
Paul Gregory on Politics, Murder, and Love in Stalin's Kremlin 07/12/2010
What this covers
This is a conversation between Russ Roberts and Paul Gregory, built on Gregory's book about Nikolai Bukharin, his struggle with Stalin, and his marriage to Anna Larina, who was 26 years younger. The story runs from Bukharin's role under Lenin, including his part in expelling intellectuals during the Red Terror, through the late-1920s collectivization dispute to his arrest, show trial, and execution. It ends with Anna's fate as the family member of a traitor: exile, ten years in the Gulag, then another ten in exile. Bukharin's farewell letter to her, written in January 1938 and delivered only in 1992, shows his faith in the socialist cause even at the end.
The range is wider than the biography. Gregory explains how Stalin turned the minor post of general secretary into a majority on the Politburo, and how he destroyed rivals slowly, with embarrassment, disgrace, a chance at redemption, and only then execution. On the economics, he treats the grain seizures of 1928-1930 as a case of force replacing market exchange, and ties them to the famine of 1932-1933, which he puts at 5 to 10 million deaths while conceding that the statistics are the weakest part of the record. His claim that the famine was partly deliberate, supported by the roadblocks that kept starving peasants from leaving, is among the contested points.
The conversation also covers the Kirov assassination and what Stalin did with it. It describes how confessions were extracted through torture and threats to relatives, and how Bukharin used his final statement to retract his. Gregory argues that the victims of the terror were mostly ordinary workers and peasants rather than party officials. The closing question is whether Stalin or someone like him was inevitable. Gregory answers with selection by ruthlessness while allowing that, as economists and historians weigh contingency versus regularity differently, Stalin's early death might have changed the outcome.
Gregory argues that Bukharin's defeat by Stalin was a predictable outcome of a system where force replaced market exchange and ruthless, patient operators beat principled intellectuals, so counterfactuals about a more humane Bolshevik path are weak.
- Stalin's 1929-1930 collectivization turned a policy dispute into a choice between voluntary market exchange and force
- Stalin used patience, unity statements, and step-by-step humiliation to destroy rivals, while Bukharin trusted the rules of intellectual debate
- Power struggles in this system select ruthless operators, so a Bukharin victory was unlikely even if Stalin had died
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Kondratiev was executed in 1937 partly because Stalin disliked him: Kondratiev headed the Business Cycle Institute, which published independent economic data, and favored private agriculture.
“Kondratiev headed what was called the Business Cycle Institute which published independent data on the economy. And um he also favored a uh favored favored private agriculture.”
Stalin's title of general secretary was initially seen as a minor position, but Stalin used it to fill all appointments, including Politburo seats, and build his own majority.
“That was Stalin's strength because as general secretary, he filled all positions, including uh Politburo positions.”
After Kirov's assassination Stalin already had a plan, ordering the NKVD chief Yagoda to find the murderers among the Trotskyites and beat their faces in if necessary; Yagoda was too slow and was replaced by Yezhov, the loyal executioner of the Great Terror.
“'The murderers of Kirov, you will find the murderers of Kirov among the Trotskyites. If necessary, beat their faces in.'”
Confessions in the Moscow show trials were generated by torture and threats; Bukharin's public confession was edited by Stalin, while his real defense came in his final statement where he retracted the confession.
“his actual confession, as you point out, was edited by Stalin. So, the public version of it... was not what the world got to see.”
Stalin's collectivization dispute with Bukharin was about whether the peasantry should pay tribute to the city through low fixed grain prices; when peasants stopped selling at prices below cost, Stalin labeled the withholding a political, anti-Soviet act and used militia and secret police to seize grain by force.
“Stalin said the surplus must come from agriculture. The peasant must pay for industrialization. And we'll make them pay by setting the price very low.”
Bukharin's farewell letter to Anna, written January 15, 1938 and delivered in 1992, told her to feel no malice, that personal fates are transitory compared with the USSR cause, and to keep her strength, reflecting his continued faith in the socialist project.
“Don't feel malice about anything. Remember that the great cause of the USSR lives on. And this is the most important thing. Personal fates are transitory and wretched by comparison.”
Stalin gave Bukharin a two-month vacation timed to coincide with the Zinoviev trial, but Bukharin returned early on the day the death sentences were announced and understood that he was finished.
“Stalin actually uh gave him a 2-months vacation, which was conveniently timed to be at the same time as the Communist Zinoviev trial.”
Under Lenin's Red Terror decree in early 1918, Bukharin was put in charge of expelling intellectuals and great writers and scientists, and the economist Kondratiev was scheduled for deportation and later executed in 1937.
“Bukharin was put in charge of expelling uh intellectuals... Kondratiev was scheduled for deportation, but somehow managed to get internal exile”
Kirov received more votes than Stalin for reappointment to the Central Committee at the 1934 Congress of Victors, making him potentially the most popular Bolshevik figure, which Gregory suggests would not have sat well with Stalin.
