
A History of Philosophy | 20 Augustine and Neo-Platonism
What this covers
This lecture, from a Wheaton College history of philosophy series, follows Augustine (354–430) from his early drift into Manichean dualism toward a Christianity built with neoplatonism. The professor treats him as the first systematic thinker whose reasoning has persistently shaped Western thought, and sets him against Eastern figures like Gregory of Nyssa, who took a more mystical Neoplatonic path. The biographical thread matters: Augustine left the Manichees partly because their traveling lecturers could not answer his questions, and partly because a dualism of eternal conflict leaves humans as pawns with no hope that good will win. The Confessions is recommended as the way in, read first for its story.
The middle of the lecture works through what Augustine took from Plotinus's tradition: God as incorporeal source of all being and as the good, and evil as a privation of form, measure, and order rather than a rival substance. Creation out of nothing explains why created things tend to decay, and Augustine even finds beauty in their passing. The contested turn comes with natural evil, which the lecturer presents as a soul-making theodicy in which decay and moral frailty discipline faith, trust, love, and hope.
The second half covers where Augustine breaks with the Neoplatonists. He rejects emanation and intermediary beings, since a graded hierarchy conflicts with the Incarnation and with the Son being of the same substance as the Father, a point tied to his writing on the Trinity. He also relocates salvation from intellect to the will, so that virtue becomes rightly directed love of God. The lecture closes on his view that authority comes first in human experience while reason comes first in the order of reality, and it places Christian thinkers within parallel worldview traditions that adapt each era's dominant science.
Augustine synthesizes Neoplatonic philosophy with Christian theology by adopting its metaphysical framework (God as incorporeal spirit, evil as privation of good) while fundamentally revising its epistemology and ethics to center on the will, free choice, and divine grace rather than intellect and emanation.
- Augustine uses Neoplatonism to escape Manichean dualism by conceiving evil as privation rather than an independent eternal force
- He rejects Neoplatonic emanation and intermediary beings in favor of creation ex nihilo and direct divine action, grounding this in Trinitarian theology
- He pivots from Platonic intellect-centered salvation to a voluntaristic ethics of love and will, making free choice—not reason—the decisive factor in moral life
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Augustine's fundamental epistemological insight is that in terms of chronological order in human experience, authority always comes first because we learn from others who tell us; but in terms of ontological order in the nature of reality itself, reason is first because the universe is created by a rational God and is rationally intelligible.
“chronologically in our experience chronologically in our own experience and thinking it's always Authority that comes first after all the things that our knowledge starts with and builds on are things we learn from others who tell us parents whatever sources and in mental knowledge and our reasoning takes off from there faith s that is to say in the very nature of reality this is an ordered rational intelligible universe created by a rational intellig intelligent deity and in that sense reason is first you and it's because of the rationality of God and the rational universe that there is Authority at all”
Augustine develops his Christian ethics as an ethic of love (carus/charity in his Latin; agape in New Testament Greek), arguing that love is the underlying significance of the whole moral law—such that the Greek virtues of temperance, courage, wisdom, and justice are all expressions of love directed toward God.
“the result of this emphasis on two loves is that Augustine develops his Christian ethic as an ethic of love you see uh translating not just in terms of AOS but in the New Testament Agape what in his Latin becomes carus our English word charity parus an ethic of love and the central theme of his ethic is that um it is love which is the uh underlying significance of the whole moral law he talks of um not just the Ten Commandments the way the New Testament does love is the fulfilling of the law but he talks of the Greek ver virtues um Temperance courage uh wisdom Justice and argues that love is the fulfilling of those so that courage is loving God most and therefore braving all else well Justice is honoring God and therefore ruling all else well”
In Neoplatonism, all intermediate beings are inferior to those above them in a hierarchy, so the Nous is inferior to the One, the World Soul is inferior to the Nous—a hierarchical gradation that contradicts Christian Trinitarian theology, which insists that the Son is not of similar substance but of the same substance as the Father (homoousios, not homoiousios).
