What this covers

This is a two-part Foreign Affairs Interview in which Dan Kurtz-Phelan speaks separately with two economists about Donald Trump's tariffs after the April "Liberation Day" announcements. Both agree the global trading system needed an overhaul, but they disagree on what it should look like. Kimberly Clausing of UCLA argues against the protectionist approach and offers a progressive alternative. Michael Pettis, who teaches at Peking University and has long doubted the free-trade consensus, treats the current moment as the product of decades of accumulated imbalance.

Clausing's material is the more detailed. She notes that tax cuts and tariffs would normally strengthen the dollar, yet the dollar has fallen, which she reads as a confidence risk premium of the kind seen in Greece or Argentina. She links that to higher borrowing costs for mortgages and credit cards if the US is seen as less safe. She calls a 10% across-the-board tariff the largest tax increase in a generation and describes the recessionary drag of uncertainty as businesses wait to invest. She also covers bilateral deficits as a misleading gauge of unfairness, subsidies versus tariffs for strategic sectors (with US steel as the cautionary case), and the constitutional argument that Congress, not the president, holds the power to tax. On China, she favors pressure through allies and rules-based processes over a unilateral 125% tariff. She also takes up manufacturing's decline, which she says began around 1950, and the real problem of regions left behind.

Pettis's segment draws on the Plaza Accords of 1985, which produced rebalancing in most countries but saw Japan's surplus return to its earlier level after about a year. He also considers whether China could sustain "helicopter money" to lift household demand, concluding that its debt levels limit this to short periods. His framing of surplus countries suppressing consumption and exporting the imbalance to partners, especially the US, shapes the case for a Keynesian rebalancing framework.

Sharpest takeaway

The global economic system faces a fundamental structural crisis rooted in imbalanced trade and capital flows that neither Trump's protectionist tariffs nor the mainstream free-trade consensus adequately addresses; what's needed is a systemic rebalancing framework based on Keynesian principles that constrains persistent trade surpluses rather than reactive tariffs.

  • The US absorbs roughly half of global trade deficits due to deep financial markets and dollar dominance, forcing it to choose between unemployment, rising household debt, or fiscal deficits
  • Countries pursuing export-led growth while suppressing domestic consumption externalize their imbalances onto trading partners, creating the current system of unsustainable deficits
  • Trump's bilateral tariffs address symptoms (trade deficits) without addressing the structural cause (capital account imbalances and weak domestic demand in surplus countries)

The claims · ranked116 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.85

Tax cuts and tariffs normally would cause dollar appreciation due to increased excess demand for US goods and raised equilibrium interest rates, but instead the US is experiencing dollar depreciation alongside these policy announcements, indicating that confidence risk premia are dominating underlying economic forces—a regime previously seen in countries like Greece or Argentina but not in the US in Clausing's lifetime.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“When we look at both the tax cuts that have been proposed by Congress and the tariffs that have been proposed by uh the administration... both of those normally would cause dollar appreciation... What we've seen in contrast is dollar depreciation... And that suggests that we're in a regime where the confidence risk premia type things that I was talking about earlier are dominating these underlying economic forces. And that's a regime that international economists will recognize from situations like Greece during the Euro crisis or Argentina off and on. you know, like there's plenty of countries that have that experience, but it hasn't been a US experience in my lifetime.”

0.80

If the US becomes perceived as less safe through trade policy chaos, assault on central bank independence, disregard for rule of law, and irresponsible fiscal policies, the US will face higher interest rates when borrowing, making debt less sustainable and requiring higher interest payments on mortgages and credit cards.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“It's not just this sort of completely shambolic and distressing set of trade policies. It's an assault on the independence of the central bank. It's a reduction in the sense that the United States government will adhere to the rule of law... all of this means that when the US goes out to borrow in world markets, the interest rates that we're going to pay are going to be higher. That makes US debt less sustainable. That means US taxpayers will get less government services per dollar of tax paid because more and more is going to go to interest.”

0.80

For strategic sectors, subsidies are a better tool than tariffs because tariffs just hope that the homegrown sector will rise to the occasion, while subsidies directly support investment, and without subsidies protected sectors (like steel) never meet world market tests.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“when you identify a strategic sector and you want to have more of it, like I think the best way to do that is to just put your money where your mouth is and subsidize the sector, right? I think if you put up tariffs and just hope that the homegrown sector, you know, rises to the occasion, you'll end up with a sector that never really can meet the test of world markets, as we've seen in our steel sector, right?”

0.80

The centrality of the dollar in the global economy helps typical Americans by allowing the US to borrow at very low interest rates due to the dollar's safe-haven status, enabling higher consumption and the ability to run large budget deficits without imperiling US investment or living standards.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“Because the United States is considered a safe place and our government debt is considered a safe investment. Historically, we've been able to borrow at very low interest rates. And this has enabled consumption in the United States to be higher than it would otherwise be. And it's made it easier to do things like run a 6% of GDP budget deficit in a perfectly good economy, which is what we've been doing lately, without it imperiling US investment or the, you know, standard of living of typical Americans.”

0.75

IRS budget cuts will reduce tax morale and tax compliance because small businesses that perceive discretion in reporting income and expenses will feel the probability of audit has declined significantly.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I'm also concerned about the big cuts in to the IRS because that's also going to reduce tax morale and tax compliance because small businesses that have, you know, perceived discretion about what they're reporting in terms of income and expenses will feel that the probability of an audit has gone down quite a lot too.”

0.75

Bilateral trade deficits are a misleading measure because most countries with which the US runs bilateral deficits have relatively fair trade policies, so the conflation of bilateral deficits with unfair trade practices is puzzling.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“You know, of course, there are examples that we could point to of countries that have unfair trade policies, but this across-the-board conflation of unfair trade policies with bilateral trade deficits is puzzling and misleading since most of the countries that we have bilateral trade deficits with have relatively fair trade policies.”

0.75

The situation of typical American workers has fallen short of expectations due to multiple reasons including technological change, decline of unionization, and rising market power of firms—not primarily due to trade policy.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“The situation of typical American workers has fallen short of expectations. And I think that's true. And there's multiple reasons for that. Many of which lie far beyond trade, including technological change and the decline of unionization, rising market power of firms.”

0.75

A 10% across-the-board tariff represents the largest tax increase in more than a generation and will cost American households thousands of dollars in increased costs for goods while risking recession through supply chain pressures and retaliation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“What's kind of astonishing to me is how little note has been really taken of how much of a tax increase a 10% across the board tariff is... these tariffs really are an enormous tax increase. And if you take sort of the set of tariffs that are in place today on April 21st, they amount to the largest tax increase in more than a generation. and they will cost American households thousands of dollars and increased costs for goods and they risk sinking the economy into a recession”

0.75

Business and investor uncertainty about whether tariff rates will stay high or decline creates recessionary headwinds as many economic actors simultaneously wait to resolve uncertainty rather than make investment decisions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“There's a lot of investor uncertainty surrounding whether that tariffs stay at that high rate or come down eventually. And in the midst of this kind of uncertainty, the natural thing to do if you're a business investor is to just wait and see what happens. But if many many actors in the economies simultaneously wait to resolve these uncertainties, that also creates recessionary headwinds.”

