What this covers
Liulevicius and Lex Fridman examine why communist regimes collapsed into catastrophe rather than utopia, tracing the failure to contradictions embedded in Marxist doctrine itself. The conversation moves across multiple registers—the intellectual origins of Marxism in Marx's adaptation of Hegel's philosophy, the specific mechanisms by which Stalin's Soviet Union produced famine and terror, the adaptation of Marxism to agrarian societies Marx never anticipated, and the paradoxical ways communist movements shared assumptions with their totalitarian enemies. Central to Liulevicius's argument is that Marxism fused scientific pretense with quasi-religious certainty about history's predetermined arc, combined with a doctrine of Situational Ethics that justified extreme violence—a combination that, when meeting actual human incentives and nature, generated the opposite of the promised world.
The conversation spans the Soviet Union's foundational contradictions through its collapse and after, examining how Incentive Distortion of Information made the state planning system inoperable, how the Great Terror's quota system became a self-amplifying machine of denunciation, and how negative selection winnowed out entrepreneurial talent across generations. Liulevicius also addresses the recurring pattern of communist movements arising not where Marx predicted—industrialized Germany—but in war-devastated backwaters requiring radical local adaptation. He considers Mao Zedong's transformation of peasants into revolutionary subjects, the German Communists' failure to oppose Hitler effectively, the ideological overlap between Nazis and communists despite their enmity, and why post-Soviet states like Russia never achieved historical reckoning. Throughout, the discussion emphasizes that understanding totalitarian systems requires studying their own logic and pronouncements rather than projecting liberal-democratic assumptions onto them.
Liulevicius argues that communist regimes failed catastrophically because Marxism combined a quasi-religious certainty about history's predestined direction with a doctrine that ethics are situational and revolution must be violent, producing systems that, when they collided with human nature and reality, generated famine, terror, and negative selection of talent rather than utopia.
- Marxism smuggled utopian, religious-structured aims into a framework that claimed the authority of science, making believers willing to take huge liberties with tactics.
- Collectivization and the Great Terror show how abstract ideals interacting with human incentives produced man-made famine, falsified statistics, and a self-perpetuating machinery of denunciation.
- Communism repeatedly came to power in power vacuums created by war and in places Marx never predicted, requiring local adaptation that drifted far from the original design.
Marxism fused historical inevitability with the imperative for exceptional individuals to accelerate revolution, a combination far more powerful than earlier utopian socialism.
- Marx took Hegel's idealist claim that history moves meaningfully toward the realization of an idea (freedom) and flipped it on its head, insisting history is instead based on matter—hence dialectical materialism, where conflict drives progress—while retaining Hegel's intoxicating confidence of being on the right side of history.
“What Marx did was to take this characteristic insistence of Hegel that history is moving in a meaningful and discernible way towards the realization of an idea and flipped it on its head. Marx insisted that... history is based on matter. So hence, dialectical materialism”
- Marx's power came from combining two seemingly contradictory ideas: that history moves with scientific inevitability toward a predestined end (total human liberation), and that exceptional individuals can heroically accelerate that process; this combination of inevitability plus a role for heroism made his ideology far more potent than earlier utopian socialism.
“the notion that there is a science of revolution that suggests that you can move in a deliberate and meaningful, rational way towards the end of history... when you add to that the notion that there's also room for heroism and the individual role, this ended up being tremendously powerful as a combination”
- Paradoxically, having confidence that you possess the broadly correct set of answers about the future allows you to take huge liberties with tactics and strategies, as long as the ultimate goal remains intact—a dynamic that gave Lenin immense confidence and enabled extreme means in pursuit of the predetermined end.
“the confidence that you have in broad strokes the right set of answers for how to get to the future also allows you to take huge liberties with the tactics and the strategies that you follow, as long as your ultimate goal remains the one sketched by this master”
- Russian nihilists, despite rejecting all prior religious and moral certainties, made an exception for science and materialism, which they saw as the foundation for an entirely new mode of existence; this materialist faith influenced Lenin (whose favorite book was Chernyshevsky's nihilist novel 'What Is to Be Done') and reinforced the conviction that total devotion and hardness were necessary for revolution.
