dialectic
The critical second half of Kant's Critique of Pure Reason cataloging the errors reason falls into when it oversteps the limits of possible experience.
As defined in 254 | William Egginton on Kant, Heisenberg, and Borges
Other definitions
In Platonic philosophy, the method of inquiry that proceeds through questioning and logical discussion to arrive at knowledge of universal forms, often understood as enabling recollection of innate knowledge
A History of Philosophy | 21 Augustine's Christian Philosophy
Where it comes up · 28
- A History of Philosophy | 04 Plato's Epistemology9 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 58 Hegel's Phenomenology of the Mind5 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 71 Jean-Paul Satre4 claims
- Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist3 claims
- Claudia Hauer on War, Education, and Strategic Humanism3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 59 Hegel on Absolute Spirit3 claims
- Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Plato and Poetry3 claims
- Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic VI-X: The Architecture of Reality3 claims
and 20 more
Most important claims · 10 of 58Search all claims for “dialectic” →
- The second, truly critical half of the Critique of Pure Reason — the dialectic — catalogs the errors and antinomies that arise when we let our presumptions about how the world should be run ahead of our observations; Borges loved these antinomies and his stories repeatedly push readers to the edge of antinomy, whereas Heisenberg paid them little attention.254 | William Egginton on Kant, Heisenberg, and Borges
- The fact that the entire Platonic dialogues are shot through with poetry and myth despite Plato's ontological devaluation of art (placing art at the lowest level of the divided line) reveals that Plato recognizes poetry's power and effectiveness, and therefore strategically uses poetry to advance philosophical understanding.Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Plato and Poetry
- Hegel's philosophical style, though appearing verbose, expresses his fundamental metaphysical framework such that even simple statements like 'a person was killed' carry implications of dialectical negation and historical significance—a finite determination of infinity further determined by its own negation.A History of Philosophy | 57 Hegel
- The key Hegelian idea is that any cultural moment or set of ideas is internally contradictory in ways it doesn't notice; over time those tensions surface and, in resolving themselves, generate something newer and better that incorporates both original sides — so the aim is not to seek consistency but to recognize that contradictions are themselves productive and push history forward.Rebecca Kukla
- Empirical generalization across particular cases does not yield knowledge of the essence of a thing; it only identifies similarities, some of which may be incidental or unnecessary—genuine knowledge requires thinking abstractly in abstraction from all particulars about the essential nature of things.A History of Philosophy | 04 Plato's Epistemology
- Knowledge is gained and transmitted through dialectic—or more precisely, elicited through the Socratic method from ideas already innately present in the soul from a previous existence, as Plato holds, rather than transmitted from outside.A History of Philosophy | 05 Plato's Theory of Forms
- True opinion based on sense experience, even when accurate, remains unreliable and unstable unless it is tethered or anchored by dialectic—like a horse that will wander away if loose, true opinion may suffice for practical daily tasks but requires dialectical grounding for genuine knowledge.A History of Philosophy | 04 Plato's Epistemology
- In Marxist theory, which transfers the Hegelian dialectic onto a materialistic rather than idealistic basis, the thesis of capitalism moves to the antithesis of the dictatorship of the proletariat to the synthesis of a classless society—and nothing comes after because there is no class conflict left and therefore no dialectic.A History of Philosophy | 58 Hegel's Phenomenology of the Mind
- Gabriel Marcel, a French Catholic philosopher and religious existentialist, critiques Sartre's dialectic between the for-itself and the in-itself as overdrawn because it fails to distinguish between negation (turning against the other) and disengagement (drifting apart), and Marcel argues that relationships exist between two poles of alienation and love rather than being wholly alienated.A History of Philosophy | 72 Other Phenomenologists
- Hegel does not explicitly reject the law of non-contradiction but regards it as trivial in a world of change, since the same thing cannot have contradictory properties in the same respect and at the same time—but in a changing process, the same thing can have contradictory properties at different times.A History of Philosophy | 56 German Idealism