
Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar: The Crack-Up of American Democracy | Foreign Affairs Interview
What this covers
This is a conversation from The Foreign Affairs Interview with Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar, a former California Supreme Court justice and now president of the Carnegie Endowment. It builds on his early-2025 essay "How to Survive a Constitutional Crisis," which separates radical policy shifts from moves that threaten the foundations of the system. The discussion applies that test to the first months of Donald Trump's second term, including the tariffs, funding withholdings, federal workforce changes, and lethal strikes on alleged drug boats.
The domestic half turns on institutions. Cuéllar treats courts as a guardrail even though they lack enforcement power, because their moral and symbolic authority still shapes business decisions and America's reputation for the rule of law. He says open defiance of an explicit Supreme Court ruling would be an unprecedented assertion of executive supremacy. He also treats federalism) as double-edged: it allows experimentation but can fracture if the balance tips. Political violence comes up as a force that wears down public faith in peaceful, law-based ways of settling disputes. A running theme is that good-faith governance means accepting short-term limits, like self-restraint taught to children.
The foreign-policy portion is the most specific. Cuéllar notes that the framers placed war powers with Congress, and he asks whether the Caribbean and Pacific strikes fit the postwar legal framework meant to discipline unilateral force. He describes war and peace as a continuum. On Venezuela he favors sanctions and diplomacy over intervention. He cites the history of Central American and Caribbean interventions that produced dictatorships, and he warns of consequences for Brazil and Colombia. He defends the Monroe Doctrine as sound but separate from a license to intervene. The conversation then moves to the economic ties with Japan and South Korea, immigration and the public's need to see order, and the fragility of the federal research funding, talent, and open-ideas system behind American innovation. It closes on AI's growing role in military decisions.
Quayle argues that while Trump's early second-term expansion of executive power raises legitimate concerns, the American system still contains effective checks—courts, federalism, and independent media—that can constrain overreach if political actors across ideological divides act decisively before institutional erosion becomes irreversible.
- Courts, federalism, and independent media remain functional guardrails despite executive assertiveness
- The real danger is incremental consolidation of power through ambiguous constitutional decisions rather than direct confrontation
- Cross-ideological coalitions and litigation remain viable mechanisms to protect constitutional limits
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
AI decisions about military activity—when to deploy vehicles/drones, whether to conduct military exercises with other countries—will increasingly be advised by AI and potentially decided by AI, fundamentally changing decision-making about military operations.
“decisions around major diplomatic initiatives, but particularly around military activity. When, for example, to not only deploy a particular vehicle or squad of drones, but increasingly how to think about the benefits and costs of doing a military exercise with another country will increasingly be advised by these technologies and perhaps even just decided.”
American courts, despite lacking independent enforcement authority and military power, retain significant moral, ethical, and symbolic authority that influences both business decisions and America's international reputation for rule of law.
“when courts, including courts that you might be taken to assume to be in sync with the president speak, they speak with the authority that is more moral, ethical, and symbolic than just like can they deploy a police force. That's point number one. And it's not just the rank and file American public. It's American business that cares about this. It's our relationship with people around the world that view America's rule of laws being a key element of the country.”
Good faith governance often involves accepting limits on what you might want to do in the short term, which is analogous to self-restraint taught to children.
“And that often involves accepting limits on what you might want to do in the short term. It's the stuff we teach our kids in a way.”
The U.S. has a history of military interventions in Central America and the Caribbean that have resulted in the rise of brutal dictatorships, complicating America's hemispheric interests even though those interventions were intended to support democracy.
“There are times when we've intervened in places like Central America, the Caribbean, and we end up perhaps even though we want to support democracy, we end up giving rise to pretty brutal dictatorships there in ways that complicate our own hemispheric situation in terms of what follows after an American military invasion.”
Political violence and fear of violence corrode civil society by making people doubt the value of peaceful, law-based mechanisms for security and dispute resolution.
“What truly makes a society vulnerable and corroded and corrosive is political violence and the fear that can permeate when you begin to see an uptick in political violence. So even if you don't actually have so much violence, if you start to get judges, state legislators, even just, you know, private citizens who speak out in conversations online to feel fear. That's not good for civil society. And it also can make people feel like the point of investing in peaceful lawbound mechanisms for public security and for dispute resolution is like not worth it.”
American innovation and technology leadership depends on federal funding for research universities and independent research institutes, national labs, free spread of ideas across society, and the ability to attract extraordinary talent—both those educated abroad and through domestic graduate programs.
“those breakthroughs depend on an infrastructure of research funding for universities and independent research institutes, breakthroughs in the national labs, the free spread of ideas across our society, our ability to pull some of the most extraordinary talent either to work in some of our companies when they've been educated abroad or very very often through uh student opportunities in our graduate schools”
Federalism can be both a strength and a weakness for the United States; while it allows diversity and policy experimentation, it can also be a source of fracture and dissension if the balance shifts too far toward federal or state power, potentially creating disarray.
“federalism has been and can be a strength for the United States. It can also be a risk and a weakness. You can see fracture and dissension growing out of federalism especially as that balance shifts.”
AI breakthroughs of recent years were hard to imagine even five years ago, and the relationship to technology is such that once it becomes ubiquitous, people stop thinking of it as advanced technology and just price it into how they think about the world, making it conventional wisdom that the US should be at the frontier of AI technology development.
“part of what has been achieved with the AI sector is breakthroughs that were hard to imagine even 5 years ago. And the the weird thing about our relationship to technology is that once it begins to be a little bit ubiquitous, you stop thinking about it even as technology a really advanced technology. it just kind of gets priced into how we think about the world. And I think now it's basic uh the conventional wisdom among American policy makers and rightly so that a major goal of the US should be to be the place that is at the frontier of this technology for two reasons.”
The U.S. can pursue legitimate policy goals toward Venezuela through public diplomacy, economic sanctions, and clear communication with allies, without resorting to military intervention.
“There are plenty of things that the US can do and probably should do from the perspective of its own interests, including public diplomacy, economic sanctions, making sure we're perfectly clear with our allies and other countries about where we stand on the dur.”
Very little about economic life, prices, farmers' ability to sell products is disconnected from the web of economic relationships that strengthen America's security and influence in Asia.
“very little about how we understand economic life, the prices we pay the ability of our farmers to sell their products is disconnected from that idea of a web of economic relationships that can then strengthen America and protect its security, strengthen and increase its influence in places like Asia that are so crucial for the future of America.”
There are interesting policy questions about managing new technologies, balancing autonomy with collaboration between people and companies that develop technologies, and government's role, but these cannot be resolved by abandoning research infrastructure.
“there are always going to be interesting policy questions about how best to manage those technologies, how best to strike a balance between our autonomy and working together with some of the companies that develop these technologies and so on, the role of government. But at the end of the day, those breakthroughs depend on an infrastructure of research funding for universities and independent research institutes”
The line between war and peace is not a sharp line but a continuum, and while the US military must act to protect American interests and security in lawful ways that might involve actions some would consider warlike, the hardest presidential judgment calls involve balancing how to protect the country militarily while still following the law and not treating decisions to target human lives or particular locations as the president's sole decision.
“the country has come to realize that the line between war and peace is not so much a line but it's continuum. That's true that at the end of the day there are many ways in which the US military has to act to protect American interests and to protect America in lawful ways that might involve actions that some would consider wararmongering. But the reality is whether you're dealing with issues in our hemisphere as they've arisen in Central America or the Caribbean or the Middle East or other parts of the world, the hardest judgment calls that presidents have to make is both how do I protect my country militarily and otherwise, but also how do I follow the law and make sure I don't end up treating the decision to target a human life or a particular boat or a particular set of people or particular city as just my without any confidence.”
