought experiment not to support quantum mechanics but to show a reductio ad absurdum against it: he hoped to demonstrate that quantum mechanics couldn't possibly be right because it implies macroscopic objects like cats can be in superposition of being alive and dead, which seems obviously false.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Schroinger like many of the pioneers of quantum mechanics, his invention went far beyond what he expected. Okay, so he invented the wave function and Schrodinger's equation, but it had implications he didn't like. Schroinger like Einstein was convinced this whole measurement problem business was completely crazy.”

0.69

A memo was circulated by the editor of the Physical Review Journal stating that papers on the foundations of quantum mechanics should be rejected without being read, indicating systematic suppression of interpretational research

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“There was even a memo sent around by the editor of the Physical Review Journal saying that if anyone sends in a paper on the foundations of quantum mechanics, you should reject it without reading it.”

0.68

Both Einstein and Schrödinger believed quantum mechanics was incomplete as a fundamental theory of reality because its measurement-dependent formulation seemed unsatisfying, though they differed in their specific critiques

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Schroinger like Einstein was convinced this whole measurement problem business was completely crazy...like Einstein he thought that quantum mechanics was incomplete as a theory of reality.”

0.68

The probability problem in many-worlds can be addressed through the concept of self-locating uncertainty: after a quantum measurement creates branching, there are now multiple copies of the observer, all identical, but each one doesn't know which branch they are on; the correct way to assign probability to being on different branches is given by the Born rule (wave function squared).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“The way that probability comes in is that among other things you branch right I branched when I did the hopping left and right. There will necessarily be a short period of time when the branching has already happened. There are two copies of me, two future selves, okay? And neither one of them knows which branch they're on. This is called self-locating uncertainty.”

0.68

Physics as a field has adopted a strategy of denial toward the measurement problem: physicists who devote their careers to understanding the foundations of quantum mechanics and the measurement problem are marginalized, labeled as not real physicists or as too old to do important work, and sent into retirement rather than being recognized as addressing one of the most important problems in physics.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“We have adopted a strategy of denial where if you're a physicist and you think hard about answering these questions, you are labeled not a physicist or a physicist who is too old to do important work anymore and you're sent off to retirement.”

0.68

The many-worlds interpretation is testable in principle—if one could observe wave function collapse occurring without decoherence (a collapse not due to entanglement with environment), that would falsify many-worlds.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“If you want to falsify the many worlds interpretation, remember that the prediction of many worlds is wave functions don't collapse. They never do. They appear to collapse because of decoherence. So you and I get the appearance of a wave function collapsing, but it never really happens. If you were able to observe a wave function collapsing without decoherence, without becoming entangled with the environment, that would be evidence that many worlds is wrong.”

0.68

An entire academic field called 'interpretations of quantum mechanics' exists precisely because the Copenhagen formulation is unsatisfying, whereas no comparable field of 'interpretations of classical mechanics' ever existed

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Because of these questions which undergo under the rubric of the measurement problem, we have a whole field of intellectual endeavor called interpretations of quantum mechanics. Okay? There was never any field of intellectual endeavor called interpretations of classical mechanics...this need, this apparent need in quantum mechanics to make measurement something special is baffling to us.”

0.66

Branching happens frequently because radioactive nuclei decay and particles scatter quantum mechanically all the time, so the wave function branches very often, but the total number of possible branches can be accommodated in Hilbert space (approximately 10^(10^122)-dimensional), which is so enormous that we won't run out of room.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“There still are a lot of worlds. It's very often that a little nucleus in an atom decays. Okay? Every time a nucleus decays or doesn't decay, that branches the wave function of the universe.”

0.66

The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics treats measurement and observation as something special and fundamental to the theory, introducing a discontinuous collapse of the wave function when a system is observed, which creates conceptual problems because it does not clearly define what counts as a measurement, who or what can perform it, or how fast it happens.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“There is some something special about measurement that the act of observing a system plays a crucially important central role in the formulation of quantum mechanics according to the Copenhagen interpretation.”

0.62

The many-worlds interpretation is simpler and more parsimonious than the Copenhagen interpretation because it requires only two components—wave functions and the Schrödinger equation—whereas Copenhagen requires additional postulates like the Born rule, measurement operators, and collapse dynamics

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“This is one of the reasons why the ever interpretation or the many worlds interpretation is actually simpler and more compact than the Copenhagen interpretation or anything else. You don't put in things like the probability rule as extra assumptions. you derive them from the formalism.”

