
Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Plato and Poetry
What this covers
This lecture from Michael Sugrue's Great Authors series takes up an apparent contradiction in the Republic. Plato places art at the bottom of the divided line), below physical objects and the eternal forms, and he accuses Homer of miseducating the young with wrathful, violent heroes. Yet the dialogues are full of poetry and myth. The lecture argues that these are complementary: because Plato recognizes poetry's power over souls, he tries to replace bad poetic influences with good ones, and he distinguishes between censoring all poetry and admitting only what benefits the young.
The middle of the talk walks through the myths one at a time. It covers the cave, with its painful ascent toward the sun, which stands in for the form of the good, the analogy being a ladder that can be discarded once climbed. It covers Gyges' ancestor and the ring of invisibility, read as a compact set of symbols for miseducation, with the bronze horse invoking Homer. It covers the myth of the metals, and the myth of Er, in which the afterlife and the choice of a next life persuade the philosophically unfit that they are responsible for their choices. Homeric heroes choosing predatory animal lives there serves as a last jab at Homer. Socrates is treated as Plato's greatest poetic construct, a philosophical hero set against the epic and tragic heroes. The talk also notes that Socrates wrote verse, a hymn to Apollo and Aesop's fables, before his execution.
The contentious part is the claim that every system rests on an unprovable axiom, as in Euclid, so myth is necessary rather than ornamental. On this reading the metals myth states human inequality dogmatically, as a "noble lie," and the lecture compares it with the modern myth of equality. Both are presented as pragmatic choices judged by their behavioral consequences rather than by literal truth. Plato's myths, in this account, also shield readers who lack philosophical capacity from dangerous implications.
Plato employs poetry and myth strategically throughout his dialogues despite his philosophical critique of poetry, using myths as pedagogical tools to communicate axiomatic truths, protect vulnerable readers from misunderstanding, and motivate moral behavior across different intellectual capacities.
- Myths serve as propedeutic devices that guide less philosophically sophisticated readers toward philosophical truth without requiring logical demonstration of axioms
- All systematic thought requires unprovable foundational axioms, making myths a necessity rather than optional—Plato recognizes this and uses poetic construction to convey what cannot be rationally demonstrated
- Plato judges myths by their behavioral consequences rather than literal truth-value: a 'good myth' produces virtuous behavior regardless of whether it is literally factual
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Because every philosophical system requires unprovable axioms, the choice between different axioms (like Plato's assumption of human inequality vs. modern assumption of human equality) cannot be made on rational grounds; instead, the choice is made pragmatically based on anticipated consequences for behavior and social order.
“we have some dispute about what we think would result in good behavior but our reason for holding on to one myth or the other turns out to be quite the same”
The fact that the entire Platonic dialogues are shot through with poetry and myth despite Plato's ontological devaluation of art (placing art at the lowest level of the divided line) reveals that Plato recognizes poetry's power and effectiveness, and therefore strategically uses poetry to advance philosophical understanding.
“how then do we find so much poetry in plato in others what's all this stuff doing there you would imagine that somebody that liked math as much as socrates and plato appear to and disapprove or at least devalue poetry to such a great extent would give you a books full of theorems would give you things like the theorem of pythagoras would give you geometry or some other really existing thing some formal knowledge at the very least it would be dialectic which leads you to ultimate truth and ultimate knowledge about the forms and yet the platonic dialogues are shot through with poetry”
Because all systematic thought—mathematical, political, moral, epistemological, and ontological—requires unprovable foundational axioms that cannot be demonstrated through reason, myths are not optional but necessary: they are the means by which foundational assumptions can be communicated persuasively to those who cannot grasp them through pure logic.
“plato had great admiration for the achievements of geometry and he had great admiration for mathematics as being a kind of real knowledge of real mathematical entities but if you've ever studied math and i assume that most of us have you notice that even euclid when he begins his elements starts by stating certain axioms and axioms don't get proven they just plain get stated... you can't prove axioms they are prior to rational proof well that's not just true about mathematical systems it's also true about political systems it's true about moral systems it's true about epistemological systems it's true about ontological systems”
The myth of the metals parallels modern societies' foundational myth of human equality: just as Plato asserted human inequality based on his assessment of what would produce good outcomes, modern societies assert human equality based on the judgment that this belief produces better behavior and society, despite the empirical inequality of human capacities—both are pragmatic choices about which myth serves the good, not literal truths.
