Richard Reinsch on the Enlightenment, Tradition, and Populism
What this covers
Richard Reinsch, editor of Law and Liberty, joins Russ Roberts on EconTalk to examine how liberalism and Enlightenment thought depend on older traditions to sustain themselves. Reinsch argues that treating these as self-sufficient intellectual systems—divorced from religious, philosophical, and cultural inheritances—creates a dangerous vacuum. The conversation ranges across the spiritual hungers masked by material prosperity, the fragmentation of the human person into autonomous individual versus state, and how ignoring the relational and transcendent dimensions of human life opens the door to the strange political upheavals of recent decades. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's 1978 Harvard address anchors much of the discussion, offering a diagnosis of Western purposelessness that Reinsch extends into current conditions.
The speakers unpack The Enlightenment as Multiple Tales—distinguishing between German, French, Scottish, and American variants—and explore how the Enlightenment's abandonment of Aristotelian purposes left science powerful but morally untethered. They weigh Indirect Production of Autonomy against crude individualism, argue for Tradition as Reasoned Exaltation rather than blind adherence, and examine how the religious impulse, when suppressed, resurfaces in displaced political and ideological forms. The conversation touches immigration policy, family as non-negotiable social unit, the role of Intellectual Humility after twentieth-century totalitarianism, and whether human agency or technological determinism explains our current predicaments. Throughout, both speakers grapple with whether a civilization can endure on secular premises alone or whether transcendence and inherited meaning remain essential to social stability.
Reinsch argues that liberalism and the Enlightenment are not self-sufficient: they depend on prior traditions and a view of the human person as a spiritual, relational being, and that ignoring this transcendent dimension produces the alienation and populist upheaval visible in modern Western politics.
- The Enlightenment is plural and has a 'dark side' of hubris and will-to-power, not just reason and progress
- Material wealth coexists with widespread anxiety and antidepressant use, pointing to an unmet spiritual longing
- Reducing man to autonomous individual plus state, ignoring relational institutions, opens the door to strange political movements
Understanding our past through inherited legal, religious, and cultural sources is essential to rational self-knowledge and wise governance.
- Knowing where a civilization came from matters because human beings are rational, questioning animals who can only understand who they are and what they should do by looking back through their legal, religious, and cultural formation; this self-formation is the nobility of politics, and a wise, humble person recognizes he does not have all the answers and needs the inherited canon.
“a human person is a being who wonders. Who asks questions... And that begins sort of this process... How do we put that down and erect that and say, 'This is who we are?' And this is sort of what I would argue is the nobility of politics: we begin to shape ourselves.”
- There is no single Enlightenment but a series of distinct national Enlightenments (German, French, Scottish, American), so the meaningful questions are which Enlightenment is being discussed, what preceded and shaped it, what its goals were, and who was inside its circle.
“my thinking in this was heavily influenced by Gertrude Himmelfarb, who had a book that basically argued the Enlightenment is a series of tales. So, the question becomes: Which Enlightenment are we discussing?”
- The post-modern claim that all accounts of where we come from are merely competing myths with no truth is illogical because it privileges its own skepticism as the ground of truth; moreover, language is not a mere stimulus-response but is creative and capable of leading to knowledge, and myths matter precisely because they form lasting human communities and reveal human nature.
“it's--it's an illogical argument, to begin with... You are privileging your skepticism itself as the ground of truth or as the ground of the myth”
- Tradition properly understood is not blind, unthinking adherence but the exaltation of the best of what a people reason their way to and find orienting, settling into practices and institutions; it is inevitable for finite imperfect beings, so even the most libertarian society will develop traditions and proscriptions.
“I don't think it's sort of a blind, unthinking, irrational, 'we've always done this, therefore we should continue to do it.'... tradition best understood is the exaltation of the best of what a people are able to achieve and do”
Human beings are fundamentally relational—shaped by family, obligation, and community bonds that cannot be replaced by state policy or market logic.
- Following Roger Scruton, there is a crucial distinction between a society that directly aims at producing autonomous individuals and one whose law and culture produce autonomous individualism indirectly, arising out of our obligations to others; genuine self-development cannot be divorced from social and familial obligations.