Americans expect research and innovation infrastructure to be part of accessible opportunity, and must make compelling case to middle America about how their families' health care is affected by research breakthroughs and how their kids are part of the innovation ecosystem.
“frankly, some of that work does include making a compelling case to so many folks in middle America who may not be thinking about this or may not realize how much their own families, their own health care might be affected by these breakthroughs that they're also part of this process that their own kids and families are part of that ecosystem and making that a real promise.”
The U.S. is the hub of cutting-edge scientific and technical innovation globally, though this is not the only place where such innovation occurs; extraordinary breakthroughs in biotech occur in Boston and New York, and fintech/edtech innovations occur nationwide.
“this is not the only place where you have cutting edge scientific and technical innovation. But it's really the hub of that and not just California. You see extraordinary breakthroughs in biotech in the Boston area and New York. You see amazing innovations in uh whether it's fintech or edtech all over the country.”
The U.S. has built a post-World War II international legal framework designed to discipline countries' use of armed force by preventing them from making unilateral decisions about military strikes; Trump's Caribbean and Pacific strikes raise questions about whether they comply with this international legal framework.
“America spent a lot of time and energy building a framework and supporting a framework post World War II that's supposed to discipline countries and make it possible to defend their interests but at the same time not just make decisions that shoot from the hip about armed attacks and so on. So I also have my questions about how this fits under international law.”
The Monroe Doctrine, which asserts U.S. commitment to sovereignty and non-intervention by external powers in the Western Hemisphere, is sound policy that serves not only American interests but global interests by preventing the region from becoming a sphere for great-power competition, but this is distinct from and should not justify U.S. military intervention to enforce hemispheric order.
“It's one thing to tell other powers, don't mess with the Western Hemisphere. Respect sovereignty in the Western Hemisphere. That's not only in America's interest, that's in the world's interest. We don't want anybody to assume that the Western Hemisphere is sort of open game for big power politics. It's another thing for the US to be engaging in military action that can lead to war.”
Historical American immigration policy shows a clear pattern (particularly from the 1960s-70s onward) that Americans need to see evidence of order in immigration processes for them to believe the system is working, which requires action at borders and coordination with other countries about their role in managing migration.
“I do note in the long history of American immigration policy, it's a pretty clear pattern. Particularly, I would say from the 1960s and '7s onward that in order to get Americans to believe that the system is working, you have to hold the line and be somewhat able to show a degree of order in the process. And that includes action in appropriate measure at the border.”
Historical precedent shows that US military interventions in Central America and the Caribbean, even when intended to support democracy, have often ended up giving rise to brutal dictatorships that subsequently complicated America's own hemispheric interests and strategic position.
“There are times when we've intervened in places like Central America, the Caribbean, and we end up perhaps even though we want to support democracy, we end up giving rise to pretty brutal dictatorships there in ways that complicate our own hemispheric situation in terms of what follows after an American military invasion.”
Potential expansion of US military strikes against Venezuela would require serious consideration of unintended consequences for regional actors like Brazil and Colombia, whose stability and cooperation are vital to US interests including migration control.
“Then that's when it's particularly incumbent on a president and the president's advisers to think what are the unintended consequences how does this affect the other countries in the region Brazil Colombia countries that are vital to our interests if we're interested in stopping the flow of migration to the US is creating a political and a military crisis there are good way to do that right”
Global prosperity and American economic security have depended significantly on the post-Cold War international order in which the US built relationships of economic and security cooperation with allies like South Korea and Japan.
“I believe that that prosperity has depended to some degree on the way the country has understood that the well-being of Americans depended on winning cold war that it depended on building relationships of international cooperation with allies abroad places like South Korea and Japan that it depended on building a robust global economy that would buy American products and services welcome American technology”
The connection between American economic prices, farmers' ability to sell products, and international economic relationships is direct and material—very little about economic life is disconnected from this web of international relationships.
“very little about how we understand economic life, the prices we pay the ability of our farmers to sell their products is disconnected from that idea of a web of economic relationships that can then strengthen America and protect its security, strengthen and increase its influence in places like Asia”
American innovation and research breakthroughs—in biotech, fintech, edtech, and other fields—are concentrated in the US and depend on a complex infrastructure of federal research funding for universities and national labs, the free spread of ideas, and the ability to attract extraordinary talent from around the world.
“those breakthroughs depend on an infrastructure of research funding for universities and independent research institutes, breakthroughs in the national labs, the free spread of ideas across our society, our ability to pull some of the most extraordinary talent either to work in some of our companies when they've been educated abroad or very very often through uh student opportunities in our graduate schools”
America has extraordinary power to improve itself constantly, create a more perfect union, build more inclusive and effective America, and provide more of its promise to more people.
“a great power our country has is the power to improve ourselves constantly to create a more perfect union to build a more inclusive and effective America to build an America that is more able to provide its promise to more people.”
If the administration directly defied an explicit Supreme Court decision, it would represent an unprecedented assertion of executive supremacy over coordinate branches and would raise fundamental questions about rule of law and the Constitution's limits on presidential power.
“It would be candor on their part to say, you know what, we think the court should do its thing and we're going to do our thing and we don't think the court has the Supreme Court here has any bearing on the outcome of this case, even this particular specific case, let alone like cases, and we're just going to do our thing because we think we are the ultimate decider when it comes to executive power.”
The framers of the Constitution deliberately did not want a president treating the decision to start a war lightly or unilaterally; formally, the power to declare war lives with Congress, not the president.
“for many many years, Americans have also generally understood that among the most important decisions that the framers of the constitution made is that they didn't want a president who was going to be treating the decision to start a war lightly. They didn't even want a president who was going to treat the decision to start a war as the president's own decision. It's unambiguous in the constitution that the process of starting a war at the end of the day, formally speaking, lives with Congress.”
The relationship between financial markets and diplomacy is direct and material—diplomatic strategy cannot be divorced from economics, and in the future, diplomatic strategy will be equally inseparable from technology strategy.
“I'll give you the analogy to sort of financial markets. At the end of the day, nobody could reasonably argue in the pages of foreign affairs that you can have a diplomatic strategy that's divorced from economics. You can just not think about what the stock market will do, what the bond market will do, or what sanctions a country might impose and still have a good diplomatic strategy. I think in the same way there will be no diplomacy that isn't accompanied by a tech strategy in effect.”
Calling out political violence from all sources and pushing back against rhetoric that targets judges or suggests they deserve harm is a fundamentally American contribution to protecting democratic institutions.
“And so calling out political violence, no matter who it comes from, and also being quite thoughtful and clear about pushing back on people who start to use loose rhetoric to target judges or to suggest that they deserve x, y, or z thing. It's a very American thing to protect those structures because that in the end is part of what will enable us to secure the full promise of America.”
Repeated disruptions to international trade relationships every 18 months to 5 years create unpredictability that undermines the American business model, which depends on innovation, dynamic technological capability, and the ability to plan for markets and partners.
“What kind of predictability does that create for the American business model which is very much about being innovative and dynamic with our technology, our services, our people and their talents.”
Democracy operates differently than other forms of governance, and having democracies at the frontier of AI development (not just authoritarians) will shape how the technology develops and is deployed.
“democracies work differently than other kinds of countries. And I'm not suggesting that every country should have the same form of government, but I do think democracy is a powerful and important contribution to the conversation about governance and how the world is run. And the fact that democracies have not only technological and military power, but economic might different even in non-democracies. So staying at the frontier of AI means that democratic forms of government will be at the four as we work through what is the world do with these breakthroughs.”