0.75

As countries working around US tariff policies, Europe closed many trade deals in the first Trump administration to insulate themselves from perceived US riskiness, and the second Trump administration has increased that perception tenfold in partner countries like the EU, Canada, Japan, and Korea.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“If you look at the first Trump administration as a possible like mini version of this, we saw Europe uh close a lot of trade deals during those four years in part to help insulate themselves from this perceived additional riskiness of the United States. I think the second Trump administration has you know tenfold and increased that impression uh in a lot of our partner countries.”

0.75

Business investors facing tariff uncertainty will naturally choose to wait and see what happens before committing to decisions, but when many actors simultaneously delay, this creates recessionary headwinds across the economy.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“There's a lot of investor uncertainty surrounding whether that tariffs stay at that high rate or come down eventually. And in the midst of this kind of uncertainty, the natural thing to do if you're a business investor is to just wait and see what happens. But if many many actors in the economies simultaneously wait to resolve these uncertainties, that also creates recessionary headwinds.”

0.75

When you identify a strategic sector and want more of it, the best approach is to subsidize it directly rather than impose tariffs, because tariffs that rely on protected sectors rising to meet world markets often fail to make sectors competitive, as evidenced by the perpetually protected US steel sector.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“when you identify a strategic sector and you want to have more of it, like I think the best way to do that is to just put your money where your mouth is and subsidize the sector, right? I think if you put up tariffs and just hope that the homegrown sector, you know, rises to the occasion, you'll end up with a sector that never really can meet the test of world markets, as we've seen in our steel sector, right? We somehow every year for, you know, what feels like decades, there's pressure to protect the steel sector.”

0.75

Putting tariffs on footwear and apparel when most people don't want to make those products is driving up consumer costs and pulling resources away from other sectors where America is genuinely competitive, like advanced manufacturing (Boeing 787 Dreamliner).

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I'm not sure why we would be putting tariffs on footwear, which we are, you know, uh, for many countries in the world, and apparel when most people don't want to make footwear and apparel. And if we do that, we're just driving up costs for consumers, and we're pulling resources away from other sectors where we're really good at making things. So, an example would be the Boeing 787 Dreamliner plane, right? We're very good at making that plane.”

0.75

Bilateral trade deficits are a misleading and puzzling metric because most countries the US has bilateral trade deficits with have relatively fair trade policies; conflating bilateral deficits with unfair trade is erroneous.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“You know, of course, there are examples that we could point to of countries that have unfair trade policies, but this acrosstheboard conflation of unfair trade policies with bilateral trade deficits is puzzling and misleading since most of the countries that we have bilateral trade deficits with have relatively fair trade policies.”

0.75

Cuts to IRS funding will reduce tax compliance and increase non-reporting by small businesses due to lower perceived audit probability, creating a multifaceted attack on government revenue streams.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I'm also concerned about the big cuts in to the IRS because that's also going to reduce tax morale and tax compliance because small businesses that have, you know, perceived discretion about what they're reporting in terms of income and expenses will feel that the probability of an audit has gone down quite a lot too.”

0.75

China could temporarily boost domestic demand through 'helicopter money' (central government borrowing to deliver funds to households), but given massive debt levels in China, this strategy is not sustainable beyond short periods.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“there is a way you can do it quickly and that's you know sort of helicopter money. You can basically have the central government borrow money and deliver that directly or indirectly to the household sector in order to boost domestic consumption. You can do that for short periods of time, but given the enormous debt levels in China and the rapid growth in debt, there's a limit to how long they can do that.”

0.74

The share of Americans working in manufacturing has been declining steadily since 1950, and this decline is not primarily a post-Cold War free trade phenomenon but a much longer-term trend.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dan Curts Failen

“You noted in a piece you wrote for us in 2019 called the progressive case for free trade... that the share of Americans working in manufacturing has been declining steadily since 1950. Not this does not all start with the you know postcold war free trade agreements. It goes much further.”

0.74

There is a real and empirically grounded story that certain regions and pockets of the country feel left behind, with fewer plentiful jobs for non-college-educated workers, which deserves concern even if manufacturing fetishism is not the right response.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“If you're in Ohio or you're in West Virginia, they may look back to an earlier era where there were more plentiful jobs available for in particular for non-oled educated men, but also more broadly. And I think this story of left behind places is a real story with empirical truth behind it. Right? So, I think there's a reason to care about uh this issue”

0.74

The Plaza Accords of 1985 attempted to force dollar depreciation through coordinated currency appreciation by Japan, Germany, France, and England; in most countries there was trade rebalancing, but in Japan the surplus returned to previous levels after about a year.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“In 1985... Japan and Germany above all, but also France and England and one or two other countries agreed to appreciate their currencies against the dollar. And in most of those countries, we did see a rebalancing of trade. But not in Japan. In Japan, we saw a rebalancing for about a year or so and then the Japanese trade surplus surged again.”

0.74

Recessionary headwinds from tariffs can reduce taxes elsewhere in the tax system because laid-off workers stop paying payroll and income taxes, creating a secondary fiscal drag beyond the tariff base erosion.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“there's also recessionary headwinds that get caused by the tariffs and that can reduce taxes elsewhere in the tax system too, right? So if people are laid off because their small business can't get access to the inputs they need, right? That means they're going to stop paying payroll taxes and income taxes, right?”

0.74

If the US perceives China has excess capacity in steel and wants to address unfair practices, the right approach is to work with allies like Canada, Australia, Japan, Korea, and Europe to pressure China on specific issues through a rules-based process, not to impose unilateral 125% tariffs.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think if that's the problem, right, then it behooves us to deal with that problem. And how would you do that? I think the best way you could do that is to work with partners like Canada and Australia and Japan and Korea and Europe and together pressure China on specific things like we think you have too much capacity in the steel sector. We want to work in a rules-based way to address that. But I think slapping up a lot of tariffs and starting a trade war that involves 125% tariffs. I think that's a very clumsy and foolish way to deal with the underlying problem.”

0.74

The president cannot unilaterally do tax policy through tariffs; Article 1 of the Constitution gives Congress authority to lay taxes. While emergency and national security exceptions exist, most international trade lawyers argue these exceptions don't truly meet the moment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“one I just alluded to, which is that you might wonder, can the president basically do tax policy by himself? Doesn't he need Congress? It seems like article one of the constitution gives Congress the authority to lay taxes, and that includes tariffs. Now, they have some exceptions for emergencies and national security, and President Trump is relying on those, but I think most international trade lawyers would tell you that exceptions uh such as those don't really meet the moment.”

0.73

The share of Americans working in manufacturing has been declining steadily since 1950, well before postwar free trade agreements, showing that the decline in manufacturing employment is not primarily a consequence of recent trade policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“the share of Americans working in manufacturing has been declining steadily since 1950. Not this does not all start with the you know postcold war free trade agreements. It goes much further.”