“Roger Scruton... makes the point between a society that aims at autonomous individuals, and versus a society whose law, culture, produces autonomous individualism indirectly. And that is to say it's something that arises out of our obligations to others”
- Given where human beings come from and the long investment required to raise them, the family is essentially non-negotiable; attempts to dismiss or replace it through government policy lead to dastardly results, which speaks to the inevitable interconnection of tradition and human nature.
“thinking about the question of the family, where do human beings come from? How long does it take to raise and the investment? All of this business is really to my mind non-negotiable... We've had attempts at that with government policy in certain respects, and I don't think it's worked very well.”
- When law and policy embrace an autonomous individualism that reduces man to a single density of the individual facing the state, ignoring his social and relational nature, society opens itself to strange and dangerous political movements; this neglect of the relational human person is a fundamental cause of current political dysfunction.
“when you reduce man to this one density of an individual, and then you've got the state, then you've sort of opened yourself up to a lot of strange political movements... we're not accounting for the human person in his full relational capacity”
- If we honestly examine our own lives, the people who shaped us most did so not through a market transaction but through a gift arising out of duty, bond, obligation, and love, so dismissing such bonds as making us suckers means losing the thread of what human beings are.
“if we acknowledge our own lives, people who have shaped us the most, it usually wasn't a market transaction. It was a gift. And it was a gift owing out of duty or bond, obligation and love.”
When societies lose confidence in shared truths and dismiss tradition, religion, and patriotism, they open themselves to ideological extremism and civilizational collapse.
- Solzhenitsyn's 1978 Harvard commencement address transformed him from a beloved, celebrated dissident into a much more difficult figure, because he told the West it was lost in its own abstractions, materialism, and purposelessness and was committing a kind of suicide in the face of Communist aggression.
“he comes to Harvard and he says something like: The West is lost in its own abstractions; and it's lost in it's own purposelessness; and it seems to be committing some sort of suicide in the face of Communist aggression... So, Solzhenitsyn sort of becomes a much more difficult figure.”
- Drawing on Polanyi's attribution to Rousseau, the modern Left takes religious motivations and makes them immanent and this-worldly, directed toward man's emancipated relief, an inheritance later layered with 19th-century scientific reason and dialectical laws of history pointing toward equality.
“what Rousseau does is he takes religious motivations and makes them imminent. And makes them [?] this worldly, and directed to sort of man's emancipated relief... It's an imminantizing[?] of religion”
- A society no longer confident in its truths produces a 'mythical I' that is afraid to think, reason, and investigate, exemplified by Yale professors being yelled at over a Halloween-costume email, representing the back side of losing confidence in shared truths.
“what you see coming out of that is sort of this mythical "I," who is afraid to think and afraid to reason and afraid to investigate. And you get... Yale professors being yelled at in the College Yard, because they send out an email over Halloween costumes.”
- Elites in both parties failed to anticipate the populist surge, partly willfully and partly because they were caught off guard, and this neglect of whether ordinary people could see themselves in their country explains the rise of both Trump and Bernie Sanders, as well as Brexit and European nationalism.
“people start to ask a question: Can I actually see myself in my country, or am I disposable and a throwaway? In that respect, people start to act up... I think those--elites in both parties didn't see that. Didn't understand that.”
- In a highly secular society the religious impulse does not disappear but reappears in displaced forms, so movements like climate-change activism and the demand to accept transgenderism function as attempts to fill a spiritual longing and account for the whole when the soul's requirements are ignored.
“It is in the sense of it's a spiritual longing. It's an attempt to account for the whole. And I think that's a part of what happens, in a secular, in a very secular society--is the religious aspect comes out in different ways.”
- Dismissing patriotism, marriage, and religion as 'for suckers' leads to emasculation and a false emancipation, which explains why one of the most secular and emancipated societies on earth, Western Europe, is basically dying and refusing to reproduce itself.
“that's when we become emasculated and sort of enter into a false emancipation... one of the most secular emancipated societies on the earth in Western Europe is basically dying. And refuses to reproduce itself. From all of the data that I can see.”
- Solzhenitsyn's Red Wheel argues that the Communist revolution in Russia was not inevitable but the product of human choices that progressively turned the wheel, a reflection on human freedom turning against human nature and producing 70 years of destruction.
“nothing of this was inevitable in the sense of a Communist revolution in Russia. It's through human choice. And it's through human beings making a choice that the Red Wheel begins to turn more and more and more.”
