63 | Solo -- Finding Gravity Within Quantum Mechanics
What this covers
Carroll presents a solo meditation on quantum gravity centered on a radical reorientation: instead of trying to quantize gravity starting from Albert Einstein's classical theory, physicists should look for gravity already hidden within quantum mechanics itself. The episode develops this argument by first establishing Many-Worlds Interpretation as the most foundational reading of quantum mechanics—one in which the wave function is the only reality and Hugh Everett's 1950s insight that the measurement problem dissolves when you apply quantum mechanics to the whole universe without invoking an external observer. From this foundation, Carroll traces how locality and classicality are not bedrock but emergence phenomena arising from entanglement and decoherence. The centerpiece is a technical result: defining distance via entanglement entropy and applying Ted Jacobson's thermodynamic reasoning reproduces Einstein's equation of general relativity in the weak-field limit, suggesting curved spacetime is an emergent structure of the underlying quantum wave function.
The episode ranges across deep conceptual terrain. Carroll critiques the physics community's long habit of dodging foundational questions in quantum mechanics, arguing this evasion has crippled progress on quantum gravity. He examines lessons from black hole physics—holography, AdS/CFT, and complementarity—to motivate why locality cannot be fundamental. A striking proposal reverses causality: rather than assuming space exists and interactions occur within it, define space as the structure with respect to which interactions are local. Carroll acknowledges these ideas remain speculative and work only under explicit assumptions, chiefly in the weak-field regime, not for strong gravity or the Big Bang. He also introduces puzzles from quantum field theory—the infinite degrees of freedom per region it permits versus the finite entropy black holes impose—and sketches how an emergent, finite Hilbert space might resolve the tension. Throughout, he defends theoretical speculation as the only path to learning, while insisting credence should scale with evidence, never reaching certainty.
Carroll argues that physicists should stop trying to 'quantize gravity' and instead find gravity already latent within quantum mechanics, treating spacetime and its geometry as emergent from the entanglement structure of an abstract quantum wave function.
- Many-Worlds is the most austere, foundational formulation of quantum mechanics, taking the wave function as the only reality
- Locality and classicality emerge from entanglement and decoherence rather than being fundamental
- Defining geometry via entanglement entropy reproduces Einstein's equation in the weak-field limit, suggesting gravity lives inside quantum mechanics
Spacetime and locality emerge from entanglement structure in the quantum wave function rather than being fundamental features.
- Cutler and collaborators showed that given only an abstract quantum system and its Schrodinger evolution, usually there is no way to decompose it into local subsystems interacting only with a few neighbors, but when such a local decomposition exists it is essentially unique—demonstrating that space and locality can emerge from the quantum wave function without being assumed.
“what Cutler et al., were able to show is that for a given abstract quantum system, usually there's no way of doing that at all. Usually there's no way of taking an abstract quantum system and dividing it into a bunch of little local subsystems just talking to their neighbors. But sometimes there are, and when there are, when there is, that way is usually unique.”
- Rather than saying interactions are local in space (which assumes space), we should reverse the logic and define space as the property with respect to which interactions are local—two things are neighbors when they interact, not the reverse—which is the driving idea that lets space emerge from the abstract quantum wave function.
“Rather than saying interactions are local in space, what you should say is space is the property with respect to which interactions are local.”
- By defining the distance between two parts of the wave function as inversely proportional to their entanglement and applying Jacobson's logic, Carroll, Cao and Michalakis showed that the natural geometry on the emergent space obeys Einstein's equation—though only under explicit assumptions and only in the weak-field limit, not for strong gravity like black holes or the Big Bang.
“you can define the distance between two parts of the universe, between two parts of the wave function of the universe, to be inversely proportional to the amount of entanglement.”
- In the emergent spacetime picture, cosmic expansion need not mean new degrees of freedom coming into existence (as the troubling sub-Planck-length mode-stretching in QFT suggests); instead, the finite degrees of freedom were always present but initially unentangled, and as space expands they become entangled and join the spacetime continuum—an idea formalized in 'Quantum Circuit Cosmology.'
“maybe the degrees of freedom were always there in some finite number of degrees of freedom, but what happens is that they were initially unentangled with the universe.”
- Lessons from black hole physics—holography, the AdS/CFT correspondence, and complementarity—suggest locality is not fundamental: descriptions with different numbers of spatial dimensions can be equally valid, so one observer's locality is another's non-locality, meaning describing reality as degrees of freedom with definite locations in space cannot be the final answer.
“what they seem to be teaching us is that the idea of describing reality as a set of degrees of freedom with definite locations in space is not the final answer.”
Gravity and general relativity emerge from quantum thermodynamics and the finite entropy of bounded regions.
- In the vacuum state of a quantum field theory, degrees of freedom are highly entangled with nearby ones and only slightly with distant ones, so the entanglement (von Neumann) entropy of a region of space is proportional to the area of its boundary rather than its volume, because most entanglement crosses the boundary.