0.72

Most academic economists missed the relationship between capital flows and trade balances; they became more interested in internally consistent models than in actual economies, making unrealistic assumptions that simplify models but divorce them from economic reality.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“I'm very unhappy with what happened in academic economics in sort of the post 1970s period because it seemed to me economists became less interested in the country in economies or in countries and much more interested in internally consistent models. And for a model to be consistent you have to make assumptions that simplify the models. But these assumptions are so unrealistic that they no longer reflect the economy.”

0.72

The president lacks constitutional authority to implement tariffs unilaterally; Article I of the Constitution gives Congress authority to lay taxes, including tariffs, and while exceptions exist for emergencies and national security, most international trade lawyers would say Trump's claimed exceptions don't meet the moment.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“You might wonder, can the president basically do tax policy by himself? Doesn't he need Congress? It seems like article one of the constitution gives Congress the authority to lay taxes, and that includes tariffs. Now, they have some exceptions for emergencies and national security, and President Trump is relying on those, but I think most international trade lawyers would tell you that exceptions uh such as those don't really meet the moment.”

0.72

The current trade tensions were inevitable regardless of whether Trump or Biden took office, as they result from structural imbalances that have been decades in the making.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“The point is that this was inevitable. It didn't take Trump or Biden to do it. It was going to happen one way or another.”

0.72

Trade deficits do serve as a reasonable proxy for addressing global imbalances because they summarize multiple policy tools; any country running large persistent surpluses must be subsidizing exports at the expense of domestic demand in one way or another.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“Absolutely. In fact, what Kane's argued is that you don't really focus on specific things like tariffs or interest rates or wages because they're all summarized in the trade balance. If a country runs large persistent surpluses, that means that one way or another, it's subsidizing exports at the expense of domestic demand.”

0.72

China is in a tough position because countries running surpluses have very weak domestic demand and are forced to run surpluses to absorb high domestic production; without surpluses they would have to close factories and fire workers.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“China's in a tough position because we know from the historical precedents and also from the logic of imbalances that countries that run surpluses do so because they have very weak domestic demand. They're forced to run surpluses in order to resolve the high production domestically. without surpluses they would have to reduce production which means closing down factories and firing workers and doing all the things that nobody wants to do.”

0.72

Academic economists largely ignore China as evidence that the Lerner Symmetry Theorem (countries that see export increases see equivalent import increases) is false; China shows exports rising while imports decline.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“We have very strong models in economics. For example, the learner symmetry theorem that argues that countries that see increases in exports see equivalent increases in imports. And that's simply not true. You only have to look at China to see exports are rising and imports are declining. But most academic economists in the US, I would argue, sort of ignore China. It isn't as real as the models.”

0.72

In a globalized system where some countries control their domestic economies and external accounts while others give up control in favor of global integration, policies in countries that control their external accounts effectively become policies for other countries, creating a system where individual country incentives conflict with collective welfare.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“If we live in a very different system in which some countries agree to give up control of their domestic economies in favor of more global integration, but other countries, major economies insist on controlling their domestic economies. Then you have a very different type of globalization in which policies in one country, countries that control their external accounts effectively become policies in other countries.”

0.71

It is more enjoyable and offers better value to design the next Nike shoe, market it, finance it, conduct R&D and advertising than to physically sew and manufacture it, so tariffs on footwear and apparel that drive up consumer costs while pulling resources from sectors where the US is genuinely good at making things is misguided.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think it's much more fun to design the next Nike shoe and to market it and to finance it and to do the R&D and the advertising for it than it is to sew it up, you know, and kind of make the shoe physically, right? So, I'm not sure why we would be putting tariffs on footwear, which we are, you know, uh, for many countries in the world, and apparel when most people don't want to make footwear and apparel.”

0.71

Under certain economic conditions, tariffs can be expansionary and increase employment and wages, but under other conditions they can be contractionary, as with the Smoot-Hawley tariffs which were implemented when the US had weak domestic demand and strong exports—the opposite of what the US needed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“The purpose of that paper was not to support tariffs. The purpose is that under certain conditions tariffs can be expansionary and under other conditions they can be contractionary. So the paper was really about the Smoot Holly tariffs which were implemented at a time when the US had a problem of weak domestic demand and very strong exports. So tariffs did exactly the opposite of what the US needed.”

0.70

The Trump administration's approach of shocking trading partners and allies with tariffs is not bringing them to the table or strengthening US arguments against China; instead, it is weakening the US argument by angering close allies early on (Canada, Mexico, Europe).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“In my conversations with people from other countries, I've seen zero evidence that this approach is bringing people to the table or winning an argument for the United States relative to China. I think on the contrary, it's weakening our argument to have us kind of lashing out. I mean, look at how we started this with this Groundhog Day, you know, proposal to put enormous tariffs on Canada and Mexico and targeting Europe really early on. I mean, it's really a set of steps that have deeply angered and frustrated our closest friends who we might normally work with on this.”

0.70

Global tensions are rising everywhere, not just between the US and China; many countries are filing WTO complaints against China and against each other, and this is spreading rapidly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“although the conflict between the US and China gets all of the attention in the press, that's a mistake. In fact, global tensions are rising everywhere. We're seeing a huge number of countries for example uh put in WTO complaints against China and it's spreading very rapidly and against each other”

0.70

A 10% across-the-board tariff represents the largest tax increase on American households in more than a generation, with tariffs on all goods as of April 21st amounting to the largest tax increase in more than a generation that will cost American households thousands of dollars in increased costs for goods.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“what's kind of astonishing to me is how little note has been really taken of how much of a tax increase a 10% across the board tariff is. You know, if if a Democrat or a Republican were announcing the largest tax increase in more than a generation, it's unlikely that they would do that in a rose garden ceremony to try to draw a lot of attention to it. Um, but these tariffs really are an enormous tax increase. And if you take sort of the set of tariffs that are in place today on April 21st, they amount to the largest tax increase in more than a generation. and they will cost American households thousands of dollars and increased costs for goods”

0.70

Countries that would normally be America's closest friends and allies (EU, Canada, Japan, Korea) are probably wondering how reliable the United States is as a partner, and are actively working around US economic relationships by building relationships with each other, evident in daily announcements of Canada-Australia, Japan-Korea cooperation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“all of them are probably wondering just how reliable the United States is, right? And thinking hard about ways that they can build relationships with each other. And you see announcements on a daily basis of Canada and Australia getting together, Japan and Korea being more friendly, you know, and so there's there's a lot of working around the United States that's happening right now.”

0.70

In a globalized system where some countries control their domestic economies while others give up that control for global integration, policies in countries that control their external accounts effectively become policies for other countries, creating a system where individually rational actions become collectively irrational.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“if we live in a very different system in which some countries agree to give up control of their domestic economies in favor of more global integration, but other countries, major economies insist on controlling their domestic economies. Then you have a very different type of globalization in which policies in one country, countries that control their external accounts effectively become policies in other countries. And the problem with that, as Kane's pointed out, is that it makes sense for countries to do things individually that doesn't make sense collectively for the system.”

