
A History of Philosophy | 59 Hegel on Absolute Spirit
What this covers
This lecture, part of a Wheaton College history of philosophy series, takes up the last stretch of Hegel's system: absolute Spirit and the three forms through which it is expressed. The lecturer sets out two readings of Hegel common in the English-speaking world. One treats him as an Enlightenment rationalist doing speculative metaphysics in the manner of Descartes or Leibniz. The other, shaped by 20th-century phenomenology, treats him as a describer of consciousness. The lecture favors the second. Hegel is also called a process metaphysician, for whom God's self-knowledge is objectified in the world as history unfolds. The lecture adds that Hegel's "death of God" means the death of a picture of a transcendent deity, not the end of God. It also places this view in a longer tradition of Christian Platonism and panentheism, running from Plato through Neoplatonism to the Cambridge Platonists and John Milton.
The middle of the lecture distinguishes art, religion, and philosophy by their forms: images), symbols, and pure concepts. Art is valued as imaginative expression, and the German Bild is tied to imagination. Religion is shown through narrative, as in the Apostles' Creed, and through conceptual care, as in the Chalcedonian formula. Myth is defined as a story with religious meaning, whatever its historicity. Hegel objects to Schleiermacher's religion of dependence with the quip that the dog would then be the most religious creature. The lecture also covers objective Spirit as national self-consciousness through law and constitutions, and Hegel's progression from Oriental pantheism through Greek polytheism to Trinitarian Christianity.
The final section follows Hegel's aftermath. It covers the old and young Hegelians, the latter turning toward praxis. It also covers Lessing's ditch) and liberal theology, and Feuerbach's inversion of Hegel, in which God-consciousness becomes human self-consciousness. That inversion leads to Marx, historical materialism, and the "opiate" remark. The lecture closes with the Neo-Hegelians, among them the St. Louis School.
Hegel should be understood as a phenomenologist describing the evolving consciousness of being—both individual and divine—unfolding through history in art, religion, and philosophy, rather than as an 18th-century speculative metaphysician building a deductive system.
- Hegel's major work is titled 'Phenomenology of Mind,' indicating he describes phenomena of consciousness rather than proving metaphysical propositions
- Hegel traces consciousness of being across three domains—subjective Spirit (individual), objective Spirit (national/historical), and absolute Spirit (divine)—each expressed through art (images), religion (symbols), and philosophy (concepts)
- Divine consciousness unfolds in and through human creativity and self-consciousness across history, making the study of art, religion, and philosophy historical observation of absolute Spirit's manifestation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Hegel is a process metaphysician who understands God's self-knowledge not as God evolving, but as God's self-knowledge being objectified in the world God is creating in the course of the unfolding history of the universe.
“in as much as Hegel is um process metaphysician you see he's thinking of God's self- knowledge not of God as evolving but of God's self knowledge as being objectified in the world he's creating you see in the course of the unfolding history of the universe”
Hegel's concept of the 'death of God' refers to the death of the picture of a transcendent deity—a concept of God which dies in the unfolding history of religious thought.
“the death of the picture of a Transcendent deity uh that's a concept of God which dies in The unfolding history of religious thought”
Dialectical materialism is also known as historical materialism, which means a materialist interpretation of history—not materialism as a philosophical position from earlier history, but materialism as the key to understanding history as a sphere of practice and action.
“that is also known as and this is an important emphasis as historical materialism and um noce carefully what that means it does not mean materialism as it was throughout history the Marxist is not thinking of going back to an earlier philosophy at an earlier stage in history no historical materialism is a materialist interpretation of History ah a materialist interpretation of history is history is the sphere of practice of action and so you want a materialist interpretation of History so that you can tap into the action of History the practice”
The Apostles' Creed exemplifies religious language as narrative (the story of God the Father, Jesus Christ's birth, crucifixion, resurrection, and future judgment) while the Chalcedonian formula exemplifies theological language as careful conceptualization of the doctrine of the Trinity.
