
Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic VI-X: The Architecture of Reality
What this covers
This is Michael Sugrue's lecture on the second half of Plato's Republic, Books VI through X. It works through the dialogue's metaphysics first and its politics and ethics second. The opening argument is that the ideal city and ideal philosopher cannot fit into space and time, and that this shows how flawed space and time are. The lecture follows the way Plato sets out an ontology and an epistemology that match each other. Images correspond to imagination (eikasia), sensible things to belief, mathematical objects to reasoning (dianoia), and the Forms to dialectical knowledge (noesis). The Divided Line and The Myth of the Cave carry this scheme. Sugrue treats dialectic as plain, rigorous, step-by-step conversation, not a mystery.
The range is wide. Geometry stands as the model of knowledge: the square drawn on a blackboard is only a reminder of the true square, which fits the Academy's inscription barring anyone ignorant of geometry. A single Form (eidos, idea)) also explains why a Rembrandt and a Dalí can both be called beautiful. The lecture sets out the philosopher-king's schedule of education, running from gymnastics and music through mathematics and dialectic to practical politics and, after fifty, possible rule. It also points to an irony: the wisest person in the city is the one forced to hold more than one job. Plato's hero is described as the educator, who replaces the epic warrior, the tragic criminal and the comic fool.
The later portion turns to decline and consequence. Regimes degrade from the ideal city to timocracy, oligarchy and democracy, and finally to tyranny, where unbounded desire keeps the soul in turmoil. Plato blames Athens itself, not the sophists, for corrupting the young. Book X revisits the critique of the poets, and the myth of Er closes the lecture with souls choosing their next lives. Wise souls choose to be private, just citizens, while foolish ones choose to be eagles or lions, which reflects the bestial Homeric ideal.
Plato argues that true knowledge and virtue come only through understanding the realm of unchanging Forms (Ideas) beyond the physical world, which requires the philosopher-king to ascend through mathematics and dialectic, making the sensory world fundamentally unreliable and inferior to intelligible reality.
- The sensory world is subject to flux and change, making it unsuitable as a basis for certain knowledge—only the eternal Forms provide absolute certainty
- The philosopher-king must be educated through mathematics and dialectic to apprehend the Form of the Good, which generates all reality like the sun generates light
- The entire republic's structure (the divided line, the myth of the cave, the degenerate regimes) instantiates this ontological hierarchy and shows how education either elevates or corrupts the soul
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Plato's new hero replaces the epic warrior and the tragic criminal and the comic fool with the hero as educator—the man of knowledge who values reasoning (logos) over poetic imagery (mythos), though he understands different people need different presentations of truth.
“this means that socrates is going to be our new hero instead of epic slaughter instead of tragic crime instead of comic foolishness we're going to have a new man with a new goal a new telos he's going to be the hero as educator the hero is man of knowledge this is a new and higher and finer ideal but this man of knowledge while he prefers logos to mythos he prefers reasoning to poetic imagery he understands that different people have different capacities so when there's a need for a poetic image he will be able to generate that”
Plato argues that since his idealizations of perfect cities and philosophers will not fit into the world of space and time, this demonstrates that space and time itself is seriously flawed and not as real as the ideal realm he constructs.
“if somehow his idealizations his perfect perfect cities and perfect philosophers and perfect rulers won't fit into this world of space and time that means that there's something very seriously wrong with space and time itself right this world around us is not real or not as real as the ideal realm he's going to construct”
Geometry does not change across years and generations—10th graders in every era learn the same geometric truths—because there is a stable Form of the triangle and other geometric entities that serve as the unchanging referent.
“also think about the fact that geometry doesn't change next year's 10th graders when they get taught geometry are all going to learn exactly the same stuff how do we account for this unusual stability of this kind of knowledge because there's a form of the triangle and a form of the seven and a form of the right angle which stays the same we just replicate that by gesturing at the idea right”
Tyranny represents the worst regime where the tyrant wants to satisfy as many desires as possible as completely as possible, but this produces a wretched life where desires always exceed one's capacity to satisfy them, keeping the soul in constant turmoil.
“we get the worst of regimes the tyrannical regime and the worst of men the tyrannical man and the tyrannical man is the one that wants to have as many desires as he can to satisfy them as completely as he can but this is a wretched life where your desires always outstrip your capacity to satisfy them so you're constantly scratching itches but you have many more itches than you can scratch so you're constantly in a wretched state being pushed around by your feelings never being able to organize your soul”
Everyone who does not understand Platonic philosophy—the entire pre-philosophical population—is living in a realm of shadows and illusions, believing images and sense perceptions to be real until they are liberated through philosophy.