“Kirov in the Congress of Victors received more vo- more votes for reappointment to the Central Committee than Stalin.”
Bukharin's confessions at the show trials were produced through torture, threats to families, and fear, and Kamenev confessed after being promised his son could live, yet his son was executed anyway, illustrating that the NKVD used the lives of relatives as leverage.
“they've been told their wife is going to be shot, their son's going to be shot. Reportedly, Kamenev confessed because he was promised that his son could live. But, the son was also executed.”
After Bukharin's execution Anna Larina was declared a ChSIR (family member of a traitor of the fatherland), sent into exile, then sentenced to 10 years in the Gulag, and then required to remain in exile another 10 years after her term.
“She was declared a ChSIR, which is an abbreviation for member of a family of a traitor of the fatherland.”
Bukharin was scheduled to confront Kamenev and Zinoviev under Soviet law, but he was delayed by a plane arriving late from Central Asia, and Stalin had them executed in his absence, showing Stalin was impatient when it served his purposes.
“he has the right under Soviet law to confront them... his plane is a couple hours late, and Stalin kills them.”
The victims of Stalin's terror were largely ordinary workers and peasants with little education, not Bolshevik party officials, and the Soviet government stopped publishing victim statistics around 1934 because the victims did not fit the 'enemies of the people' narrative.
“If you look at the statistics on Stalin's victims, which they ceased publishing around 1934, they were all workers and peasants.”
The 1928-1930 Soviet confiscation of grain by force shows a clear link between violence and non-market allocation: Stalin understood that the choice was between voluntary exchange through markets and the application of force.
“Stalin and Bukharin understood very well that you have a choice between voluntary exchange through markets and the application of force.”
The Soviet regime blocked famine victims from fleeing their regions by setting up roadblocks and refusing train tickets, so people who tried to escape were caught, sent back, and died, which Gregory cites as evidence of deliberate policy.
“he also denied those in famine regions sort of the natural equilibration, which is to leave... roadblocks were set up. You couldn't get on a train if you were in a famine area. And they caught you, and they sent you back, and you died.”
Bukharin's eventual death sentence rested on the charge that he and the Trotskyites had formed a coalition to assassinate Stalin, a charge built on the fact of the Kamenev meeting and on testimony extracted from people trying to save themselves.
“that meeting, by the way, was the basis for his death sentence. Because the death sentence read that he and the Trotskyites had formed a coalition to assassinate Stalin”
The Kirov assassination on December 1, 1934 marked the start of the phase of physical survival for Bukharin and other top Bolsheviks, since the ban on executing top-level Bolsheviks was broken by the August 1936 Moscow show trial that sentenced Zinoviev, Kamenev, and others to death.
“Stage three begins on December 1, 1934 with the assassination of uh Kirov... That ban was broken in the first Moscow Show Trial of August 1936”
The 1932-1933 famine killed roughly 5 to 10 million people, concentrated in Ukraine, and was worsened by deportations, bad harvests, and roadblocks that prevented starving peasants from leaving famine regions and sent them back to die.
“It's somewhere you know, 5 to 10 million people died... Uh so, roadblocks were set up. Uh you couldn't get on a train if you were in a famine area. And they caught you, and they sent you back, and you died.”
Early-1930s famine deaths in the Soviet countryside were mostly starvation during forced deportation, with deportees sent to remote Kazakhstan and Siberia without support, and the total death toll is estimated at 5 to 10 million, though statistics are the weakest part of the record.
“It's somewhere you know, 5 to 10 million people died.”
Economists tend to look for models and regularities while historians look at special circumstances and unique events, so contingency matters: if Stalin had died of heart disease or been assassinated, Bukharin might have won.
“historians like to look at special circumstances, unique events, whereas we like to uh look at models and regularities.”
Gregory interprets Stalin's famine policy as partly deliberate: Stalin reportedly understood that losing that many people could cost him Ukraine, and tried belatedly to improve matters, but it was too late.
“Stalin understood that if you lost that many people, you could actually lose Ukraine. So, at one point he said, 'You know, this is dangerous. We can't lose Ukraine.'”
The Kirov assassination on December 1, 1934 began the final phase of Bukharin's decline: Kirov had received more votes than Stalin for reappointment to the Central Committee at the Congress of Victors, and Stalin had a plan ready to use the killing to eliminate opponents.
“Stage three begins on December 1, 1934 with the assassination of uh Kirov, the Leningrad party boss.”
Stalin used Politburo and Central Committee 'statements of unity' to conceal policy splits before radical policies like collectivization and forced industrialization, because the party had to appear unanimous.
“So, it was very important for him to get these unity statements, which Bukharin was foolish enough to sign.”