“all of the intermediate beings are inferior to those above them in the hierarchy so the Noose is inferior to the one God the world's soul is inferior to The Noose the logos so you have a hierarchy of increasingly inferior beings but that doesn't fit the Christian understanding of the Trinity you see the Trinity which is trying to say not that and you remember the nyine Creed uh not that Jesus is of a similar substance though inferior but of the same substance as the father do you remember the Aran controversy we mentioned it as growing out of the alexandrian Christianity the tendency was to say that the son is heteros uh with respect uh to the father heter heteros meaning of a different nature of a different being of a different essence of a different substance and that would have made the of a similar nature a similar substance hos and the um debate at Moos similar heteros means different you see this is sometimes called the battle over an ioda”
Augustine became disillusioned with Manichean dualism not merely through philosophical argument, but because traveling Manichean lecturers could not adequately answer his questions about the doctrine, and because Manichean dualism provided no hope for the triumph of good over evil—if the two are locked in eternal conflict, humans are merely pawns in a conflict they did not start and cannot resolve.
“he met some of the um traveling lecturers in the manakan lecture circuit and started quizzing them and became disillusioned with their capacity to answer the questions the problem that he saw with Manic and dualism was that it provided no hope for the Triumph of good over evil if the two are locked in an everlasting conflict no hope and that it reduced humans to Simply porns in an everlasting conflict that ultimately they had nothing to do with starting”
Augustine adopts the Platonic and Neoplatonic emphasis on two loves—love of things below and love of things above—but rejects the Neoplatonic idea that it is the intellect (nous) that saves the soul by focusing attention on higher things, because Augustine sees salvation as requiring free willing and loving of God, not merely intellectual contemplation.
“as a result he Echoes the platonic emphasis on two loves you remember that in Plato and it was there in the neoplatonists there is um a love and taking the divided line a love of for things below and a love for things above...Austine likes the story of two loves but he doesn't like to think that it's the intellect that saves us that's not where the source of Hope is and so you see where he's going to have to make some modifications”
Augustine shares Plato's concern about the improvement of the soul, and argues in one place that Jesus Christ brings to fulfillment all of Plato's philosophical hopes, suggesting that if Plato were alive in Augustine's time (circa 400 AD) he would become a Christian because his philosophy was leaning in that direction.
“Augustine shares Plato's concern about the Improvement of the Soul very much so uh the same kind of theme in fact he argues in one place that Jesus Christ brings to fulfillment all of Plato's philosophical hopes and says in another place that if Plato were a Christian today no take it back if Plato were alive today 400 ad he would become a Christian simply because his philosophy was leaning so much in that direction”
In the Neoplatonic framework Augustine adopts, evil is understood as a privation—a perversion or corruption of something good—rather than as having a separate, independent existence as it does in Manichean dualism, because evil is parasitical on the good and derives its reality only from what is good.
“in the neoplatonic tradition evil is a privation a perversion a Corruption of something that's good it doesn't have a separate existence as it does for the manans evil is parasitical on the good it's not something quite independent in itself”
Augustine objects to Neoplatonic intermediary beings because if God requires all these intermediary beings to influence his creatures, then God is not directly present to creation—but the Christian story of the Incarnation asserts that God acts directly in the world, and therefore Augustine rejects the need for a hierarchy of intermediary beings between God and creation.
“Augustine is troubled by this uh that um in order to influence us his creatures God has to work through all these intermediary beings isn't the Christian story that God acts directly what about the Incarnation isn't that a direct presence of God in his creation”
In his early years, despite being raised Christian by his mother, Augustine drifted into Manichean dualism—a fourth-century form of Gnostic philosophy with Zoroastrian roots that conceived of two eternal, opposed realms (Kingdom of Light/Reason and Kingdom of Darkness/Matter) and taught that salvation comes through ascetic denial of the body.
“his early years while raised by um mother who was Christian his father apparently Pagan he drifted in his early years into um manican dualism now manism was a fourth Century version of that gnosticism uh more explicitly dualistic than many other versions in the sense that they uh saw uh two Eternal Realms of being the Kingdom of Light and the kingdom of darkness the light is good the darkness is evil the light is the light of reason the darkness the confused world of material existence and it was a form of um dualism that had some roots in Zoroastrianism”
The Alexandrian school used Middle Platonism to respond to Gnostic dualism and the problem of evil by arguing that because the Platonic forms give order to nature, the material world is not evil but good, which resolves the Christian theological problem of explaining how God can create a good physical world if matter is inherently evil.