0.62

According to the many-worlds interpretation, when the Universe Splitter app branched the universe by splitting the photon, Carroll created two separate versions of himself—one hopping left and one hopping right—both equally real in separate branches of the wave function.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“According to the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, there is another truly existent part of reality in which I just hop to the left and I'm right there. And that person right there who's no longer me, it's a different person is gesturing over to their right saying that there's another version of me over there. Okay, this is not science fiction. This is what many of us, including myself, think is likely to be true, a correct description of nature, this many worlds version of quantum mechanics.”

0.62

The Copenhagen interpretation provides a story for students about what happens in quantum mechanics, but the story has no real foundation in the underlying physics and is taught despite known conceptual problems precisely because it 'works' pragmatically for calculations

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“This is what we teach our students...the problem is it is bizarre and crazy this can't be right what we teach our students cannot possibly be how nature works at a fundamental level...This is what we teach our youngsters today this is how we teach them to use quantum mechanics”

0.61

Recent theoretical research suggests that spacetime geometry defined from quantum entanglement patterns naturally obeys Einstein's equations of general relativity, suggesting that gravity might emerge from quantum mechanics rather than requiring a separate quantum theory of gravity.

factualhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“What we seem to find under assumptions that seem reasonable is that this emergent geometry that we define from quantum entanglement obeys a an equation just like anything should in a good well- definfined physical theory. And the equation it obeys is Einstein's equation for general relativity.”

0.60

If you truly absorb the lessons of quantum mechanics, what should seem weird is not that objects can be in superposition (that's just the rules of quantum mechanics), but that when you observe a cat in superposition you never see it in superposition—you always see it in one definite state or the other, never a mixture.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Of course, cats can be in arbitrary superp positions. Everything in the universe can be in arbitrary superp positions. This idea of objects having positions and velocities and so forth is just a relic of our pre-existing classical intuition. What is weird, what is surprising, what is hard to understand is that when you open the box, you never see a cat in a superp position. That's what's weird.”

0.52

When students ask the difficult questions about what measurement is or why collapse happens, they are typically told to stop asking and accept the mathematical formalism without understanding, which Carroll characterizes as a terrible policy for a scientific field

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“If the students have these questions, we tell them to shut up. I don't think this is a good policy. I think we should be able to do better than that.”

0.52

People object to many-worlds for wrong reasons (too many universes, can't be tested) when there are actually good reasons to worry about it: it's not a fully developed theory yet, and physicists haven't completely finished mapping many-worlds onto what we observe experimentally.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“I get a little frustrated by the public discussion of the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics because a lot of people object to it for the wrong reasons which is frustrating because there are good reasons to object to it. I think it's true. I would personally say there's about a 90% chance that the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics is the right one. But there are perfectly rational reasons to be worried about it. It's not a fully developed theory yet.”

0.52

Richard Feynman famously said 'I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics,' and the physics community has interpreted this to mean that nobody will ever understand quantum mechanics and that's acceptable, rather than treating it as motivation to devote resources to understanding quantum mechanics more deeply.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Richard Feineman said many things. Uh he's very quotable physicist and one of his quotes is I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics. Now, this is true if what we mean by this is nobody has an understanding that all the other physicists agree is right.”

0.41

Max Planck launched the quantum revolution by proposing that when light is emitted from hot objects, it comes in discrete packets, whereas Einstein five years later made the more radical claim that light always comes in discrete packets (quanta) as a fundamental property of nature.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“For example there was Mox plunk who really launched the quantum revolution by trying to understand the radiation of hot objects. We had a theoretical understanding of that but it was all wrong and plunk said well maybe when light is emitted from these hot objects it comes in discrete packets but it wasn't until Einstein five years later that he real he said maybe just light always comes in discrete packets.”

0.41

Niels Bohr realized that if electrons orbit atoms like planets orbit the sun, they should spiral inward due to electromagnetic radiation and all atoms should collapse in a tiny fraction of a second, yet atoms don't collapse; Bohr said this is very mysterious but asserted atoms don't collapse without explaining why.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Neils Boore realized that if you believe electrons orbit in atoms, they should spiral in and all atoms should collapse in a tiny fraction of a second. So he said they don't for some reason. It's very very mysterious why Boore said that they shouldn't collapse.”