Liberalism depends on transcendent sources and cannot survive on procedural neutrality alone.
- Liberalism, best understood as a roughly neutral set of ideas protecting humans from coercive power claims, cannot stand on its own accord; it depends on a conception of the human person as filled with infinite longing and a need for transcendence, drawing on Greek philosophy and the Jewish/Christian tradition as indispensable tributary sources.
“I think Liberalism depends on a view of the human person that is filled with an infinite longing, with a need for transcendence, with a need to know the truth about ourselves... It's not a self-sufficient body of ideas that doesn't require a lot of tributary sources.”
- Despite unprecedented wealth and opportunity, Americans exhibit immense sadness and anxiety, evidenced by widespread antidepressant use, because man is not only an animal but a spiritual, transcendent being whose longing cannot be satisfied by material accomplishment; ignoring the soul's requirements brings big trouble rushing in.
“this incredibly wealthy country, incredible opportunities, and yet, sort of, in another sense, immense sadness and anxiety--my chief evidence would be antidepressant medications and antidepressant subscriptions--how do you account for that?”
Modern science and technology are powerful but morally neutral tools whose purpose and use depend on deeper questions about human flourishing and the soul.
- The gifts of science and technology from the Enlightenment are simultaneously a profound trial of the human will, because they can be used either for the relief of man's estate or as tools of power against other people, as shown by the nuclear bomb being a product of science rather than religion or superstition.
“these gifts of science and technology coming out of the Enlightenment are also a profound trial of the human will. And, can you actually use them ultimately for the relief of man's estate, or do they get used as tools of power against other people?”
- Things are getting better and worse at the same time, so one should be neither a reactionary against technology nor a naive progressive, and should always be aware of the seeds of destruction within something good, such as liberalism or modern technology.
“what I would say is things are getting better and worse at the same time. And, we should always keep that in mind.”
- Modern science gained its power by abandoning Aristotle's formal and final causes and focusing only on the immanent process of experiment, observation, and prediction, which leaves unanswered the question of purpose: what science is for and whom it serves.
“Part of the Enlightenment, part of the explanation that's given for the power the science is you no longer think about formal and final cause--which had been such a tremendous part of Aristotle's thinking... And you strip away final cause, and you are just focused on this imminent process of what you are doing”
- The rapid rise of Jordan Peterson, enabled by the Internet and YouTube, reflects technology feeding a genuine existential hunger especially among young people, whose intellectual project is to recover and not forget what humanity has learned about itself.
“The technology, I think, feeding an existential hunger and an impulse, particularly amongst our young people, which I've found very encouraging.”
Wise statecraft should balance patriotic tradition with respect for individual rights and avoid both reactionary nationalism and cosmopolitan elite detachment.
- Although there is a tradition of racism in America, the country also developed a counter-tradition of individual rights and fair treatment based on people's status as human persons, and through reasoned engagement the tradition that ultimately won out was not racism, illustrating that tradition involves reason rather than blind continuation.
“Racism--there is a tradition of racism, obviously, in this country. And yet... we also have this counter-tradition of the individual, of rights, and of treating people, you know, fairly... And I think the tradition that won wasn't racism.”
- The wise statesman should find the median between a reductive nationalism and an unreflective elite cosmopolitanism, combining a measure of patriotism and consent of the governed with respect for the country's history and trajectory, accepting qualified rather than pure free trade.
“the wise course is to find the median between a reductive nationalism and an unreflective cosmopolitanism of our elite. And, I think that you have to sort of show what the good is, and how, I think, a certain amount of patriotism, a certain amount of consent to the governed”
- A central problem with modern immigration reform is the state using multicultural dictates to turn immigrants into client groups rather than treating them as individual rights-bearers entrusted to become Americans, which contrasts with an older model emphasizing assimilation and active republican citizenship rather than rent-seeking.
“you are bringing immigrants into America not as individuals, not as rights-bearers who are going to be entrusted with becoming Americans... but your goal is to use the state to turn them into client groups.”
- When Law and Liberty launched in 2012, many arguments and ideas on the American Right—in the judicial sphere, economics, institutions, government power, and federalism—were stale and needed a new, fresh, and even controversial approach.
“it was sort of my thinking and position that a lot of arguments and rhetoric and ideas on the Right in America were stale.”