“the language of the calcedonian formula and the language of the preaching in the book of Acts you see um whom you Cru no the God who sent his son whom you crucified whom God raised from the dead that's the preaching of the book of Acts you see whereas the language of Caledon is rather and I said Caledon rather than Nia is a rather careful conceptualization of the three person of the Trinity you see”
Objective Spirit describes the way in which national self-consciousness arises through the concepts of Law and constitutional government, with national identity emerging through these institutional frameworks.
“talking of um objective Spirit he's talking of the way in which national self-consciousness arises in the light of the concept of Law and constitutional government national identity begins to emerge”
There is a historical tradition of Christian platonism and panentheistic Christian theology; Plato's idealism (where matter is non-being and physical particulars are manifestations of form) develops into neoplatonism (where forms are emanations from the One), and this neoplatonic tradition influenced medieval Christian theologians and Cambridge Platonists, including John Milton.
“there's a history though of Christian theologians or people writing at least matters of theology who are somewhat panentheistic that was true of um a certain amount of the Christian platonism that developed historically you remember the question in um discussion of Plato is he a dualist or an idealist now if he's an idealist matter is simply non-being has no existence so that physical particulars are simply manifestations of form”
In Hegel's system, once the synthesis is achieved (the complete concept of being), history does not end but continues with dialectical movements within the synthesis, with subsequent history being 'footnotes to Hegel' that flesh out the complete concept in detail.
“now once you get the complete synthesis the full concept of being all you're doing now is fleshing it out in detail that is to say the little dialectical movements within the synthesis”
Hegel has been interpreted in two fundamentally different ways in the English-speaking world: first as an 18th-century Enlightenment rationalist attempting speculative metaphysics in the style of Descartes or Leibniz; second, influenced by 20th-century phenomenology, as a phenomenologist describing the phenomena of consciousness.
“however with the growing influence in the 20th century of phenomenology in Europe um an alternative interpretation uh has developed”
In Hegel's view, myth is a story with religious meaning, and the term 'myth' does not judge the question of historical or non-historical—mythos is a story that has religious significance regardless of factual historicity.
“the term myth does not um judge the question of um historical or not historical Mythos is a story that has religious meaning”
History, as the activity of Divine Spirit, makes the study of history—particularly the history of art, religion, and philosophy—essential to understanding absolute Spirit, because the movement of the absolute becomes most evident in the history of these creative expressions.
“in as much as history as the activity of the Divine Spirit his discussion of art religion and philosophy is historical you see because it's in the history of these Creative Expressions that the movement of the absolute becomes most evident”
Hegel differentiates art, religion, and philosophy by the form of expression they use: art uses images (artistic images, visual images, verbal images like poetry), religion uses symbolic representation and pictorial representation, and philosophy uses the pure concept expressed through clear and distinct conceptual thought.
“he's the the four of the form in which the way in which um expression um finds articulation the the Arts are using images artistic images”
The German term 'Bild' (image) is cognate with imagination, which is the distinctive activity of the artist, involving not so much craft in applying pigments but imagination in coming up with images—thinking imaginatively in images.
“the German term built image now obviously the uh the term image is um cognate of imagination which is the distinctive activity of the artist not so much craft in um applying the pigments as imagination in coming up with the images thinking imaginatively that is to say in images”
The tremendous value of art is the expression of the human Spirit through imagination—the creative expression of consciousness of being in imaginative images.
“that's the tremendous view of art the expression of the human Spirit imagine in imagination um and accordingly as he uh traces out the um unfolding of the history of art uh you'll find that sort of thing um given an expression”
Above mere feelings of dependence, religion involves imagination (as in art) and symbolizing activity (religious stories about God as creator, maker, begetter), which means religious symbols carry significant meaning beyond just emotional feeling.
“you have the imagination involved in the Arts you have um the symbolizing activity involved in um religious stories um God is a son God begat God makes he creates he's Creator you see the symbolism of religion is going significant Beyond The Mighty acts of God in history”
Lessing's ditch is the logical gap between a historical statement (e.g., 'Jesus Christ died') and a statement about faith (e.g., 'He died for our sins'), which became one of the dominant issues in tensions between liberal and traditional theology in the late 19th and first half of the 20th century.