0.69

Since the Bretton Woods collapse in the early 1970s, the US and to a lesser extent the UK and Canada have served as 'great absorbers' of excess savings from the rest of the world, accounting for roughly half of all deficits in the world and three-quarters when including Anglophone economies.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“The US plays a very special role in the global imbalances basically since we went off the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s and the role of the US and to a lesser extent of the UK and Canada is as the great absorber of excess savings in the rest of the world. So... the US accounts for roughly half of all of the deficits in the world, which is another way of saying that roughly half of the excess savings in the surplus countries are balanced by the acquisition of US assets. And if you include England and Canada, you account for roughly three quarters.”

0.69

To increase domestic demand quickly in China would require 'helicopter money'—having the central government borrow and deliver funds to the household sector to boost consumption—but given enormous debt levels and rapid debt growth, there are limits to how long this can continue.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“There is a way you can do it quickly and that's you know sort of helicopter money. You can basically have the central government borrow money and deliver that directly or indirectly to the household sector in order to boost domestic consumption. You can do that for short periods of time, but given the enormous debt levels in China and the rapid growth in debt, there's a limit to how long they can do that.”

0.69

The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) would have been a powerful tool for the US to build productive economic links with like-minded partners and allies, and its failure to pass during the Obama administration was a lost opportunity.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think you're right that TPP is a lost opportunity. I think it's really unfortunate that that didn't get done during the Obama administration that we don't have that as a powerful tool because if you think about the best way for the United States to sort of build up its productive economic links with like-minded partners and allies, TPP is a perfect solution.”

0.69

The "new Washington consensus" on trade assumes decades of growing economic openness have hurt American workers, increased inequality, and gutted the middle class, and that new restrictions on trade and immigration can reverse this damage.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“decades of growing economic openness have hurt American workers, increased inequality, and gutted the middle class, and new restrictions on trade and immigration can work to reverse the damage.”

0.69

The United States has done really well by the rules of the global system that it spent seven decades building, and the characterization of how the global economic system has harmed the United States is fundamentally wrong—the rules themselves do not disadvantage the US.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“In particular, the United States has really done well by the rules of the global system. And we spent, you know, seven decades trying to build those rules in part because we thought a free and open trading system that was rules-based was really in the interest of the United States. And when you look at how the US economy has done as a whole in recent decades, it's done really remarkably well. So I don't think the rules themselves disadvantage the United States.”

0.69

The Trump administration and Congress are posed to move in the opposite direction from addressing the unsustainable government fiscal situation, despite some rhetorical agreement that deficits are a problem.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think unfortunately the Trump administration together with Congress is really posed to move in the opposite direction from addressing that problem.”

0.69

The United States has done remarkably well by the rules of the global economic system, which was built over seven decades specifically because policymakers believed a free and open trading system was in the interest of the United States.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“the United States has really done well by the rules of the global system. And we spent, you know, seven decades trying to build those rules in part because we thought a free and open trading system that was rules-based was really in the interest of the United States.”

0.69

There is a story of 'left behind' regions and pockets in America (like Ohio and West Virginia) that feel disconnected from economic opportunity, with historical access to plentiful jobs for non-college educated workers, and this story has empirical truth behind it and merits policy attention.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“there's a sense that there are regions and pockets of this country that feel left behind. Right? So if you're in Ohio or you're in West Virginia, they may look back to an earlier era where there were more plentiful jobs available for in particular for non-oled educated men, but also more broadly. And I think this story of left behind places is a real story with empirical truth behind it. Right?”

0.69

If other countries address global problems like climate change, public health, and tax competition without US participation, that is a better outcome for the world than if countries abandon these efforts entirely.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think it would be a much better world if countries do move ahead without us than if they simply give up on these efforts.”

0.68

Bilateral trade deficits are meaningless and do not deserve policy focus; what matters is systemic surpluses and deficits—the degree to which each country's balance-of-payments accounts balance with the rest of the world, not whether the US has a deficit with any particular country.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“The problem is you should never focus on bilateral surpluses and deficits. They're quite meaningless. What really matters is systemic surpluses and deficits.”

0.68

A worst-case scenario is that imbalances continue for several more years and get worse, making the eventual retaliation more violent and problematic; this is a problem that should have been addressed 10-15 years ago.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“A worst case scenario would be that the imbalances continue for several more years and get worse, in which case the reaction will be that much more violent, that that much more problematic. This is something we should have addressed 10 or 15 years ago. the longer it takes us to address it, the worse the likely outcome is going to be.”

0.68

The decline of the US as a powerful actor in the world economy is occurring at a rapid pace, with diminishing soft power and credibility as a benevolent leader in global collective action problems, which is a major loss for the United States.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think what that will do in the long run is put the United States in a less powerful position in the world economy. Not just with respect to economic considerations, but also with this sort of amorphous concept of soft power, like the view of the United States as a potentially benevolent actor and leader in a host of global collective action problems. I think that view is diminishing at a much more rapid pace over the past 90 days than it's ever diminished in my lifetime.”

0.68

For every country, internal imbalances must be perfectly aligned with external imbalances, and every country's external imbalances must be aligned with the external imbalances of the rest of the world through the balance of payments balance.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“For every country the internal imbalances must be perfectly aligned with the external imbalances. And then of course for every country its external imbalances must be aligned with the external imbalances of the rest of the world. The balance of payments balance.”

0.68

China is in a tough position because countries running surpluses have weak domestic demand and are forced to run surpluses to resolve this weakness; if the US reduces its deficit, it puts enormous pressure on China to reduce its surpluses by either producing less (firing workers) or increasing domestic demand.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“China's in a tough position because we know from the historical precedents and also from the logic of imbalances that countries that run surpluses do so because they have very weak domestic demand. They're forced to run surpluses in order to resolve the high production domestically. without surpluses they would have to reduce production which means closing down factories and firing workers and doing all the things that nobody wants to do. So if the US is successful in reducing its deficit, and it's not clear that the Trump tariffs will do that, but if the US is successful in doing that, that puts enormous pressure on China to reduce its surpluses.”

0.68

Typical American workers' situation has fallen short of expectations, driven by technological change, decline of unionization, and rising market power of firms—factors far beyond trade—but there is some consensus that lower-income Americans have reason to be dissatisfied.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“One would be that, you know, the situation of typical American workers has fallen short of expectations. And I think that's true. And there's multiple reasons for that. Many of which lie far beyond trade, including technological change and the decline of unionization, rising market power of firms.”

0.68

Since the US went off the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s, the US and to lesser extent the UK and Canada have served as the great absorber of excess savings in the rest of the world.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“since we went off the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s and the role of the US and to a lesser extent of the UK and Canada is as the great absorber of excess savings in the rest of the world.”

0.68

The US central bank's independence is being threatened by the current administration, US government adherence to rule of law is declining (evidenced by conflicts with Harvard and the Supreme Court), and Republicans in Congress are proposing budget rules that would make $4 trillion in future deficits effectively disappear—all of which undermines international confidence in US assets.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“It's not just this sort of completely shambolic and distressing set of trade policies. It's an assault on the independence of the central bank. It's a reduction in the sense that the United States government will adhere to the rule of law in any number of areas, including, you know, in their tussle with Harvard, in their exchanges with the Supreme Court about due process and the like. And then at the same time, we've got Republicans in Congress suggesting that we adopt a new budget rule that would effectively make$4 trillion dollars worth of future deficits utterly disappear.”