Post-Civil War, the balance of federal and state power was formally settled (states do not secede), but the Constitution itself is founded on federalism and shared sovereignty—the Constitution's own name reflects this core commitment.
“There was always I think a sense post the civil war that this question of federal and state power and its balance had been settled in a way. I think if you look a little bit more closely there was also probably if you're honest an appreciation that some things had been settled. You know, this is one nation. States don't succeed. But it's also a nation founded up to and including in its very name, the core of it being about a federation and about a model of shared power and shared sovereignty.”
Government actors have a fiduciary duty to act in good faith, which means they must consider impacts beyond short-term political advantage and accept limits on executive action to preserve institutional trust and leave the country in better shape for future generations.
“Americans expect that the executive branch works in good faith. What does it mean to act in good faith? I think it means to take seriously that any action you take is about more than just the short-term policy impact of politics. It's about safeguarding the trust that any of us who's ever served in government, I know felt or should feel that we are stewards. We're fiduciaries for a country and we have to hand it off in better shape than we got it.”
The International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does give the president broad powers to act, but those powers are contingent on the existence of a genuine emergency—the question of when an emergency exists should limit presidential discretion, not simply give the president a tool to activate whenever he feels like it.
“the International Emergency Economic Powers Act is that the powers that it confers to act when it allows action are broader. But the question of when it allows action, what constitutes the kind of emergency that really allows you go forward.”
Respected presidents in American history—Washington, Lincoln, FDR, Reagan—understood that the Constitution left gaps and required presidential judgment calls, but they also recognized that such judgment had to operate within meaningful constraints and in service of constitutional principles rather than unchecked executive authority.
“presidents that have a role in our history and are generally viewed in a benign light...And all these presidents, they understood that the constitution left some gaps and that those gaps would require a president to sometimes engage in judgment calls about how to execute the power that was given to the federal government through a statute, how to deal with some of these hard questions around line drawing of what's military action that's permissible that isn't. But my point in the piece was to assert faith in America and its framework by starting from the premise that we've dealt with questions of executive power for a long time.”
Cross-ideological coalitions recognizing common interests in constitutional limits on executive power are essential—protecting what the country is about is 'macropolitics' that must precede ordinary partisan disagreements about taxes, regulation, and infrastructure.
“two, I would say forming coalitions across divides of ideology in particular and recognizing that there are common interests and making sure that yes, we have a vigorous presidency, but not one that can decide to just sort of like declare a particular statute means whatever the president wants it to mean, full stop. And I think that cross ideology I think is so important because this is not just ordinary politics. It's really about macropolitics of protecting what the country's about first and foremost so that we can have all the other political conversations about taxes or regulation or you know infrastructure and so on.”
Devolution of power to states requires responsible behavior by state officials and also requires remembering that being one nation with one Supreme Court, one president, and one foreign policy creates burden and responsibility on states.
“that does call for responsible behavior on the part of state officials again and it does also require us to remember that being one nation having one US Supreme Court having one president having ultimately one foreign policy does create a a burden and a responsibility on the states as well.”
There is tension between the speed at which government can act and move and the time courts need to hear arguments and reasoned deliberation, which should be taken seriously in assessing court performance during periods of rapid executive action.
“cases do take time sometimes and the mismatch between how fast the public needs a decision and how long the court needs to hear argument to get their ducks in a row, you know, has to be taken seriously.”
Governor Nuomo's statement after Charlie Kirk's killing emphasized the importance of peace and dialogue on college campuses, contrasting this with risk of political violence.
“Governor Nuomo after the very tragic killing of Charlie Kirk made a powerful statement about the importance of peace and believing in the sort of dialogue and disagreement that can come to college campuses with people like Charlie Kirk and how awful it was that we are risking descending into real political violence sometimes.”
Information transmission and consumption across borders is already beginning to show the intersection of diplomacy and tech strategy, though this will become more severe and interesting.
“I mean already we see some beginnings of that around uh the way information is transmitted and consumed across borders but I think that will become a more severe and interesting part of the picture.”
The US military strikes on boats in the Caribbean and Pacific alleged to be smuggling drugs are legally ambiguous because the administration has not articulated a clear legal theory for the strikes under either domestic constitutional law or the post-WWII international legal framework, and the stated justification (stopping drug flows) does not align with how fentanyl actually enters the United States.
“I'm not sure the administration has articulated a particularly clear theory of the case for these strikes. You know, they've talked about stopping drug flows, but as many critics have pointed out, this is not how fentinyl comes into the United States.”
Responsible governance of AI that includes middle-of-the-road trust-but-verify approaches (asking companies about testing and responsible scaling plans) would not limit America's frontier status and might even provide competitive advantages.
“I think at the end of the a responsible governance that does take seriously the need for further innovation, it's going to land us in a good place and might even end up being an advantage when it comes to competition.”
Military decisions—including decisions about when to deploy vehicles, drones, military exercises, or other military assets—will increasingly be made with advice from AI systems, and eventually some decisions may be made by AI systems, which creates new challenges for human oversight and international security.
“We're likely moving to a world where the decisions around major diplomatic initiatives, but particularly around military activity. When, for example, to not only deploy a particular vehicle or squad of drones, but increasingly how to think about the benefits and costs of doing a military exercise with another country will increasingly be advised by these technologies and perhaps even just decided.”
Even prestigious presidents like George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, and Ronald Reagan understood that the Constitution left gaps requiring presidential judgment about executing federal power, yet they recognized that gap-filling had limits and could not justify unilateral presidential authority.
“Let's take presidents that have a role in our history and are generally viewed in a benign light. doesn't mean that everything they did was positive. But you can talk about George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, Ronald Reagan, uh some more recent ones. And all these presidents, they understood that the constitution left some gaps and that those gaps would require a president to sometimes engage in judgment calls about how to execute the power that was given to the federal government through a statute, how to deal with some of these hard questions around line drawing of what's military action that's permissible that isn't.”
American lives are better now than 50 years ago by a significant margin, with cleaner air and water and access to extraordinary technology, supercomputers on wrists, ability to communicate across divides, and scientific breakthroughs on healthcare—all dependent on a giant complex infrastructure for research, innovation, and ideas centered in the United States.
“the lives that people are leading right now with cleaner air and cleaner water with access to extraordinary technology supercomputers on their wrist and in their pockets the ability we have to communicate information across divides and push the frontiers of science on the issues that matter so much to so many American families around uh healthcare for their loved ones. All those things depend on this giant and complex infrastructure that the hub of which is in the United States.”
States serving as laboratories of democracy—experimenting with policy approaches—is critical to America's story; the country's diverse history and continent-sized economy work best when states have latitude on matters affecting people's daily lives like education, law enforcement, and land use.
“states as laboratories of democracy states is critical to the story of America is just like unambiguously correct...We have got a continent-sized economy and geography that best works by allowing states to play around with ideas a little bit and figure out on the crucial matters that so daily affect people's lives ranging from education to law enforcement to land use to have just a degree of latitude in making the democratic project succeed.”
U.S. actions available to address the Maduro regime include public diplomacy, economic sanctions, and clear statements to allies about U.S. position, all within the law and international norms.
“There are plenty of things that the US can do and probably should do from the perspective of its own interests, including public diplomacy, economic sanctions, making sure we're perfectly clear with our allies and other countries about where we stand on the dur.”
The research enterprise has generated enormous benefits including spin-offs that fuel startups, medical breakthroughs and drug trials, innovations in biomedical engineering and medical devices, and intellectual contributions to understanding economics, social dynamics, and psychological challenges facing organizations and people.