“our basic myth about our society is that people are equal we allow for equality before the law and things like that but is that a literal factor is that one of the myths we've we've accepted... what we mean is that they're equal before the law where this actually comes from as a matter of historical fact is the idea that all souls are equal in the sight of god right it's a judeo-christian myth”
The greatest of Plato's poetic constructs is Socrates himself, who functions as the philosophical hero replacing the tragic and epic heroes of previous literature; Socrates embodies reason, insight, virtue, and the obligation to improve others rather than gratify individual passions.
“the greatest of plato's poetic constructs is i would say socrates and socrates is very interesting things to say about poetry”
The form of the good cannot be directly apprehended or spoken about, just as the sun illuminates everything else but cannot be looked at directly; Plato acknowledges that the analogy 'the good is like the sun' is not illuminating in itself but serves as a ladder to climb toward understanding, which can be discarded once one reaches philosophical insight.
“we really can't talk about the form of the good i mean it's the source of all reality and the source of all knowledge and all kinds of great stuff but you can't say a great deal about the form of the good you get immediate apprehension of it perhaps when you have that ultimate philosophical insight but the fact of the matter is it's hard to talk about any kind of sensible way it's like theologians trying to talk about god good luck what plato says is that you know even though we all agree that there is some such thing as the sun and the sun is what when we go outside if the sun is what informs us about the facts of the world because we you know it illuminates the world for us we can't look directly at the sun”
Platonic myths form a coherent ring of teaching, moving from one myth to another and creating a unified network of symbolic representations that communicate Plato's philosophical doctrines through poetic means while the literal dialectical arguments proceed in the foreground.
“the important dialogues have some sort of myth in them and they move from one to another they kind of form a coherent ring of platonic teaching which is given in both a literal sense in many of the back and forth dialectics but also given a poetic representation some of the time in various passages from these dialogues”
In the cave myth, philosophical truths initially seem unbelievable and strain credulity, just as sunlight hurts the eyes of someone emerging from darkness; but gradual habituation to philosophical insight leads to permanent conviction that cannot be shaken by skeptics or the crowd's denial.
“we often don't believe the first results of our philosophical inquiries it sounds too queer it sounds too strange it makes too great a strain on our on our credulity plato says well this is like a man who's lived in a cave all his life coming out into the sunshine and the lights hurt his eyes... he says well we squint a little bit and it takes some getting used to but after you start thinking about it you become accustomed to the real light you would never trade the realm of reality the realm of philosophical insight and light for the darkness and shadows no matter how many people are down there no matter how many people tell you you are wrong”
The myth of Gyges' ancestor illustrates how a shepherd who finds a magic ring that grants invisibility uses it to commit murder, adultery, and usurpation; this myth is propedeutic, compact with symbolism (gold representing philosophical insight, bronze representing material ignorance, the hollow horse representing bad education), and teaches that miseducation leads to inversion of proper order and immoral behavior.
“gaiji's ancestor gaijis was a lydian was a shepherd for the king and he took care of the sheep and he was out in the field one day there was an earthquake and the earth opened up and he saw down at the bottom and when he went down to investigate a hollow bronze horse which was hollowed out... inside he saw the body of a hero and on that hero's hand there was a gold ring and gaiji's ancestor stole this gold ring... when he turned it back to front when he turned the collet around towards the inside of his hand it made him invisible as a consequence of that iges was able to go back to the king of lydia make himself invisible have sex with the king's wife kill the king and become the king of lydia”
The myth of Gyges' ancestor contains multiple layers of symbolism that only become clear after reading the entire Republic multiple times: the descent represents miseducation, the bronze horse invokes Homer as a bad educator, the gold ring stolen inverts proper order, and the subsequent moral corruption illustrates how miseducation leads to vice.
“you really can't understand plato's republic until you've read it three or four five times i mean the first time you go through this since you haven't gotten to the myth of the cave yet you haven't gotten to the divided line and the myth of the medals you really can't completely understand this but when you go back and look at that myth of gaijis it is very clear that what he is saying is that this will lead you on to the right path”
No philosophical system can start from pure reason without presuppositions; all systems require foundational axioms (like Euclid's postulates in geometry) that cannot be proven and must be accepted dogmatically or persuasively through myth.