0.68

While US financial dominance is good for American banks globally, it comes at enormous cost: an overvalued US dollar, a contraction in US manufacturing, and an expansion in US consumption, forcing the US to balance world surpluses either with rising unemployment (per Joan Robinson) or, since Bretton Woods ended, with rising household debt or fiscal deficits.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“While that is very good for the financial system of these countries and British and American uh banks dominate globally, it comes at an enormous cost. And the cost is an overvaluation of the US dollar and a contraction in US manufacturing in favor of an expansion in US consumption. Which means that basically the US has to balance the surpluses of the rest of the world either with rising unemployment, which is what Joan Robinson argued back in the 30s, or since the break up of Breton Woods, with rising household debt or rising fiscal deficits.”

0.68

Current trade tensions and retaliation were inevitable regardless of Trump or Biden, driven by structural imbalances that have accumulated over decades and reached unsustainability—this is not a policy accident but a system breaking point.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“once that retaliation begins, we will see a rise in global tensions, a contraction in global trade, and all the things we are worried about. The point is that this was inevitable. It didn't take Trump or Biden to do it. It was going to happen one way or another.”

0.66

Pettis's December Foreign Affairs paper argued that under certain conditions tariffs can be expansionary and under others contractionary, using the Smoot-Hawley tariffs as an example where they were contractionary because the US needed to boost domestic demand, which tariffs reduced by raising import prices.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“The purpose of that paper was not to support tariffs. The purpose is that under certain conditions tariffs can be expansionary and under other conditions they can be contractionary. So the paper was really about the Smoot Holly tariffs which were implemented at a time when the US had a problem of weak domestic demand and very strong exports. So tariffs did exactly the opposite of what the US needed. The US needed to boost domestic demand and tariffs did the opposite because by raising the price of imports it actually reduces real domestic demand.”

0.66

A more progressive tax system, stronger safety net, more investments in community college and infrastructure can help left-behind people and communities and make growth inclusive, which is superior to trade and immigration barriers as a policy response.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think a more progressive tax system, a stronger safety net, more investments in community college and infrastructure, all of these things can help left behind people's and communities and can make that growth inclusive. But trade barriers and immigration barriers are just plain wrong.”

0.66

A higher currency is a tax on production and a subsidy for consumption because currency appreciation reduces import costs for consumers and makes it harder for producers to compete globally.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“A currency appreciation is basically a tax on production and a subsidy for consumption because a higher currency reduces the cost of imports of consumer imports and it makes it more difficult for producers to compete globally.”

0.66

Protectionism shrinks the sectors the US is good at (high-value manufacturing, services) while expanding sectors where the US isn't well-suited to production, making this a problematic response to left-behind communities.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“One of the dangers of protectionism as a response to this lost manufacturing sector is it's actually kind of shrinking the sectors that we're good at and expanding sectors where I don't think we're really well suited to production.”

0.66

Tariffs are a regressive tax that disproportionately hurts poor people because they spend all their income and cannot avoid the tariff, whereas richer people can save some income and avoid tariff impacts.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“In the case of trade restrictions, you're not just putting on a regressive tax, which is what a tariff is. It's a tax that disproportionately hurts those that are poorer because they're spending all of their income, whereas those that are richer can save some and avoid the tariff.”

0.66

Trade has created a lot of jobs and destroyed some jobs, and while we should be sensitive to the harms, robots destroy jobs too, big companies displacing little companies destroy jobs, and capitalism itself constantly creates and destroys jobs—so blaming trade specifically for manufacturing decline is misleading.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“Trade has created a lot of jobs and of course it's destroyed some jobs too and we should be sensitive to the harms that happen in the economy but robots destroy jobs too. Big companies displacing little companies destroy jobs. Capitalism itself constantly creates and destroys jobs.”

0.66

The tax base for tariffs is roughly $3 trillion of goods imports while the income tax base is closer to $20 trillion, so tariffs would have to reach crazy-high levels to generate serious revenue, and at such levels the economy would be strangled, making tariffs a poor revenue source.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kimberly Clausing

“If you look at the tax base for tariffs, it's really about $3 trillion worth of goods imports. If you look at the tax base for the income tax, it's closer to $20 trillion, right? So, you really have to get tariffs up to a really crazy high level to get serious amounts of revenue out of them. And by the time you're at such a high level, you're really strangling the economy.”

0.65

As Joan Robinson argued, the cost of absorbing global surpluses through rising household debt or fiscal deficits only goes up to a point; at some point the cost becomes so great that countries begin to retaliate, leading to rising global tensions, contraction in global trade, and all the resulting negative effects.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“As Joan Robinson argued, that only goes up to a point, at some point the cost becomes so great that countries begin to retaliate. And once that retaliation begins, we will see a rise in global tensions, a contraction in global trade, and all the things we are worried about.”

0.65

Tariff are a regressive tax that disproportionately hurts poorer people because they spend all their income on consumption while richer people can save some income and avoid tariff impacts.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“in the case of trade restrictions, you're not just putting on a regressive tax, which is what a tariff is. It's a tax that disproportionately hurts those that are poorer because they're spending all of their income, whereas those that are richer can save some and avoid the tariff.”

0.65

The Kleski paradox holds that while rising wages drive demand, business investment, and productivity growth—making wages important for individual workers—individual businesses benefit from suppressing wage growth relative to productivity, creating a contradiction between individual and collective rationality.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“You want rising wages because rising wages drives demand, which drives business investment and particularly investment in increasing the productivity of individual workers and that's how you get rich. But individual businesses benefit from suppressing wage growth relative to productivity growth. And that was the paradox.”

0.64

Countries pursuing export-led growth policies that expand manufacturing exports at the cost of domestic consumption (subsidizing manufacturing at the expense of the household sector) grow faster but require running trade surpluses because of the gap between domestic production and consumption.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“if you're um a country that puts into place policies that are uh aimed at expanding manufacturing exports at the cost of domestic consumption, which basically means you subsidize manufacturing at the expense of the household sector. then you're going to grow more quickly, but you're going to require trade surpluses to balance the gap between your domestic production and your domestic consumption.”

0.64

More efficient ways to address the US deficit than tariffs would be a new global trade agreement along Keynes lines, or alternatively, interrupting the ability of countries with excess savings to balance those by acquiring US assets through capital controls or taxes on inflows.

normativehigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“I think there are much more efficient ways of addressing the US deficit. One way, as I argue in the most recent piece, would be a new global trade agreement along the lines that Kanes proposed. If that isn't possible, then the next best way is for the US to interrupt the ability of countries with excess savings to balance those by acquiring US assets. So some sort of capital controls, taxes on inflows, etc.”

0.64

A revival of Keynes's 1944 Breton Woods proposal would be preferable to a new Plaza Accord because it would establish a systemic framework rather than just currency coordination.

normativehigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“I would prefer a revival of Kanes's proposal in 1944 at Breton Woods than a new plaza accords.”