Stalin dealt with rivals in slow, step-by-step stages: he first embarrassed, then disgraced, then offered a chance to redeem oneself, and only then had the rival executed, often after a show trial, and he was willing to wait years for revenge.
“He would first embarrass you, then he would disgrace you, uh then he would say, 'Well, we need to give this guy a chance to redeem himself.' Uh and then the axe would fall.”
In Stalin's Bolshevik system, toughness and the willingness to show no sympathy were prized traits, so soft-hearted people who play by the rules cannot win power struggles, and Stalin's victory over Bukharin was therefore predictable.
“this is a great case study of showing that soft hearted people who play by the rules simply can't win in power struggles in such a system.”
If Stalin had died, the next worst figure, such as Zinoviev, would have succeeded, because in these power struggles the ruthless near-Stalins hold the ammunition, not the Bukharins.
“If Stalin had had the heart attack or been assassinated, then the next worst person would have been standing in line... It's not the Bukharins.”
Bukharin's private meeting with Kamenev, held in an apartment with listening devices, was a fatal mistake because Stalin's rule forbade private meetings that could form a faction, and the meeting later became the basis of Bukharin's death sentence.
“that meeting, by the way, uh was the basis for the uh for his death sentence.”
Bukharin's intellectual naivety led him to believe that political disputes would follow the norms of a faculty lounge, and he remained hopeful to the end that his past friendship with Stalin would spare him.
“Bukharin to the very end harbored this hope, 'We were one time good friends. He surely he's going to spare me.'”
Stalin and Bukharin understood the choice clearly: they were choosing between voluntary exchange through markets and the application of force, so the split was about that choice rather than about failure to grasp elementary economics.
“Stalin and Bukharin understood very well that you have a choice between voluntary exchange through markets and the application of force.”
Lenin's first repressive targets were the socialist parties he had recently allied with, not the so-called bourgeois parties, because he wanted no competition and saw socialist rivals as the greater threat.
“Lenin did not want to have any opposition whatsoever and his first targets were socialist parties with which he had been allied only a few months earlier.”
Gorbachev rehabilitated Bukharin in 1988 because he needed an alternative socialist system and the only one available seemed to be Bukharin's proposal, creating a 'Bukharin boom' in Soviet reform circles.
“the only socialist system alternative that he thought existed was the one that Bukharin had proposed. So, there was this Bukharin boom.”
Stalin and Bukharin formed a voting block in the Politburo to expel Trotsky, Zinoviev, and Kamenev, but once those rivals were removed Stalin filled the Politburo with allies such as Molotov and Ordzhonikidze, making Bukharin dispensable.
“So, Molotov was elevated, uh Ordzhonikidze was elevated... he wouldn't need Bukharin.”
Kamenev confessed after being promised that his son would live, but both of his sons were executed anyway, one of them a teenager.
“Reportedly, Kamenev confessed because he was promised that his son could live. But, the son was also executed.”
Anna Larina memorized Bukharin's political testament because it could not be written down, and recited it daily in the Gulag, intended for a future generation of party leaders who would correct the failed experiment.
“he had her memorize what he called his last political testament... every day in the gulag, she would begin her day reciting it to herself.”
Bukharin's son Yuri, separated from his mother as an infant when she was arrested, was placed in an NKVD orphanage, which Gregory describes as including reeducation, and Anna did not find him until after Khrushchev's 1956 denunciation of Stalin, when Yuri was 21 and she was 42.
“she lost the infant son when she was arrested. He went into orphanages... She was able to contact him after Khrushchev's denunciation of Stalin in 1956.”
Bukharin, having been a left communist, changed position after the New Economic Policy's success and argued for private agriculture and market-set prices as a way to avoid force in the countryside, because destroying agriculture would destroy social cohesion.
“Bukharin uh argued that we have to have a private agriculture. We have to let the market set prices. In this way we can avoid force in the countryside.”
Pravda's editor after the October Revolution held a more influential position in the country than the editor of the New York Times would hold in America, because the paper was the official voice of the party and in charge of propaganda.
“So that's an even more influential position than say editor of the New York Times, possibly, within that country. He was the official voice of the party. He was in charge of propaganda.”
Bukharin, after touring Ukraine and seeing starvation, told Anna's father that if this is what the revolution brings we should have had no revolution, and his stomach for the regime's methods was weaker than Stalin's.
“Bukharin, who had already lost the political struggle in 1930 and 1931, traveled through Ukraine. And saw he had no stomach for this.”
Bukharin's young wife Anna Larina, then 22 with an infant son, fell into deep shock when the papers reported the trials, and the couple understood by August 1936 that they had little chance of survival.
“Anna, his young wife, she was then 22. They had an infant son also read in the papers. And she went into a deep shock.”
