What this covers

Claudia Hauer of St. John's College and the Air Force Academy joins Russ Roberts to discuss her book Strategic Humanism, which argues that classical texts remain urgent guides for warfare and citizenship precisely because war's chaos cannot be systematized. The conversation weaves together ancient literature, military strategy, moral philosophy, and contemporary politics. Hauer contends that the emotional and psychological patterns in Homer—betrayal, withdrawal, grief cycles, rage—recur on modern battlefields, making the Iliad a practical witness to timeless patterns rather than historical artifact. The central claim is that [Aristotle](person:Aristotle)'s emphasis on judgment and moral deliberation is what technology and algorithms cannot replace, especially when warriors and citizens face the fog of war and the fog of life alike.

The discussion spans how democracies channel the human appetite for agon—the drive to contest—from violence into words and reason, how nations need a sustaining national narrative to act well, and how preemptive logic and the possession of destructive technology dangerously tempt policy makers into overreach. Hauer and Roberts examine the civil-military divide created by America's all-volunteer military system, the corrupting temptation of moral superiority in statecraft, and the paradox that technology narrows human choice while people remain drawn to hardship and meaningful struggle. They also contest how classical education should work—whether great texts should be rejected wholesale for their moral failures or engaged as architectures of ideas that reveal something worth learning. The dialectic method of seminar discussion itself becomes part of the argument, as a practice endangered in 2021 by demands for ideological purity.

Sharpest takeaway

Hauer argues that the ancient Greek classics remain timely rather than obsolete because war's madness cannot be reduced to rubrics or algorithms; the liberal arts and Aristotelian judgment are what prepare warriors and citizens to hold moral contradictions and exercise judgment that technology cannot replace.

  • War combines method and madness, and only exposure to the liberal arts addresses the madness side
  • Technology narrows human judgment and lets us offload thinking, eroding the moral arena Aristotle prized
  • The emotional cycles in the Iliad (betrayal, withdrawal, grief, berserk rage) are timeless patterns still seen in modern combat

The argument · threads4 threads · 33 claims
0.78

Partisan loyalty and moral superiority corrupt sound judgment and collective action.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Viewing everything through a partisan political lens is terribly destructive to improving the world, as shown by the COVID lab-leak hypothesis getting little traction partly because it was associated with Trump, even though understanding how a pandemic that killed many people began is obviously important and China's blocking of the WHO investigation is disturbing.

    “people were uneasy about that, because that was kind of Trump's idea: 'So, we can't go along with that.' And it just--oh, my gosh, we've so handicapped ourselves in thinking about how to improve the world, when everything has got to be viewed through that political lens.”

  • Holding the moral high ground tempts a nation into the dangerous idea that 'we're right, so whatever we do has to also be right' and 'if we have the tools, of course we should use them'—a logic that does not follow and is bound up with a dangerous strain of American exceptionalism that treats moral superiority as entitlement.

    “which is, 'We're right, so whatever we do has to also be right,' and, 'If we have the tools, of course, we should use them,' when in fact, that does not follow.”

  • Americans are increasingly deriving meaning from political combat and partisanship—satisfying both tribal urges and a need for moral superiority and a sense of victory—and this is a destructive way to channel the human appetite for contest, with large external consequences; healthier outlets like watching football would better satisfy the same urge.

    “we are increasingly getting a sense of meaning from political combat, from partisanship, both our tribal urge and a sense of, a need for moral superiority, a sense of victory.”

0.71

Nations and individuals require shared narratives and intellectual humility to act well.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A nation needs a national narrative—even a flawed, unfulfilled aspirational one like America's 1789 promise of equality and the pursuit of happiness—to act well; when that narrative is lost and people are merely arguing over what the next one should be, the resulting stasis and self-righteousness make it hard to act well, just as it does for individuals.

    “If you don't have a narrative you're proud of, at the national level, it's really hard to act well. That's true of us as individuals, I think, as we go through life”

  • Just as there is no rubric or algorithm that works in the fog of war, there is a fog of life as well; the human desire for life hacks and tricks to solve moral dilemmas and dangers is unsatisfiable, and the liberal arts function to sensitize us to the reality that no foolproof algorithm exists for resolving the situations we find ourselves in.

    “in the fog of war, there are no tricks. There is no rubric. There is no algorithm; and you have to have a sense of yourself and your environment and how they interact.”

  • The purpose of intellectual diversity on campus is not to assemble left- and right-wing views so you can pick the correct one—there probably isn't a single right view and all likely have flaws—but to entertain and engage other people's ideas in the spirit of dialectic, pursuing a deeper understanding of ourselves and the world rather than reaching a verdict.

    “the idea of diversity of ideas on campus isn't so you can figure out which one's right? It's not like, 'Oh, we need left-wing and right-wing views together, because that way you can pick the right one' That's not education.”

  • The modern Twitterverse habit of sorting thinkers into saints or sinners—acceptable or unacceptable lists—such that any praise of someone on the unacceptable list must be prefaced by condemnation, is a bad strategy for life; one should be able to learn from anyone who can teach you something and hold nuanced views, as one can admire Hayek while disagreeing with his case for socialized medicine.

    “in the modern debate, in the Twitterverse, there are all these people who they're either saints or sinners. They're on the acceptable list, or they're unacceptable.”

0.64

Humans seek meaning through contest and struggle, which can be channeled destructively or healthily.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Much of what makes humans feel alive is the messy world of challenge, suffering, and failure, so even as public policy raises living standards and reduces danger, some people will choose hardship for themselves; there is a tension between collective progress toward comfort and the individual human appetite for contest that we lack good ways of thinking about except through the humanities.

    “A lot of what makes us feel alive, I would argue, is that very messy world of challenge and suffering and failure.”

  • War, if you survive it, makes you feel alive and forges a camaraderie and brotherhood in a way few things can, comparable to but deeper than the bond between athletes in the trenches of football; one reason veterans don't talk about their experiences is guilt over how much they liked it despite the pain and suffering.

    “war if you survive it, makes you feel alive in a way that a few things do... after war--again, if you survived, that's an important footnote--you can't ever have anything quite like that again in your life.”

  • While an individual is free to turn the other cheek and absorb damage, a democracy cannot simply endure occasional terrorist attacks without response, because the public demands a response, and almost no response is fully discriminate; this is part of the cycle of human nature even though it produces moral discomfort.

    “In your own personal life, you're free to ignore damage from others and turn the other cheek. In a democracy, people tend to demand a response; and no response is discriminate--they're all indiscriminate, almost, by definition.”

0.29

Literature like the Iliad remains urgent for those confronting war and mortality.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Russ Roberts is a fan of the Odyssey and the Fagles translation but has not read the Iliad, finding on its surface that a blood-soaked killing epic doesn't seem worth reading.

    “I'm a big fan of the Odyssey, by Homer. I have not read the Iliad--shame on me.”

  • For people who have served in the army and confronted death and war—as nearly all Shalem students have—the Iliad is not ancient or vague but present and real; how to behave in war is very much on the minds of modern Israelis, making the Iliad not merely timeless but timely.

    “It's not like some distant vague thing like it is fortunately for people in the United States. It's very present... It's not ancient and old. Timeless isn't even the word for it: it's timely.”