What this covers

Sean Carroll interviews physicist and science writer Adam Becker about the organizational and political history of quantum mechanics—specifically, why foundational questions about what the theory actually means have been treated as out-of-bounds by the physics community for nearly a century. Becker argues that the Copenhagen interpretation became orthodoxy not because it solved the deep problems but because post-war institutional forces, military funding, and professional incentives made foundational work a career liability. The discussion traces how figures like David Bohm, Hugh Everett, and John Bell—who refused to stop asking what quantum mechanics says about reality—paid real professional costs for their persistence, while textbook authors and funding agencies systematically sidelined the measurement problem in favor of practical applications.

The conversation spans several interlocking historical moments. Becker examines the myth of Albert Einstein as a quantum-mechanics skeptic who couldn't keep up with the theory, showing instead that Einstein was among its founders and spent enormous effort thinking through its implications. Bell's theorem and the EPR paradox become central: Bell proved Einstein was right to worry about locality and instantaneous correlations, yet his solution—hidden variables—cannot escape those very problems. The episode details how Bohm's political persecution kept him from defending his pilot wave theory, how physicist Alain Aspect later revived interest in Bell experiments, and how even the editorial policies of major journals actively suppressed foundational papers. Both speakers stress that the real problem is not intellectual difficulty but a professional culture that has normalized the dismissal of foundational inquiry itself.

Sharpest takeaway

Becker argues that physicists abandoned the foundational measurement problem of quantum mechanics not because it was solved but for sociological and historical reasons, and that the Copenhagen interpretation won by PR and institutional pressure rather than by being correct, while iconoclasts like Bohm, Everett, and Bell who took the foundations seriously paid professional prices for it.

  • Post-WWII funding and big-science culture redirected physics toward applications and away from foundational questions
  • Bell's theorem showed locality cannot survive without either spooky action at a distance or something even stranger like many-worlds, vindicating Einstein's worry while refuting his proposed fix
  • Foundational thinkers (Bohm, Everett, Clauser) suffered career damage, showing the field treated foundations as illegitimate

The argument · threads10 threads · 47 claims
0.74

Quantum mechanics contains an unresolved internal contradiction between deterministic evolution and probabilistic collapse that defines the measurement problem.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Quantum mechanics has two contradictory rules for how wave functions behave: the deterministic Schrodinger equation when nothing is being measured, and the probabilistic collapse described by the Born rule when a measurement occurs; the unresolved question of which rule to apply when, and what counts as a measurement, is the measurement problem.

    “the problem is that these two rules for how wave functions work contradict each other.”

  • Quantum mechanics is a highly successful mathematical tool for predicting experimental outcomes, but what it tells us is actually going on in the world is a separate question of interpretation that remains controversial and unresolved since the 1920s.

    “quantum mechanics is this really good mathematical tool, for predicting the outcomes of experiments... As for what it tells us is going on in the world, that's a question of interpreting the mathematical structure and the results of the experiments that we do.”

  • Schrodinger devised the cat thought experiment to support the EPR position by showing that quantum superposition, if taken literally, leads to a cat that is neither dead nor alive before observation, which is intuitively absurd and suggests quantum mechanics fails to capture some deeper fact about reality.

    “you can set up an experiment where a cat is neither dead nor alive before you look... cats are either dead or alive.”

  • The measurement problem is a genuine and important open problem in physics, comparable to the lack of a well-accepted theory of quantum gravity, even though acknowledging it does not require that everyone work on it.

    “the measurement problem is a thing, and it's an important open problem in physics. That doesn't mean that everybody has to work on it”

  • Quantum mechanics is a phenomenally successful physical theory that predicts the behavior of very small objects and everything made of them, making it effectively our best physical theory of everything except where gravity dominates (general relativity).

    “It is the best theory we have to account for the behavior and predict the behavior of very small objects, but also things that are constituted of very small objects, which is basically everything.”

0.70

Einstein and Podolsky-Rosen's argument that quantum mechanics is incomplete because entangled particles must carry pre-existing properties remains logically sound.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen argued that distant entangled measurements have correlated outcomes, so either there is an instantaneous spooky influence between them or the particles already carried agreed-upon properties before measurement, and the reasonable choice is that they had pre-existing properties, implying quantum mechanics is incomplete rather than wrong.

