Conversations with Tyler - Annie Lowrey
What this covers
Annie Lowrey and Tyler Cowen discuss what government costs people in hours rather than dollars. Lowrey's best estimate, from the American Time Use Survey, is about 50 hours per person per year, and she thinks that undercounts because the survey misses multitasking. The examples are concrete: submerged benefits delivered through the tax code, pre-filled tax returns that peer democracies use but the IRS is barred from offering, SNAP's missing definition of a household, and disability insurance, where some applications exceed 1,000 pages and about 11,000 Americans die each year awaiting a determination. The burden reaches the rich too, as with 500-day renovation permits in San Francisco.
The middle of the conversation is about fraud and state capacity. Lowrey says most Medicare and Medicaid fraud happens on the provider side, and that pandemic-era fraud came from criminal groups running sham businesses, not from individual applicants. State unemployment systems still run on COBOL because governors with low unemployment have no reason to fund upgrades. She calls the safety net the worst-run part of government. Cowen answers with deterrence through random audits: if only one application in 5,000 is caught, punishment has to be harsh.
The talk then branches out. They take up the welfare magnet hypothesis and Cowen's view that a clunky system selects for ambitious immigrants. They disagree over whether voting should be made harder, with Cowen favoring higher costs and Lowrey holding to participation as a principle. They also debate abolishing the postal service on the Danish model, whether email illustrates Jevons paradox, and what Christianity contributed to ideas of individual rights.
Lowrey argues that administrative 'time taxes' imposed by government paperwork, complexity, and friction fall hardest on the poor and marginalized, are often a deliberate or unexamined policy choice, and can be cut through simpler rules, federal administration, and better digital systems, without sacrificing fraud control or access to benefits. Cowen pushes back that some friction screens out fraud and selects for capable immigrants and voters.
- Submerged benefits like the child tax credit get high take-up but low awareness, so they are easier to run but do not build public understanding or support.
- Fraud is mostly organized, provider-side or criminal rather than individual, so burdening individual applicants is a poor fix that costs legitimate users time.
- Federal administration of mass programs reduces overhead and duplication across the 100-plus TANF and 56 Medicaid programs.
Strict enforcement and friction in benefit programs are needed to deter fraud and overuse.
- If AI is a major advance and people live to 100 but are not happier day to day, the purpose of UBI becomes stabilizing people so they do not become less happy from instability, rather than raising happiness.
“Then the purpose of UBI is not to make people happier, but just to stop them from being less happy due to instability.”
- Cowen argues that if audits catch only one in 5,000 applications, people will assume they can get away with fraud, so punishment must be harsh enough to deter.
“If you only audit one in 5,000, people will think, 'Oh, I can get away with it.' The punishment needs to really be harsh to scare them off.”
- Cowen argues that many knee and back surgeries are ineffective, that government should be tougher by forcing people through more hoops or dropping coverage entirely, and that most ways of saving money are not nice.
“I know it’s not nice, but most ways of saving money are not nice. If it’s not an effective medical procedure, let’s be much tougher.”
- Voters are more outraged by individual fraud even though it costs less, and this has fueled turning against immigration, so Cowen suggests strictness with individuals is needed because that is what bothers voters.
“Voters often seem more outraged by individual fraud, even though it costs less.”
- Cowen argues that the Minnesota Medicaid fraud over Somali autism claims became a big headline with probably small total dollar amounts, and that the outrage made policy and discourse worse, even though there was clearly some fraud.
“It’s probably not a lot of money, but it became a big headline, and people claim it’s a lot of money. ... it makes policy much worse, it makes discourse much worse”
- Cowen argues that fraud rose sharply when the US relaxed benefit controls during COVID, suggesting time taxes and other frictions may be needed to prevent fraud when they are removed.
“It seems that fraud went up a lot. In net terms, maybe we need the time taxes and the other nonsense just to prevent what happens when we take them away.”
- From 1990 to 2014, the number of people on disability insurance rose about fourfold while workplace fatalities steadily declined, and Cowen argues disability insurance should therefore be much tougher to obtain.
“from 1990 to 2014, the number of people on disability insurance increased by about four times. Even though jobs got safer, the number of people killed by their job went down steadily.”
A clunky immigration system selects ambitious immigrants, so expand O-1 and H-1B visas.
- The current US immigration and benefits system selects for stamina, conscientiousness, focus, drive, and willingness to endure indignities, producing negative selection relative to IQ, so a clunky system may be attracting people who can navigate it rather than the most capable.
“It selects for people having stamina, conscientiousness, focus, drive, willing to put up with indignities... It’s become negative selection, relative to IQ.”
- Cowen argues that many PhD students are lazy and that this does not make a good standard for immigration selection, so an immigration system should not rely on the qualities that happen to filter in lazy people.
“I know plenty of lazy PhDs. Most PhDs are lazy, I would say. I don’t want that to be the standard.”
- The US should expand O-1 visas and reform H-1B to allow more of them, removing the $100,000 fees, rather than keeping benefits stingy to deter applicants.
“More O-1s, and then somewhat reform H-1B, and to have more of them, and none of these crazy $100,000 fees.”
- Cowen argues that because the US immigration and benefit system is clunky and hard to navigate, it selects for ambitious, self-sufficient immigrants rather than those seeking easy benefits, which matters greatly given low native fertility.
“If we have a welfare system where it's really hard to get benefits, don't we, in fact, attract a higher quality of immigrant, more ambitious people and more self-sustaining, than if benefits are just easy to get?”
Liberalism's health depends on restricted, educated voting and Christian moral foundations.
- Christianity's story of an individual who was the victim of power, rather than might makes right, helped valorize the victim and translated into individual rights, liberties, and constitutional procedure, though Cowen notes this has been argued rather than proven.
“the notion that Jesus Christ was an individual. It’s a story very different from 'might makes right.' We valorize the victim.”
- Cowen argues that higher voting costs would still be acceptable and that half of the population voting, skewed toward the educated, would produce better outcomes, because more educated people on average make better voting choices.
“Don’t we just get better outcomes if, say, only half the people vote, which of course will skew toward the more educated?”
- Cowen worries that as the US becomes less Christian, the prospects for liberalism may suffer, and Lowrey agrees this might be right while noting the church's role in reminding people of sin, integrity, and care for neighbors, even as a less Christian world has become safer and more redistributive.
“I tend to worry quite a bit, now that we are genuinely less Christian, that this will hurt the chances of liberalism in our future.”
- Tyler argues voting should not be too easy; the cost of voting can be set as a policy choice, and making it cheaper yields inferior outcomes, including on issues voters care about, because less educated people vote less well on average.
“There's some cost. You can set the cost where you want. ... You make the costs lower, you get inferior outcomes”
Too many separate messaging networks create friction, and one email and one texting system is preferable.
- Having many separate messaging networks such as Signal, WhatsApp, iMessage, and Twitter direct messages creates unnecessary friction, and Cowen would prefer one system of texting plus email.
“there’s too many networks, so I feel there should be email and one system of texting.”
- Tyler argues there are too many messaging networks, such as Signal, WhatsApp, iMessage, and Twitter DMs, and that there should be one email and one texting system; Lowrey agrees and says she has left X, which rewards unseemly emotions.
“there’s too many networks, so I feel there should be email and one system of texting.”