366 | Jim Al-Khalili on Time, Quantum, Biology, and Cosmology
What this covers
Sean Carroll talks with physicist Jim Al-Khalili about his book On Time, which runs through physics, biology and cosmology. The conversation starts from the philosophers' split between physical and manifest time. Al-Khalili admits he cannot reconcile the felt flow of time, or the specialness of the present, with the time in the equations. He treats time as a real part of four-dimensional spacetime and finds eternalism natural without committing firmly to it. He also allows that time may emerge from entanglement, the way temperature emerges from molecular motion.
The quantum material is the most technical stretch. Al-Khalili breaks measurement into three stages and says decoherence removes interference without selecting an outcome. He describes himself as a realist who believes one interpretation is correct, and he concedes that many-worlds is the cleanest answer to the measurement problem. He also cautions against reading entanglement as an instantaneous force, and he argues undergraduate courses should teach open-systems quantum mechanics.
The biology and cosmology sections carry the more speculative claims. On quantum biology, he covers the entangled-electron compass proposed for migratory birds and proton tunneling in DNA as a source of mutations. He answers the "warm, wet cell" objection by suggesting life may have evolved environments that sustain coherence. Life, he says, feeds on low-entropy sunlight rather than fighting the second law. On cosmology, he and Eddy Chen propose a low-entanglement-entropy starting state as an alternative to the thermodynamic past hypothesis. Carroll wonders whether quantum computing could learn from nature's long-lived coherence.
Al-Khalili argues that the arrow of time is more fundamental than time-symmetric laws, which he treats as idealizations of isolated systems, and that quantum entanglement and decoherence may supply a better past hypothesis than thermodynamic entropy alone.
- Time-symmetric equations such as Schrödinger's apply exactly only to isolated systems, and no real system is truly isolated, so irreversibility is built into open systems.
- The standard account needs a low-entropy past hypothesis, which Al-Khalili proposes replacing with a low-entanglement-entropy 'pure state' starting condition.
- Time is real and emergent in his view, and even a universe at thermal equilibrium would still have time passing.
Physicists need formal structures to communicate and must openly separate known answers from unknown ones.
- Carroll argues that physicists often lack understanding of basic statistical analysis and philosophy of physics, and that the answer is formal structures for physicists and other fields to talk, not merely reading lists.
“I think we need to actually talk to each other and there should be more formal structures to allow that to happen.”
- Carroll values Al-Khalili openly saying what is not yet known, arguing that people must accept that some answers are known and some are not.
“Kudos to you for actually saying what we don't know the answer to. It is... People have to accept that there's some things we do know the answers to and some things we don't”
Open-system framing is central, and nature may hold quantum strategies engineers could learn.
- Carroll reads Al-Khalili's position as taking the open-system point of view front and center, deriving open-system equations from isolated-system equations applied to a larger system, and Al-Khalili accepts this framing.
“you're suggesting a change of perspective where we should take the open system point of view more front and center?”
- Quantum computing efforts maintain entanglement among a few qubits with difficulty, while nature has maintained quantum effects in cells for billions of years, so nature may have discovered clever strategies that engineers could learn from.
“people who are trying to build quantum computers are spending lots of money trying to maintain entanglement between a few qubits... and nature's been doing it for billions of years, and maybe they've come up with some clever strategies.”