“he thinks this is the whole pre and non-philosophic group of all the world's people in other words everyone that doesn't understand the platonic theory of forms is living in the realm of shadows because they believe in images and sense perceptions they believe that these things are real in fact plato says until we learn philosophy we are living in the realm of the senses in the realm of space and time in the realm of unreality”
In the myth of Er, bad people receive punishment and good people receive reward in the afterlife; souls then choose their next lives, with wise souls choosing to live as private, just citizens while foolish souls choose to be eagles, lions, or other animals, reflecting the bestial nature of Homeric ideals.
“the myth of er er was a good man and died and for some reason the gods allowed him to retain his own consciousness in the afterlife and he saw that in the afterlife bad things happen to bad people and good things happen to good people and when good things happen to good people they get the reward of the blessed they go to the aisles of the blessed and they get all kinds of nice stuff it's essentially heaven and in hades bad things happen to bad people uh the homeric heroes are in hades where they belong and not only that but these homeric men these bad men that have been sent to hades some of them wise up some of them don't you get their true nature because after you get punished you are forced to become reincarnated and the life you choose is all up to you if you but choose with wisdom so the great homeric heroes they choose to be eagles lions predatory animals the implication of course is that the ideals offered us by homer are really bestial inferior subhuman carnivorous and impressive in a certain kind of natural way but less than human the smartest of the homeric heroes odysseus great irony here decides looks around decides he doesn't want to be a hero anymore but but since he's the smartest of the homeowners he does he doesn't want to be a hero either he decides he doesn't want to be an animal and doesn't want to be a homeric hero he chooses the life of a quiet private citizen and he says fine i'm going to mind my own business do what i ought to do and i'm going to be essentially just in that platonic sense”
Book X returns to and recapitulates Plato's critique of the poets, emphasizing that poetry is educational, these dialogues are educational, and education either teaches truth or makes people worse rather than better; all knowledge is virtue and all ignorance is vice, making education the source of all political and moral good.
“then book 10 is very important he goes back to a recapitulation of his critique of the poets why because he shows that poetry is educational and these dialogues are intended to be educational and education can either either teach you the truth or not and if it doesn't teach you the truth it makes you worse rather than better and this is the source of all our political and moral evils because all knowledge is virtue and all ignorance is violence so all our vices are really ignorance”
When a geometry teacher draws a square on the blackboard, it is not truly a square but merely a reminder of the true square that exists in the Form-realm; the drawn square has irregular lines and imperfect angles, whereas the true Form of squareness is eternally perfect.
“when your geometry teacher draws a square on the blackboard here's an important fact it's not really a square he says that let's consider this as a square but if you were to actually look with a microscope at that chalk on that blackboard which you find is that it's kind of roughly straight but it's really not a straight line spacing time doesn't have straight lines in it to be a square it has to have straight lines also not perfect 90 degree angles on all sides so this is a reminder this image that he draws on the blackboard this is a reminder here in the realm of space and time of the true square which is up in heaven or up outside of space and time altogether right”
When we encounter beauty in diverse forms—a Rembrandt portrait and a Salvador Dalí painting—that have nothing in common except being paintings, we can meaningfully say both are beautiful because they both participate in the Form of ultimate beauty outside space and time.
“so when we go to an art museum and we look at a at a painting by salvador dali and we look at a painting by rembrandt two paintings that have nothing in common except that they are paintings and they participate in the form of painting this i suppose we would say about both of those paintings those are both truly beautiful an entirely possible reaction well what do we mean by the rembrandt portrait and some very bizarre construction by salvador dali what do we mean when we say both of them are beautiful what plato thinks is that they both participate in some form of ultimate beauty which is outside the realm of space and time”
The Platonic Academy inscribed at its gate 'Let no one enter who has not studied geometry' because geometry is the paradigm of knowledge and essential preparation for understanding Platonic philosophy.
“this is why every everyone that gets a platonic education has to know quite a bit of math over the academy at the gate it said uh let no one enter who has not studied geometry if you want to go and study platonic philosophy you have to know your geometry because that's the big paradigm of knowledge”
The philosopher-king's education involves gymnastics and music until age 20, mathematics from age 20 to 30, exposure to dialectic from age 30 to 35, practical politics from age 35 to 50, and then (if worthy) the possibility of becoming philosopher-king after age 50.