0.64

Tariffs on goods will risk sinking the economy into a recession because much of the goods imported are critical parts of the US supply chain, and retaliatory trade measures will hurt US export industries.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“they risk sinking the economy into a recession because a lot of the goods that we import are really important parts of our supply chain and the pressures of retaliation will really hurt our export industries.”

0.63

Dollar is depreciating despite tariffs and fiscal expansion that would normally cause dollar appreciation, suggesting that confidence risk premia are dominating underlying economic forces—a regime historically seen in crises like Greece in the Euro crisis or Argentina, but not in the US in living memory.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“both of those normally would cause dollar appreciation. the tariffs because there'd be an excess demand for US goods which would increase the value of the dollar and the fiscal expansion because it would tend to raise equilibrium interest rates which would make US assets look in theory more attractive and also raise the value of the dollar. What we've seen in contrast is dollar depreciation accompanying both these budget announcements and these trade tussles. And that suggests that we're in a regime where the confidence risk premia type things that I was talking about earlier are dominating these underlying economic forces. And that's a regime that international economists will recognize from situations like Greece during the Euro crisis or Argentina off and on.”

0.63

Bond market reaction to Trump's reciprocal tariff announcement was so negative that it was recognized as a signal scary enough to prompt the administration to pause those tariffs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“news reporting suggested that the bond market reaction to the so-called reciprocal tariffs um was part of why they were paused is that was recognized as a very scary sign.”

0.63

There is zero evidence from conversations with other countries that Trump's tariff approach is winning arguments relative to China or bringing people to the table; instead, it's weakening US arguments by angering closest allies early on.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Kimberly Clausing

“In my conversations with people from other countries, I've seen zero evidence that this approach is bringing people to the table or winning an argument for the United States relative to China. I think on the contrary, it's weakening our argument to have us kind of lashing out. I mean, look at how we started this with this Groundhog Day, you know, proposal to put enormous tariffs on Canada and Mexico and targeting Europe really early on. I mean, it's really a set of steps that have deeply angered and frustrated our closest friends who we might normally work with on this. So, I think it's just plain wrong to say that that's a great starting point for bringing together the community of nations to counter the challenge of China.”

0.61

The 'new Washington consensus' holds that decades of growing economic openness have hurt American workers, increased inequality, and gutted the middle class, and that new restrictions on trade and immigration can reverse this damage, though Clausing sees some welcome elements in focusing on inclusive growth while challenging the diagnosis of trade's role.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Foreign Affairs Host

“You wrote about a quote, "New Washington consensus that was taking hold, describing that consensus. He wrote that it held that decades of growing economic openness have hurt American workers, increased inequality, and gutted the middle class, and new restrictions on trade and immigration can work to reverse the damage.”

0.61

The Plaza Accord of 1985 was an attempt to force appreciation of yen and mark against the dollar during Reagan administration; in most countries it led to rebalancing of trade, but in Japan it only caused rebalancing for about a year before Japanese trade surplus surged again.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“In 1985. So under the Plaza Accord, Japan and Germany above all, but also France and England and one or two other countries agreed to appreciate their currencies against the dollar. And in most of those countries, we did see a rebalancing of trade. But not in Japan. In Japan, we saw a rebalancing for about a year or so and then the Japanese trade surplus surged again.”

0.61

Because the US is considered a safe place and US government debt a safe investment, the US has historically been able to borrow at very low interest rates, which has enabled consumption to be higher than otherwise and allowed the US to run a 6% of GDP budget deficit in a healthy economy without imperiling investment or living standards.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“Because the United States is considered a safe place and our government debt is considered a safe investment. Historically, we've been able to borrow at very low interest rates. And this has enabled consumption in the United States to be higher than it would otherwise be. And it's made it easier to do things like run a 6% of GDP budget deficit in a perfectly good economy, which is what we've been doing lately, without it imperiling US investment or the, you know, standard of living of typical Americans.”

0.61

The tax base for tariffs is only about $3 trillion of goods imports, while the tax base for income tax is closer to $20 trillion, so you would need tariffs at crazy high levels to get serious revenue, and at such levels you would strangle the economy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“if you look at the tax base for tariffs, it's really about $3 trillion worth of goods imports. If you look at the tax base for the income tax, it's closer to $20 trillion, right? So, you really have to get tariffs up to a really crazy high level to get serious amounts of revenue out of them. And by the time you're at such a high level, you're really strangling the economy.”

0.61

The Biden administration kept some Trump-era tariffs on China in place because of disagreement within the administration about how successful those tariffs were in achieving policy aims, though it pursued a far more strategic and nuanced approach than Trump's scattered application of tariffs to 125% of goods compared to Biden's $28 billion in new tariffs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think that they were interested in addressing some of the problems with respect to competition with China and they were reluctant to pull back entirely on the Chinese tariffs. I think there was some disagreement within the administration about how successful those tariffs were in achieving their policy aim. And there was of course uh late in the administration some new tariffs that were put on now just on 28 billion dollars worth of goods or I forget the exact number but a very small number of goods compared to say the Trumpian proposals which involve tariffs on $3 trillion worth of goods potentially all of the world”

0.61

If the US were to lose its privileged borrowing status due to diminished confidence, interest rates on US mortgages and credit card debt would rise significantly, directly harming the borrowing costs faced by ordinary Americans.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“you and I if we go out and take a mortgage on our houses or acrue credit card debt, you know, even debts like that are going to face higher interest rates in a world where the United States isn't considered a safe location to invest in.”

0.61

Robots, big companies displacing small companies, and capitalism itself constantly create and destroy jobs, so singling out trade as the dominant force causing job loss misattributes the problem to outsiders when the real causes are technological change and market dynamics.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“trade has created a lot of jobs and of course it's destroyed some jobs too and we should be sensitive to the harms that happen in the economy but robots destroy jobs too. Big companies displacing little companies destroy jobs. Capitalism itself constantly creates and destroys jobs. So I think this tendency to try to blame outsiders for things that are really not the outsiders problem, right, is harmful and actually risks hurting the very people you're trying to help.”

0.61

The US, UK, and Canada share deep, flexible financial markets, good corporate governance, and strong reputations for safe assets, which is why they are preferred destinations for foreign capital investment when countries acquire foreign assets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“What these economies have in common is not just that they all speak English, but rather that they all have very deep, flexible financial markets, very good corporate governance, a strong reputation for safe assets.”

0.61

Currency appreciation is a tax on production and subsidy for consumption because higher currency reduces the cost of imports of consumer goods and makes it more difficult for producers to compete globally.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“a currency appreciation is basically a tax on production and a subsidy for consumption because a higher currency reduces the cost of imports of consumer imports and it makes it more difficult for producers to compete globally.”

0.61

Modern academic economics in the US ignores China as a counterexample to theoretical models like the Lerner Symmetry Theorem that predicts exports and imports rise together, but China shows exports rising and imports declining, contradicting the theory.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“We have very strong models in economics. For example, the learner symmetry theorem that argues that countries that see increases in exports see equivalent increases in imports. And that's simply not true. You only have to look at China to see exports are rising and imports are declining. But most academic economists in the US, I would argue, sort of ignore China. It isn't as real as the models.”

