
What this covers
This lecture is the fourth in a university history-of-philosophy series, delivered by a lecturer at Wheaton College. It follows Plato's attempt to answer the relativism of the presocratics and the sophists, for whom each person is the measure of all things. The lecturer builds the account from the Meno, Phaedo, Symposium and Republic. The argument runs from why sense perception cannot give stable knowledge, since it depends on the state of the organs and on objects that are constantly changing, to what can. The answer is dialectic, which the lecturer describes as thinking a matter through to a conclusion true of all times and places. A dialectician can give an account of an essence and withstand every objection. The lecture also argues that empirical generalization across cases only finds similarities, some of them incidental.
The lecture then turns to the metaphors that carry the theory. The cave allegory and the sun analogy are read alongside the divided line, with its ranks of awareness. Mathematics ranks above sense perception but below dialectic, because it must assume its first principles without proving them. The Phaedo's two equal sticks and its arguments for the soul's pre-existence support the claim that learning is recollection). The lecturer also notes that full vision of the ultimate reality comes only at death.
Several side-turns are worth noting. The Meno leaves an ambiguity: the sophists cannot teach virtue, yet virtuous civic leaders seem to fail at it too, so moral development involves more than knowing what virtue is. The Symposium's eros is presented as a broad desire for the good, the true and the beautiful, and it resolves a circle in which one must already know what one loves. The lecture ends on reception. It covers Platonism's long dominance in Christian theology until roughly 1100–1200, and the early church's dispute over the soul's origin. It closes with Alan Bloom's complaint about relativism in the modern university and his proposed return to the great books as a kind of informal dialectic.
Plato's epistemology resolves the sophistic skepticism inherited by Socrates by positing two realms of being—the intelligible realm of unchanging universal forms knowable through dialectic, and the sensible realm of changing particulars accessible only through opinion—and arguing that knowledge requires transcending sense perception through recollection of innate ideas via dialectical reasoning.
- Sense perception yields only variable, relative opinions about changing particulars, not reliable knowledge of unchanging truths
- Dialectic is the method that enables recollection of innate knowledge from a previous existence and ascent to first principles
- The divided line and cave allegory depict two distinct realms with correspondingly different modes of awareness: illusion, sense perception, mathematical reasoning, and dialectical knowledge
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
True opinion based on sense experience, even when accurate, remains unreliable and unstable unless it is tethered or anchored by dialectic—like a horse that will wander away if loose, true opinion may suffice for practical daily tasks but requires dialectical grounding for genuine knowledge.
“true opinion may be all right for practical purposes like avoiding chariots while you cross the street maybe all right for the daily tasks in world of particulars but it uh it really needs tethering that's it like a horse that'll wander away if it's loose it needs tethering and the thing to tether an opinion is dialectic”
There is a paradoxical dilemma in Plato's account: to grasp the vision of the Good and the Beautiful, one must love them, but to love something, one must already see or know it; this vicious circle is resolved only through an unsatisfied hunger and desire (eros) that draws one toward what one does not yet fully comprehend.
“in a way there's a vicious circle if only you could grasp the vision of The Good The Beautiful in it's ideal in principle grasp it with your mind you would love it yeah but how can I grasp it if I don't love it get the Vicious Circle it takes love to see with the eye of the mind but how can I love what I don't see unless there is a unsatisfied hunger I deser and Eros in that sense”
Empirical generalization across particular cases does not yield knowledge of the essence of a thing; it only identifies similarities, some of which may be incidental or unnecessary—genuine knowledge requires thinking abstractly in abstraction from all particulars about the essential nature of things.
“dialectic is not empirical generalization across a lot of particular cases empirical generalization doesn't get you to the essence of the thing only to similarities some of which may be very incidental and unnecessary so you have to get beyond the sense perception and the empirical generalization to thinking abstractly in abstraction from all of those particulars about the essential nature of things”
The appeal of Platonism to Christian thought follows from Plato's emphasis on the eternal, immaterial realm and his opposition to relativism and sophistic skepticism—these features made Platonic philosophy compatible with and useful for Christian theology.