“the enormous benefits that our research enterprise has generated, the spin-offs that go into startups, the breakthroughs that fuel then drug uh trials, the medical devices that result from the extraordinary breakthroughs in engineering and biomedical engineering and so on. but also the ideas, our ability to understand our society, our economics, our social dynamics, um the psychological challenges that sometimes face particular organizations or people and so on.”
States acting as laboratories of democracy—experimenting with different policies at the state level while maintaining unity as a nation—is both theoretically correct and practically essential for a large, diverse, continent-sized economy.
“This is one area Dan where the rhetoric about states as laboratories of democracy states is critical to the story of America is just like unambiguously correct. Let's remember a couple of things. Number one, this country has a very diverse history. Not every American lives in a state that can trace its origins to the 13 colonies. At the end of the day, many kinds of life experiences from all over the world coexist in this beautiful and extraordinary country. We believe in one nation, but at the same time, we pursue that belief in different ways. And then we've got a continent-sized economy and geography that best works by allowing states to play around with ideas a little bit and figure out on the crucial matters that so daily affect people's lives ranging from education to law enforcement to land use to have just a degree of latitude in making the democratic project succeed.”
Litigation is an important mechanism for checking executive power—lawsuits by states, businesses, and civil society actors asking courts to enforce statutory limits and constitutional boundaries remain valuable even when they do not immediately solve problems.
“I would say number one, lawsuits are very important and lots of them potentially at the end of the day. Like there are times when litigation does not solve a problem, but there are times when yes, bringing the administration back to court or anyone back to court, private sector entities saying like you promise to do X and you're not doing it. Court, can you please get involved? That is not a bad thing.”
Some observers worry that the administration has taken apart the constitutional clock and that the question of whether institutional checks will work runs through broader questions about executive power, elections, and democratic processes.
“for some other people it feels like the clock's been taken apart and the question of like does the pendulum swing back runs through bigger and broader questions about well what does executive power look like in a couple years? How do elections play into all this? You know what if we can't assume that elections are going to work the same way that they've always worked and so on.”
AI has enormous potential to make expertise and analytical insight available to billions of people in ways previously restricted to wealthy clients of lawyers, doctors, and other professionals, enabling real improvements in education, healthcare, legal services, and agriculture.
“The technology has to my mind enormous potential to make expertise and uh analytical insight available to billions of people in ways that previously was really restricted to folks who could pay for a sophisticated doctor, lawyer, etc. And I think that is likely to provide room for real improvements in human welfare around education, health care, even legal services, all kinds of other domains, agriculture.”
Universities should be placed on a more financially secure footing by asking: (1) What role can states play in supporting private universities? (2) How can the private sector support universities while maintaining their independence? (3) How can universities make themselves feel connected and accessible to a broader range of Americans?
“making sure that more Americans feel like this whole university sector really does have a connection to them, that they can send their kids there, that they can afford it, that their ideas from all backgrounds that are being discussed, that no matter what your background as an American is, that you can feel welcome there.”
If the US wants to make sure that lawfully-arriving foreign talent feels welcome and engaged in the country, it must ensure that immigrants do not perceive systematic hostility toward foreign-born people simply because they were not born in America.
“If we want to make sure that Americans who come here lawfully to be part of our talent economy feel like they're welcome and engaged, we have to make sure that there isn't some sense that folks are not welcome in this country simply because they weren't born here.”
Justice Anthony Kennedy's concept that the Constitution 'split the atom of sovereignty' between federal and state governments was a remarkable contribution to the physics of American politics and reflected the framers' remarkable achievement.
“Justice Anthony Kennedy likes to talk about how the framework split the atom of sovereignty and that was one of their remarkable contributions into the sort of physics of our politics.”
An independent media and ideas sector, including organizations like the Council on Foreign Relations, Carnegie, and Brookings Institution, plays an essential role in ensuring Americans have access to honest information and in maintaining civic capacity to respond to executive overreach.
“And then number three, we have an independent media and ideas sector. So press media organizations, ideas sector, places like CFR, Carnegie Brookings, they all play a role in making sure people have access to honest information.”
Many countries near the United States experience pervasive fear and threat as a feature of public life for both officials and ordinary citizens who participate in civic life, and Americans should not take for granted the special trust of living in a country without this fear.
“And you travel outside the US to any number of countries, including ones that are right next to us. And that nearly pervasive sense of fear and feeling threatened is just a very big reality of public life, particularly for people in public life, but also for regular citizens who just publish an op-ed or, you know, do their part to make sure their business is not entangled with corruption.”
The president claiming that he is essentially the same as the entire executive branch contradicts the constitutional text, which gives Congress the power to create offices and pass laws; the Take Care Clause does not give the president a line-item veto to refuse to spend congressionally appropriated money.
“the idea that the president is the same almost as the entire executive branch is just hard for me to square with what the text of the constitution says. Congress has the power to create offices. Congress ultimately is passing the laws. And certainly the fact that the president has to take care that the laws be faithfully executed is not the same thing as a line item veto saying, 'Oh, well, I take care of the laws faithfully executed. This money is supposed to be spent, but I don't think it really needs to be spent.'”
It is not a conservative or liberal issue to insist that the U.S. is a country of limited powers for the presidency; this principle should transcend partisan division.
“I think it's not a conservative or liberal issue to say like we live in a country of limited powers for the presidency.”
The framers of the Constitution deliberately denied the president unilateral power to decide to start a war, vesting that formal authority in Congress, because they did not want a president treating the decision to wage war lightly or as the president's own decision alone.
“for many many years, Americans have also generally understood that among the most important decisions that the framers of the constitution made is that they didn't want a president who was going to be treating the decision to start a war lightly. They didn't even want a president who was going to treat the decision to start a war as the president's own decision. It's unambiguous in the constitution that the process of starting a war at the end of the day, formally speaking, lives with Congress.”
Chief Justice William Rehnquist made it a central principle of his jurisprudence to protect state sovereignty and prevent the federal government from commandeering states and repurposing them as mere departments of the federal government.
“Justice Ranquist both as an associate justice and as chief justice made it a central plank of his juristp prudence to protect the role of the states to assure that states were not going to be commandeered by the federal government and repurposed and just sort of told you're just going to be a department of the federal government.”
The American federal system deliberately concentrates the vast majority of government spending (excluding debt service, military, and entitlements) and law enforcement responsibility at the state and local level, which serves as a structural check on expansive federal executive power.
“If you take spending and look at all government spending and take out debt service, the military and entitlements, the vast majority of spending by any government in the US is done by state and local governments.”
The president does not have constitutional authority equivalent to the entire executive branch, nor does the 'Take Care Clause' (requiring the president to faithfully execute laws) grant the president a line-item veto over congressionally appropriated spending.
“The idea that the president is the same almost as the entire executive branch is just hard for me to square with what the text of the constitution says. Congress has the power to create offices. Congress ultimately is passing the laws. And certainly the fact that the president has to take care that the laws be faithfully executed is not the same thing as a line item veto saying, 'Oh, well, I take care of the laws faithfully executed. This money is supposed to be spent, but I don't think it really needs to be spent.'”
Precedent established in Train v. New York during the Nixon years makes clear that Congress must remain central to decisions about spending authority, and this precedent should guide the Court's resolution of current spending disputes.
“We have precedent on the books. You know, the train versus New York case and the Nixon years that make me feel like it's pretty clear that you got to keep Congress front and center on those spending issues.”
The principle that the president operates under limited powers—not unlimited Article II authority—is not a conservative or liberal issue but a fundamental feature of American constitutional law that has bipartisan support.