“that is the key thing that the philosopher king is going to have to be led towards towards the realm of the forms that's why his study is going to be dialectical from the years 30 to 35 in other words until he's 20 he's going to get the same gymnastics gymnastic and music education as the regular ones as the regular guardians then from 20 to 30 the education of the guardian will involve war but also mathematics because mathematics is our bridge up into the realm of the forms he's going to learn a lot of geometry you'll be able to prove all kinds of great stuff anybody incidentally in the potential dialogues that have spent their time studying math or is caught studying mathematics like uh theaters always a good interlocutor always smart it's always a sign that he's gotten a good education if you're studying with the sophists bad education doesn't do any math i mean it always tips you off so find out who someone who taught someone you'll always find if his argument is any good before you even read it well after some exposure to dialectic from 30 to 35 then the philosopher king in training will go down and help conduct practical politics for until he's 50 years old thereafter if one has gotten the appropriate training and shown worthy of this philosophical education you might be able to become a philosopher philosopher king after the age of 50”
Plato's ontology (theory of being) and epistemology (theory of knowledge) perfectly overlap: to each level of being corresponds a mental process—images correspond to imagination, sensibles to belief, mathematical objects to reasoning (dianoia), and Forms to dialectical knowledge (noesis).
“this is plato's ontology which perfectly overlaps his epistemology in other words philosophers only construct ontological positions and ontology just means the logos of being it's the kind of the stratifications and different types of being well once you go to the trouble of stratifying the different sorts of beings you might as well construct various kinds of mental processes to get you in touch with those different kinds of things so the ontology and the epistemology perfectly overlap”
Plato argues that the true corrupter of people and youth is not the sophists but Athens itself—the city—while the philosopher is the one who saves and improves those who listen to him.
“in defending the philosopher socrates also argues that the real corrupter of the people the real corrupter of youth is athens itself in other words the philosopher is the one who saves and reclaims and improves the people that listen to him the city is what causes these corruptions brings in these innovations generates all kinds of skepticism and immorality”
There is an ironic paradox in the Republic's concept of justice: the most wise and philosophically insightful person in the city—the philosopher-king—is the only person forced by necessity to pursue more than one job, violating the principle of one-job-one-person that defines justice in the city.
“we've established justice by making sure that there's one man one job everyone pursues only one course in life except for the best and most wise person in the city the philosopher king because to be a philosopher is not the same thing as being a king he's the only person that has two jobs so apparently the justice man in the city the man with the most wisdom and the most philosophical uh insight is also the person who we force due to our own necessity to engage in a kind of injustice to pursue more than one job”
The decline of the ideal city into degenerate regimes follows a specific sequence: from the ideal city to timocracy (honor-based rule), to oligarchy (wealth-based rule), to democracy (freedom-based rule), to tyranny (unchecked desire).
“now having come up to that point we're now going to gradually be led down away from the realm of the forms and what's going to be picked up next after the education of the philosopher king in book eight is the degenerate regimes for each of the bad uh souls and there are several there are five kinds there are five kinds of souls and four of them are bad there's going to be four kinds of regime and four of them will be bad and one will be connected to the other those of you who know nietzsche's book the genealogy of morals will find in book eight a genealogy of morals”
Books six and seven of Plato's Republic present his ontological and epistemological doctrines that explain how true reality exists in a realm outside of space and time, entirely separate from the sensory world.
“book six and seven of the republic are in some ways the high point of this dialogue it's in book six and seven that plato presents us with his ontological and epistemological doctrines”
Plato does not trust sense perception as reliable because it is subject to illusions and errors, exemplified by mirages in the desert, refraction of light through water making objects appear bent, and the general uncertainty about whether physical objects will retain their properties.
“plato doesn't think it's reliable and maybe if you lived in 4 or 400 bc you would find sense perception unreliable as well remember that he doesn't have modern natural science and the technological and logical triumphs of modern natural science to make him feel comfortable with the world of the senses he lives in a world where we don't have an accurate or adequate or satisfactory theory of the world of space and time and for that reason he thinks it's uncertain for example imagine for the ancient greeks what the problem of the mirage must have been like you know what a mirage is when you are in the desert and you see in the distance a lake of water and then you walk to that lake of water and there's nothing there”
When we engage in imagination—mentally receiving and absorbing images from poetry, painting, or mirrors—we are performing a specific mental activity and adopting a specific state of the soul that Plato calls imagination (eikasia).