0.41

Louis de Broglie proposed that particles we think of as electrons are really waves, whereas Einstein said waves are really particles; this confusion between wave and particle properties was resolved in the late 1920s when Heisenberg and Schrödinger invented the wave function as a new concept distinct from both classical particles and classical waves.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Einstein said many maybe waves are really particles. Deberly says maybe particles are really waves. It wasn't until the late 1920s that we basically figured it all out. There were two people who figured it out more or less simultaneously. It looked very different but we later figured out it's the same theory. Heisenberg and Schroinger and they said you know put aside the idea of a particle with a position and a velocity invent something new which we call the wave function.”

0.34

In classical Newtonian mechanics, if you know the position and velocity of every piece of stuff in the universe, the laws of physics can tell you exactly where it will go in the future and exactly where it was in the past, with no fundamental obstacles to measuring exactly what the universe is doing in principle.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“If you tell me everything that's going on in the universe, which is to say the position and the velocity of every piece of stuff in the universe, the laws of physics can tell you exactly where it will go in the future and indeed exactly where it was in the past. There's no obstacle to measuring exactly what the universe is doing.”

0.34

Schrödinger's equation is the quantum mechanical version of Newton's second law (F=ma): just as Newton's law tells you how a classical system evolves if you know positions and velocities, Schrödinger's equation tells you how a quantum system's wave function evolves if you know the wave function and the energy of the system.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Schroinger's equation is the quantum version of Isaac Newton's second law. Just like if you knew the positions and velocities of all the particles in a system, and you knew Newton's second law, you could tell how it would evolve. If you knew the quantum state of a system, the wave function of a system, and you have Schroinger's equation, then you can tell exactly how that wave function will evolve.”

0.34

Entanglement in quantum mechanics means that the quantum state of one part of reality can be correlated with the quantum state of another part such that knowing something about one part tells you something about the other, and Einstein called this 'spooky action at a distance' because the correlation persists even if the parts are separated by vast distances.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“Einstein said this is spooky. This is the origin of the phrase spooky action at a distance. How does the particle far away know that the universe is that we got the result we did for this particle?”

0.34

In quantum field theory, particles are actually vibrations in underlying quantum fields, and different regions of space have different field degrees of freedom that are highly entangled when nearby but unentangled when far apart.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“our best theories of the universe are not theories of particles. They're theories of fields. There's the electric field, the magnetic field, the gravitational field. Even the particles that you know about nutrinos, electrons, quarks, etc. So these are all based on fields. And what a particle is is a vibration in the field.”

0.17

The speaker personally estimates about a 90% probability that the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics is correct, but acknowledges that there are substantive open questions about mapping many-worlds onto experimental observations that haven't been fully resolved.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“I would personally say there's about a 90% chance that the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics is the right one. But there are perfectly rational reasons to be worried about it. It's not a fully developed theory yet. We haven't completely finished the task of matching many worlds onto what we see in the experimental world.”

0.17

The view that quantum mechanics is literally true (as opposed to instrumentalism) is still controversial in the field, but taking this seriously and exploring its implications can reduce incomprehension and potentially replace cynicism and anger with genuine engagement.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“What he means, of course, by quantum theory is the many worlds version of quantum theory. Quantum theory without anything else, anything besides wave functions and the shortinger equation. That theory leads you to believe in a lot of stuff including multiple branches of the wave function where there's many copies of you and you might not want to believe that but after my talk I think I hope at least that there is less incomprehension in the room. The cynicism and the anger are up to you.”

0.12

Many different people over many years contributed to developing quantum mechanics, unlike Newtonian physics where Isaac Newton figured it out essentially by himself.

factual· Sean Carroll

“Unlike Newtonian physics, which burst from the mind of Isaac Newton, there were predecessors, but he really figured it all out. Quantum mechanics had a difficult birth. It took many people over the course of years to figure it all out.”

0.12

Newton's second law (F = ma) is the foundational rule of classical mechanics that specifies that acceleration is proportional to the force applied to an object.

definition· Sean Carroll

“This rule is the laws of physics in particular Newton's second law f= ma when you put a force on something it accelerates proportional to the amount of force.”

0.12

The Universe Splitter iPhone app sends a signal to a laboratory in Geneva, Switzerland that causes a photon to be split by a beam splitter, and according to quantum mechanics there is a 50% probability it goes left and 50% probability it goes right.

factual· Sean Carroll

“So, here, this is an app you can get on your iPhone called Universe Splitter. What will happen is I will push the button, it will send a signal to a laboratory in Geneva, Switzerland that will send a photon down a beam and then the photon will be split left and right. And according to the rules of quantum mechanics, there's a 50% chance that it goes left and a 50% chance it goes right.”