“I think it's not a conservative or liberal issue to say like we live in a country of limited powers for the presidency.”
America's special power is its capacity to improve itself continuously and create a more perfect union, and this capacity depends on maintaining the structures that allow peaceful disagreement and institutional check on power.
“A great power our country has is the power to improve ourselves constantly to create a more perfect union to build a more inclusive and effective America to build an America that is more able to provide its promise to more people.”
Lawsuits are important and potentially necessary; bringing the administration or any entity back to court when promises are broken or authorities are exceeded is not a bad thing and can help restore compliance with law.
“lawsuits are very important and lots of them potentially at the end of the day. Like there are times when litigation does not solve a problem, but there are times when yes, bringing the administration back to court or anyone back to court, private sector entities saying like you promise to do X and you're not doing it. Court, can you please get involved? That is not a bad thing.”
Debates between governors and the federal government over policy authority are a natural and expected feature of the constitutional design, and such dynamics are healthy for the system.
“It feels to me like that naturally now is playing out as a set of arguments between governors and the federal government that are part of what the design of our system allows for and expects in some ways.”
AI creativity cuts both ways: it enables remarkable breakthroughs and applications, but it also means AI systems can behave in unexpected ways that humans do not fully anticipate or understand.
“And that cuts both ways. Obviously, that's an enormously enabling thing. We are creating a new kind of intelligence that can be creative to my mind, but it also means it can behave in ways that we don't expect.”
The fact that state legislators have been murdered and public figures like Charlie Kirk have been killed creates legitimate worry about political violence trend among those in public life, making the violence risk scenario credible.
“I know enough people who are either in elected office or public commentators who watch the murders of the state legislators in Minnesota or Charlie Kirk's killing in Utah and and are worried about that kind of violence which uh which makes me concerned about the kind of scenario you're laying out.”
AI poses risks including enabling malicious behavior, cyber exploits, potential development of biological weapons, and complication of governance, collective action, diplomacy, and international security.
“it's hard for me to imagine that you can have all those benefits and not also face some risks that come from having these models enable behavior that is malicious. cyber exploits, for example, possibly the development of biological weapons in some settings, but also that maybe just complicates uh governance and complicates collective action among people, complicates diplomacy, complicates international security.”
The LA Declaration, which the previous administration worked on with Colombia, Central America, and other countries, aimed to get migrants to stay in their origin or transit countries rather than using them as stepping stones to the US.
“I note the LA Declaration, which is something the previous administration worked on to get countries like Colombia and countries in Central America and others to be part of a process where migrants stay in the countries that they're in rather than having them effectively use those countries as transit points to get to the US.”
Congress is currently experiencing an erosion of norms and restraint that historically balanced partisan pushes—there is no longer a sense that political opponents deserve a modicum of respect or that parties will work across divides on transpartisan projects.
“For all the disagreement that has to be part of the American experiment and project like about taxes, about foreign policy, about technology policy and so on. You also hope and expect there's going to be some commitment to working across divides sometimes on partisan projects that then become transpartisan and even bipartisan. And you also expect that when people are thinking about gaming out their strategies, how it is, for example, that Congress might simply not even give a nominee of a president for the Supreme Court like a hearing, an up or down vote, that there's always been, not always, but there's long been when there's been a period of productive congressional activity, a sense that it's not just the written law in the constitution, but a set of norms, an understanding about how you need to treat the opposition with it. modicum of respect so that that can balance the natural partisan urges and pushes. That's largely gone from Congress right now.”
No university, even the most sophisticated and innovative research powerhouses, is perfect, and universities face legitimate issues to work on seriously including affordability and ensuring they are vibrant places where different ideas are accepted and warmly welcomed.
“no university, not even the most sophisticated, most innovative, most dynamic research powerhouses are perfect. And to my mind, there are issues that the university sector has to work on seriously. affordability. We don't want Americans priced out of a great university education, which is the right path for many Americans, maybe not all Americans. Two, uh we need to make sure that universities are vibrant places where different ideas are accepted and warmly welcomed.”
Congress is designed to represent many different interests, voices, and perspectives, which means it rarely acts with complete coherence, but this is a feature of democratic representation rather than a flaw.
“Congress is sort of designed to represent so many different interests, voices, perspectives. It it rarely acts with sort of like beautiful coherence.”
Queyroz clearly believes states should have more power devolved from the federal government, which would improve both American democracy and America's role in the world.
“Yes. is the short unambiguous and clear answer. It's good to be clear about it. Absolutely I do.”
The International Emergency Economic Powers Act has broader powers that it confers on the president than other statutes Congress has enacted, but it still contains constraints on when the president can act; the question is whether statutory language that specifies when the president can do something actually limits the president or just tells the world when the president can activate those authorities.
“if there are statutory provisions that talk about when the president can do something, does that actually limit the president or does it just tell uh the world that the president can just activate those authorities like whenever the president feels like it?”
Federalism—the distribution of power between federal government and states—is a foundational check on executive power; states retain law enforcement authority, and the vast majority of government spending (excluding debt service, military, and entitlements) is done by state and local governments.
“the country is a federation. At the end of the day, we have an enormously powerful tradition balancing the power of the federal government with the power of the states...If you take spending and look at all government spending and take out debt service, the military and entitlements, the vast majority of spending by any government in the US is done by state and local governments.”
Precedent from Lincoln v. New York and the Nixon-era case Train v. New York makes it pretty clear that Congress must be kept front and center on spending issues; courts will likely reach a better constitutional place on spending disputes.
“We have precedent on the books...the train versus New York case and the Nixon years that make me feel like it's pretty clear that you got to keep Congress front and center on those spending issues.”
As AI models become less constrained by commercial imperatives to serve multiple purposes and instead become more specialized, they will demonstrate creativity and capabilities that are not apparent in current multi-purpose models.
“particularly I think as the models evolve and are less constrained by the uh the current commercial imperative at least that was felt earlier to make the same model effectively useful for a thousand or a million different things and instead to create more specialized models. You can kind of get at this a little bit with different prompting strategies, but all that is going to make people understand that whatever else we think are limitations in these technologies, even under the current paradigm of technology, there's not a lack of creativity there.”
The Supreme Court has shown reluctance to use its full reasoning power on emergency docket decisions, instead issuing rulings without detailed opinions explaining the constitutional reasoning, which creates uncertainty about the ultimate boundaries of executive power.
“I have to acknowledge that for some other people it feels like the clock's been taken apart and the question of like does the pendulum swing back runs through bigger and broader questions about well what does executive power look like in a couple years? How do elections play into all this? You know what if we can't assume that elections are going to work the same way that they've always worked and so on. And here the point I'd make is I think there are legitimate questions about whether for example the Supreme Court is relying too much on the emergency docket rather than giving opinions that get into why exactly they're deciding something and what the ultimate question is and how they're ruling on it.”
Foundation models and generative AI technologies are trained on vast corpora of existing text and data, but this does not mean they can only function as glorified web search—they can perform genuine inference and creative synthesis that goes beyond their training data.
“They're trained on a giant corpus of existing words of articles that you and I have written of uh you know blog posts of you know endless um quora queries and so on. And at the end of the day how can it do anything that different from simply scraping that data and serving as a kind of glorified web search? First of all, I think the technology we're now dealing with, which involves models that are, yes, pre-trained, but that also do inference time reasoning, already transcends that paradigm quite a bit.”
State officials in Arizona, Georgia, and Michigan have been responsible in protecting electoral integrity and deserve recognition for doing so despite partisan pressure.