“what we do when we cogitate when we mentally arrest and absorb and envelop these images is plato calls imagination in other words and to imagine is a very specific and definite mental activity an activity of the soul in which we operate when we listen to paul to poems by homer we imagine hector and achilles fighting it out when we look at a painting we imagine the scene represented by the painting but in fact it's just a set of pigments on a piece of paper or on a piece of canvas right so we do a definite mental activity there's a definite state of the soul which corresponds to this particular kind of thing”
Without knowledge of the Form of the Good, rulers legislate only in their own interest or on whim, which leads to injustice, factional conflict, and a city that is internally incoherent and externally evil.
“but you need that knowledge of the form of the good elsewise you are only legislating in your own interest or in whatever strikes your fancy and that's going to lead to all kinds of complications and that's going to lead to all sorts of degeneracy and that's going to lead to all sorts of injustice and injustice will of course cause the city to factionalize and you'll get an internally incoherent city and an externally evil city”
A Form (Idea/eidos) is a single entity in which all examples of a particular quality in the sensory world participate and correspond, explaining why we use the same term for diverse things that seem to have nothing in common.
“the final the most real thing the most completely permanent things are the forms and form is sometimes translated as idea egos and what it means is some image some entity in which all of the examples of that quality in this world correspond or participate let me give you an example this is a book or it's a book of plato there are other books on the table in front of me the reason why we call this a book and that a book and that a book even though they they don't perfectly correspond they take up different points in space they have different covers they have different qualities in many respects the reason we call we use the term book for all of these things is that this book and that book and the other book all participate in the form of bookness up in the realm of the forms”
Mathematical objects like triangles, squares, and the number seven do not change and are susceptible to precise, demonstrable, logical analysis, making them objects of true knowledge rather than mere opinion.
“the next step up when we move from opinion to not to knowledge on the divided line we move to mathematical objects objects like triangles squares sevens that don't change and that are susceptible to precise demonstrable logical analysis and you can really think about these things you don't just have opinions about triangles uh if you think about something like the theorem of pythagoras that's the way right triangles are and next year when we bring 10th graders into geometry class we're going to teach them that and if some 10th grader puts up santa says no i don't think it works this way we're going to say well look you don't understand what we mean by triangle”
Ignorance is the source of all corruption and evil in the city, which means that the philosopher-king must understand the Form of the Good—the true, changeless, atemporal, aspatial goodness—to rule properly.
“the real corruption doesn't come from sophists or philosophers the real corruption comes from the people themselves in every city ignorance is the source of all corruption and evil now if we're going to have a philosopher king we have to figure out how to educate a philosopher king what he'll have to know and how he'll be different from the defenders the silver people in society and what we're going to do is have to figure out what it is that the philosopher king knows that everybody else doesn't know and what he knows it turns out is the form of the good the form of the good is the true changeless a temporal a spatial goodness in which all other good things in the world somehow participate”
The dialectic is not a mysterious process but simply rigorous conversation—philosopher-kings and others involved in society talk seriously step by step and honestly try to figure out what is going on, attempting to move from mere flux and change to the realm of real knowledge and the Forms.
“the dialectic is crucial because this is what the philosopher king is going to do the philosopher king is going to engage in the dialectic which sounds like a very mysterious thing to do the dialectic it sounds like like you should get a capital d doesn't it's a very special kind of thing no it's not the dialectic is just a very rigorous kind of conversation in other words you talk about it and you talk about it seriously and you talk about it step by step and you honestly with another person try and figure out what's going on so the dialectic while it sounds terribly mysterious is just the philosopher king and his philosopher pals and the other people that are involved in this the running of this society talking about the best way to do things and they try and move and to some extent they do move up from this mere realm of flux and change and becoming to the realm of real knowledge and this is the realm of the forms”
The philosopher who escapes the cave and climbs to the sun (knowledge of the Form of the Good) must eventually return to the cave and help others, but will struggle to see in the darkness and will be mocked for appearing corrupted by the journey—a perfect metaphor for the difficulty and sacrifice of teaching.