“plato is very well aware of the fact that there is no such thing as presuppositionless thought in other words we can't bootstrap ourselves into the stratosphere where the forms are kept without making certain assumptions without taking things as axiomatic”
In Plato's ontological hierarchy (the divided line), the form of the good sits at the top as the source of all being and reality; below it are the eternal forms; below that are physical objects in space and time; and at the very bottom are representations and imitations, including all works of art, which are therefore the least real and furthest from truth.
“in the platonic hierarchy in other words plato has a very detailed and complicated conception of ontology ontology as i said before speech about beings it's the kind of quality that different beings have and it's found in the republicans something called the divided line and at the top of this hierarchy we find uh the form of the good which is a source of all being and the source of all reality below that are the forms and forms our pure essences of the individual things that we encounter here in the world of space and time”
The myth of the cave presents the unphilosophical human condition as imprisonment in darkness watching shadows on a wall, with the philosophical journey as a painful ascent toward light and the form of the good (analogized to the sun), which is the source of all reality and knowledge but cannot be directly apprehended or spoken about.
“plato says that the unphilosophic human condition is like a person who is stuck in a dark cave and they're chained by the neck and chained by the legs so they can't take their eyes off a screen on a wall of the cave behind them there is a fire and there are certain people who bring out objects which cast shadows on the wall and these poor wretched benighted people in the cave believe these shadows to be reality”
In the myth of the metals, Plato presents fundamental inequality of human souls as an axiom that cannot be demonstrated but must be stated dogmatically; he wraps this axiom in a myth to make it acceptable and to prevent the philosophically unfit from grasping its full implications and rejecting social order.
“the point of course is to under to first of all assert the basic axiom of platonic politics and platonic ethics and platonic epistemology which is that souls are basically not equal now you could assume either some systems like the system that we have today is that there's we assume the equality of all people plato wants to assume the opposite but whatever you assume there's no way of demonstrating that souls are not equal”
Plato uses myths in his dialogues to serve different functions: protecting stupid or unphilosophical people from misunderstanding by providing 'true opinion' (which produces correct behavior) when rational knowledge is inaccessible to them; protecting readers who lack philosophical capacity from the dangerous implications of philosophical arguments; providing propedeutic (preparatory) guidance toward philosophical understanding; and expressing the unprovable axioms that must underlie any philosophical system.
“one function would be to protect stupid people from themselves in other words perhaps you don't have the ability or perhaps you're just a child or perhaps you're just your character is vicious there are a number of possible contingencies in which a person may not be fertile ground for the platonic teachings... if you can't give them knowledge is to give them what plato would call true opinion which is like knowledge it'll get them to behave as if they had knowledge but all they'll have is the shadow or the semblance or the imitation of knowledge”
Plato's critique of Homer in the Republic, his fear of poetry's miseducative power, and his use of myths in his dialogues are not contradictory but complementary: Plato recognizes poetry's power to shape souls and therefore seeks to control that power by replacing bad poetic influences (Homeric heroes) with good poetic influences (philosophical myths and the Socratic dialogue).
“why should the devil have all the good poetry why shouldn't the good guys have good poetry once in a while if it does the job well let's have poetry on our side if it advances the cause of philosophic insight”
Plato accuses the poets, particularly Homer, of being dangerous miseducators of youth in the Republic because Homer's depiction of wrathful, passionate, violent heroes encourages young men to emulate destructive behavior rather than pursue philosophical virtue and moral wisdom.
“plato thought that homer had had a bad effect on greek culture in the sense that homer miseducated young men to try and become something like the homeric heroes heroes of wrath heroes of passion men of violence rather than men of philosophical morality and philosophical virtue”
Socrates, facing death, wrote poetry just before his execution—specifically a hymn to Apollo and Aesop's fables in verse—because he received a divine dream instructing him to 'study poetry, practice and cultivate the arts,' and he feared disobeying divine injunctions more than he feared death itself.