“I can point to state officials on either party side that have been very responsible in trying to safeguard or protect that in places like Arizona, in places like Georgia, in places like Michigan.”
Immigration crackdowns create three distinct questions: (1) What are we trying to accomplish? (2) Who else is being affected, including Americans and American families? (3) What is the proper balance of law enforcement priorities between immigration enforcement and other strategic goals like drug trafficking and national security?
“I think it it interacts with these issues and there are sort of three questions to my mind that come from that kind of crackdown. The first one is what is it that are we really trying to accomplish? ... Second, who else is being affected? Are the Americans being affected? Are their American families being affected? And then third is the question of what is the proper balance and set of priorities for the federal government?”
The irony of success is that when people experience prosperity and take it for granted, they stop thinking about the intricate ways the ecosystem that produced it must be continuously supported and protected.
“do you know the irony of success sometimes, Dan, is that when people experience it and begin to take it for granted, they stop to think about all the intricate ways in which that ecosystem has to be supported and cherished and protected.”
Americans expect that the executive branch works in good faith, which means taking seriously that actions are about more than short-term policy impact; it means recognizing that government officials are stewards and fiduciaries who must hand off the country in better shape than they received it.
“Americans expect that the executive branch works in good faith. What does it mean to act in good faith? I think it means to take seriously that any action you take is about more than just the short-term policy impact of politics. It's about safeguarding the trust that any of us who's ever served in government, I know felt or should feel that we are stewards. We're fiduciaries for a country and we have to hand it off in better shape than we got it.”
Americans have a special responsibility to protect democratic and institutional trust because when one travels outside the U.S. to many countries, a pervasive sense of fear and threat is a reality of public life, particularly for public officials and citizens who publish op-eds or take anti-corruption stands.
“we travel outside the US to any number of countries, including ones that are right next to us. And that nearly pervasive sense of fear and feeling threatened is just a very big reality of public life, particularly for people in public life, but also for regular citizens who just publish an op-ed or, you know, do their part to make sure their business is not entangled with corruption. And I think as Americans, we have a giant responsibility not to be ignorant about that special trust we have in keeping at bay, I think, our worst impulses”
AI models trained on a giant corpus of existing words, articles, and web content can transcend simple data-scraping paradigms, particularly when they involve inference-time reasoning; increases in mathematical abilities demonstrate this transcendence.
“I think the technology we're now dealing with, which involves models that are, yes, pre-trained, but that also do inference time reasoning, already transcends that paradigm quite a bit. You can particularly see it in the increases in mathematical abilities.”
If the U.S. wants to ensure that Americans who come here lawfully to participate in the talent economy feel welcome, the country must ensure there is no sense that people are unwelcome simply for not being born in America.
“if we want to make sure that Americans who come here lawfully to be part of our talent economy feel like they're welcome and engaged, we have to make sure that there isn't some sense that folks are not welcome in this country simply because they weren't born here.”
Just as no diplomatic strategy can be divorced from economics and financial markets (stocks, bonds, sanctions), in the future there will be no diplomacy that isn't accompanied by a tech strategy involving AI.
“nobody could reasonably argue in the pages of foreign affairs that you can have a diplomatic strategy that's divorced from economics. You can just not think about what the stock market will do, what the bond market will do, or what sanctions a country might impose and still have a good diplomatic strategy. I think in the same way there will be no diplomacy that isn't accompanied by a tech strategy in effect.”
Political violence and fear permeating civil society corrode and erode it; even without large-scale actual violence, if judges, legislators, and citizens speaking out feel fear, that undermines civil society and makes people abandon peaceful, law-bound mechanisms for public security and dispute resolution.
“what truly makes a society vulnerable and corroded and corrosive is political violence and the fear that can permeate when you begin to see an uptick in political violence. So even if you don't actually have so much violence, if you start to get judges, state legislators, even just, you know, private citizens who speak out in conversations online to feel fear. That's not good for civil society. And it also can make people feel like the point of investing in peaceful lawbound mechanisms for public security and for dispute resolution is like not worth it.”
Federalism is naturally playing out as arguments between governors and the federal government as part of what the system's design allows for and expects, and state and federal courts play a role in arbitrating these disputes alongside elected officials' decisions about their constituencies.
“it feels to me like that naturally now is playing out as a set of arguments between governors and the federal government that are part of what the design of our system allows for and expects in some ways.”
A responsible leader contemplating military intervention must think hard about unintended consequences and effects on other countries in the region vital to U.S. interests, such as Brazil and Colombia, before deciding to wage war.
“when one thinks about the decision to engage in military action that can lead to wars, the most serious decision that any president can make. Then that's when it's particularly incumbent on a president and the president's advisers to think what are the unintended consequences how does this affect the other countries in the region Brazil Colombia countries that are vital to our interests”
Vice President JD Vance has publicly warned that judges aren't allowed to control the executive's legitimate power; there is a distinction between such public pressure and the administration actually ignoring an explicit, unambiguous court decision.
“It is one thing for Vice President JD Vance to publicly warn that quote, 'Judges aren't allowed to control the executives's legitimate power, but quite another for the president to ignore an explicit, unambiguous decision from a court.”
Democracies work differently than other forms of government; ensuring that democracies stay at the frontier of AI technology means that democratic forms of governance will remain at the forefront as the world works through implications of AI breakthroughs.
“A major goal of the US should be to be the place that is at the frontier of this technology for two reasons. One of them goes back to your point about safety and risk. Point number one is that democracies work differently than other kinds of countries...democracies have not only technological and military power, but economic might different even in non-democracies. So staying at the frontier of AI means that democratic forms of government will be at the four as we work through what is the world do with these breakthroughs.”
Free and fair elections in America are fundamentally a state responsibility, and their integrity depends on state officials exercising restraint rather than maximizing partisan advantage, which is an eroding 'muscle memory.'
“free and fair elections in America are first and foremost a state responsibility and depend on the kind of restraint I'm talking about and I can point to state officials on either party side that have been very responsible in trying to safeguard or protect that in places like Arizona, in places like Georgia, in places like Michigan. So, I do worry about eroding that muscle memory that allows us to sustain that.”
The more insidious constitutional threat is incremental consolidation through a cloud of uncertainty created by ambiguous court decisions, unclear administration compliance, and unclear Supreme Court response, all of which can be exploited to gradually undermine rule of law.
“the more insidious challenge is where a set of constitutional decisions are a little ambiguous they're not taken on directly but meanwhile a consolidation's happening behind the scenes with a whole set of actions that at the trial court and appellet court level are creating just a cloud of uncertainty both because the decisions are not super clear, what the Supreme Court might do is not super clear, the administration's broader compliance is not super clear. And that cloud of uncertainty I think can be exploited.”
There is an irony of success: when people experience it and take it for granted, they stop thinking about all the intricate ways the ecosystem supporting that success must be supported and cherished.
“do you know the irony of success sometimes, Dan, is that when people experience it and begin to take it for granted, they stop to think about all the intricate ways in which that ecosystem has to be supported and cherished and protected.”
Acute constitutional crises would be ironically easier to deal with than insidious ones because they involve clear confrontation and honesty; the more dangerous scenario is incremental consolidation of power through ambiguous legal decisions that create uncertainty while actual compliance remains unclear.
“the most acute kind of crisis might misleadingly end up or ironically end up being a little bit easier to deal with because it so clearly calls the question...the more insidious challenge is where a set of constitutional decisions are a little ambiguous they're not taken on directly but meanwhile a consolidation's happening behind the scenes with a whole set of actions that at the trial court and appellet court level are creating just a cloud of uncertainty...And that cloud of uncertainty I think can be exploited.”