“now what the philosopher has to do is come back down from the realm of reality to the realm of shadows and of course he can't see his way around i mean it's a beautiful image a perfect metaphor i mean what an inspired day when plato thought this up so he comes back down to the realm of the dark and people laugh at him because he can't find his way around but of course he's the only man that understands ultimate reality”
The myth of the cave and the divided line overlap and support each other: the divided line is a purely logical and ontological doctrine, while the myth makes it vivid and politically instantiated, translating abstract metaphysics into narrative that appeals to imagination.
“the myth of the cave and the divided line are overlaps one is a purely logical doctrine an ontological and epistemological doctrine which is instantiated in this myth of the cave and made political”
In the divided line, the least real things are images such as shadows and mirror reflections, which are less real than the objects they represent.
“the bottom the least real things are things like shadows when i put my hand up and it catches these these lights there's a shadow cast on the back wall well the shadow is very different from my hand and the shadow is somehow less real than my hand well plato thinks that the least real things what we might call images and this realm this bottom least real set of things that include images like shadows also if you hold up a mirror to someone the image of your face in the mirror is somehow less than your face itself”
The philosopher-king paradox is that no empirical city actually wants philosophers to run things; most Greeks view philosophers as corrupt corrupters, recalling instead the model of the Homeric hero like Agamemnon as the ideal king.
“not till philosophers are kings where we have a good city the difficulty is that no empirical city wants philosophers to run things there's no regime that is looking for a philosopher to come in and run things philosophers are thought of as being corrupt and corrupting remember that socrates is condemned for corrupting the youth of athens for teaching the wrong kinds of religious beliefs and philosophers don't seem to be the appropriate sort of person to run a city most greeks are thinking back to the homeric hero you want to think of a king think of agamemnon there's a real king for you but socrates would not be any greeks idea of a good ruler”
Plato must censor Homer when he speaks falsely or encourages wrathfulness and petulance, because Homer teaches young men to become like Achilles—wrathful and tyrannical—and this bad education leads to actual tyranny and injustice in the city.
“that means that we're really going to have to double back and censor homer because when homer speaks well we'll bring him in but when he doesn't speak well out he goes he tries to make our young men into achilles and they get wrathful and petulant and want to kill something they want to become tyrants that's no good”
Poetry, epic, comedy, and tragedy are imitations less real than the realm of Forms, and because poets are ignorant of the Forms, they create ignorant students, resulting in widespread ignorance and moral corruption across the city.
“he criticizes epic and he criticizes imitators in general uh comedies and tragedies in addition because these imitations are less real than the realm of the forms which he has just explained to us and the poets are ignorant of so these ignorant instructors create ignorant students and the result is ignorance advice across the board”
The myth of the cave illustrates the divided line: prisoners chained to see only shadows represent those trapped in the realm of images; their ascent to see the fire and real objects represents movement to belief; their exit to sunlight represents movement to knowledge; the sun represents the Form of the Good.
“he offers us the myth of the cave he says think about this i think he's talking to glaucon at this point he says imagine people stuck in the bottom of a cave there's an opening to the cave up in the front and everyone is in the cave has their head and shoulders chained so they can only look at a wall and behind them is a large fire and men carry things between the fire and the wall so the people can't see them carrying these objects and they look at the shadows cast by the fire and these objects on that wall and say those shadows are reality in other words they are fundamentally mistaken in their ontological views”
The journey toward the Form of the Good through dialectic is asymptotic—one may glimpse the sun itself but cannot fully possess it through language; human perfection and virtue are tied to knowledge that remains always slightly beyond final grasp.
“well that's what the form of the good is is and the way in which we get to that is through dialectic because that brings us to the knowledge of the forms and we gradually climb up further and further towards the final form but our journey of dialectic and this is very important because uh plato emphasizes in book six the journey aspect of this the journey motif the journey of dialect comes up again and again and again and the point here is that the journey is asymptotic we might actually be able to find out get a tiny glimpse of the sun itself but the difficulty is language won't contain it so at the end of the journey glaucon asks all right tell me about the form of the good what's going on what is the form of the good and he says glaucon i'd take you there if i could son but i can't i mean i i've been up there i've climbed the mountain but you got to climb the last stage you got to take yourself apparently one goes beyond electric too i know not what maybe we don't ultimately get to maybe it's just an asymptotic move”
Mathematics is the domain where Plato shows his strongest argumentative power; when defending platonism, a platonist arguing about arithmetic cannot be evaded with relativism because mathematical truths are absolute and unchanging.
