What this covers

Yuval Levin traces the origins of the modern political Left-Right divide to an eighteenth-century intellectual clash between Edmund Burke and Thomas Paine. Both were liberals committed to rights and property within a framework of classical liberalism, yet they disagreed fundamentally on whether liberalism represented a break from the past or its fulfillment. In this conversation with Russ Roberts, Levin argues that their disagreement established two recurring political dispositions that persist in contemporary debates over the welfare state, markets, and redistribution—even as the surface positions of Left and Right have seemingly reversed.

Levin examines how Burke's approach rested on epistemic humility: the belief that institutions contain tacit knowledge exceeding what any individual can rationally grasp, and that reform should proceed incrementally, building on what works rather than attempting radical reconstruction. Paine, by contrast, embraced Politics as Applied Principle—the conviction that politics must begin from first principles of human equality and liberty, discarding historical accretions that contradict them. The discussion spans Burke's debt to Adam Smith, Paine's surprising role as an architect of the welfare state through Lockean state of nature reasoning, and how Radical Individualism Leads to Statism. Levin shows that contemporary conservatism remains fundamentally Burkean in its skepticism of wholesale transformation, even when arguing for institutional change, while modern progressivism continues Paine's impulse toward rational reconstruction—an argument that becomes clearer when examining how Mediating Institutions Between Individual and State function differently under each vision.

Sharpest takeaway

Levin argues that the modern Left/Right divide originates in the Burke-Paine debate of the 1700s: Paine's rationalist, principle-first politics of breaking from the past versus Burke's evolutionary, tradition-respecting politics of building on the best of what exists — and that today's conservatism remains fundamentally Burkean even when it argues for change.

  • Burke and Paine were both liberals who shared belief in rights and property but differed on whether liberalism is a break from tradition (Paine) or its achievement (Burke).
  • Burke's view rests on the limits of human knowledge and a Hayekian sense that institutions contain more wisdom than any individual can rationally grasp.
  • Contemporary debates over the welfare state, redistribution, and markets recapitulate these two dispositions, even though the Right now argues for transformation and the Left for preservation.

The argument · threads9 threads · 38 claims
0.85

The Burke-Paine divide arises from opposite baseline expectations about human capacity and the acceptability of the status quo.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Although one cannot draw a genealogical line from the 18th century to today, the two dispositions toward politics — gratitude-and-skepticism versus outrage-at-injustice — arise almost inevitably in any free society like ours, and Burke and Paine simply articulate those recurring dispositions more clearly than almost anyone.

    “the two dispositions to politics arise almost inevitably in a free society like ours, and that Burke and Paine articulate those dispositions more clearly than almost anybody.”

  • The two men's politics flow from opposite baseline expectations: Paine begins from very high expectations of human possibility — believing we can overcome our faults so the status quo is unacceptable — while Burke begins from low expectations, seeing humans as fallen and broken and being surprised anything works, so that whatever does work must be valued and built upon rather than discarded.

    “Paine begins from very high expectations of human possibilities... Burke begins from much lower expectations. He says human creatures are fallen creatures; we are very broken; and in fact he is surprised that anything works in society. And so when anything does work, we have to value it.”

  • A fundamental distinction between the two visions of government is that all of Paine's metaphors are metaphors of emotion and forward motion — a direction we must constantly progress toward — whereas Burke's metaphors are metaphors of space: government's purpose is to build a space for society to thrive, giving people room to build the lives they want rather than pushing them into the right grooves, and this difference still distinguishes Left and Right.

    “all of Paine's metaphors are metaphors of emotion. There's a sense of 'that's where we have to go and we need to progress in that direction constantly.' Burke's metaphors are metaphors of space. He thought of government in terms of building a space for society to thrive.”

  • On the surface the sides appear to have switched — conservatives now want to transform governing institutions while liberals protect every inch of the welfare state — but this is only a second-order argument about change: the Right still begins, as Burke did, in gratitude for the good and skepticism about rebuilding from scratch, and the entitlement system liberals defend is itself an instrument of the Progressive, technocratic vision Paine would recognize.