    “given that the two options are something totally normal like that or this long distance what he called 'spooky action at a distance,' he chose door number one.”

  • Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen's persistence after Solvay effectively forced the physics community to recognize entanglement—instantaneous correlations between distant systems—as perhaps the defining trait of quantum mechanics.

    “it forced the rest of the physics community to understand that entanglement was maybe the defining trait of quantum mechanics.”

  • The common claim that locality can be saved by giving up hidden variables is false because Einstein's EPR argument still applies; and the claim that locality survives by giving up 'realism' lacks any satisfying definition of realism unless one abandons the notion of things altogether, in which case locality becomes meaningless.

    “you'll sometimes hear people say, 'No, you can save locality if you get rid of the hidden variables.' That's not true because then you're still left with Einstein's EPR argument.”

  • Although entanglement produces what looks like an instantaneous influence between distant particles, it is provable that it cannot be used to send signals or communicate faster than light.

    “you can prove that you can't use it to send signals like that. It looks like an instantaneous influence, it doesn't look like something that you could use for instantaneous communication.”

0.64

Professional stigma and career penalties against foundational research prevented physicists from seriously pursuing alternative interpretations despite their merit.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • John Bell, a respected quantum field theorist at CERN, did not advertise his work on quantum foundations and only pursued it seriously after his career was established and safe, reflecting the professional stigma attached to foundational research.

    “He also didn't work on it in a serious way at great length until well after his career was established and safe.”

  • David Bohm's brief Communist Party membership led to denied security clearance, a HUAC contempt charge, effective firing from Princeton, inability to find academic work in the US or Europe despite recommendations from Einstein and Oppenheimer, and eventual exile in Brazil where his passport was confiscated, all of which prevented him from defending his pilot-wave theory.

    “Princeton effectively fired him after that, and he couldn't get a job anywhere else, even though he had recommendation letters from Einstein and Oppenheimer.”

  • Unlike Bohm who was chased out of the country, Everett was not forced out of physics; though traumatized by the cold reception of his work and Wheeler's failed attempt to get Bohr's blessing, Everett was never going to stay in academia and chose to work for the military-industrial complex doing nuclear war-gaming.

    “Everett was never gonna stay in academia... it wasn't where his passions were.”

  • John Bell was so worried about damaging young physicists' careers that he refused to discuss the proposed Bell-test experiment with Alain Aspect until Aspect assured him he already held a permanent position.

    “Bell wouldn't even talk to him about it until Aspect assured him that he had a permanent position, because Bell was so worried about damaging the careers of young physicists.”

  • John Clauser, with Stuart Freedman, performed the first experimental test of Bell's inequalities around 1971-72 and found quantum mechanics held (ruling out local hidden variables), yet because he did this as a postdoc without a permanent position, the foundational work damaged rather than advanced his career.

    “Clauser who at this point is a postdoc at Berkeley, along with another guy named Stuart Freedman, actually do an experiment to test the predictions of quantum mechanics in this situation, and that they find that quantum mechanics works.”

  • The genuine problem is not that physicists find foundations hard and choose not to work on them, but that they convert this into a normative claim that one should not work on foundations because it is not what physicists do, which is what is harmful and endemic.

    “The problem is when you change that to this normative statement, when you say, 'Oh it's very hard and you shouldn't work on it, it's a bad idea to work on it... because that's not the thing that we do as physicists.'”

0.56

The Copenhagen interpretation is incoherent, its founders held mutually incompatible positions, and Bohr's response to EPR served rhetorical rather than logical function.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • There is no single Copenhagen interpretation; Bohr, Born, Pauli and Heisenberg each held their own positions that cannot be combined into something coherent, and in Bohr's case it is not even clear what his position was.

    “I don't think that there is any single Copenhagen interpretation... I don't think that you can combine all of those to make something coherent.”

  • At the 1927 Solvay Conference the Copenhagen camp solved the measurement problem by declaring it not good scientific practice to talk about what is going on when you are not looking, effectively making the unobserved world off-limits to physics.

    “the solution that was proposed was it's not right, it's not good scientific practice to talk about what's going on when you're not looking.”

  • Niels Bohr's famously impenetrable reply to the EPR paper served an important social function simply by existing: people could point to it and say the objection had been handled without actually reading or understanding it.