“just before his death socrates wrote poetry and that's written by plato i mean it's not a matter of historical fact actually it's found in the dialogues that are that come just before the death of socrates particularly in the phaedo socrates says that he had a dream and that in his dream he was told socrates study poetry practice and cultivate the arts”
Plato distinguishes between censoring all poetry and allowing poetry that properly educates youth, aiming to restrict youth access only to poetry and myths that benefit their souls while preventing exposure to corrupting poetic traditions.
“it's not that plato necessarily disapproves of poetry because he himself is one of the great poets of ancient greece in fact what he wants to do is allow for a certain kind of poetry poetry which properly educates youth and on the other hand limit that the access of youth to poetry limit limit the access of youth to poetry that is good for their souls that will give them a good education”
The myth of Er presents the afterlife as a place of rewards and punishments proportional to one's goodness or badness in life, followed by reincarnation in which each soul chooses the life it will live next; the myth's purpose is to persuade the philosophically unfit that their choices have moral consequences and responsibility cannot be avoided.
“er was a man who died and came back most of the great world religions have somebody like this or a couple of people like this maybe a whole bunch of people but he comes back and tells us about the afterlife... er found out that after you die you go to a place of rewards and punishments and everybody's requited tenfold for their goods and their evils and if you were good in life then you get supreme bliss and if you are bad in life you get supreme you get the appropriate torment”
The myth of the metals teaches that souls are inherently unequal in capacity—some are gold (rational), some silver (spirited), some bronze (appetitive)—and this inequality is presented as a 'noble lie': not literally true, but necessary for social stability and justified because people do in fact have different aptitudes for different social roles.
“in the myth of the medals what socrates says is that we are going to teach in our ideal city we're going to raise the gold the silver and the bronze children the children with gold that have the appetite souls and the spirited souls and the rational souls the children who are going to become guardians and auxiliaries and common people in their public craftsmen and artisans and farmers”
Aesop's fables, which Socrates turned to verse before death and which modern societies tell to children, are morally educative myths: they are not literally true (there is no actual tortoise-and-hare race), but they effectively teach virtues like diligence and perseverance, and this pragmatic benefit justifies the use of the fiction.
“other myths which are quite benign and we believe and we still give to our children aesop's fables remember that socrates when he was in prison just before he died could have chosen any fictional any lie any poetic myth to turn into verse he chooses aesop's fables why because they have a morally educative point they're didactic”
Homeric heroes (like Achilles) choose to become predatory animals (lions, eagles) when given the chance to reincarnate in the Er myth, reflecting Plato's persistent critique of Homer as promoting violent, bestial rather than philosophical virtues.
“homeric heroes silver men great spirited men it turns out choose the life of predatory animals another dig at homer he never lets up on homer he's so jealous achilles decides to become a lion and i think ajax becomes an eagle”
Plato acknowledges that not everyone is capable of philosophical insight and therefore not everyone should be expected to understand his dialogues literally; he provides myths as accessible truths for those without philosophical capacity, allowing them to behave virtuously without understanding the philosophical reasoning.
“not all the meaning is going to be accessible to everyone not everyone is called to be a philosopher not everyone has that gold in their soul which gives them the potential to truly understand the platonic teachings”
Plato's use of the phrase 'I think the truth might be something like this' or 'it seems' before introducing myths signals to the philosophically sophisticated that the myth is persuasive, not demonstrative, and the reader should not take it as literal truth but as propedeutic guidance.
“plato even though he uses quite a few myths never mistakes myth for reality in other words plato doesn't say at the end of the republic that er is a real guy is a real man who came back down to earth and you know had seen the fate of people who die and things like that he says i think the truth might be something like this now whenever plato understates his case he's waving a flag towards the philosophically sophisticated saying look this isn't conclusive it's just meant to be persuasive”
Plato judges whether a myth is good or bad based not on its literal truth-value or logical coherence, but on its behavioral consequences: a good myth produces virtuous behavior regardless of factual accuracy, while a bad myth produces harmful behavior; the criterion is pragmatic and moral, not epistemic.
“our judgment of whether we want to accept or reject a myth will come on a couple of different grounds the first ground will be whether it's adequate to our experience of the world another ground will be whether it's logically continuous with the other things that we know and the final and most important ground for judging myth is how do we anticipate people will behave if they believe this myth a good myth is one that gets people to do good stuff and a bad myth is one that gets people to do bad stuff”
The Platonic dialogue, as a literary form, represents a philosophical innovation: a new poetic genre that moves beyond epic and tragedy to create a 'philosophical hero' (Socrates) who embodies reason, insight, and moral improvement rather than the wrathful passion and violence of Homeric and tragic heroes.