“the alexandrian school found middle platonism very helpful in responding to the dualism of of the gnostics and the problem of evil that was involved in the Gnostic view of matter as evil platonism enabled them to say that by virtue of the the forms which give order to Nature you see the material world is not evil it's good and after all the Christian wants to say that it's not the fact that we have bodies that's the source of the evilness something other than that”
From Neoplatonism, Augustine gains the core ideas that God is incorporeal spirit (not material as the Stoics and Manichaeans held), that God is the source of all being (not just part of it), and that God is the good—ideas that enable Augustine to develop his theology as a kind of teleological inner-theology where all creation seeks to return to God as the source and purpose of being.
“the things which he gains from platonism are first the idea that God is not a material being as the stoics had held and the manicans had held but that God is an incorporeal spirit that God is the source of all being not just half of it but all of it that God is the good and you'll notice on the very first page of his confessions that much quoted line of his thou has made us for thyself oh God and our hearts are restless till they rest in thee you see Augustine see is an inner thology such that all creation seeks to turn to God the source purpose of being the good”
For natural evil, Augustine suggests that natural decay and the human proclivity to moral failure are built into created nature as a necessity for the discipline required to build faith, trust, love, and hope into the human soul—a soul-making theodicy.
“for natural evil he's thinking of uh to the effect that all um natural evil and human proclivity is built into our nature as a um um so as to create the necessity for that kind of discipline which will build not just Greek courage but faith and trust and Love and Hope into the backbone of the human soul you Soul making”
All things are created out of nothing, and because they are created out of nothing, they have a tendency to return to nothing—exemplified in the natural decay of created things like apples that lose their form and revert to nothingness.
“in all those regards things are created out of nothing and since they're created out of nothing they have a tendency to return to nothing why does an apple rot created a makes Kno if it loses its form what's going to happen back to nothing”
Evil is a loss of order, harmony, and ordered unity, and in that evil is a privation of form—a failure to participate as fully as possible in form—and since a thing's essential being is measured by the form it participates in, evil is fundamentally a privation of essential being and a loss of measure.
“evil is a loss of order of ordered Unity Harmony and in as much as ordered Unity is a product of form evil is a failure to participate as fully as we could in form you see it's a loss of form privation of form in as much as a things essential being is measured by the form evil is in measure privation of essential being”
Augustine argues that the human soul, like God, is immaterial and incorporeal, and the soul is capable of distinguishing between true and false without reliance on sensory experience through dialectical reasoning, suggesting the soul's functioning can be independent of bodily input and is not limited by space and time as the body is.
“the human soul is immaterial as well if God can be an incorporeal spirit so can the human soul be an incorporeal spirit and he argues interestingly about that that uh that the soul is able to distribute to dis take it back to distinguish the soul is able to distinguish between true and false without use of sense experience by dialectic oh so the soul seems to be in its functioning capable of independence from bodily UT and the soul in its thinking can Embrace vast reaches of space and time time in memory space in imagination yeah the soul is not limited by space and time like the body is”
Augustine argues that even the corruption and destruction of inferior things—physical things made of nothing—contributes to the beauty of the universe, such that temporal beauty belongs to things in their falling away and succession toward the end of their existence.
“from the corruption and destruction of inferior things is the beauty of the universe the rest of things that are made of nothing physical things assuredly inferior to rational Soul can be neither blessed nor miserable but in proportion to their fashion and appearance um they're good nor could there be good things in a less or lesser degree to things falling away and succeeding halfway to the end of the paragraph a certain temporal Beauty belongs temporal Beauty”
If God creates ex nihilo (out of nothing), then the inner dynamics and self-sufficiency of God's being provide the reason for creation; therefore human reason, understood as a finite manifestation of divine reason, can access truth through participation in divine reason, whereas if humans were part of God by emanation, truth would need to be gained through self-understanding of human reason as part of the divine.
“if God creates ex neolo out of nothing then the inner dynamics of God's inner internal being finally that reason is sufficient to rule the life because if we of the very being of God then human reason is part of the Divine reason human reason is a finite manifestation of divine reason if we're part of the being of God by emanation and it's in the self understanding of human reason therefore that we would gain the truth”
Throughout the history of Western thought, there are parallel worldview traditions (naturalistic, idealistic, and theistic philosophies) that work with the dominant scientific paradigm of their era—Greek essentialism, mechanistic science of the Scientific Revolution, and relational/organic models of the 19th-20th centuries—such that Christian philosophers in each period adapt these same underlying conceptual apparatus rather than operating in isolation.