“nihilists, as the name would suggest, do reject all prior certainties, but they make an exception for science and see that as the possibility for founding an entirely new mode of existence”
- Although Marx insisted his system was rigorous science laying out the iron laws of history (and bitterly rejected being called utopian), his vision of the post-revolutionary state—people freed from necessity, working one job in the morning and pursuing leisure in another in the afternoon, free of contradictions—is deeply utopian; the key difference from earlier socialists was that Marx charted a route to that outcome dressed in the prestige of 19th-century science.
“smuggled in among those things are most definitely utopian elements... The difference was that Marx charted a route towards that outcome that presented itself as cutting-edge science”
Communist movements systematized ideology as secular religion, structurally demanding transcendence and apocalyptic fulfillment that functioned like faith despite official atheism.
- The Soviet Union's official atheism did not produce a vacuum of belief but a demanding faith of its own—evidenced by the reverential filing past Lenin's mummified body, the cults around figures like Mao and Ho Chi Minh, and the reverence for relics—because human nature longs for transcendental explanations and nature abhors a vacuum.
“communist mummies like Mao or Ho Chi Minh really, I think, speak to a blending of earlier religious sensibility, reverence for relics of great figures, almost saintly figures, so that even what got proclaimed as atheism turned out to be a very demanding faith as well”
- Marxism and Soviet communism, despite proclaiming atheism, functioned as a secular or political religion: Marx as a savior/Moses figure, the final revolution as apocalypse, the post-revolutionary utopia as a secular heaven, the working class as humanity to be redeemed—a structure scholars like Niebuhr and Voegelin identified, with Voegelin warning that promising the eschaton in the here and now leads to disaster.
“there is a religious element. Not a vowed one, but a kind of hidden religious or secular religious element to Marx's vision... The apocalypse or the end times is this final revolution that will usher in a blessed final state, a utopia, which is equivalent to a secular version of heaven”
- When asked in the 1990s whether the Soviet sacrifices were worth it, Marxist historian Eric Hobsbawm answered that because the Soviet Union failed, such sacrifices were inordinate—but that if the experiment had succeeded and opened a glorious future for mankind, his reply would be different, illustrating the ends-justify-the-means reasoning that the utopian goal could license.
“he stated forthrightly that because the Soviet Union failed such sacrifices were inordinate. But if the experiment had succeeded and a glorious future had been open for mankind as a result of the Soviet Union's success, that would lead to a different reply”
- Marx promised that after a transitional period requiring centralized control and 'despotic inroads against property' (dispossession of the bourgeoisie), the state—because it would represent everybody rather than conflicting class interests—would eventually wither away, leaving people to enjoy authentic freedom without necessity or poverty.
“the state, because it represents everybody rather than representing particular class interests that are in conflict with other classes, the state will eventually wither away, so there won't be need for it”
Marxist ethics as purely situational, tied only to class material reality, removed moral restraints from pursuit of historical goals, opening the door to atrocity from inception.
- The Marxist grounding that ethics are entirely situational—that any ethical system is merely an outgrowth of a particular class and material reality—left the door wide open to atrocity from the very beginning, because it removed any fixed moral restraint on what could be done in pursuit of the historical goal.
“The notion that ethics are entirely situational and that any ethical system is an outgrowth of a particular class reality, a particular material reality, and that leaves the door wide open”
- A core destructive mechanism of Soviet collectivization and terror was negative selection: those with the most enterprise, entrepreneurship, self-discipline, and organizational ability were winnowed out again and again, sending the lasting societal message that mediocrity is far safer than talent—a pattern that extended from the countryside to the Russian intelligentsia and left scars enduring to this day.