Soviet interrogation transcripts were written down in full, and the pattern of resistance followed by a pause and then confession suggests the prisoner had been beaten or threatened with harm to family members.
“this was a system that wrote everything down, surprisingly, unlike the Nazis... So, the suspicion is they've been beaten.”
Bukharin lost the political struggle by early 1929, and after that he withdrew from politics and avoided contact with opposition figures, but good behavior did not save him.
“once Bukharin lost the the political power struggle, he avoided any contact with anyone like Kamenev or Zinoviev... but good behavior did not save him.”
Trial testimony against Bukharin was generated by NKVD torture, and the charge that he plotted Stalin's murder was a trumped-up accusation, yet many defendants testified to it in a Kafkaesque process.
“which of course was a trumped-up charge. But many, many people testified that this was true... These testimonies were generated by torture, by the NKVD.”
If Bukharin had prevailed, the USSR would likely have moved quickly toward social democracy with multiparty systems, but Gregory judges this outcome unlikely.
“if Bukharin had prevailed, which I think unlikely, what would have happened in my view would have been a rather quick move to a social democracy.”
Anna Larina, Bukharin's third wife, was 26 years younger than him; she had known him since childhood as a close friend's daughter, married him at age 20 when he was 46, and their romance began when she was 16 in the Crimea.
“he was 26 years older than her. And he as you said, her father was his best friend... And uh they marry at 20. Uh when she's 20 and he's 46.”
Economists and historians have difficulty with the question of a more humane revolution because the historical record turns on individual contingencies while economic analysis turns on regularities.
“Well, economists and historians have difficulty dealing with this issue”
Bukharin was at the level of Trotsky, Lenin, Stalin, and Zinoviev among the most influential Bolsheviks in the movement that took power, and was among the top figures from the early revolution onward.
“He's at that time at the level of Trotsky, Lenin, Stalin, uh Zinoviev, the the most important influential people in the Bolshevik movement”
Bukharin was perhaps the only trained economist among the Bolshevik founders; he studied economics during his German exile and attended lectures of Böhm-Bawerk.
“He was perhaps the only trained economist among the Bolshevik founders. He studied economics during his exile in Germany and attended lectures of the uh great Austrians, including uh Böhm-Bawerk.”
Soviet interrogations were transcribed in full, unlike Nazi practice, and the transcripts are available in the Hoover Institution archives on microfilm, showing the sequence of resistance, pause, and eventual confession.
“this was a system that wrote everything down, surprisingly, unlike the Nazis. So, all of the interrogations were transcribed.”
Trotsky was exiled from the Soviet Union after expulsion from the party and was eventually assassinated in Mexico by an agent of Stalin, while Zinoviev and Kamenev were internally exiled to Kaluga for a couple of years before being reinstated.
“he ended up in Mexico where he was assassinated by an agent of Stalin. Zinoviev and Kamenev were internally exiled to a remote city called Kaluga.”
Lenin put Bukharin in charge of Pravda after the revolution because Bukharin was the best educated and a strong writer, and Bukharin then wrote the textbook ABC of Communism for the new socialist state.
“Lenin immediately put him in charge of Pravda because Bukharin was next to Lenin perhaps the best educated of the Bolsheviks. He was a good writer.”
Bukharin was the youngest of the Bolshevik founders, and he is not an obscure figure in Gregory's view because Gregory has been acquainted with his work for over 45 years.
“Nikolai Bukharin was the youngest of the Bolshevik founders. Um in my view, he was not an obscure figure”
Anna Larina may have survived partly because she was beautiful and possibly because Stalin had a personal soft spot for her; Beria told her, 'If the master wanted you dead, you'd be dead.'
“Beria more or less tells her, 'If the master wanted you dead, you'd be dead.' So, I have the feeling that Stalin rarely had any emotions whatsoever, but he may have had uh some kind of emotion for her.”
Gregory's approach moved from economics to terror and repression, and he decided that to understand how the Soviet system worked he had to study it at the personal level, which made Bukharin and Anna's story an ideal vehicle.
“I then decided that if you really want to understand how this system works, you had to look at it at a personal level.”
Bukharin is called 'the last Bolshevik' because he remained a true believer in the Soviet project even as few true believers remained by 1938.
“this is one reason why Bukharin is called the last Bolshevik because it shows that he remained a true believer.”
Roberts reads the Soviet period's 70 years of bad weather as a fact that makes it hard to attribute the famine to weather alone, since weather was bad every year from 1917 to 1987.
“Didn't they have 70 years of bad weather between 1917 and 1987?”
In the United States, state power is historically limited and abuse of power is usually revealed through a free press, unlike the Soviet system in which the state could pull anyone over and make people up charges with no recourse.
“in America we're pretty lucky. Uh power of the state is historically fairly limited most of the time. There's a free press.”