“you can see its appeal right away”
The fundamental epistemological problem Plato inherits from the presocratic period and the sophists is the question of whether we can achieve genuine knowledge that transcends relative, changing opinions about both cosmology and moral order, or whether we are trapped in skepticism where every person is the measure of all things.
“whether we take the scientific cosmology approach or the moral order approach the same questions about knowledge versus skepticism develop in the sophists and of course in Socrates attempt to counter the thinking of the sophists now Plato inherits that debate from Socrates”
Dialectic is associated with recollection (reminiscence) because the way dialectic uncovers what is true works like recollecting something forgotten—as you describe details and circumstances, the forgotten memory comes back to you; similarly, dialectic enables the recall of unchanging truths known in a previous existence of the soul.
“in uh speaking of um dialectic he often um Associates it as well with what he calls recollection reminiscence because the way in which dialectic uncovers what is true is very much like the way in which you recollect something which you have forgotten you know the way that goes you you simply don't remember meeting such and such an individual but then as I describe the individual tell you certain of her mannerisms and perhaps start um describing the occasion when you met oh it begins to as we say come back and while it's not initially clear you say oh yes now I be to remember to recollect”
In the Symposium, the Greek word 'eros' refers to love as desire in general, not exclusively to sexuality as the term has become narrowed in modern usage; Plato uses 'eros' to denote love of the good, desire to know what is true, love of wisdom, and love of beauty.
“the word that he's using is the word AOS desire now the word Eros and its um cognates erotic in our day have narrowed down in their reference to sexuality but not so among the Greeks AOS was simply the kind of love that wants that desires and when he talks of an Aeros for the good it means love of what is good a desire to know what's good love of Truth a desire to know what's true you see a love of wisdom a love of beauty”
The visual metaphor 'seeing with the eye of the mind' is not merely metaphorical but captures genuine intellectual experience: mathematical reasoning and abstract thinking involve a kind of 'seeing' or comprehension that is not sensory but intellectual.
“you think you're following a um mathematical proof and the conclusion comes out clearly and you say oh I see what I ought to have done yes seeing abstractly not with reference to sense particulars but with reference to some abstract line of thought you see we say it again and again”
The Meno presents a fundamental ambiguity: while the sophists with their mere rhetoric cannot teach virtue because they lack genuine knowledge of what virtue is, the people who should know virtue—outstanding moral civic leaders and parents—also appear ineffective at teaching it, as evidenced by the poor character of their own children.
“while of course the um the sophists with their rhetoric can't teach something when all they've got is their own relative opinions rhetoric doesn't teach virtue in the hands of those rather unver virtuous sophists but the people who should know what virtue is um outstanding morally U right Civic leaders and parents well they don't seem to have been very effective at teaching virtue look at the kinds of kids they've got the sons that grow up in their homes you see”
Plato proposes two primary suggestions in the Republic for cultivating the pursuit of the good: first, the city state should be so ordered as to encourage the love of the good, with government's task being the improvement of the soul; second, an educational system should gradually take people through a developmental process.
“in the Republic uh Plato makes I think two suggestions that he works with in a variety of places one is that it's the task of the city state so to order the good society as to encourage that sort of pursuit of the good uh so he sees the task of government as the Improvement of the Soul loving the right the good the true um secondly he conceives of an educational system which will gradually take people through a developmental process”
Moral development involves more than simply knowing the essence of a virtue; there are additional variables beyond imparting knowledge of what virtue is or what particular virtues (temperance, courage, wisdom, justice) are—though Plato does not fully explore these variables in the Meno.
“there are other variables involved in moral education besides simply imparting knowledge of what is virtue even what is a particular virtue like the classic Greek virtues of temperance courage wisdom as well as Justice um there's more to moral development than knowing the essence of any of those virtues and in the MEO Plato doesn't get into the more he does a little bit in the Republic and elsewhere”
In Plato's cave allegory, the soul imprisoned in the body at birth is like a prisoner chained to look only at the rear wall of a cave, seeing only flickering shadows cast by a fire, representing the world of changing appearances and relative, unreliable sensory perception from which the soul suffers amnesia.