“a variety of world viw Traditions developing along parallel paths throughout the history of Western thought there are certain major junctures in the history of thought in the transition from ancient and medieval to Modern...Romanticism and postmodern thought...distinctives of these three main periods have to do with scientific models that change”
Plotinus would respond to Augustine's rhetorical critique by noting that he is not talking of parts of God but of emanations that suffer from privation of being and form, and thus account for evils in the world—a response that, while logically available, still does not address Augustine's deeper theological objection to intermediary beings.
“well I uh I don't think it takes much imagination to see how plonus would respond to that that you're not talking of parts of God you're talking of emanations out of the Divine being suffering from privation of being therefore privation of form privation of ordered unity and you account for the evils in that way but uh on the other hand Augustine objects to the notion of intermediary beings”
The implication of Manichaean dualism—that the body is evil—leads logically to a soteriology based on self-denial and asceticism as the means of escaping the body and achieving salvation
“the um implication of all of this was if the body is evil the way of salvation lives in a lies in a life of self-denial and asceticism in order to escape the body you see”
Augustine wrote approximately 15 scrolls on the Trinity (not 15 volumes) in response to Neoplatonism's intermediary inferior beings, insisting that the Son is co-equal with the Father and co-eternal, expressing the Chalcedonian formula's affirmation of the full divinity of Christ without subordination.
“Augustine riding 3/4 of a century later on and by the time he got to riding on the Trinity it was three quarters of a century wrote 15 books on the Trinity not 15 volumes but 15 whatever Scrolls I presume on the Trinity um and he insists in trying to spell this out in response to neoplatonism with its intermediary inferior beings he insists that what this means is that the son is co-equal with the father father and co-eternal Caledonian formula”
Augustine uses rhetorical arguments against emanation theory: if emanation is true, then when an animal is butchered, part of God is being slaughtered; when a naughty boy is punished, a part of God is being whipped—making God subject to wickedness and dirt, which contradicts God's absolute goodness.
“he he says for instance that if the theory of emanation is right then when an animal is butchered part of God is being slaughtered and when a naughty boy is punished a part of God is being whipped it would mean that parts of God alude Wicked dirty so forth well um if that's the case then God is Not altogether the good”
Augustine's Confessions functions simultaneously as an inspirational classic, an intellectual autobiography, and a profound treatise on the nature of the human soul, and can be read initially for its narrative storyline to understand Augustine's philosophical journey.
“the confessions Augustine's confessions in a word way it's an inspirational classic in another way it's an intellectual autobiography in another way it's a profound treaties on the nature of the human soul it's all of that and more but um one of the things that you get from Simply reading the story line and um I suppose that's what we do at the first reading”
Augustine (354–430) is the first systematic thinker whose range of philosophical and theological reasoning has persistently influenced the Western tradition, despite the existence of important Eastern Church thinkers like Gregory of Nyssa who shaped Eastern Christianity along more mystical Neoplatonic lines.
“Augustine of Hippo um born in 354 died in 430 um tremendous tremendously influential figure and I think it's fair to say the the first systematic thinker um whose thinking encompassed the range of philosophical issues theological issues as well um whose influence has um persisted in the west it's not to say there weren't important thinkers in the Eastern Church the capid Doan fathers if you hear of them um Gregory of NASA and others in the um Black Sea area influential in shaping the Eastern Church also with platonic influence but along more mystical lines than in the west but certainly it's Augustine who by all measures stands out”
Augustine's account of measure, form, and order as synonyms for good means that degrees of good correspond to degrees of form, order, and unity in a thing.
“measure form order four synonyms good synonyms yeah they mean the same thing s ordered are assuredly good in a higher degree so degrees of good and degrees of form order Unity”
Augustine makes a distinction between natural evil and moral evil, though the speaker suspects there is some combination of both involved in Augustine's thinking.
“he makes a clearer distinction between natural and moral evil and irony and St you disagree with um yeah um do you um this will probably therefore be next time uh to talk somewhat more systematically about how he develops the theory of forms how that shapes his epistemology um how it affects his thinking about the nature of the Soul”