0.61

The solution of trade and immigration restrictions is worse than the disease of inequality and left-behind regions, so it would be better to do nothing at all than implement protectionist policies.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I worry very much that the solution, this post- neoliberal solution is worse than the disease, you know, and it'd be better to do nothing at all than do that.”

0.61

Trump's fixation on trade deficits, while he may not understand the underlying drivers, is in some ways a reasonable proxy for addressing global imbalances, because according to Keynes, trade surpluses and deficits summarize all the policy distortions—tariffs, interest rates, wages—that cause them.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“Trump of course fixates on trade deficits even if he doesn't exactly understand the drivers beneath them. Is that in some ways a reasonable proxy for addressing the imbalances that you're identifying in the global economy? Absolutely. In fact, what Kane's argued is that you don't really focus on specific things like tariffs or interest rates or wages because they're all summarized in the trade balance.”

0.61

If tariffs must be used, they should be across-the-board tariffs on all imports to change savings-investment imbalances in the rest of the world, not bilateral tariffs which simply do not address the underlying structural problem.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“If you're going to use tariffs, which are probably the least effective way of doing so and the most contentious, by the way, then probably what you would want is tariffs across the board on all imports because the purpose of the tariffs would be to change the savings investment imbalances in the rest of the world. And of course, bilateral tariffs simply do not do that.”

0.61

If global trade imbalances aren't addressed, the reaction from trading partners will be increasingly violent and problematic the longer the imbalances persist; these imbalances should have been addressed 10-15 years ago and the longer delay makes the eventual resolution worse.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“the problem, you know, as Joan Robinson said, is that inevitably we're going to see a rise in retaliation if these imbalances aren't resolved. So, a worst case scenario would be that the imbalances continue for several more years and get worse, in which case the reaction will be that much more violent, that that much more problematic. This is something we should have addressed 10 or 15 years ago. the longer it takes us to address it, the worse the likely outcome is going to be.”

0.61

There are many ways to intervene in trade (tariffs, interest rates, wages, capital controls), so if countries agree on currency appreciation, they still have many avenues open to reverse that appreciation and maintain surpluses.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“There are many many ways you can intervene in trade. And my concern is that if they agree on a change in the value of the currency, so for example, if we come to a new plaza accord and Germany agree to appreciate their currencies against the dollar, that still leaves many other avenues open for them to reverse that appreciation.”

0.61

In the ideal system, the main reason for increasing exports would be to increase domestic welfare by increasing imports, creating a balanced trading system, not a mercantilist one focused on maximizing export volumes.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“And in in that case, we would once again have a balanced trading system in which the main reason for increasing your exports would be to increase domestic welfare by increasing your imports.”

0.60

Just as major shifts in global trade and payments balances in the 1930s and 1970s triggered major changes in economic thinking, the current moment may be undergoing a similar shift toward more realistic and policy-relevant economics.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“Just as in the 1930s there was a major change in the global balance of trade and payments and a major change in the way we thought about economics and that happened again in the 1970s. I hope we're undergoing a new change in the way we think about economics that's a bit more realistic and a bit more meaningful to people in Wall Street or in government.”

0.60

For every country, internal imbalances must be perfectly aligned with external imbalances, and for every country its external imbalances must be aligned with the external imbalances of the rest of the world through the balance of payments balance—a fundamental accounting identity in economics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“for every country the internal imbalances must be perfectly aligned with the external imbalances. And then of course for every country its external imbalances must be aligned with the external imbalances of the rest of the world. The balance of payments balance.”

0.60

The second Trump administration has increased allied perceptions of US unreliability by ten-fold relative to the first administration, causing allies to view the US as more risky and less dependable.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think the second Trump administration has you know tenfold and increased that impression uh in a lot of our partner countries.”

0.60

The view of the United States as a potentially benevolent actor and leader in addressing global collective action problems is diminishing at a much more rapid pace over the past 90 days than at any point in Clausing's lifetime.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think that view is diminishing at a much more rapid pace over the past 90 days than it's ever diminished in my lifetime.”

0.59

Global tensions are rising everywhere, not just between US and China, with huge numbers of countries filing WTO complaints against China and each other, spreading rapidly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Michael Pettis

“Well, one thing I would say is that although the conflict between the US and China gets all of the attention in the press, that's a mistake. In fact, global tensions are rising everywhere. We're seeing a huge number of countries for example uh put in WTO complaints against China and it's spreading very rapidly and against each other we're going to see more and more of this”

0.59

A more progressive tax system, stronger safety net, more investments in community college and infrastructure are better ways to help left-behind communities and make growth inclusive than trade barriers and immigration barriers, which are plainly wrong.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think a more progressive tax system, a stronger safety net, more investments in community college and infrastructure, all of these things can help left behind people's and communities and can make that growth inclusive. But trade barriers and immigration barriers are just plain wrong.”

0.59

The Trans-Pacific Partnership was a lost opportunity that would have been a powerful tool for the United States to build productive economic relationships with like-minded partners and allies in the region.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“I think you're right that TPP is a lost opportunity. I think it's really unfortunate that that didn't get done during the Obama administration that we don't have that as a powerful tool because if you think about the best way for the United States to sort of build up its productive economic links with like-minded partners and allies, TPP is a perfect solution.”

0.57

The Biden administration kept in place some Trump-era tariffs on China and was reluctant to rejoin the Trans-Pacific Partnership, but these actions were much more strategic, nuanced, and careful compared to Trump's current across-the-board tariff approach affecting $3 trillion worth of goods globally.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“if you compare the two I think they're really incomparable like the Biden administration's views while one could critique them are are far more strategic nuanced and careful than this sort of you know slapshot scattered approach of the Trump administration which encompasses a lot of countries for which there is no strategic threat where trade policies aren't unfair.”

0.56

Bond market reactions to Trump's reciprocal tariff announcements showed adverse and unexpectedly concerning responses, and news reporting suggested that bond market reaction was part of why the reciprocal tariffs were paused.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Kimberly Clausing

“You've seen interest rates and bond prices respond to some of these recent announcements and moments in an adverse way, in an unexpectedly concerning way. And in fact, news reporting suggested that the bond market reaction to the so-called reciprocal tariffs um was part of why they were paused is that was recognized as a very scary sign.”

0.56

This creates what Pettis calls the 'Michael Kleski paradox': individual businesses benefit from suppressing wage growth relative to productivity growth even though rising wages are necessary for economic growth—what makes sense individually does not make sense collectively.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“In my piece in foreign affairs, I refer to that as the Michael Kleski paradox. And you know, Kleski argued that in an economy, you want rising wages because rising wages drives demand, which drives business investment and particularly investment in increasing the productivity of individual workers and that's how you get rich. But individual businesses benefit from suppressing wage growth relative to productivity growth.”