“Those who have most enterprise, those who are most entrepreneurial, those who have most self-discipline, those who are best organized will be winnowed again and again and again, sending the message that mediocrity is comparatively much safer than talent”
- The Great Terror took on a life of its own through quotas the provinces were ordered to meet and overachieve, and through inviting people to denounce neighbors, coworkers, and family; tortured confessions produced new lists of suspects, who under torture named more, expanding the secret police's reach indefinitely—a self-amplifying machine in which even total loyalty was no protection.
“people were invited to denounce neighbors, coworkers, maybe even family members, meant that ever larger groups of people would be brought into the orbit of the secret police, tortured in order to produce confessions. Those confessions then would lead to more lists of suspects”
- A famous joke—'what's the difference between capitalism and communism? Capitalism is the exploitation of man by man and communism is the exact opposite'—shows how communist history produced jokes that were reactions to the ideological claims of figures like Marx.
“capitalism is the exploitation of man by man and communism is the exact opposite”
- The Terror disaggregated society and broke down bonds of trust because dedicated communists sent to the Gulag assumed their own case was a mistake while believing everyone else accused must be genuinely guilty, and neighbors who were taken away in the night could not be spoken of—leaving lasting traces of social atomization that endure to this day.
“talk about ways of disaggregating a society, ways of breaking down bonds of trust. This left lasting traces on an entire society that endured to this very day”
Marx's theory proved empirically wrong in developed economies where reform movements and unions improved working conditions rather than intensifying misery and revolution.
- Marx expected the revolution to occur in industrialized, developed Germany (also Britain, France, eventually the US), so it is a central irony that the first government claiming to realize his vision arose in the wreckage of the agrarian, under-industrialized Russian Empire; the Bolsheviks knew this was a gamble and staked their survival on a workers' revolution erupting in Germany to link up with theirs—which never came.
“it's a lasting irony or a central irony of this whole story that when a government establishes itself that claims to be following Marx's prescriptions... it happens in the wreckage of the Russian Empire, a place that did not match the requirements of being industrialized”
- Marx's key prediction of growing misery (Verelendung/immiseration)—that the working class condition would continuously worsen until a final revolutionary explosion—was already failing in his own lifetime in developed economies like Britain and Germany, where reform movements and unions carved out improved conditions, undermining the empirical core of his forecast.
“even in his own lifetime, there were already hints that in fact, if you looked sociologically at the really developed working classes in places like Great Britain or Germany, that process was not playing out as he had expected”
- Lenin accepted the humiliating Treaty of Brest-Litovsk—surrendering large territories—because he expected revolution to soon erupt everywhere and render the treaty a dead letter; for German nationalists the treaty meant Germany had essentially won WWI in the East, fueling the conviction that Germany had not really lost the war and helping lay the resentment-driven groundwork for World War II.
“For German sensibilities, for German nationalists, that treaty meant that Germany had essentially won World War I... Germany, between the wars, was full of people who were convinced that Germany had actually not lost the war”
- Marx's flexibility is shown by his response to a Russian socialist who asked whether Russia might escape some stages of capitalist development rather than rigidly following the scheme; Marx's answer was convoluted but not a 'no,' suggesting he was willing to entertain various scenarios despite his confidence that he had cracked the big intellectual problem of the future.
“A Russian socialist wrote to Marx asking, 'Might it not be possible for Russia to escape some stages of capitalist development?'... And Marx's answer was convoluted, but it wasn't a no, and that suggests that Marx was willing to entertain all sorts of possible scenarios”
Marxism harbored fundamental internal contradictions between internationalism and nationalism, collective forces and individual agency, and universal claims versus particular national outcomes.
- Marxism is riddled with internal contradictions that became pressure points: religious adherence versus rejection of religion, internationalism versus the nationalism that emerged in practice, collective historical forces versus the importance of singular individuals, global universality versus restriction to particular countries, and a call to break with the past that itself became one of history's strongest traditions—a tradition of radical rupture.
