What this covers

This is a 49-minute lecture by Michael Sugrue on the Book of Job, placed within the wisdom literature of the Old Testament and treated as universal rather than tied to Hebrews, Christians, or Muslims. The speaker follows the narrative in order. It opens with the wager in which Satan claims that Job's righteousness is heteronomous, driven by expected rewards, and then moves through Job's afflictions: boils, lost family, destroyed property, and a wife who urges him to curse his creator. It then covers the long dispute with his friends, the speech from the whirlwind, and the ending. The framing question is the oldest one: where evil comes from and why bad things happen to good people under an all-good, all-knowing God.

The range is mostly a tour of the explanations on offer and the lecturer's verdict on each. Job's three friends variously suggest secret sin, inherited family guilt, or unknowing transgression, and Job refutes each. He observes that the wicked often prosper while the innocent suffer, which the lecture calls the greatest test of faith. Elihu then recasts Job's self-defense as impertinence, and God's questions about mountains, birds, and stars press the point that humans sit nearer to worms than to the divine. The lecture reads this as a rejection of theodicy itself, with disputing God counted as satanic pride.

The lecture also raises some contentious or unexpected points. It compares asking why God permits evil to a child asking why the goldfish died. It speculates that Job may have harbored a hidden pride in thinking he deserved good things, when they come as free grace. It notes that God never explains why Satan was in heaven. It suggests the restoration of Job at twice his former prosperity may have been appended to the original. Brief contrasts with the gentler faces of God in the Song of Solomon and the Beatitudes close out the picture.

Sharpest takeaway

The Book of Job teaches that authentic religious faith requires complete submission to God's inscrutable will without attempting to rationalize or justify divine actions, rejecting theology as a form of concealed pride and presumption.

  • Job's friends represent failed theodicy—the attempt to fit God into human rational categories, which is itself a form of satanic pride
  • Elihu and God's speech from the whirlwind establish that humans occupy an ontologically insignificant position (like worms compared to God) and thus have no standing to judge or question divine providence
  • True religious faith is 'autonomous'—accepting God's will regardless of whether it brings suffering or prosperity, not because of promised rewards

The claims · ranked51 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Satan argues to God that Job's devotion and righteousness are heteronomous—motivated not by autonomous love but by expectation of divine rewards—and therefore Job would blaspheme if those rewards were withdrawn.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“satan retorts well of course he's good and and praises you and shows fear of the lord you've given him all this great stuff you gave him health you gave him wealth you gave him family you gave him everything a human being could possibly want if he gave me everything a human being or perhaps an angel could possibly want i think we could make a deal but naturally enough the only reason that job praises you the only reason that job is god's faithful servant is because of the fact that you've given him these things”

0.80

Job observes that the world shows promiscuous distribution of divine reward and punishment: evil people often prosper and escape justice, while innocent people suffer undeserved afflictions, suggesting God does not distribute rewards and punishments according to moral merit.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job continues to maintain his blamelessness and there's a a whole series of back and forth discussions about what could possibly be the origin of job's troubles and job continues to maintain his innocence and the friends are now kind of grasping at straws they're looking around trying to say well look there's got to be some rational explanation for why god would send such evil to you he doesn't send it arbitrarily and job says yes he does have you looked around at the world and here's the part of the wisdom in this literature he says often it turns out that people who do evil prosper and we all know that as a matter of practical fact when we look around in the world there are people who do evil repeatedly again and again and again and they continue to do well they cheated cards and they continue to get to win they never get caught they steal and they never get arrested they do all manner of evil and god never sends them retribution”

0.80

Job rejects his friends' theological explanations, maintaining that he is blameless and that God is arbitrary and promiscuous in distributing suffering and pleasure, and while Job does not understand why, he continues to remain God's faithful servant.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job flatly contradicts this he says look one of the worst things that you can do is to place yourself in a position of judging god now i think that myself blameless but i'm very very skeptical about the theological pseudo-explanations which my friends are giving here each one of them has offered some apparently reasonable account of why i suffer but i know first of all that's not true that i haven't committed any transgression and in fact i think that god just is arbitrary and promiscuous in the way he kicks thing in the way he gives out suffering and pleasure i don't know why he is that way but i continue to remain god's faithful servant”