    “I do think we sometimes see now Conservatives very eager to transform out governing institutions in very profound ways, and we find Liberals very protective of every last inch of the welfare state. But I think that that is a kind of second-order argument about politically change.”

  • Neither Burke nor Paine — nor Adam Smith — foresaw the scale of the Industrial Revolution, which was already beginning in Britain as they wrote; because they could not anticipate how transformative it would become, the parts of their disagreement that concern the scale and character of the economy and what a market economy looks like sound least contemporary today.

    “the striking thing about it is that they did not foresee the Industrial Revolution, which was in some ways already beginning. Especially in Britain, in the time they were writing. But they couldn't see the scale that it was about to reach.”

  • Burke's response to Paine's apparent moral high ground is that morality is not a simple set of abstract rules applied directly to life but must speak to the realities and complexities of human experience; Burke claimed the high ground by arguing his way of life has proven in practice to be better for the weak, poor, and vulnerable, so Paine's abstract, simple Quaker-derived rule of always preferring the weak over the strong, while it may guide an individual life, is not a workable way to think about how a whole society should function.

    “Burke's response to that is basically that morality is not as simple as it seems. It's not just a set of abstract rules that you then apply directly to life. Morality has to speak to the realities and the complexities of the human experience.”

0.80

Burke grounds conservatism in skepticism about human knowledge and reliance on evolved institutions that contain more wisdom than any individual possesses.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Edmund Burke became a father of modern conservatism not because he opposed progress but because he believed progress comes from building on the best of a country's traditions and existing institutions, rooted in skepticism about the limits of human power and knowledge.

    “He's been thought of as one of the fathers of modern conservatism, because of his emphasis on generational continuity, on gradualism, on respect for tradition and for existing institutions. And really because of his skepticism about human power and human knowledge.”

  • Burke argued that statesmen should approach society as physicians rather than engineers: just as doctors lack an exact definition of health and don't understand everything about the body but can recognize sickness and health and work to turn one into the other, reformers should improve institutions incrementally without claiming complete rational knowledge of how they work.

    “we should approach it, he says at one time, as physicians rather than as engineers”

  • Burke held a distinctly modern sense of tradition: not that the past was better and should be clung to, but that the present is better because history is a process of gradual evolution in which societies learn from mistakes, keep what works, and drop what doesn't — so existing institutions contain more knowledge than any individual can rationally possess and should be improved at the margins rather than overhauled.

    “The present is better than the past, but it's better because history has been a process of gradual evolution, and what evolution really means in this historical sense just as in the biological sense is that you learn from mistakes. You've tried things, you keep what's working and you drop what's not working.”

  • Burke was a reformer rather than a defender of the status quo — he worked to restrain the King's power, supported the mistreated Americans, reformed British criminal law and imperial practices, opposed the mistreatment of India's natives, protected Irish Catholics, and was an early opponent of slavery — but he was a particular kind of reformer who believed improvement must build on the system to protect its best parts, since letting problems fester invites radicals to overthrow what is good.

    “He's been thought of as one of the fathers of modern conservatism, because of his emphasis on generational continuity, on gradualism, on respect for tradition and for existing institutions. And really because of his skepticism about human power and human knowledge.”

  • Burke feared the French were breaking with their own traditions and trying to start from scratch in the most radical way, which he argued could only lead to totalitarianism — there are passages in his writing that eerily predict the rise of a Napoleon-type military dictator who would use the Revolution's circumstances to undermine the Revolution's own principles.

    “there are passages in Burke's writing on France that really eerily predict the rise of a Napoleon-type figure, of a military dictator who would use the circumstances created by the Revolution to undermine all of the principles of Revolution.”