“Marx points out that the need for revolution is in order to break with the traditions... And what happens instead is a tradition of radical rupture emerges, and that's really tough”
- Bolsheviks and communists generally had a deeply conflicted relationship with agriculture because peasants' utopia—being left alone to farm their own land—directly contradicted the Marxist vision of progress through industrialization; Marx dismissed peasants as conservative 'sacks of potatoes,' and the goal was to put farming on a factory model, so traditional independent farming ranked far below heavy industry in the communist hierarchy of desired outcomes.
“peasants, throughout history, for centuries, had wanted one thing, and that was to be left alone to farm their own land. That's their utopia. And that, for someone like Marx who had a vision of historical development and transcendence... does not mesh at all with that vision”
- The German Communists' belief that 'after Hitler, it's our turn' and their failure to ally with Social Democrats traces to the 1919 revolution in which Socialists killed Socialists, producing a dynamic so negative that cooperation against Hitler became nearly impossible—compounded by Communists viewing Social Democrats as rivals for working-class loyalty; the most likely alternative outcome was a military dictatorship rather than a Communist victory.
“The very fact that the German revolution in 1919 sees Socialists killing Socialists produces a dynamic that's so negative that it's nearly impossible to settle on cooperation, added to the fact that the Communists see the Social Democrats as rivals”
- Mao adapted Lenin's playbook to an even more surprising context by making peasants—whom Marx dismissed as conservative sacks of potatoes—the prime movers of revolution rather than the proletariat, an adaptation so far from the original design that scholars like Kolakowski threw up their hands; this raises the recurring question of when an ideological adaptation remains valid versus becoming something entirely distinct.
“to make the peasants, rather than being conservative sacks of potatoes, to make them into the prime movers of the success of this political venture... When is an adaptation of an ideology... a valid adjustment... And when is it already so different that it's something entirely distinct?”
Lenin's vanguard model embedded intellectuals as world-movers, creating persistent gaps between revolutionary elites and working classes they claimed to represent.
- A frequent reality of communist movements is that the founding elites were not factory workers who experienced industrialization firsthand but intellectuals; Marx and Engels carved out a special role for exceptional individuals who could transcend their class origins to ally with the proletariat, a celebration of intellectuals as world-movers that is intrinsically appealing to intellectuals and produced a persistent gap between revolutionaries and the classes they claimed to represent.
“this sort of special role that they carved out for themselves is enormously appealing for intellectuals, because any celebration of intellectuals as world movers is going to appeal to intellectuals”
- Lenin argued that left to their own devices, workers focus on their families, workplaces, and improving conditions through unions and reform—an accommodation with the system Lenin considered a fatal half-measure—which is why he demanded a disciplined vanguard of hardcore professional revolutionaries to push past reformism toward overthrow of the system.
“left to their own devices, Lenin announces, workers tend to focus on their reality, their families, their workplace... And for Lenin, that's not enough, because that's a half measure. That's the sort of thing that leads you into an accommodation with the system rather than the overthrow of the system”
- Bakunin was the first in a recurring pattern of anarchists trying to make common cause with communists, and in every case—the Russian Revolution, the Russian Civil War, the Spanish Civil War—it ended badly for the anarchists, because the Leninist prescription demanded a tightly organized, disciplined professional revolutionary movement that targeted the anarchists precisely for their skepticism toward hierarchy and discipline.
“Bakunin is the first in a longer series of approaches between anarchists and communists where they try to make common cause, and you have to say that in every case, it ends badly for the anarchists”
- Marx and Engels formed one of the most important and influential intellectual partnerships in history despite being very different men: Marx an academic-turned-radical-journalist married to a baron's daughter, dynamic and determined to dominate arguments; Engels the son of an industrialist who owned factories—decidedly not a member of the proletariat they celebrated.
“stepping into all of this are Marx and Engels together in what has been called, I think with justice, one of the most important and influential intellectual partnerships of history”
Stalin's personality and ideology mutually reinforced rather than opposed, with totalitarian structure rendering singular leaders potentially interchangeable within the system.