“here's where plato plays this ace in the whole mathematics mathematics is god's gift to platonists whenever you argue with the platonist if the platonist knows of his business he's going to start talking to you about arithmetic because you can't weasel out when you start talking about with me you can't get all relativistic and say well you believe this i believe that he's going to bring you right back to the number line not going to take any nonsense from you when plato has to go to his strong suit he always goes to a mathematical example”
The isomorphism between city and man is a main idea of the Republic: just as the city has five kinds of regimes corresponding to five soul-types, the five interlocutors embody these soul-types, and they all improve through dialogue, demonstrating that education lifts the soul and bad education debases it.
“and this instantiates the thing that is trying to explain to you that good education will bring you up and bad education will bring you down and me when i first read this i didn't know books could do stuff like that i mean that's one of the great things in plato i mean if you read this book seriously you occasionally get this landslide of information and landslide of of coherence and this is an example of that”
Book nine examines the soul of the tyrant, showing that the tyrant is wretched and miserable; the book also critiques Euripides as a praiser of tyrants whose art makes tyrannical souls even worse by providing bad education.
“we get these demo these uh degenerate regimes and we get the the way to satisfy the problems generated by these degenerate regimes and book nine looks at the soul of the tyrant it shows that the tyrant is wretched and miserable and also takes a crack at euripides socrates of and plato obviously hate euripides and who can blame them i mean those of you who know europeans i don't much care for these tragedies and uh he goes after europe he's saying look he's a praiser of tyrants which he is and says that we don't need that kind of art in our good society it makes tyrannical men even worse it gives them the bad education that i've just shown you how to add a reverse”
Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morals in part reflects Platonic precedent, as Book VIII of the Republic contains the first great genealogy of morals in Western philosophy, tracing the degeneration of the ideal city through stages of vice.
“there are five kinds there are five kinds of souls and four of them are bad there's going to be four kinds of regime and four of them will be bad and one will be connected to the other those of you who know nietzsche's book the genealogy of morals will find in book eight a genealogy of morals nietzsche was full of well envy of plato because he was the great educator of the west and wanted to supplant him so many of nietzsche's ideas that look real kind of um new and uh kind of original are not new or original at all plato uh nietzsche was a philologist so in book aid of the public we get the first of the great genealogies of morals”
In a Platonic dialogue, nothing happens by accident—votes, losses, and symbolic actions all tell us about the souls involved, and the structure of the entire dialogue embodies the political theory it espouses.
“nothing happens by accident in a platonic dialogue if somebody votes it tells you something about them if he loses something whatever he's lost is symbolic of something if he has to go somewhere and do something whatever he's going to do that's symbolic of something everything is symbolic”
Adeimantus begins as an oligarchic man interested in property but moves upward to become more moderate and oligarchic when he realizes the benefits of the community of women and abolition of private property.
“his brother adam montes who at the beginning of book four is really interested in property he wants big houses and stuff the beginning of book six polymeric says to him you know whispers to him socrates hasn't explained the community of women and the abolition of private property glaucon who used to be kind of timid and reserved and moderate in austere walks out because he's now the democratic man he's moved up a notch from oligarchic to democratic he says socrates stand right there i'm arresting you a second time he's gotten brave all of a sudden why up we go he's gotten ratcheted up from oligarch to timocrat says now you're going to stand and answer our questions clearly the kind of interaction that he has with socrates the good education that he gets morally improves him polemicus polemica starts out as our democratic man in the beginning and then he gets all kinds of well moderate and restrained and austere and instead of directly confronting socrates at that beginning of book six he goes to or beginning of book five he whispers to adamantis he's moved from being the democratic man to being the oligarchic man up we go”
The sophists are great souls with bad educations who, had they been given proper education, would be potential philosopher-kings; they only serve as employees of whatever regime controls them—oligarchy, democracy, or tyranny.
“the similarity of soul between socrates and thrasymachus the only there's a similarity in the depth or the profundity of their souls the difference really amounts to the fact that socrates by divine dispensation or maybe the diamond or something has gotten these philosophical insights has gotten a philosophical education i guess a self-education whereas thrasymachus because he has been denied these insights with his great soul goes to the greatest of extremes what is it in paradise lost where satan is one of the greatest of angels and then falls and when the greatest fall they fall all the way so that's true of all the sophists they are great souls with bad educations and not only bad educations but they pander to the city in an oligarchic city they penetrate the oligarchy in a democratic city they append to the people but in every case they are just employees”
Thrasymachus, the tyrannical man advocating the advantage of the stronger, has been brought into the social/political organization through Socratic dialogue; he votes with the group, making him now a democratic man—everyone improves when exposed to philosophical reasoning.