0.70

Paine grounds progressivism in extraordinary faith in human reason and belief that politics must be built from scratch on universal abstract principles.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Thomas Paine became one of the faces of late-18th-century radicalism and a father of modern progressivism through his emphasis on liberating the individual from the restraints of tradition, his extraordinary faith in human reason, and his desire to break with the past and build social institutions from scratch on proper foundations.

    “He started as one of the Fathers of modern Progressivism or of the modern Left because of his emphasis on, especially on liberating the individual from the restraints of tradition, the authority of the past.”

  • Paine believed politics is applied principle — it must start from the right philosophical principles (human equality and liberty as individuals) and apply them absolutely, because those principles are the natural truth about human beings; deviations from them throughout history explain all war and poverty, and modern Enlightenment science of politics finally lets us see the right principles and build politics on them by throwing off the past.

    “Paine believes that ultimately that politics is applied principle, and so that it has to start from the right philosophical principles, and it has to apply them absolutely, because those principles are the natural truth about human beings”

  • The French Revolution was far more radical than the American, advocating a complete break with the past in pursuit of a new Enlightenment politics that would escape all the burdens of history and find a path beyond war, beyond poverty, and even beyond politics itself — a maximalist expression of Enlightenment Liberalism.

    “They understood themselves to be advocating for a new enlightenment politics that would allow us to escape all of the burdens of the past and find a path beyond war, beyond poverty--really, beyond politics.”

0.61

Both Burke and Paine were classical liberals committed to free society and rights, yet arrived there from opposite starting points within shared liberal consensus.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Burke and Paine were both liberals who believed in a free society, democratic elements, rights, and especially property rights — a classical liberalism — but they arrived at it from opposite places, which is why their debate illuminates how the modern Left/Right divide consists of profound disagreements 'between the 40-yard lines' of a shared liberal consensus.

    “what you see in them are two liberals--they both believed in the liberal society as we would understand it--a free society with a democratic element to its regime. They both believed in rights. They both believed especially in the importance of property rights.”

  • Levin argues that a liberal society is not the result of a great Enlightenment break from the Western tradition but is in fact the epitome and achievement of that tradition, which gradually improved upon itself until — especially in Britain and America — it achieved an extraordinary balance between liberty and order that must be maintained by building on the best of itself rather than starting over.

    “what we think of as a liberal society is not the result of a great break from the Western tradition that was made possible by Enlightenment ideas, but is in fact the epitome of the Western tradition, the achievement of the Western tradition.”

  • The claim that American progressivism is a foreign implant — a German invention of the 19th century — is false; reading Paine and even Jefferson shows the Left strand of American politics is deeply rooted in the founding-era tradition and has always been present, so Left and Right have coexisted for as long as America has known itself.

    “There is an inclination among some conservatives to think of today's Left, of American Progressivism as some kind of foreign implant, as an import from Germany, an invention of the 19th century. I think that's just not true.”

  • Burke was deeply influenced by Adam Smith, having read and written a glowing review of The Theory of Moral Sentiments as a young man; Burke's emphasis on sentiments in politics and on how the statesman should consider the ways politics shapes people's moral understanding was very much shaped by Smith, and Burke was later influenced by Smith's economic views as well, while Paine in The Rights of Man claimed to be the true Smithian in the debate.

    “Burke was very, very influenced by Smith... He read The Theory of Moral Sentiments as a fairly young man. He wrote a review of it in the Annual Register... a very glowing review which suggests that he took it to be a very profound book.”

0.56

Radical individualism that denies intermediary groups paradoxically demands statism, since individuals rely on government for what community cannot provide.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Radical individualism — the view that society consists only of individuals and the government — paradoxically leads to statism, because by denying that individuals belong to smaller intermediary groups, it ends up arguing that anything individuals cannot do for themselves, the government should do, an argument now made by American progressives (e.g., 'government is the things we do together').

    “The way in which radical individualism leads to statism. Because by insisting that society consists only of individuals and government, they ultimately argue that anything that individuals can't do, government should do.”