- The question of whether Stalin was a true believer or a cynical pragmatist using ideology for power is likely a false dichotomy; ideology providing a master plan for history and the unprecedented accumulation of personal power—including tormenting his own followers to keep them unsettled—may not have been opposed but mutually reinforcing in his psychology, which is a more frightening possibility.
“this may be a false alternative, a false dichotomy... these were actually perfectly compatible in his historical role... those might not actually be opposed, but might even be mutually reinforcing, which is a very scary thought”
- One disturbing feature of Hannah Arendt's model of totalitarianism is that while the system structurally demands an all-powerful, all-knowing, prophetic leader, the particular person filling that role may be interchangeable—raising the key question of whether singular figures like Hitler or Stalin were truly unique or replaceable within the system.
“the leader can be changed. The system itself demands that there be a leader who allegedly is all-powerful and all-knowing and prophetic and the like, but whether particular figures are interchangeable in that role is a key question”
- Contrary to a self-made-strongman image, Stalin did not brawl his way to dominance but was co-opted and promoted by Lenin, who saw him as rough and unsophisticated but dependable and reliable; archives opened after the Soviet collapse confirm these careers were connected rather than an unconnected series, and Stalin inherited a secret police apparatus (the Cheka, under Iron Felix Dzerzhinsky) already built up under Lenin.
“Stalin doesn't brawl his way into the Bolshevik party and dominate. He's co-opted and promoted to positions of importance by Lenin who sees him as a somewhat rough around the edges... But dependable, reliable, and committed revolutionary”
- The best way to understand a leader is to grasp their Erwartungshorizont (horizon of expectation)—how their prior background, formative childhood influences, and experiences (e.g., Churchill's and Hitler's WWI experience shaping their WWII actions) set their expectations; a revealing measure of a leader is how they treat people from whom they expect nothing, indicating whether they are condescending or genuinely interested in others.
“the more one understands about their prior background and formative influences, the better a fix, I think, one gets on the question of what are their expectations... in German, it's Erwartungshorizont, the horizon of expectation”
Soviet communism came to power through war-created power vacuums, not Marxist prediction, setting up crisis cycles of resistance breeding repression breeding further problems.
- Communism repeatedly came to power not where Marx predicted but by stepping into power vacuums created by war and the destruction of what came before—the WWI collapse of Tsarism in Russia, the Red Army's post-WWII expansion into Eastern Europe, the founding of communist China after WWII and civil war, and cases like Korea and Vietnam—and this war-born origin itself sets up further crisis through a ratchet effect of resistance breeding repression breeding more problems.
“the sheer fact that communism comes to power in most of these instances as a result of war. As a result of the destruction of what came before and a power vacuum”
- Because revolutionaries had to adapt Marxism to local conditions, communism in Vietnam, Cuba, Cambodia, and Russia differed substantially in its local themes and resonance from what Marx envisioned for Germany; in Russia specifically, the homegrown nihilist and populist revolutionary tradition (predating Marxism's arrival) shaped Lenin's insistence on total commitment and hardness.
“Marxism or communism in Vietnam, or in Cuba, or in Cambodia, or in Russia will be very different in its local adaptations and local themes and resonance than it was in Germany where Marx would've expected all of this to unfold”
- The common claim that Marxism was just a theoretical construct never meant to be tried in practice is heroically wrong; Marx and Engels emphasized the unity of theory and practice—Marx insisted previous philosophers merely interpreted reality while the point was to change it—so delivering the answer to how history evolves obligated action, making the political prescription inseparable from the economic analysis.
“Marx would have been furious to hear this and it's almost heroically wrong as a historical statement, because Marx insisted that all previous philosophers have theorized about reality. What now is really necessary is to change it”
Understanding foreign societies requires studying their own declarations and pronouncements rather than imposing analytic categories rooted in Western expectations and assumptions.