“it turns out that that entropy of the region inside is proportional to the area of the boundary, which makes perfect sense”
- Ted Jacobson in 1995 suggested that in a theory with gravity the entropy of every region is always proportional to the area of its boundary, and by combining an equation relating entropy to geometry with one relating entropy to energy, he derived an equation relating geometry to energy that is exactly Einstein's equation of general relativity—a program known as thermodynamic or entropic gravity.
“Jacobson argued it is exactly Einstein's equation for general relativity.”
- Black holes are maximum-entropy configurations for a region of space, with entropy proportional to the area of their horizon in Planckian units, which suggests gravity implies only a finite number of states (a finite-dimensional Hilbert space) in any region—directly contradicting quantum field theory, which always implies an infinite number of degrees of freedom per region.
“this seems to be telling us that according to gravity, which is necessary for making black holes, there's only a finite number of different states that you can ever have in a region of space which we turn quantum mechanically into the statement that there's a finite-dimensional Hilbert space.”
- Because our accelerating, expanding universe has a horizon around us much like a black hole's, our observable universe has a finite entropy of about 10 to the 122, implying a finite number of degrees of freedom and a finite-dimensional Hilbert space of roughly 10 to the 10 to the 122.
“there's an entropy of our observable universe that turns out to be about 10 to the 122 when you go through the numbers.”
The many-worlds interpretation arises naturally from applying quantum mechanics to the entire universe without external collapse.
- Hugh Everett invented the many-worlds interpretation in the 1950s inspired by the problem of quantum gravity: applying Copenhagen quantum mechanics to the whole universe makes no sense because there is no external observer to collapse the wave function, which led Everett to ask what happens if wave functions just evolve by themselves—and the answer was many-worlds.
“Hugh Everett when he invented the many-worlds interpretation was inspired by the problem of quantum gravity.”
- In Schrodinger's cat the Everettian view says the wave function does not collapse when you open the box; instead you, as a quantum system, become entangled with the cat, so there is one branch with an awake cat and an observer who saw it awake and another branch with an asleep cat and an observer who saw it asleep, and both branches are real and predicted by the Schrodinger equation—and the branching actually happened earlier when the cat became entangled with its environment.
“what happens when you open the box is that not the wave function collapses, but rather that you become entangled with the cat.”
- Hugh Everett did not posit many worlds; he stripped quantum mechanics to its bare essentials of a wave function evolving by the Schrodinger equation, and the branching into multiple worlds pops out of that formalism automatically, whereas other interpretations work hard to add machinery that gets rid of the other worlds.
“this idea of many universes, many worlds of quantum mechanics, that's the label given to the theory, but it's not the central point of the theory.”
Classical behavior emerges from decoherence and the local interaction structure of macroscopic objects with their environment.
- A single electron has no classical limit—its wave function, under the Schrodinger equation, spreads out everywhere rather than following a well-defined trajectory; even a macroscopic dust grain treated in isolation would have its center of mass spread out, so large particle number alone does not produce classical behavior.
“for a single electron, there's kind of no such thing as a classical limit, single electrons by themselves do not act classically at all.”
- We observe the cat as either awake or asleep, never a superposition, because those two configurations are spatially coherent and the photons that interact with the cat are local in space; locality together with decoherence determines the particular classical states that get singled out, revealing a deep connection between locality and the emergence of the classical world.
“the reason why you see the cat as either awake or asleep is because those are the two possibilities that are spatially coherent.”
- Macroscopic objects look classical because they are constantly monitored by their environment—for example cosmic microwave background photons bumping into a dust grain—which entangles the object with the environment and branches the wave function so that on each branch the object appears to follow a single classical trajectory; this process is called decoherence.
“The reason why the world often looks approximately classical is because what should be a wave function spread out all over the place is monitored by the environment and decoheres and different parts of the wave function go their own separate way.”
The wave function and entanglement, not particles with definite properties, constitute quantum reality.
- In quantum mechanics it is not merely that you cannot predict or know a particle's position and velocity; those quantities do not exist, because the complete state of a particle is the wave function—a spread-out cloud of probability—and on the Many-Worlds view there is nothing else besides the wave function.
“it's not just that you don't know what they are, or you can't predict what you will measure them to be, it's that they don't exist.”
- There are not separate wave functions for each particle; there is only one wave function—the wave function of the entire universe—and because subsystems can be entangled, particles do not have independent quantum states the way classical particles can be treated individually.
“There are not separate wave functions for every particle in the universe, there is only one wave function.”
The Copenhagen interpretation's measurement problem and reliance on undefined observation concepts has hindered foundational physics progress.
- The Copenhagen interpretation's claim that the wave function collapses upon observation leaves crucial questions completely ambiguous—what counts as making an observation, whether a human, another cat, the cat itself, or a video camera triggers collapse—and this ambiguity has bothered physicists and students for generations.