A key concern is what basic pattern will emerge for international economic relationships going forward: will there be repeated explosions and ruptures every 18 months, two years, or five years, and what kind of predictability does this create for American business, which depends on being innovative and dynamic with technology, services, and talent?
“questions that come up in my mind include what is the basic pattern going forward now? Are we going to have these explosions and ruptures in international relationships every 18 months, every two years, every 3 years, every 5 years? Like when and how? What kind of predictability does that create for the American business model which is very much about being innovative and dynamic with our technology, our services, our people and their talents.”
Courts lack independent enforcement power (no standing military or police force to deploy), move slowly, and are constrained to decide cases one at a time, but despite these limitations, courts retain significant moral, ethical, and symbolic authority that matters to American business, the general public, and the international community.
“It's true that courts in some respects seem like what Alexander Bickl once called the least dangerous branch. They don't have a standing military. They don't have a giant police force they can deploy. They're supposed to decide things one case at a time. But it's not by accident that so many Americans have come to care deeply about what a Supreme Court says and does. And by the way, as I point out in the piece, when you have a particularly conservative Supreme Court, nobody can argue the Supreme Court isn't filled with jurists that have been chosen by uh Republicans in some cases.”
The Supreme Court's reliance on emergency dockets rather than issuing full opinions with reasoned explanation about why cases are decided and how they are being ruled on is problematic, because it creates uncertainty about the Court's ultimate reasoning and fails to give the public and lower courts clear guidance.
“I think there are legitimate questions about whether for example the Supreme Court is relying too much on the emergency docket rather than giving opinions that get into why exactly they're deciding something and what the ultimate question is and how they're ruling on it.”
The immigration crackdown raises three key questions: (1) what are we trying to accomplish; (2) who else is being affected, including American families; and (3) what is the proper balance of law enforcement priorities—does the crackdown support or undermine broader strategic goals like targeting drug trafficking or national security threats?
“there are sort of three questions to my mind that come from that kind of crackdown. The first one is what is it that are we really trying to accomplish?...Second, who else is being affected? Are the Americans being affected?...And then third is the question of what is the proper balance and set of priorities for the federal government?”
America is big and good enough to avoid the worst scenarios where court decisions are followed but increasingly irrelevant, though protecting the country requires specific actions.
“America is sort of big and good enough to avoid the worst of those scenarios, which is that increasingly court decisions are sort of followed but irrelevant.”
A full-fledged constitutional showdown between the branches would look like the administration publicly asserting that it believes courts have no bearing on executive power and explicitly declaring its intention to ignore Supreme Court orders.
“It would be cander on their part to say, you know what, we think the court should do its thing and we're going to do our thing and we don't think the court has the Supreme Court here has any bearing on the outcome of this case, even this particular specific case, let alone like cases, and we're just going to do our thing because we think we are the ultimate decider when it comes to executive power.”
AI has enormous potential to make expertise and analytical insight available to billions of people in ways previously restricted to those who could pay for sophisticated professionals (doctors, lawyers); this could improve human welfare in education, healthcare, legal services, and agriculture.
“the technology has to my mind enormous potential to make expertise and uh analytical insight available to billions of people in ways that previously was really restricted to folks who could pay for a sophisticated doctor, lawyer, etc. And I think that is likely to provide room for real improvements in human welfare around education, health care, even legal services, all kinds of other domains, agriculture.”
Some observers voice concern that any effort to govern aspects of AI by providing guard rails (trust-but-verify approaches, asking companies to test their technology and be transparent about responsible scaling) would limit America's ability to be at the frontier; Quayle is not persuaded this concern is justified.
“I think we've seen some folks voice the concern that if there's any effort any move towards governing some aspects of the technology by just trying to provide a kind of middle-of the road trust but verify kind of approach to guard rails asking companies well what have you done to at least test your technology can you be transparent about your overall responsible scaling plan that that would somehow limit America's ability to be at the frontier I'm not persuaded”
The administration has used legal channels to gradually neutralize constraints on executive power by using statutes like the 1798 Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelan migrants to El Salvador, starting with unpopular targets like immigrants from dangerous countries, establishing precedent for expansive interpretation of executive authority.
“Consider a scenario in which the administration sits out to consolidate power more incrementally. It might begin by using legal channels to gradually neutralize constraints on executive power, building on, say, its use of the 1798 Alien Enemies Act to port Venezuelan migrants to El Salvador. It can then advance expansive interpretations of executive privilege or national security authority through actions that initially involve unpopular targets such as immigrants from countries considered dangerous or allegedly affiliated with violent gangs.”
There is a natural expectation in American politics that when there is productive congressional activity, there exists a set of norms and understanding about treating the opposition with modicum of respect; this norm is largely absent from Congress right now.
“there's long been when there's been a period of productive congressional activity, a sense that it's not just the written law in the constitution, but a set of norms, an understanding about how you need to treat the opposition with it. modicum of respect so that that can balance the natural partisan urges and pushes. That's largely gone from Congress right now.”
Even a conservative Supreme Court filled with Republican-appointed justices is not a court that will simply rubber-stamp executive power; reading their opinions suggests they will resist some executive overreach.
“when you have a particularly conservative Supreme Court, nobody can argue the Supreme Court isn't filled with jurists that have been chosen by uh Republicans in some cases. And as a judge, I can tell you this. You shed your any partisan background when you get onto the court. But the point is to the extent you can kind of read the tea leaves, read the opinions, get a sense for where the court is, you know, this is not a court that is not conservative if I can put it that way.”
As AI models evolve and become less constrained by the commercial imperative to be useful for a thousand different things, moving instead to more specialized models, people will increasingly understand that while limitations may exist, there is genuine creativity in these technologies, which cuts both ways—enabling and unpredictable.
“particularly I think as the models evolve and are less constrained by the uh the current commercial imperative at least that was felt earlier to make the same model effectively useful for a thousand or a million different things and instead to create more specialized models...all that is going to make people understand that whatever else we think are limitations in these technologies, even under the current paradigm of technology, there's not a lack of creativity there. And that cuts both ways. Obviously, that's an enormously enabling thing. We are creating a new kind of intelligence that can be creative to my mind, but it also means it can behave in ways that we don't expect.”
The immigration crackdown presents an acute threat to the research ecosystem by discouraging foreign students and talented workers from wanting to come to or stay in the United States, reducing the ability to attract extraordinary talent that collaborates with Americans in graduate schools and companies.
“To what extent does the immigration crackdown present a kind of acute threat to that in the medium-term? I think it it interacts with these issues”
American prosperity over the last 50 years has depended on the country's understanding that American well-being required winning the Cold War, building international cooperation with allies like South Korea and Japan, and maintaining a robust global economy that buys American products and services.
“prosperity that has been achieved in America...where lives are better now than they were 50 years ago, by a good long margin. I believe that that prosperity has depended to some degree on the way the country has understood that the well-being of Americans depended on winning cold war that it depended on building relationships of international cooperation with allies abroad places like South Korea and Japan that it depended on building a robust global economy that would buy American products and services”
The disruption in international trade patterns and relationships caused by Trump's tariff policies may have lasting negative effects that will go far beyond any trade deal that does or does not happen with China.
“I have been concerned about how much the disruption in those patterns is going to leave a lasting effect that is going to go way beyond any trade deal that does or doesn't happen with China in the next few days.”
Calling out political violence from whoever it comes from and being thoughtful about pushback against rhetoric that targets judges or suggests they deserve harm is a very American thing and part of what will enable the country to secure the full promise of America.