    “Bohr's reply served this very important social function just by existing, because people could say, 'Oh, you don't have to worry about that EPR thing, Bohr worked it out, it's on that page.' And so people didn't actually read it, it was just there.”

  • Some defenders of Copenhagen-like views jump between mutually contradictory positions, which is an effective rhetorical move because anything follows from a contradiction, allowing them to answer any objection by simply contradicting themselves.

    “you get them jumping between mutually contradictory positions, which, if you can pull that off is a really effective rhetorical move 'cause it turns out that anything follows from a contradiction.”

0.56

Post-WWII influx of applied physics funding and military priorities redirected the field away from foundational questions toward technical applications and problem-solving.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • After the Manhattan Project, governments, industry and the military recognized the value of funding massive applied physics, and this influx of money and personnel redirected the field toward working out implications of quantum theory rather than its foundations, sweeping questions of meaning under the rug.

    “there was recognition by governments and industry and the military that there was a lot of value to be had in funding massive amounts of applied physics. And so rather than worrying about the foundations of quantum mechanics, this influx of money and the people who came along with that were concerned with working out implications of quantum physics”

  • Historian David Kaiser's analysis of post-war physics curricula and textbooks found that the larger the classroom, the less time was spent on the meaning and foundations of quantum theory and the more on applications, because it is easier to teach solving differential equations than thorny philosophical issues.

    “the larger the classroom the less time spent on the meaning and foundations of the theory and the more time spent on applications.”

  • Most popular histories of quantum mechanics run from 1900 to about 1935 and end happily with Bohr defeating Einstein, but a better understanding comes from inverting that structure and focusing on what happened from 1945 onward, after World War II.

    “My book inverts that structure. I only have a chapter or two at the beginning about the very early days of quantum mechanics and most of the book focuses on stuff that happened from, say, 1945 onward”

  • For about fifty years the physics community made the collective choice that the foundations of quantum mechanics were not worth worrying about, and even today the standard position is a softened 'don't worry about it' rather than the earlier prescriptive 'you shouldn't worry about it.'

    “For 50 years, the physics as a field, made the choice that the foundations were not worth worrying about.”

0.53

Bell proved that no local hidden-variable theory can reproduce quantum predictions, yet Bohmian mechanics, Einstein's preferred option, requires nonlocality and faces deep incompatibility with relativity.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Bohm's pilot-wave theory is the hidden-variable theory Einstein wanted, but instead of avoiding spooky action at a distance it is riddled with it, so that shaking a magnet would instantaneously affect the position of every electron in the universe; Bell remarked it resolved EPR in the way Einstein would have liked least.

    “his theory, the pilot wave theory was the hidden variable theory that Einstein wanted, except rather than avoiding spooky action at a distance, it... So spooky action is doing all the work here.”

  • John Bell proved that Einstein was right to be worried about quantum mechanics but that his proposed solution could not work: any theory reproducing quantum predictions in which experiments have definite outcomes (and excluding superdeterminism) must contain spooky action at a distance or something even weirder, so locality cannot be saved merely by adding hidden variables.

    “what Bell proved was that Einstein was right to be worried, but that his proposed solution couldn't work.”

  • The fundamental difficulty with Bohmian/pilot-wave mechanics is that it does not seem compatible with relativity, since relativity has no preferred reference frame and forbids faster-than-light influence while Bohmian mechanics requires nonlocal effects, and no fully convincing relativistic quantum field theory version has been achieved.

    “the fundamental problem with pilot wave theory, Bohmian mechanics, whatever you wanna call it, is that it doesn't seem to play nice with relativity”

0.44

Physics shifted from being natural philosophy with philosophical rigor toward practical-minded applied work, creating disciplinary contempt for philosophical foundations.

8 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The popular myth that Einstein could not keep up with quantum mechanics is the opposite of true: he was one of its founders via the 1905 photoelectric-effect paper, won his Nobel Prize for quantum work, and reportedly spent more effort thinking about quantum mechanics than about relativity.

    “There is no evidence whatsoever that he couldn't keep up with it, he definitely understood it.”

  • Science is a human process affected by history, personalities, and culture, and these factors are genuinely reflected in scientific outcomes, even though this does not mean science is arbitrary or made up.

    “there is general attitude or idea among some physicists and some scientists of various stripes, that history and personalities and culture don't really matter that much in science and aren't really reflected in science, and that's just wrong.”