  • Libertarianism contains two strands: a Burkean one emphasizing the limits of knowledge and skepticism about power, which inclines libertarians toward market economics and restraints on government; and a Painean, utopian one holding that liberating people from moral, social, and cultural constraints will unlock human happiness — and Paine shows that this radical individualism can paradoxically lead to statism.

    “There is a strong and important strand of libertarianism that is very Burkean, because it emphasizes especially the limits of our knowledge and the kind of skepticism about the uses of power.”

  • Burke answered radical individualism by arguing that the life of a society happens in the space between the individual and the state — in the family, community, civil society, and the market — so the most important things about a society are found in that intermediary space, whereas Paine argued (as many progressives do today) that these unelected power centers are illegitimate and should be cleared away as 'a wilderness of turnpike gates' between the individual and his rights.

    “Burke answered this by saying the life of a society happens between the individual and the state--in the family, in the community, in civil society as we would now describe it; and in the market.”

0.56

Markets achieve continuous improvement through experimentation, evaluation, and evolution; government programs lack these mechanisms and become permanent.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Markets solve problems through a three-step process — experimentation (many ways to provide what people want), evaluation (consumers choose what works for them), and evolution (keep what works, drop what doesn't) — arranged by incentives, which produces continuous incremental improvement; government programs deliver none of these steps because regulation prevents experimentation, beneficiaries never decide what works, and programs never go away as interests build around them.

    “markets work by a kind of three-step process, where there's a great deal of room for experimentation... there is evaluation where consumers can choose for themselves what's working and what's not... And then there is evolution, which is simply: keep what works; drop what doesn't work.”

  • The core Left/Right disagreement on an inefficient health care system reflects the Burke/Paine split: the Left says make it efficient by centralizing it under expert control, while the Right says make it efficient by decentralizing it and letting it be the sum of its parts run on the ground between buyers and sellers — a very Burkean reliance on evolved institutions versus a technocratic, Painean reliance on expertise.

    “we've got a very inefficient system; the Left says we make it more efficient by centralizing it and subjecting it to expert control; the Right says we make it more efficient by decentralizing it and allowing it to be the sum of its parts run on the ground between buyers and sellers.”

  • Conservatives fail to make the simple point that the market system has been the best thing that has ever happened to the poor in human history — it has dramatically reduced extreme poverty around the world and is still doing so, lifting up the needy and vulnerable far better than anything else ever tried and far better than anything the Left has tried economically — and that historical fact should weigh heavily in policy debates.

    “the market system that we are advocating has been the best thing that has ever happened to the poor in human history. And has dramatically reduced extreme poverty around the world and is still doing it right now”

0.43

Burke valued inherited institutions and unchosen obligations like family and religion; Paine championed liberation from such constraints.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Burke challenges the view that emphasizes choice, arguing that many of the most important institutions we belong to — first and foremost the family, but also religion — are not really chosen; familial obligations define the shape of human lives in ways we cannot easily escape, and most people simply inherit rather than rationally select their religion, so we should be grateful for the good in the world we are born into and fix the bad without pretending it is good only because we chose it.

    “a lot of the most important institutions that we're part of aren't really chosen. Especially first and foremost the family, which of course in some respects is a choice but in some very, very important respects is not a choice.”

  • Paine held a recognizably American attitude toward authority — government deserves respect only if it is legitimate, and legitimacy is tested not by history but by what it is currently doing with its power; in short, to be respected you have to be respectable, in contrast to Burke's implicit respect for established authority grounded in tradition.

    “Paine basically said, if government is legitimate, then I'll respect it. If it's not, then I won't. And the test of that is not in history but in what it's doing, in how it's using its power.”

  • Burke observed that Americans are always alert to abuses of government power and believe such abuses happen constantly, so authorities must be careful not to prove them right; this less reverential strand is what American conservatives, as Americans, conserve — the implicit respect for all authority Burke himself exhibited is not much a part of American conservatism, and Levin thinks that is justified.