“calling out political violence, no matter who it comes from, and also being quite thoughtful and clear about pushing back on people who start to use loose rhetoric to target judges or to suggest that they deserve x, y, or z thing. It's a very American thing to protect those structures because that in the end is part of what will enable us to secure the full promise of America.”
An independent media and ideas sector (press, media organizations, think tanks like CFR, Carnegie, Brookings) plays a crucial role in ensuring that people have access to honest information and can respond to government actions that raise concerns.
“we have an independent media and ideas sector. So press media organizations, ideas sector, places like CFR, Carnegie Brookings, they all play a role in making sure people have access to honest information.”
The misunderstanding that AI cannot be creative because it was trained on existing data misapprehends the relationship between knowledge and intelligence; humans begin with absorbed knowledge but generate creative and fundamentally new ideas, and similarly, AI models enabled by vast knowledge bases can be genuinely creative.
“I think that misapprehends the relationship between knowledge and intelligence. And here I don't mean to suggest that every brain works the same or that we even fully understand the human brain. But it would surely be false to assume that because the human brain certainly begins with a corpus of knowledge that we absorb that we ourselves don't end up being creative and come up with sometimes just fundamentally new ideas. And I think the whether you call it synthetic data or something else at the end of the day what all that knowledge enables either in artificial or in natural intelligence can be genuinely creative.”
Over the first eight months of Trump's second term, courts have been too solicitous of executive branch arguments that the president's interests outweigh other interests in interim periods, particularly on spending issues.
“the court's been a little bit too solicitous to the arguments from the executive branch that the president's interests outweigh other interests in the interim period.”
The Court is likely to move through three phases: first, arguments and interim rulings creating uncertainty; second, clear Supreme Court decisions (possibly 5-4 or 6-3); and third, responses from governors, state attorneys general, business, civil society, media, and rank-and-file Americans—and it is hard to imagine five Supreme Court votes supporting some of the administration's spending authority claims.
“Let me just look ahead, right? So like phase one of all this is we argue about it. There are some court cases. There are some interim rulings and people are trying to figure out what is actually going on. Phase two is the court has to step up to the plate and make some clear decisions. And sometimes to just be honest, I think it's hard for me to imagine that there are five votes that would be totally willing to embrace some of what the administration is doing on spending, for example, which is a clear congressional area of authority. Phase three is going to be how the country, governors, state attorneys general, business, civil society, the media, rank and file Americans respond to all that picture.”
Free and fair elections in America are first and foremost a state responsibility and depend on state officials exercising restraint rather than maximizing partisan advantage; responsible state officials in Arizona, Georgia, and Michigan have protected this.
“free and fair elections in America are first and foremost a state responsibility and depend on the kind of restraint I'm talking about and I can point to state officials on either party side that have been very responsible in trying to safeguard or protect that in places like Arizona, in places like Georgia, in places like Michigan.”
Since 1960s-1970s, there has been a clear pattern in American immigration policy: in order to get Americans to believe that the immigration system is working, there must be a degree of order in the process, including action at the border and coordination with other countries.
“in the long history of American immigration policy, it's a pretty clear pattern. Particularly, I would say from the 1960s and '7s onward that in order to get Americans to believe that the system is working, you have to hold the line and be somewhat able to show a degree of order in the process.”
The LA Declaration and prior administration efforts to get countries like Colombia and Central American nations to keep migrants in their own countries rather than serving as transit points represent a productive approach to regional migration management.
“I note the LA Declaration, which is something the previous administration worked on to get countries like Colombia and countries in Central America and others to be part of a process where migrants stay in the countries that they're in rather than having them effectively use those countries as transit points to get to the US.”
Governor Andrew Cuomo made powerful statements after Charlie Kirk's killing in Utah emphasizing the importance of dialogue and peaceful disagreement on college campuses, modeling the kind of leadership needed to prevent political violence.
“Governor Nuomo after the very tragic killing of Charlie Kirk made a powerful statement about the importance of peace and believing in the sort of dialogue and disagreement that can come to college campuses with people like Charlie Kirk and how awful it was that we are risking descending into real political violence sometimes.”
There was a shift in AI policy discourse around late 2023 from focused discussions about guard rails and risks to an accelerationist mode driven by perceived U.S.-China competition, some of which is aligned with administration policy changes.
“there was a period after I don't know probably in late 2023 after the initial release of chat GBT when there was a lot of discussion of putting guard rails on AI and you know looking at risks and regulation in in pretty focused ways is I think it's fair to say that over the last year or two, we've shifted to a much more kind of accelerationist mode. Some of that is driven by the sense that there's a a race between the United States and China”
Governor Spencer Cox of Utah's work modeling productive disagreement and Governor Andrew Cuomo's powerful statements about the importance of dialogue and rejecting political violence demonstrate how governors can make clear statements on behalf of the American project that provide hope.
“the work that Governor Spencer Cox is doing in Utah to highlight the need for governors and state officials to model productive disagreement is a powerful contribution to the country. I'll also just note Governor Nuomo after the very tragic killing of Charlie Kirk made a powerful statement about the importance of peace and believing in the sort of dialogue and disagreement that can come to college campuses”
Justice Anthony Kennedy's concept that the Constitution's federalism framework 'split the atom of sovereignty,' dividing it between federal and state authorities, represents a remarkable contribution to understanding American constitutional physics and power distribution.
“Justice Anthony Kennedy likes to talk about how the framework split the atom of sovereignty and that was one of their remarkable contributions into the sort of physics of our politics.”
The Maduro regime in Venezuela has treated its own people unfairly and brutally, disrespected democratic decisions, and engaged in irresponsible conduct abroad.
“The Maduro regime is in many ways an abomination. It's treated its own people unfairly and brutally. It's not engaged in responsible conduct abroad. It's uh not respected, its own people, and their own democratic decisions.”
Chief Justice William Rehnquist made protection of state power against federal commandeering a central plank of his jurisprudence, ensuring states retained separate power and sovereignty rather than becoming mere departments of the federal government.
“Justice Ranquist both as an associate justice and as chief justice made it a central plank of his juristp prudence to protect the role of the states to assure that states were not going to be commandeered by the federal government and repurposed and just sort of told you're just going to be a department of the federal government.”
The last several months have featured dense action and movement with military deployments, treatment of non-citizen residents, dismantling of agencies, and emergency docket cases raising constitutional questions.
“We could talk for hours about even one single case. I mean, that gives you a sense of how dense with action and movement and fact patterns that raise concerns just the last few months have been, right? The military deployments. You've got questions involving the treatment of people who are resident in the US but who are not American and like where do the constitutional rights end. There are questions about the dismantling of whole agencies.”
Trump has used the International Emergency Economic Powers Act as basis for at least some of his tariffs.
“Trump, just to be clear, has used AIPA as the basis for at least some of his tariffs at this point.”
Queyranne and Jenna Bedner co-wrote a 2022 Foreign Affairs piece examining how federalism can be both a strength and a weakness for the U.S., with risks of fracture and dissension as the federal-state balance shifts.
“You and Jenna Bedner wrote a fascinating piece in foreign affairs in 2022 I believe about this shifting dynamic between states and federal government. This piece at any rate you know it argues that federalism has been and can be a strength for the United States. It can also be a risk and a weakness.”
The Maduro regime in Venezuela is an abomination that has treated its people unfairly and brutally, not respected democratic decisions, and not engaged in responsible conduct abroad.
“The Maduro regime is in many ways an abomination. It's treated its own people unfairly and brutally. It's not engaged in responsible conduct abroad. It's uh not respected, its own people, and their own democratic decisions.”