“Plato Likens the um um the soul in this life to a prisoner in a cave okay um The Prisoner who is um tied in such a way that he can only look towards the rear wall of the cave and um the light of the sun filters in there's a fire burning in the mouth of the cave casting a flickering light so that Shadows appear here on the wall in front of the prisoner constantly changing never reliable you can never really pin them down nail them down tether them okay meanwhile um your captors scowl big sticking hand walk um to and fro casting further Shadows on that wall ahead you think the soul is a prisoner in the body born into this life you are imprisoned by being born and as a result um you're unable to see the way things are out there in the the real world as you say all you get is flickering Shadows far removed from reality it a world of changing appearances relative and unreliable you're suffering from Amnesia”
A person can be freed from the chains of the cave and begin to see reality by turning around and becoming acquainted with things outside the cave, but this is a gradual process: first seeing things in the cave itself (still shadowy), then exiting to see things illuminated by the fire, and finally seeing things in daylight outside the cave to know the way things are in reality.
“it's possible then that a person can be freed from those um those chains and be able at least to turn around and get acquainted with the um Earth while to was behind and with the reality of this cave what this is but that's still very shadowy you'll see it's only when we are able to reach outside the cave and see things then we come to know the way things are in reality”
Plato's scheme distinguishes two realms of being: a realm of physical particulars (the sensible world, accessible through sense perception and opinion) and a realm of universal truths (the intelligible world, accessible through reason and dialectic); genuine knowledge is knowledge of the intelligible realm of unchanging universals.
“so what Plato is depicting then is um a scheme in which we have two Realms of being okay two Realms of being a realm of physical particulars a realm of universal truths reality okay Universal truths yeah this is what we have to know this is simply the arena of opinion and somehow or other even while we're in this life we have to engage in a dialectic which enables us to think up there rather than being simply confined to ICS down there”
In the early church, three competing views about the origin of the individual soul were debated: the Platonic view of soul pre-existence, the Stoic view of reproduction with physical procreation, and the view of special divine creation at some point in fetal development.
“in the early church uh there were three views that were debated concerning the origin of the individual soul um either the platonic view that it pre-existed uh or the view that it was somehow reprod educed with physical procreation or that it is a special creation of God at some point in fetal development um curiously the first was characteristic of Plato and the platonic influence the second of the um more of the stoics and the third seems to have been separately introduced”
Platonism became the dominant philosophical influence within Christianity until around 1100-1200 CE, when it was superseded by other philosophical traditions; the history of theology is very much indebted to the Greek philosophical tradition.
“the history of theology in that way is very much indebted to the Greek tradition very much”
A dialectician is someone able to render an account of the essence of each thing and withstand all tests, objections, and counterarguments through rigorous examination—without this ability to give and defend an essentialist account, one possesses only opinion, not true knowledge.
“we give the name dialectician to the man who's able to exact an account of the essence of each thing will you not say that the one who's unable to do it capable of rendering an account to himself and others doesn't possess full reason and intelligence about the matter but the man who is able”
According to Plato, the full vision of the ultimate reality (the sun in the analogy, representing the source of being and light) is achieved only at death; in this life, understanding of first principles comes in limited form, with full understanding deferred to the afterlife.
“he seems to think that it's only only at death that we get the full vision of the sun which in the analogy is the most Ultimate Reality the source of being the source of light yeah so that that full understanding comes later and uh incidentally that becomes the basis for the development of certain mystical Traditions when platonism was taken over in the judeo-christian tradition and the sun becomes likened to God so the vision of God the mystical Vision you see is it possible in this life in limited way does it await the Hereafter fully”
Mathematical reasoning is a form of abstract thought superior to sense perception because it deals with abstract objects and relationships, but it is inferior to dialectic because mathematical reasoning must assume its first principles without proving them, whereas dialectic alone can reach those first principles themselves.
“as we know from ukian geometry onwards all mathematical systems and inferences defend depend on first principles um first principles which are assumed in the inference okay”
Sense perception does not yield unchanging knowledge of unchanging truths because sense perception is relative to the condition of the sense organs, relative to the condition and position of the object being viewed, and physical objects are constantly changing, so sense perception yields only variable and relative awareness of changing particulars.