“there is a logical Gap a ditch between a historical statement and the statement about faith Jesus Christ died he died for our sins how do he get from the one to the other he rose from the dead he rose for our justification how do you get from one to the other you see and this was one of the um this became one of the dominant uh issues in the um tensions conflicts between liberal and traditional theology”
There are two ways of talking about the immediate influence of Hegel: in terms of left and right wings, where the left wing emphasizes the evolution of religion and its symbolic nature, spurring the development of liberal theology.
“there are two ways of talking about the immediate influence of Hegel one is in terms of the left and right wings of religion where the leftwing Lays emphasis on the evolution of religion the history of religion and the symbolic nature of religion and that left wing as you might gather from the name left really um Spurs the development of liberal theology”
Feuerbach inverted Hegel by claiming that man's God-consciousness is the self-consciousness of man (not God's self-consciousness), and that the concept of God is something humans project as an extension of their own self-consciousness.
“furar says man's God Consciousness is the self-consciousness of man and man's God Consciousness is the self-consciousness of man and so the idea of God the concept of God is something that we project as an extension of our own self-consciousness and we ascribe to God attributes that are symbolic of what we see ourselves to be”
When Karl Marx says religion is 'the opiate of the masses,' he is drawing on Feuerbach's notion that religion is a sublimation of our own ideals and desires that we project into a mythical being.
“when Carl Marx says that religion is the opiate of the masses what he's doing is drawing on what furbach says you see he's drawing on the notion that religion is um a form of um um sublimation of our own uh ideals desires for ourself that we project into a hypothetical mythical being”
The old Hegelians are more conservative in their interpretation, agreeing that Hegel brought philosophy to its finest hour and that Hegelian philosophy is probably the system to end all systems.
“the old hegelians are more conservative in their interpretation they agree that Hegel brought philosophy to its finest Hour 19th century evolutionary idealism you see that hegelian philosophy is probably the system to end all systems”
The young Hegelians wanted to leave to Hegel the theoretical philosophical conceptualization and system building, and turn to the praxis implicit within Hegelian thinking—aiming not to contemplate the world but to change it.
“the Young hegelians Who Um wanted to leave to Hegel the theoretical philosophical conceptualization the system building the theoretical work and turn to the kind of action that is implicit within hegel's thinking that is to say they wanted to turn more to prais to use the term that's current nowadays to turn to the prais implicit in hegelian thinking where the aim is not to contemplate the world but to change it”
Hegel criticizes Schleiermacher's definition of religion as a feeling of dependence on the all-encompassing absolute by arguing that the most religious of all creatures would then be the dog, showing that such a definition is phenomenologically impoverished.
“schl marker tended to Define religion in terms of a feeling of dependence on the all encompassing absolute to which Hegel responds if the feeling of dependence were the core of religion then the most religious of All Creatures is the dog um yeah even Hegel had something of a sense of humor uh his point being that obviously there is something phenomenologically arai in that description of religion um above feelings of dependence”
Ludwig Feuerbach was a materialist who combined Hegel's dialectic of self-consciousness with a materialistic interpretation of history, and was one of the primary influences shaping Karl Marx's thinking.
“Ludwig furar who is one of the people I've asked you to read some selections from for this week uh very Vivid uh furar is um one of the primary influences in shaping the thinking of KL mark that is to say furar was a materialist uh a materialist who combined hegel's dialectic of self-consciousness with a materialistic interpretation of history”
In Hegel's history of religion, there is a progression from Oriental religion (largely pantheist—everything is one) through Greek religion (polytheistic with many finite deities as antithesis) to Christian religion (trinitarian—three-in-one, combining infinity of God with finite expression of deity, incarnate in history).
