collectivization
The state seizure and pooling of private land, tools, and property into collective farms, abolishing private ownership; under Mao it meant villagers owned nothing and worked under state direction.
As defined in Frank Dikotter on Mao's Great Famine
Where it comes up · 12
- Frank Dikotter on Mao's Great Famine4 claims
- Stephen Kotkin3 claims
- Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history3 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Julia Ioffe2 claims
- Vejas Liulevicius2 claims
- Is Trump Really a Russian Asset? Glenn Carle2 claims
- Paul Gregory on Politics, Murder, and Love in Stalin's Kremlin 07/12/20101 claim
- Jung Chang (Wild Swans author) — Living through history's largest man-made famine1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “collectivization” →
- Much of the work of illegitimate power is done by 'slave volunteers' through euphemism—finding a nice word for a nasty thing (e.g. 'collectivization' for forced dispossession, 'collateral damage' for civilian casualties, 'purge' for mass murder)—so that getting a deed renamed accomplishes half the job of legitimizing it.Christopher Hitchens on George Orwell
- Stalin's collectivization dispute with Bukharin was about whether the peasantry should pay tribute to the city through low fixed grain prices; when peasants stopped selling at prices below cost, Stalin labeled the withholding a political, anti-Soviet act and used militia and secret police to seize grain by force.Paul Gregory on Politics, Murder, and Love in Stalin's Kremlin 07/12/2010
- Russia had a replicable template for building its Eastern European bloc: install Communists in the power ministries (Defense and Interior) to monopolize coercion and eliminate opposition, control Justice and Information to arrest or kill at will and control the narrative, and control Agriculture to buy allegiance by redistributing land and wiping out rural elites—all while using democratic forms as a fiction to maintain a dictatorship.Sarah Paine – How Russia sabotaged China's rise
- Trotsky's solution to the peasant problem — forcibly amalgamating the 85% peasant population's farms into huge state-owned collective farms, providing tractors and fertilizers, and creaming off the proceeds while claiming peasants would be grateful — was essentially the collectivization that Stalin would implement a decade later, and Trotsky's contemporaries warned correctly that it could only be achieved through force, not persuasion.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- While the Great Leap Forward was ostensibly an attempt to overtake capitalist countries in production, in effect it was driven by rivalry between Beijing and Moscow, specifically Mao's desire to best Khrushchev for leadership of the socialist camp after Stalin's death, triggered by Khrushchev's 1957 boast to overtake the US in dairy production.Frank Dikotter on Mao's Great Famine
- Stalin's gigantic secret police was built in the very act of enslaving the hundred million peasants—you couldn't enslave the peasants without a huge secret police, but enslaving them produced exactly that capacity—a chicken-and-egg process where the repressive apparatus and the act of repression were constructed simultaneously.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- The Soviet Union lost about 27 million people in World War II, roughly 21 million of them men, and after decades of war, famine, and repression the gender imbalance reached places with 100 women for every 19 men.Conversations with Tyler - Julia Ioffe
- A statement repeated sufficiently becomes one's perceived reality and therefore the truth, which is empirically established and allows authoritarian states to shape perceptions even in the face of contradictory evidence like starvation or material deprivation.Is Trump Really a Russian Asset? Glenn Carle
- The famine was not a natural disaster or the result of bad harvests but a man-made catastrophe produced by the Soviet state's compulsion to extract resources, cordoning off the area and refusing to let starving people escape; while the falsification of statistics up and down the chain was an inadvertent side effect, the deliberate fostering of class conflict and civil war in the countryside was intentional doctrine.Vejas Liulevicius
- Paradoxically, the one person who restrained the Stalinization of China was Stalin himself, who viewed Mao as a potential competitor and advised him to slow collectivization; Stalin's death in 1953 was Mao's liberation, removing all restraint and prompting him to accelerate collectivization and impose a grain monopoly.Frank Dikotter on Mao's Great Famine