  • Epistemic interpretations hold that the wave function represents our knowledge about the world rather than a thing in the world, but supporting such a view does not require denying realism; for example Matt Leifer is a scientific realist who believes there is a real world of stuff but that the wave function is not one of those things.

    “Epistemic, meaning that the wave function is about our knowledge about the world rather than a thing in the world.”

  • Part of the recent resurgence of efforts to make Copenhagen-like views respectable comes from a realization among its sympathizers that, having long relied on the strategy of denying any alternatives existed, they can no longer survive by ignoring the competition.

    “if they want it to survive, they can no longer ignore the competition. So there... For many, many years, the strategy was, what alternatives, right? There are no alternatives.”

  • Alain Aspect's permanent position and skill at giving talks let him spread awareness of the Bell-test experiment, which renewed interest in quantum foundations and helped drive the new fields of quantum information and quantum computing.

    “He made people aware that there was at least one really nice experiment to be done in quantum foundations, and that, in turn, caused people take a look at Bell's work... this also drove the new field of quantum information and quantum computing.”

  • Some physicists fully embraced the Copenhagen claim that physics is only about measurement outcomes, yet would then go off and do work that was clearly not about measurement outcomes, paralleling how scientists deny outside influences on science while being subject to them.

    “you can see somebody saying, 'Oh, no, no, no, no, physics is definitely all about the outcomes of measurements,' and then they'd go off and do something that's clearly not about the outcomes.”

  • Princeton in the early 1950s was one of the best places to do physics, and smart people gathered there are more likely to question truths handed to them on a platter, which helped foster the foundational work of Bohm and Everett, though questioning such truths does not itself make one smart.

    “I think that smart people are more likely to question these truths that they've just been handed on a platter. Which is not to say that if you question those truths that makes you a smart person.”

  • The disciplinary split between physics and philosophy is a recent invention—scientists were once called natural philosophers and generally had good philosophical schooling—yet in less than a century many prominent physicists have developed open public contempt for philosophy, possibly tied to physics's center of gravity shifting from Europe to the more practical-minded United States and the rise of big science after WWII.

    “The whole disciplinary split between physics and philosophy is a pretty modern invention. We used to call scientists 'natural philosophers'”

0.35

Quantum mechanics explains natural phenomena like stellar fusion and semiconductors, contradicting Copenhagen's claim that physics concerns only measurement outcomes.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Quantum mechanics has always been used to do more than predict experimental outcomes; it explains natural phenomena like why the sun shines, why silicon is a semiconductor, and why solid matter is impenetrable, which contradicts the Copenhagen claim that physics is only about measurement outcomes.

    “Quantum mechanics has always been used to do more than just predict the outcomes of experiments. It has also been used to explain all kinds of very interesting natural phenomena”

  • The Lamb shift, a small discrepancy between predicted and observed atomic light emission, drove development of quantum electrodynamics by Feynman, Schwinger, Tomonaga and Dyson, which was foundational rather than applied work even though it had nothing to do with the measurement problem.

    “this led to the development of a new foundational theory of quantum physics called quantum electrodynamics, and this is what the single piece of work that Richard Feynman is most well known for”

0.31

David Bohm developed pilot-wave theory after his faith in Copenhagen collapsed while defending it, but political persecution exiled him and prevented him from advancing his alternative.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • While writing a textbook attempting to present the clearest possible version of the Copenhagen interpretation, David Bohm's faith in it collapsed, and Einstein told him this was because he was trying to defend an indefensible position, prompting Bohm to seek and rediscover the pilot-wave alternative.

    “in the process of trying to do that Bohm's faith in the Copenhagen interpretation just plummeted, until by the end of the process, he was just completely plagued with doubt.”

0.18

Von Neumann's famous proof against hidden variables was flawed and easily criticized, yet it was widely ignored in favor of the orthodox position and its dismissal of alternatives.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • John von Neumann's famous proof, widely cited as showing quantum mechanics must be fundamentally chance-driven and that hidden variables are impossible, did not actually prove that; Bell found it fell apart on inspection, ruling out only a particular kind of hidden variable, a flaw Grete Hermann had identified within a few years of its 1935 publication but which was ignored.

    “I looked at von Neumann's proof and it fell apart in my hands. It's not just wrong, it's silly, It clearly doesn't work.”