“religious expression from Oriental religion which was largely pantheist everything is one to Greek religion which is polytheistic there's the antithesis there are many deities finite deities to the Christian religion which is trinitarian three in one and one in three combining the Infinity of God with the finite expression of the deity infinite Spirit incarnate in all in his of History”
According to Feuerbach, theology becomes a failed exercise in psychology and anthropology—the essence of religion is the relationship of man to man, and this became a main source for religious humanism, where religion is reduced to the pursuit of human ideals.
“theology really becomes simply a failed exercise in Psychology and anthropology simply that the essence of religion is the relationship of man to man and um that in furbach is one of the main sources for religious humanism as that developed in the 19th and on into the early 20th century that is to say a humanistic religion such as you are often find in the Unity Church um where religion is reduced indeed to um uh pursuit of human ideals”
From a Marxist perspective, the place to address human need is not in religion but in addressing the material conditions of human existence—the story of Marxism.
“and human need and the place to address human need is not in religion but there's the story of Marxism uh”
There was an extensive Neo-Hegelian movement throughout Europe, particularly centered in Oxford in Britain, and in St. Louis in the United States, becoming known as the St. Louis School.
“was an extensive Neo heelan movement in uh throughout Europe certainly in Britain it took over Oxford in this country uh in this country uh it was particularly centered in St Louis and became known as the St Louis School”
When reading Hegel, one should not look for him to prove things in an old-fashioned deductive way or treat the work as a speculative system without grounding; instead, his discussion relies on introspective observation (of consciousness) and historical observation (of cultural and religious development) throughout.
“don't look for him to prove things in the old fashion don't look at this as a speculative system with no grounding in observation it's introspective observation or historical observation all the way up”
Philosophy expresses consciousness through the pure concept—philosophers attempt to avoid metaphor, imagery, and story in order to conceptualize truth directly with clear and distinct abstract thought, dealing with concepts of being rather than pictures or stories about being.
“it is in um philosophy that you find the pure concept as the form of expression um the philosopher in his analysis of Concepts tries to avoid metaphor imagery story and to conceptualize with clear and distinct thought you see that's the function of philosophy dealing with the the bth the concept of being not picture stories about not images of but conceptualizing in a non sensory way”
The thesis-antithesis-synthesis dialectic is not a rigid three-stage hierarchy where each stage replaces the previous one; rather, it is an organic developmental process where thesis logically entails antithesis, and thesis and antithesis together produce synthesis which preserves and cancels out what has gone before, as seen in biological growth (child→adult→elder) and botanical cycles (seed→plant→new seed).
“it's not exactly a hierarchy it's not a case of a serial business where the second replaces the first and the third replaces the second no uh the relationship between thesis and antithesis is that in the dialectic the thesis logically entails an antithesis you see and the thesis and antithesis together produce the synthesis which both uh preserves and cancels out what's gone before”
Panentheism appears to be a logically unstable position because theists can be reduced logically to pantheists, meaning panentheism (God is more than everything) requires grounding that may be difficult to maintain.
“there are others who can be reduced logically to theists but in itself it's an unstable position”
Hegel describes consciousness of being at three distinct levels: individual consciousness (one's own consciousness of being), societal/national consciousness (a nation's consciousness of its being), and absolute consciousness (the all-inclusive divine consciousness of its being).
“your own consciousness of being at perhaps the societal level a nation's consciousness of its being and in the case of the absolute the all-inclusive the absolute consciousness of its being”
The history of art unfolds dialectically from Egyptian art (religious, symbolic) to classical art (rational, harmonious, orderly) to romantic art (imagination overflowing rational order), showing art's progressive self-understanding and conscious development.
“he moves from for instance Egyptian art which was more religious and symbolic uh to um a classical art which has more emphasis on rational Harmony and Order to romantic art which overflows the order in its imaginative expression there's an unfolding of it as art finds its own self- understanding conscious being”
Religion, at least Christian religion, is the relation of man to his own nature: the divine nature is nothing else than human nature freed from individual limits and made objective, so all divine attributes are human attributes projected outward.