“plato was such a profound and gifted poet that he was able to construct a new kind of poetic mode or a poetic genre called the socratic dialogue”
Plato's accusers made the same argument against Socrates that Plato later makes against the poets: that he corrupted youth by making them disbelieve traditional gods and harming their souls; Plato turns this accusation around in the Republic by charging that the real corrupters of youth are the poets, not the philosophers.
“the argument that plato made in the republic has been criticized by many people... the argument that plato makes about the homeric heroes about the tragic heroes about the epic and tragedy which had been so important a part of the artistic life of greece is exactly the same argument that the accusers of socrates made against him socrates was condemned to death because it was said that he corrupted the youth of athens and that it made them disbelieve in the traditional gods... plato turns that around in the republic when he talks about censoring the poets and limiting the myths that the young the children will get and he says no the real corrupters of youth are these poets”
Although Plato devalues poetry within his ontological hierarchy and criticizes it as dangerous miseducation, he acknowledges that poetry is a powerful force—'a moderately helpful friend and a very dangerous enemy'—and therefore the true philosopher wants to control and direct poetry toward good ends rather than eliminate it.
“plato acknowledges the power and significance of poetry while it is potentially very dangerous and might mis-educate people it is at least a moderately helpful friend and a very dangerous enemy so the true philosopher is going to want poetry on his side he just wants it tamed and sort of house broken so it doesn't make a mess of his philosophical system”
The Platonic dialogues are written in a deliberately obscure, multi-layered style with meanings embedded beneath meanings, creating protection against misunderstanding: philosophically dangerous ideas are veiled so that the philosophically weak or evil cannot grasp them fully and misapply them, while the philosophically sophisticated can read beneath the surface.
“the platonic dialogues are written in an intentionally obscure multi-layered style in other words there are meanings below meanings and within meanings it's like peeling an onion and not all the meaning is going to be accessible to everyone”
An apocryphal but instructive story claims that Plato met Socrates after writing a cycle of tragedies for religious festival competitions, and after discussing tragedy with Socrates, Plato burned his tragedies and never wrote tragedy again, signifying Socrates' deep influence and the philosophical rejection of tragic form.
“it's said that plato first made the acquaintance of socrates after he'd written a cycle of tragedies and he wanted to enter these tragedies in the competition that they held during religious festivals and he wanted to win the prize for tragedy and socrates had already always been rather critical of tragedy and epic and the influence of poetry on society so it's alleged the story is apocryphal that they had a dialogue that they talked to each other and that plato read him some of these tragic poems and that after reading the tragedies to socrates and talking with socrates about the nature of tragedy apparently he went home and burned his tragedies and never wrote tragedy again”
Oaths sworn in court before God (the 'ancient god of the Semites') are useful myths that improve judicial processes by making testimony more reliable, even though the belief that God supervises and punishes perjury may not be literally true; the pragmatic benefit justifies the ritual.
“we swear people in they're going to give testimony in a court of law we asked the the ancient god the the sky daddy the ancient god of the semites to come down and supervise the giving of this testimony it doesn't follow from that that i want people not to be sworn in i think swearing people in probably does a certain amount of good to our judicial processes but it doesn't really follow that i believe that god is watching them and he's going to strike them dead or some such thing you see what i think it's a useful myth”
Santa Claus is a useful myth parents tell children in early December to motivate virtuous behavior (eating vegetables, being good) by promising rewards; the myth is justified pragmatically despite being factually false because it achieves its behavioral goal of improving child conduct.
“in the early part of december all over america or not all over but in many parts of america at dinner tables mothers and fathers tell their children that if the kids don't eat their spinach santa claus isn't coming he only comes for good girls and boys who eat their spinach and it doesn't follow that i believe that santa is a literal thing but it seems to me a useful myth in order to get kids to eat their spinach and if they eat their spinach since they're getting toys at christmas anyway why not tell them that santa only brings toys to good girls and boys if it does the job if it improves the hearer if it has that pragmatic advantage well then it's a good myth”