collective action problem
A situation where individuals would be better off cooperating but face incentives not to, making coordinated action difficult to achieve.
As defined in Chris Blattman
Other definitions
A situation where individual rational behavior leads to collectively irrational outcomes because actors cannot coordinate or face incentives to defect
Kimberly Clausing & Michael Pettis: Why Trump’s Tariffs Won't Fix Global Trade
Where it comes up · 24
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)3 claims
- 269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics2 claims
- Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/20111 claim
- Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’1 claim
- Daron Acemoglu on the Financial Crisis 02/09/20091 claim
- Chris Blattman1 claim
- Ezra Klein1 claim
- Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history1 claim
and 16 more
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “collective action problem” →
- Dictators like Stalin survive assassination from within because of a collective action problem rooted in pervasive distrust: anyone who proposes a coup cannot know whether the other person is a provocateur sent to test loyalty, so the rational move is to immediately denounce the conspirator to the dictator for self-preservation—the surveillance system (drivers, maids, tapped phones, provocateurs) deliberately enmeshes everyone in distrust, making coordination against the leader nearly impossible.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- Covid warranted deferring to whatever expert consensus existed at any moment because it was a public-health emergency with tremendous uncertainty, collective-action problems, a ticking clock, and a moving target—unlike static topics such as jihadism or crime/police-violence data, where 'doing your own research' was responsible because the facts were accessible and unchanging.335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid
- Unlike an ideal gas where individuals act independently, people are tied to their neighbors with significant interaction, and adding this interdependence changes the structure of the collective action problem—repeated interaction, more information about each other, and the emergence of salient norms create ways for people to solve problems they otherwise couldn't.269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics
- Collective-action problems lead people to believe their own small contribution will matter or spur others even when it will not, which underlies confused individual and subnational efforts on climate change.Cass Sunstein on Worst-case Scenarios 11/19/2007
- Despite numbering 3 million, Native Americans get little political traction because they are scattered in small groups across hundreds of reservations rather than concentrated, creating a typical collective action problem—their dispersed voices struggle against a well-organized D.C. bureaucracy and tribal leaderships through which federal money flows.Terry Anderson on Native American Economics
- Political outcomes are often captured by a vocal organized minority that has solved its collective action problem, so even when a general majority would benefit from a policy like free trade, a concentrated protectionist group can prevail—explaining why protectionism, car-scrappage schemes, and Buy-American mandates gain traction despite being poor policy.Daron Acemoglu on the Financial Crisis 02/09/2009
- If forced to pick one variable in 1800 to bet on where development would later occur, Blattman would choose historical levels of state capacity, because it is the most apparent cross-country correlation in his experience and serves as a proxy for general social organization—the ability to solve collective action problems and make collective decisions without devolving into conflict—functioning like a general-purpose technology.Chris Blattman
- A successful entrepreneur who avoids urban blight by working in a high office, arranging private transport, and living in a secure neighborhood ends up locked into those private expenditures, so when government asks for higher taxes to address homelessness he can no longer afford them—turning individual rational opt-outs into a collective action problem that starves the public solutions.232 - Inequality Revolution
- Because the global footwear and apparel supply chain is too large and badly policed for any single firm to clean up alone, Nike set up the Sustainable Apparel Coalition to align Western buyers behind common standards; these coalitions are hard to police, so they increasingly partner with local governments to raise the floor and build local institutional capacity in countries like Bangladesh and Vietnam.Rebecca Henderson on Reimagining Capitalism
- Portland's strict growth limits can be understood as a collective action problem: homeowners buy the neighborhood but lack ownership rights over its character, so each neighborhood resists density even though the city as a whole would be better off with more density, and bargains across neighborhoods could make everyone better off.Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/2011