- To understand another society or government, projection of what we assume they are about is no substitute for actually studying the sources that society produces—its declarations of what matters most and its leadership's own pronouncements; when an example like North Korea's Juche-communist dynastic monarchy escapes your analytic categories, the problem is likely with your categories rather than the messy example, and humility and realism beat the pious hope that everyone will eventually come to resemble us.
“projection onto others of what we think they're about is no substitute for actual study of the sources that a society like that produces”
- Mao viewed human beings as 'beautiful blank pieces of paper upon which one can write new characters,' a view sharply at variance with the actual complex nature of humans; imposing one-size-fits-all schemes on a country as vast and varied as China inevitably produced serious malfunctions and suppressed entrepreneurial energies that re-emerged dramatically under Deng Xiaoping's reforms.
“Mao himself had a view of human beings as being, as he put it, beautiful blank pieces of paper upon which one can write new characters. And that is clearly at variance with what you and I know about the complex nature of human beings”
- Mao resented being Stalin's junior partner and, after being snubbed for days in Moscow in 1950 and especially after Stalin's death in 1953, sought to surpass the Soviet Union; the Great Leap Forward was literally an attempt to outdo Stalin's crash industrialization—through backyard smelting furnaces, gigantic communes, and Lysenko-inspired pseudoscientific agriculture—in a race to reach full communism first, and the toll for that hubris was vast.
“many of Mao's actions like the Great Leap Forward and the agricultural disasters that follow from that are literally attempts to outdo Stalin, to outperform Stalin, to show that what Stalin was not able to do, the Chinese Communist regime will be able to bring off. And the toll for that hubris is vast”
- Unlike Khrushchev who could denounce Stalin's crimes in 1956 and return to founder Lenin's intentions, China cannot repudiate Mao because Mao was not the equivalent of Stalin but of Lenin—the founder himself—which is why the party is stuck with the formula that Mao was '70% correct,' acknowledging some problems while affirming the leadership was fundamentally right.
“Nothing like that, it's argued, is possible in the Chinese case because Mao was not the equivalent of Stalin for communist China. Mao was the equivalent of Lenin. Mao was the founder. So there's no repudiating of him”
- The condemnation of cultural appropriation is misguided because a synonym for cultural appropriation is world history itself—trade, the transfer of ideas, and mutual influences; valuing that which is unlike your own culture is literally a form of appropriation, and this inexhaustible variety of human reaction and exchange is a source of optimism about the future.
“a synonym for cultural appropriation is world history. Trade, transfer of ideas, influences. Valuing that which is unlike your own culture is also a form of appropriation”
Soviet state planning collapsed under pervasive, systematic falsification of statistics throughout the command chain to avoid punishment, undermining the system's claimed rationality.
- Because everyone up and down the chain of command falsified, tinkered with, or prettified their statistics to avoid looking bad and escape vengeance, the Soviet state planning system—which pretended to comprehensive knowledge and produced five-year plans requiring accurate data—was founded on a foundation of sand, an inadvertent but pervasive corruption that haunted the rest of the Soviet experience.
“everybody is falsifying or tinkering with or prettifying the statistics or their reports in order not to look bad... reaches the point where nobody, in spite of the pretense of comprehensive knowledge... All of this is founded upon a foundation of sand”
- The famine was not a natural disaster or the result of bad harvests but a man-made catastrophe produced by the Soviet state's compulsion to extract resources, cordoning off the area and refusing to let starving people escape; while the falsification of statistics up and down the chain was an inadvertent side effect, the deliberate fostering of class conflict and civil war in the countryside was intentional doctrine.
“the outcome here is a horrific manmade famine. Not a natural disaster, not bad harvest, but a manmade famine as a result of then the compulsion that gets used by the Soviet state to extract those resources, cordoning off the area, not allowing starving people to escape”
Nazis and communists shared rejection of democracy and liberalism, cooperated cynically, and both centralized expansionist ambitions in Eastern Europe as core to their visions.