“sense perception is basically a matter of sense perception of particular things in the world in which we live and sense perception Plato points out some of his predecessors had sense perception tends to be relative relative to um the condition of the sense of organs um relative to the condition and position of the object you're viewing and of course particular objects are constantly changing in some regards and so the condition of the object is very significant sense perception in other words does does not yield us unchanging knowledge of unchanging truths it tends to yield a variable relative awareness of changing particulars”
In the Fedo, Plato provides a series of arguments for both the pre-existence and the immortality of the soul—establishing metaphysical foundations for the epistemological claim that knowledge is recollection of innate ideas.
“the fedo which you're reading um part of the full fat gives a whole series of arguments for both both the pre-existence and the immortality of the Soul”
Dialectic is the process of thinking something through to a conclusion that will be true of all times and places, transcending the relativities of sense perception, the conditions of particular sense organs, and the variability of particular times or objects to arrive at unchanging truth.
“dial itic is well it's thinking something through to a conclusion that's going to be true of all times and places in other words Thinking Beyond the relativities of a particular time or condition of an object Thinking Beyond the relativity of different sense organs with different degrees of sharpness at different times see Thinking Beyond the relativities of sense perception to something some truth which is unchanging”
In the Phaedo, Plato uses the example of two equal-length sticks to show that judgments of equality presuppose a non-empirical concept of equality that cannot be derived from sensory observation, since no two physical objects are ever exactly equal in length.
“how do you judge that two sticks two pieces of chalk or for that matter um two sticks of so-called dry ink uh or do they call this liquid chalk well whichever it is are um equal in length you'll see by looking at them no no you you cannot say they're equal in length unless you already have a concept of equality to know what you're saying when you say they're equal in length in other words a judgment like these two sticks are equal in length presupposes a non-empirical concept of equality which um may be elicited by talking about two sticks being equal in length you'll see but is not as such an empirical property no two physical things are ever exactly the same after all”
Alan Bloom's contemporary criticism of the modern university is that students speak as if there is no such thing as truth or falsity, right or wrong, but his prescription involves returning to the study of the classics and great books, not to find one set of unchanging values but to engage in informal dialectic with those great ideas that would lead people to ask basic questions about first principles even if they disagree on conclusions.
“I think what Alan Bloom is doing is calling us back to um the kind of liberal education through a study of the Classics for which University of Chicago is famous uh that is to say while his criticism is that the Contemporary University student talks as if there is no such thing as truth or falsity right or wrong but the time you get to the end of the book and he talks about his prescription for our society and for Education he's talking about reading all of the classics back to the Greeks and so forth now why it's not that you find um one set of unchanging values I mean if you go through the great books you find a whole variety of different things a pot perie it's a regular cafeteria Resort you'll see now I think what he is after is um a dialogue that would go on with those great books if you like a kind of informal dialectic with those Alternatives that would lead people to ask basic questions even though they might disagree on the conclusions they'll be trying to get back to First principles”
There exists a contrast between education understood as dialectical (liberal arts education leading to questioning and pursuit of first principles) and education understood as rhetorical (teaching tricks of the trade so one can get ahead in one's chosen vocation), the latter being the sophistic approach.
“on the other hand I I think there is a kind of education that is much more the rhetorical kind that teaches you the tricks of the trade so you can get ahead in your chosen VOA vocation you see that's uh that's more the rhetoricians kind”
Mathematics is the best preparation for dialectic because it trains logical processes and the capacity for rigorous reasoning—mathematics majors who later study philosophy tend to be much sharper in their logical thinking than students from other backgrounds.
“the discipline of mathematics which is the best preparation for doing dialectic yeah to this day I'd by that math Majors who come to philosophy usually are much sharper in their logical processes than other people”
The Phaedrus dialogue (next week's reading) will show the theme of dialectic versus rhetoric powerfully, arguing that good rhetoric must be guided by knowledge gained through dialectic, raising the question of what motivates people to pursue dialectical knowledge and the good.
“you're going to be reading the fedus next week another of his dialogues and you will find the um dialectic versus rhetoric theme coming out in the second part of the fadis powerfully what constitutes good rhetoric is against nuts of good rhetoric it's rhetoric Guided by knowledge gained through dialectic”