    “Burke says: One of the things we have to understand about the Americans is that they are always alert to abuses of government power. And they believe they are happening constantly. And we have to be very careful not to prove them right”

0.39

Burke and Paine publicly answered each other's writings and personally knew one another, making their disagreement a genuine mutual debate.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Burke and Paine ended up on the same side of the American question for entirely different reasons: Paine championed independence in principled, radical liberal terms, while Burke thought Parliament had the right to tax the colonies but was behaving foolishly and that the Americans were right to resist — and those differing reasons placed them in opposite camps on the French Revolution.

    “Paine, of course, was a great champion of American independence in very principal, liberal--we would think of as radical--terms. Burke supported the Americans because although he thought that Parliament had the right to tax them as it chose to, he thought that the British Parliament was behaving foolishly and that the Americans were right to resist.”

  • The extraordinary profusion of philosophical and political genius in the late-18th-century Anglo-American world (and in other periods like classical Athens) was not coincidental but a product of an era of theological, economic, and political flux; times of crisis call out people of greatness into political life and push down ordinary strivers, which is why figures like Lincoln emerge when they do.

    “I think that times of crisis call out people of greatness... I think the time calls out people of a certain kind of ability and pushes down people who normally would be in politics, who are just strivers, who are just trying to make a name for themselves.”

  • Burke and Paine knew each other personally, met several times, and exchanged letters, but most importantly for studying their disagreement as a genuine debate, they publicly answered one another's published writings, with some of their most important works written as direct responses to each other.

    “they publicly answered one another's published writings. Some of their most important writings were in response to one another.”

  • Both men ended their lives anxious about their legacies: Burke feared the triumphant French would dig up his body and asked to be buried in an unmarked grave, though his family buried him on the family plot where he remains; Paine, having attacked Christianity in The Age of Reason, was refused a Quaker burial and interred on his farm, only to be dug up by an admiring English radical, William Cobbett, who failed to build a monument, so that Paine's remains' ultimate disposition is unknown.

    “He was literally worried that they would dig up his body from his grave and make an example of him. He actually asked in his final days to be buried in an unmarked grave”

  • Federalism is one way to import market-style trial-and-error into government, but the common conservative framing of states as laboratories that will discover what works in one place to then apply everywhere misses the point, because solutions will not work everywhere; what is really needed is continuous on-the-ground problem-solving, which means devolving service provision to private providers and using government to create incentives to experiment.

    “There's an inclination... we refer to the states as laboratories, in the sense that they are going to figure out in Wisconsin what works and we're going to do it everywhere. But even that is not what is meant by this kind of process. Because it's not going to work everywhere.”

0.38

Burke disputed redistribution as entitlement and insisted on the distinction between charity and rights; Paine built the welfare state from Lockean principles.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Burke resisted Paine's redistribution by insisting it must never be thought of as a 'right': a good society might decide as a matter of charity to provide benefits to the poor through government, but no person is ever entitled to the property of another, and the difference between charity and entitlement is an extraordinarily important distinction that reflects an entirely different way of thinking about the relationship between an individual and society.

    “he insists again and again that it should not be thought of in terms of a 'right.' He says it may well be that a good society would decide as a matter of charity that it ought to provide some benefits to the poor... But it's not a matter of right. There is no way in which one person is entitled to the property of another person.”

  • Paine is one of the fathers of the welfare state, building it from Lockean premises: since the earth originally belongs to everyone in common yet property is essential to human progress, property holders possess something that belongs to everyone else, so a general tax should fund benefits — to new parents, to everyone at 21, and to everyone at 50 (an 18th-century retirement age) — making redistribution a native Liberal, not foreign, idea.

    “He says that Locke shows us that the earth belongs to everyone in common--originally--but also that property is absolutely essential to human progress... people who possess property have something that belongs to everybody else that they are not allowing those others to benefit from.”