- Invasion of the Soviet Union was always central, not peripheral, to Nazi ambitions—written into Mein Kampf as necessary to realize the racial utopia—with timing flexible but intent definite; the Generalplan Ost foresaw mega-highways for the Germanic master race vacationing in Crimea and scientifically distributed settlements across Ukraine, confirming the East was central to Nazi aims.
“as you can read in Mein Kampf, this is what's necessary in order to bring that racial utopia to pass. And so, while the timetable might be flexible... it was most definitely on his list”
- Despite total ideological opposition, communists and Nazis shared the conviction that the age of democracy and classical liberalism was bankrupt, and engaged in cynical cooperation—Nazi Stormtroopers and Communist street fighters together made Weimar democracy unworkable, and the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 1939, with secret clauses dividing Eastern Europe, enabled Hitler to start World War II.
“This produced, at one in the same time, both ideological opposition and instances, a vastly cynical cooperation”
- Hitler and Himmler envisioned not a peace treaty or fixed border in the East but permanent war—moving the border hundreds of miles east every generation to keep winning living space and to keep training new generations of soldiers in aggression—while Himmler planned that surviving Slavs would remain as 'slaves for our culture,' representing one of history's most nightmarish visions.
“Hitler and Himmler envisioned permanent war on the Eastern Front, not a peace treaty, not a settlement, not a border, but a constant moving of the border, every generation, hundreds of miles east in order to keep winning more and more living space”
Territorial conquest to change borders breaks postwar taboo and creates ratchet effects of escalating conflict incentives with worse future consequences.
- War takes on a life of its own and escapes human management because accumulated suffering eliminates compromises that look reasonable in the abstract—settlements proposed by distant outsiders are refused by those who have personally experienced the war's destruction—so an 'equally unhappy' negotiated peace is very hard to strike, and a ceasefire that leaves people desperately unhappy can lay the foundation for worse trouble later.
“war takes on a life of its own as accumulated suffering actually eliminates possible compromises or settlements that one might talk about in the abstract”
- The use of force to change borders in Europe had been a taboo since 1945, and the war in Ukraine breaks that taboo; if such territorial conquest is validated, it sets up incentives for more of the same—potentially meaning we may already be in a worse situation that lays the foundation for future conflict.
“ratifying the use of force to change borders in Europe was a taboo since 1945 and now look where we are. If that is validated, then it sets up incentives for more of the same”
Post-Soviet Russia never underwent full historical reckoning or transparency, leaving Putin to traffic in eclectic, contradictory historical memories without accountability.
- After the Soviet collapse, Russia and other ex-communist states never underwent a full historical reckoning—no Nuremberg-style trials to assign responsibility and, crucially, to collect and publicize information creating transparency about the past—because economic misery left little surplus for introspection; in the resulting vacuum Putin trafficks in eclectic, mutually contradictory historical memories, rehabilitating the Tsars while viewing Lenin negatively.
“no Nuremberg trial took place in order to hold responsible those who had repressed others in the aftermath of the collapse of the Soviet Union”
- Radical socialism had less purchase in the United States than in Europe, and the American Communist Party faced the particular challenge of being identified with immigrant communities, so its ethnic variety appeared unfamiliar to many American workers; only with Earl Browder's slogan 'Communism is 20th Century Americanism' did the movement attempt to root itself in American political discourse, before Browder fell for expecting permanent US-Soviet cooperation as the Cold War dawned.
“the party was often identified with immigrants... for many American workers, they saw the sheer ethnic variety and difference of this movement as something that was unfamiliar”
Sustained deep reading of full texts cultivates empathy and resistance to manipulation in ways summaries and digital snippets cannot replicate.
- Sustained reading of full books—not summaries or digital snippets—is irreplaceable because the experience of thinking your way into other people's minds within the categories and values of an author is crucial to human empathy and to broadening one's sense of the full range of being human; without a resurgence of such reading, people fall prey to manipulators and to AI-generated versions of realities that never existed.
“the experience of thinking your way into other people's minds that sustained reading offers is so crucial to human empathy, a broadening of your own sensibilities of what's possible”