Trotsky's solution to the peasant problem — forcibly amalgamating the 85% peasant population's farms into huge state-owned collective farms, providing tractors and fertilizers, and creaming off the proceeds while claiming peasants would be grateful — was essentially the collectivization that Stalin would implement a decade later, and Trotsky's contemporaries warned correctly that it could only be achieved through force, not persuasion.

factualpending

Speaker

Robert Service

Evidence Quote

“Stalin ended up doing what the enemies of Trotsky in the 1920s said that Trotsky would have to do if he wanted to collective eyes”

Source

Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:24:37 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...