“There's all these questions that are left completely ambiguous in the conventional Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics.”
- The physics community's mostly unwritten agreement since roughly 1935 to ignore the measurement problem and the foundations of quantum mechanics has held the field back enormously on hard, fundamental questions like quantum gravity and the emergence of spacetime; progress on quantum gravity may require first fully understanding quantum mechanics.
“I really do think that this choice that's been made by the Physics community as a whole, has held us back enormously when we're looking at questions that are as hard and as fundamental as quantum gravity and the emergence of spacetime.”
Evidence should constrain belief in all physics theories including foundational ones, and AdS/CFT research priorities may misdirect effort.
- No matter how charmed we are by an idea in physics, the degree to which we accept it should only be proportional to the evidence we have for it, and that should never be 100 percent—so even foundational ideas like special relativity might turn out to be only excellent approximations rather than exactly true.
“the amount that we accept that idea should only be proportional to the evidence we have for it, and that should never be 100%.”
- The AdS/CFT correspondence provides the best-understood example of holography but describes anti-de Sitter space with a negative cosmological constant, whereas the real universe has a positive cosmological constant (discovered via accelerating expansion in 1998), so the field may be spending too much time on AdS/CFT—analogous to searching for keys under a lamp post because the light is better there, not because that's where they were lost.
“anti-de Sitter space is a really bright lamp post when it comes to holography and quantum gravity, but it's not where we lost our keys, it's not the world we live in.”
- Because quantum mechanics is more fundamental than general relativity, we should not be quantizing gravity (starting from a classical theory and quantizing it); instead we should adopt a quantum-mechanics-first perspective and find gravity within quantum mechanics by extracting an emergent classical spacetime from the quantum wave function.
“we shouldn't be quantizing gravity at all. What we should be doing is finding gravity within quantum mechanics.”
- Undergraduate quantum mechanics education does a serious disservice by de-emphasizing entanglement—one can take an entire introductory course without hearing about it—when entanglement, more than anything else, is what makes the quantum world different from the classical world.
“I think that we do our undergraduate students an incredible disservice by de-emphasizing the role of entanglement in quantum mechanics.”
- Quantum mechanics is the most spectacularly successful theory physicists have ever devised, yet physicists do not agree on what it actually says; there is a working recipe for predictions but multiple fundamentally different formulations that match experiments while disagreeing about what is really going on.
“Quantum mechanics is the most spectacularly successful theory that physicists have ever devised, and yet we don't understand what it actually says.”
- Theoretical physics works by proposing speculative ideas and seeing where they lead, even knowing they may turn out useless for the ultimate problem, because trying is the only way to learn lessons about how the universe works.
“be completely useless in figuring out, ultimately, how to reconcile gravity with quantum mechanics, but we don't know yet. That's why we have to try it. That's what theoretical physics is all about.”
- To allow black holes to evaporate via Hawking radiation without destroying quantum information that falls in, while strong arguments show the information cannot escape if locality is fully respected, Susskind and collaborators proposed horizon complementarity: an infalling observer sees ordinary local three-dimensional physics, while an outside observer sees information smeared across the two-dimensional event horizon, and both descriptions are true but not simultaneously.
“what Susskind says is what they see is your quantum information becomes spread around the event horizon. You get sort of smeared onto this two-dimensional surface.”
- Spiros Michalakis, a mathematical physicist and Carroll's collaborator, served as a science consultant on Ant-Man and is responsible for the 'quantum realm' becoming an important element of the Marvel universe.
“it's Spiros' fault that there's something called the quantum realm that plays such an important role in the Marvel universe”
Quantum field theory succeeds by meeting Lorentz invariance requirements, but finite degrees of freedom may make special relativity only approximate.
- Because the universe may be finite-dimensional with built-in locality (parts interacting only with nearest neighbors), one can model the whole universe as a quantum circuit whose time evolution is the action of generalized AND and NOT gates, analogous to quantum computing circuit diagrams.
“you can think of the whole universe as a quantum circuit, and the evolution of the universe through time is the action of all sorts of generalized versions of AND gates and NOT gates and so forth.”
- If there are only a finite number of degrees of freedom in a region, it is very hard for special relativity to be exactly true, because Lorentz invariance requires distances to be able to be infinitely short (as speeds approach light); this could mean Lorentz invariance is only approximate, which opens the possibility of future experimental tests of quantum gravity.
“if you have a finite number of degrees of freedom, it's very hard for special relativity to be exactly true.”
- Quantum field theory is, in some sense, the natural and arguably unique way to reconcile quantum mechanics with special relativity; the requirements of Lorentz invariance and no shortest distance push toward an infinite number of degrees of freedom, which is why QFT is so successful and so foundational.
“Quantum field theory is in some sense the natural, maybe even arguably the unique way to reconcile quantum mechanics with special relativity”