federalism
A system of government in which power is divided between a central national authority and constituent regional units such as states.
As defined in Matt Yglesias
Other definitions
The constitutional division of power between a national government and the states; Greve's work emphasized the national-commercial aspect within which states compete.
Richard Reinsch on the Enlightenment, Tradition, and Populism
Where it comes up · 15
- Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar: The Crack-Up of American Democracy | Foreign Affairs Interview6 claims
- Tyler Cowen on how AI will reorder economies, schools, and spirituality5 claims
- Matt Yglesias2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Annie Lowrey1 claim
- Jamal Greene1 claim
- Yuval Levin on Burke, Paine, and the Great Debate1 claim
- Richard Reinsch on the Enlightenment, Tradition, and Populism1 claim
- Michael Munger on Constitutions1 claim
and 7 more
Most important claims · 10 of 25Search all claims for “federalism” →
- Following Jacob Levy, there are two strains of liberalism—rationalist (imposing a single uniform liberal order, even via a Pinochet-style dictator imposing categorical property rights) and pluralist (federalism, checks and balances, regional difference)—and neither is correct alone: the rationalist failure mode is the enlightened-dictator argument, while the pluralist failure mode allows reactionary localities like Jim Crow to persist below the national level.344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
- Every government activity should face two tests: first, whether the state should be involved at all—with the burden of proof on those wanting it to act, presuming markets over a state that is bad, expensive, slow, and resource-diverting; and second, the 10th Amendment test of whether it is a federal versus state responsibility, which the Department of Education and Department of Commerce both fail.Will DOGE and Musk Make a Difference? (with Michael Munger)
- De Jasay's central concept is exit: one's ability to coerce another is sharply limited by the other's viable ability to exit, so American Federalism (competition among states you could escape to) and the American frontier were more important than the Constitution itself—and the combination of frontier and Constitution is what made America great.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- Following David Schleicher's argument, concentrating more power in governors' hands could improve state government because people actually know who the governor is, pay attention, and replace bad governors — meaning you strengthen decentralized institutions of American government paradoxically by centralizing them.Matt Yglesias
- The real bulwark against a stolen election is American federalism—thousands of counties running their own elections with no centralized authority—which is why proposed internet-based national voting would be a disaster, creating a single choke point where an autocrat could claim victory with no way to verify reality.454 - More From Sam Minnesota Greenland Iran Sthole Countries And More
- Federalism is one way to import market-style trial-and-error into government, but the common conservative framing of states as laboratories that will discover what works in one place to then apply everywhere misses the point, because solutions will not work everywhere; what is really needed is continuous on-the-ground problem-solving, which means devolving service provision to private providers and using government to create incentives to experiment.Yuval Levin on Burke, Paine, and the Great Debate
- A billion-American nation would likely produce messier, uglier national politics because people who don't know each other and share little in common are more easily mobilized by politicians inventing new identity cleavages, whereas homogeneous small towns let dissatisfied people leave and allow direct self-monitoring of officials.Matt Yglesias
- US federalism creates extreme complexity to build out the grid; you need approval from state and local governments, feds, and environmental review boards, each layer adding years; removing a single federal regulation can take 2-3 years alone.Tyler Cowen on how AI will reorder economies, schools, and spirituality
- US federalism enables competitive policy experimentation (different power grids, regulations), allowing rapid discovery of what works; this is an advantage over EU harmonization and UK centralization, though still slower than directed Gulf initiatives.Tyler Cowen on how AI will reorder economies, schools, and spirituality
- Federalism can be both a strength and a weakness for the United States; while it allows diversity and policy experimentation, it can also be a source of fracture and dissension if the balance shifts too far toward federal or state power, potentially creating disarray.Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar: The Crack-Up of American Democracy | Foreign Affairs Interview