0.56

The point of Pettis's analysis is to argue that we've locked ourselves into a type of globalization that Keynes thought was problematic, and we need to break out of it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“the point of the paper is to argue that we've locked ourselves into the kind of globalization that people like Kanes thought was a real problem and we need to break out of it.”

0.56

Miran wants to reverse the dollar appreciation to reduce the production-tax consumption-subsidy effect by engineering a dollar decline, but this is difficult because there are many ways countries can intervene in trade, and changing the currency still leaves avenues open for reversal.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“And one of the ways of reversing that process would be to engineer a decline in the value of the dollar. The problem with a repeat of the plaza accords is that tariffs and currency appreciation or depreciation are ways of intervening in trade. But there are many many different ways of intervening in trade.”

0.55

Pettis's arguments about global imbalances are a revival of arguments made by John Maynard Keynes, Joan Robinson, and other economists from the 1920s-30s dealing with similar imbalances and their consequences, not novel heterodox economics but rather pre-1970s mainstream economics.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“my view of these imbalances is not particularly new. It's only new in the context of a sort of American academic economist who seem to have forgotten a lot about what we used to know. In effect, I'm reviving arguments made by John Maynard Kanes, uh, Joan Robinson, Ragna Nerksky, and a whole bunch of economists from the 1920s and 30s”

0.55

Post-1970s economics prioritizes internally consistent models with unrealistic assumptions that no longer reflect actual economies; for models to be consistent they require simplifying assumptions so unrealistic they're detached from reality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“For a model to be consistent you have to make assumptions that simplify the models. But these assumptions are so unrealistic that they no longer reflect the economy.”

0.52

Polls show most Americans say there should be more manufacturing jobs, but when asked if they personally would want to work in manufacturing, most say no—suggesting a disconnect between the appeal of manufacturing as a policy goal and its actual desirability as work.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“If you poll Americans and you say, "Should there be more manufacturing jobs?" Most of them are like, "Sure, yes." But if you ask them, would you like to work in a manufacturing job? Most of them are like, no, I would really rather not.”

0.52

When working outside the US—in Latin America and Asia—there is much more realistic understanding of the relationship between economic theory and economic practice and actuality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“I think when you're outside of China, and most of my career has been in Latin America, Asia, outside of the US, I think there's a much more realistic view of the relationship between economic theory and economic practice and actuality.”

0.52

If you poll Americans asking whether there should be more manufacturing jobs, most say yes, but if you ask whether they would personally want to work in a manufacturing job, most say no, preferring design, marketing, finance, and R&D over physical manufacturing work.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“If you poll Americans and you say, "Should there be more manufacturing jobs?" Most of them are like, "Sure, yes." But if you ask them, would you like to work in a manufacturing job? Most of them are like, no, I would really rather not. I mean, I think it's much more fun to design the next Nike shoe and to market it and to finance it and to do the R&D and the advertising for it than it is to sew it up”

0.52

When you're outside the US and sitting in emerging markets like Latin America, Asia, or China, you get a much more realistic view of the relationship between economic theory and economic practice, explaining Pettis's perspective.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“I think when you're outside of China, and most of my career has been in Latin America, Asia, outside of the US, I think there's a much more realistic view of the relationship between economic theory and economic practice and actuality.”

0.52

A reformed trade agreement should penalize countries running persistent trade surpluses and allow exception for developing countries and small economies, establishing the principle that surpluses externalize adjustment costs onto trade partners.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“There could be exception for developing countries for small economies for special cases but generally the agreement is that you manage your internal imbalances in such a way that you don't export them to your trade partners. If you do, you get penalized.”

0.52

In a Keynesian balanced system, the main reason for increasing exports would be to increase domestic welfare by increasing imports—exports exist to pay for imports, not the reverse.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“in that case, we would once again have a balanced trading system in which the main reason for increasing your exports would be to increase domestic welfare by increasing your imports. That's the kind of system Kane's proposed and that's what I would support.”

0.52

Pettis hopes that just as major changes in global trade balances and economic thinking occurred in the 1930s and 1970s, a new change in how we think about economics is underway that's more realistic and meaningful to people in Wall Street and government.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“So what I'm hoping is just as in the 1930s there was a major change in the global balance of trade and payments and a major change in the way we thought about economics and that happened again in the 1970s. I hope we're undergoing a new change in the way we think about economics that's a bit more realistic and a bit more meaningful to people in Wall Street or in government.”

0.51

Pettis's understanding of trade imbalances is not new—it revives arguments from Keynes, Robinson, Nurkse, and 1920s-30s economists about imbalances and their consequences, which American economists have largely forgotten.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Pettis

“My view of these imbalances is not particularly new. It's only new in the context of a sort of American academic economist who seem to have forgotten a lot about what we used to know. In effect, I'm reviving arguments made by John Maynard Kanes, uh, Joan Robinson, Ragna Nerksky, and a whole bunch of economists from the 1920s and 30s”

0.49

Moran wants to reverse the process of dollar appreciation through capital inflows by engineering a decline in the dollar's value, similar to the Plaza Accords of 1985.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“And so what he wants to see is a reversal of that process. And one of the ways of reversing that process would be to engineer a decline in the value of the dollar. The problem with a repeat of the plaza accords is that tariffs and currency appreciation or depreciation are ways of intervening in trade.”

0.49

Pettis expects China to implement fiscal deficits oriented toward the demand side (supporting consumption) rather than the supply side (traditional approach) in the coming year to address structural pressures.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Pettis

“But I suspect that this year that's what they'll do. will see more of a fiscal deficit oriented towards supporting the demand side of the economy rather than the supply side which is what they traditionally do.”

0.48

Steven Moren's paper on the 'Mara Lago Accord' recognizes that the capital account side of the equation drives US trade imbalances, manufacturing contraction, and dollar overvaluation, and proposes reversing this process through currency appreciation engineering.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Pettis

“My reading of Moran is that he's broadly right. He recognizes that it's really the capital side of the equation that drives the US trade imbalances that drives the contraction in US manufacturing etc etc. He's very concerned by the fact that if countries mostly resolve their savings imbalances by buying US assets, they're going to drive up the value of the dollar.”

0.48

If other countries work around the United States to establish trade rules without it, that would be preferable to a scenario where countries abandon rule-based trade altogether and adopt a purely beggar-thy-neighbor approach.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“in a way I think we should hope that that other countries work around us because I think the alternative is is even worse than that, right? We kind of want to have an adequately functioning rules-based world system should we want to join it again, right?”

0.48

A better path to reform than Trump's tariffs would be working legitimately with partners and friends to make the WTO more responsive to US, European, and other concerns, led by a coalition of willing leaders rolling up their sleeves.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kimberly Clausing

“Yeah. So, I think a better path to reform would be to recognize that of course the WTO isn't perfect and to roll up your sleeves and work in a legitimate way with with partners and friends to make the WTO more responsive to some of the concerns the United States, Europe, and others have had about the WTO. I think throwing out the rule book isn't the answer, but I can imagine, you know, a round of reforms is necessary and it probably does need to be led by a coalition of willing leaders, right, who can kind of come to the table and say, "Here's a way we could do this."”