“trusimica says the only other thing that he says outside of book one he makes two statements one he says i'll go with that i vote with that make it unanimous we all want you to stand and explain the community of women and the three ways socrates what has happened to thrasymachus he has moved from being the tyrannical man he has been made a social animal brought into our little political organization and he votes so now he's the democratic man up we go up we go up we go everybody gets improved”
Adeimantus represents the oligarchic soul interested in accumulating property; Polemarchus represents the democratic soul; and Thrasymachus represents the tyrannical soul advocating that justice is the advantage of the stronger.
“his brother adam montes beginning of book four adamanta says you know what socrates i don't see how your rulers can be happy since after all they don't get to have a lot of property in big houses and nice things like that glaucon is the oligarchic man who's interested in accumulating property i mean he's remember he comes from plato's families plato's brother and they're a high ranking family within athens and they're an influential family so glaucon represents at least initially the oligarchic man now in that beginning in book one when polemicus sends his slave to pull socrates and say look stay here socrates i mean i'm going to hold on until polemicus gets here and then they talk and say look we're a lot more of us than there are of you um this is about power and knowledge can you stay if we uh can you leave if we won't listen to your persuasion no well then we'll have a vote and we'll all vote that you will come with us polymercus is the democratic man and that's why they have that vote nothing happens by accident in a platonic dialogue if somebody votes it tells you something about them if he loses something whatever he's lost is symbolic of something if he has to go somewhere and do something whatever he's going to do that's symbolic of something everything is symbolic so when they have that little vote in the beginning that's tremendously important because it tells you what kind of souls we're dealing with we're in a democratic city and polemicus the guy who initiates this is the democratic man and it's not hard to figure out who the tyrannical man is it's thrasymachus right who says justice is the advantage of the stronger let's take control of the city and indulge ourselves”
The myth of Er concludes the Republic by placing a 'child-proof cap' on Platonic philosophy as a dangerous medicine, offering moral incentive through afterlife consequences for those who cannot grasp the pure logic of the earlier books.
“also it's true that platonism is potentially a very dangerous medicine that you don't want this to fall into just anyone's hands socrates never wrote a book he has very grave doubts about the written word so plato in writing these finishes the republic off and like many of the dialogues with a myth the point being that he's going to put something like a child proof cap on this dangerous medicine right you don't want kids getting into this don't do this at home kids if you didn't understand the 300 pages of my discussion about the form of the good and the divided line and the perfect city and the education of the guardians well here's a scary story for you to finish off”
The Form of the Good is like the sun: it generates being and reality, makes all other things visible and intelligible, is the one unique perfect universal object, and is fundamentally inexpressible in language—comparable to the unknowable nature of god stripped of personality and reduced to pure logical principle.
“you can't directly apprehend the sun but the sun makes everything else in the world visible and possible in some ways it generates being it generates no ability it is the one unique perfect universal object which somehow generates the reality of everything else so the form of the good which is what the philosopher king finds out about is like the sun”
There will be philosopher-queens as well as philosopher-kings because sex and body should make no difference if women show that they are wise, courageous, moderate, and just—since philosophy is about souls and minds, not bodies.
“and also i believe that the i mean the implications of platonic feminism are that there will be philosopher queens too in other words i can't see how the body is going to make much difference if they show that they're wise courageous moderate and just i don't think that sex is going to have very much to do with this this is about souls and minds this is not about bodies”
Socrates represents the philosopher-king and the most morally wise and intelligent person in the Republic dialogue, while Glaucon represents the next step down—a timocratic soul with homeric virtues and vices, closest in affinity to Socrates and most capable of being uplifted.
“it is important to note two things one that our interlocutors in this book have been these kinds of men this is often overlooked it is clear enough that socrates represents the philosopher king the good man the man of wisdom however you want to put that i mean even when the or even leaving the irony in there's no doubt that he's the morally best most intelligent man in the dialogue number two the democratic man glaucon is most brave in all things glaucon rushes in glaucon is interested in war glaucon is interested in sex glaucon has a really silver soul he has many of the homeric virtues but also some of the homeric vices and glaucon represents that next step down from socrates that's why it's most closely associated with socrates in the dialogue the democratic man has the greatest affinity to the philosopher why are they together at the very beginning because they have the most in common”