“religion at least the Christian is the relation of man to himself to his own nature the Divine thing is nothing else than the human being the human being freed from the limits of the individual and made objective contemplated and revered as another distinct being all the attributes of divine nature are therefore attributes of human nature”
Only when we abandon theology as distinct from psychology and anthropology and recognize anthropology as itself theology do we attain true identity of the divine and human, meaning the dissolution of theology into psychology.
“only when we abandon theology distinct from psychology and anthropology and recognize anthropology as itself theology do we attain to a true self-satisfying identity of the Divine and the human being the identity of the human being with itself”
God's self-consciousness is objectified in God's thinking of the natural world, and in the medieval theological tradition, all of nature images the manifold perfection of the deity, so that in contemplating nature we are drawn to contemplate God's perfection, and God in contemplating his handiwork is contemplating himself.
“God's self-consciousness is objectified in um shall we say his um thinking of the world of nature which he has created you see and certainly in the medieval tradition if all of nature in some way was Imaging the manifold Perfection of the deity if we contemplating nature are drawn to contemplate the Perfection of God then certainly God in contemplating his handiwork is contemplating himself”
The only way to know anything about divine consciousness is through creation, and therefore what remainder of divine consciousness might exist beyond creation cannot be known.
“the only other comment I can make I think is this that if we are to know anything about the Divine Consciousness it can only be through the creation and if it can only be through the creation then what that remainder of Consciousness left over is we've no way of knowing”
There is an inevitable dialectic between religious and theological expression: the theologian works toward conceptualization, steps back into worship to sing hymns with religious imagery and symbolism, listens to theological prayer that includes both religious and conceptual dimensions—and this tension is inevitable if conceiving of Christian religion as involving personal relationship.
“there is sort of a dialectic that goes on between religious and Theological EXP you see the Theologian works for the conceptualization then he steps back into his worship and sings the hymns with all of the imagery and symbolism of popular religion yeah and listen to the Theologian prey you see and his prayers all often include the religious as distinct from the conceptualization yeah and I think that that's inevitable if you conceive of Christian religion as having to do with personal relationship”
Personal relationship requires narrative and story, not just conceptualization, so talking about a personal God and relationship to a personal God cannot avoid the story dimension, because the way we speak about persons and relationships is in terms of story.
“I think that there is a story Dimension that's necessary in talking of a personal God and a relationship to a personal God particularly when he's known because of the way in which he has acted you can't avoid the story um okay”
Divine intervention stories (such as the Exodus or incarnation) should be understood as symbolic rather than as strictly historical events, with the question being what within the conceptual scheme the symbol represents.
“he'd say um any story of divine intervention is symbolic now the question is uh what within the conceptual scheme is it symbolic of you see so if um you regard the Incarnation as an intervention or some miraculous deed as an intervention The Exodus from Egypt as an intervention”
Philosophy is trying to conceptualize what religion is symbolizing, which is why the history of philosophy finds its culmination in Hegelian idealism with panentheistic being—because this is the truest conceptualization of what religion has been symbolizing.
“philosophy is trying to conceptualize what religion is symbolizing which is why the history of philosophy Finds Its culmination in a heelan kind of idealism with a panentheistic being because this is the truest conceptualization of what religion has and symbolizing”
The doctrine of biblical inerrancy is an attempt to reinforce emphasis on the historicity of biblical stories, making sure the historical dimension is significant to faith rather than losing it in symbolic interpretation.
“the inherency business is simply an attempt um to my mind to uh reinforce emphasis on the historicity of the story you see that's why it's significant”
Hegel regards himself as a Lutheran Christian and takes the calcedonian formulation of the doctrine of the Trinity seriously, though it is questionable whether he accepts the traditional interpretation of the Chalcedon formula as the speaker doubts Hegel would accept it in its intended form.
“Hegel thought of himself as a Christian Theologian um my guess is he would have difficulty taking uh the calcedonian formulation of the doctrine of the Trinity um in its um intended form seriously”