theodicy
The theological problem of why evil and suffering are allowed to flourish in a world governed by a good God.
As defined in ms_206
Other definitions
Theological attempt to justify God's goodness and power in the face of evil and suffering in the world; Nietzsche's critique is that theodicy makes suffering worse by claiming it has divine meaning rather than being meaningless chaos
Nietzsche's Critique of Christianity: The Genealogy of Morals
Where it comes up · 18
- Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book of Job3 claims
- Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)3 claims
- Great Authors - Neo-Classical and Romantic Literature - Voltaire, Candide3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 60 Post-Hegelian Idealism2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 40 Leibniz on Evil2 claims
- Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Defoe, Robinson Crusoe1 claim
- Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God1 claim
- 156 - The Evolution Of Culture1 claim
and 10 more
Most important claims · 10 of 26Search all claims for “theodicy” →
- Leibniz argues in the Theodicy that causes incline the will without compelling it, meaning inclinations determine choices with certainty (from God's perspective who knows all things) but not with absolute necessity, preserving a residual freedom to act otherwise.A History of Philosophy | 40 Leibniz on Evil
- Voltaire objects to Enlightenment optimism, particularly the theodicies of Alexander Pope and Leibniz, which attempt to justify God's ways to man by suggesting that apparent evil serves a greater providential good, a position Voltaire believes is fundamentally wrong because it miseducates us about the actual arbitrariness of suffering.Great Authors - Neo-Classical and Romantic Literature - Voltaire, Candide
- Plato's view of evil in Christian theology would not satisfy Christian theodicy, but it helps set up the problem of evil that Christian theologians must subsequently address.A History of Philosophy | 06 Plato on God
- Just as there is a problem of evil for believers, there is a problem of good for skeptics: they must explain both the surplus of moral aspiration coexisting with human darkness and the excessive, unnecessary good woven into everyday life (we could have eaten or had sex from mere compulsion without enjoyment), which gives confidence that at bottom there is a goodness worth associating with.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- Idealist philosophy faces a particular problem with the soul-making theodicy because if the physical order exists only in God's mind or human minds (Berkeley-style idealism), then there is no external cause of evil, and the problem of evil rolls back onto God rather than being externalized to an ordered cosmos.A History of Philosophy | 60 Post-Hegelian Idealism
- Section 1 of the Theodicy presents the greater good argument: evil is part of a larger inclusive teleology and like every other thing and property contributes to the perfection of the whole within the hierarchy of being.A History of Philosophy | 40 Leibniz on Evil
- The character Pangloss, the court philosopher, is designed to lampoon Leibniz and his theodicy, and he embodies the dangerous miseducation of optimism: everything he says is demonstrated to be false immediately afterward, showing that optimistic philosophy ill-prepares one to meet real challenges.Great Authors - Neo-Classical and Romantic Literature - Voltaire, Candide
- For natural evil, Augustine suggests that natural decay and the human proclivity to moral failure are built into created nature as a necessity for the discipline required to build faith, trust, love, and hope into the human soul—a soul-making theodicy.A History of Philosophy | 20 Augustine and Neo-Platonism
- The problem of evil is a real and serious problem with no podcast-ready solution, but it is a mistake to treat it as a reason not to be religious; if one accepts the evidence for a religious framework, then confronting evil should prompt either adopting a non-classical theology (pantheism, dualism, process theology) or wrestling with the mystery inside the framework of belief, which is more sensible than becoming an atheist.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- Virulent bacteria are invariably the result of loss of information through mutation rather than gain of information; this supports a theological perspective that evil or dysfunction results from privation (defect in good) rather than independent existence, and demonstrates that the mutational process produces degradation, not innovation.Mathematical Challenges to Darwin’s Theory of Evolution