0.80

We are faced with the paradox that there is no obvious reason why God would allow children to be run over, and although we believe in God, we cannot account for this; yet Job maintains his position as God's faithful servant despite not being able to justify God's actions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the very wrenching fact that there's no obvious reason for it why should my child get run over i mean i believe in god but i still can't account for this well job is left with is stuck in that situation he can't account for god's organization and running of the world and yet he maintains his position as god's faithful servant”

0.80

Elihu rebukes Job by arguing that Job is not righteous in the sight of God compared to God's inscrutable majesty, and that attempting to justify oneself at God's expense is blasphemy, the height of impertinence, and a retreat from fidelity to God's status.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“you are not righteous in the sight of god no matter how righteous you think you are compared to the complete awesome inscrutable majesty of god you are not justified the only way to justify yourself is to blame god and that doesn't make any sense by definition that's contradictory that's incoherent and most important it is blasphemous”

0.80

The promiscuous distribution of divine rewards and punishments—good people suffering, evil people prospering—constitutes 'the greatest test of faith' because it undermines belief in a loving, all-powerful, all-knowing God and makes religious faith seem irrational.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“this is a problem it could easily make a person lose their faith in god it is a a real moral test perhaps the greatest test of faith that there is because if our god is a loving god and an all-powerful god an all-knowing god why is it that he would tantalize us and torment us with unrequited virtue and why is that he would reward people who were obviously evil”

0.80

The ultimate counsel from God's speech is that we are not in a position to judge God or to justify ourselves; such presumption is ridiculous and ultimately irreligious; our stance toward being if we are truly religious is that of Job: complete acceptance of God's providence.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“so god speaks to job out of the whirlwind and the ultimate counsel that we get here is that we are not in a position to judge or just to judge god or to justify ourselves it's presumptuous it's ridiculous and it's ultimately irreligious our stance towards being if we are truly religious is that of job the answer to the question why does god send evil into the world is is as dumb as the question itself don't ask it”

0.74

The Book of Job addresses a foundational question for all human beings by virtue of the human condition: what is the point of evil, where does evil come from, and why do bad things happen to good people in a world governed by an omnipotent, omniscient, and all-good God.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the book of job illustrates one of the main or perhaps the foundational stance towards being of the religious person in other words it has a message which is timeless it answers and it asks and answers a question which all human beings by the very nature of the human condition have to be forced to confront and the question that the book of job asks and tries to answer is what's the point of evil where does evil come from how do we account for evil in a in a world that's run by god by his almighty providence”

0.74

Despite physical torment from boils, loss of family, destruction of possessions, and even his wife's urging to curse God, Job refuses to blaspheme and maintains 'I will not curse my creator; I will not curse the almighty,' proving God correct about Job's autonomous faith.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“but job is god's faithful servant and job just stays there and says although i've been afflicted with many great things with many evil things i will not blaspheme i'm still god's faithful servant”

0.74

The closest we can come to virtue and righteousness is to align our views, desires, hopes, and aspirations with those of the deity; when we understand God's ways, we acknowledge His sovereignty; when we don't understand, we must accept His providence with appropriate humility.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the closest we can come to virtue and to righteousness and to a correct understanding of the world is to align our views and desires and hopes and aspirations with those of the deity when we understand or when we believe we understand his ways well then that's just fine we acknowledge god's sovereignty and we go about our business when we believe we don't understand his ways the proper thing to do is to accept god's providence with the appropriate humility”

0.74

Even the sun, moon, and celestial objects are not clean or perfect in God's eyes; compared to the standard of divine righteousness, none of God's creatures are justified or match up to His standard.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and the analogy is made in chapter 25 when he says look even the sun the moon and celestial objects are not clean are not perfect they're not good in god's eyes when we talk about the standard of divine righteousness none of us are justified none of god's creatures really match up to his standard”

0.74

In disputes between God and any other being, God is always right, having absolute knowledge and power; the person who argues with God manifests satanic pride and presumption, as all arguments with God are unwinnable by definition.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“that's worth noting here that god was right from the beginning in this little dispute between god and satan it turns out that god was right and at the end of the story we'll find out that in all disputes between god and anybody else god is the heavy favorite as a matter of fact he's not just the heavy favorite he's always right it's a it's a sure bet all right the big message or one of the big messages we ought to learn here is that in all our contests with the deity if we hold any view beyond that which god endorses we're wrong”

0.74

Job's three friends are eventually silenced, unable to convince Job that he is sinful or to provide satisfactory explanations for his suffering; their theological explanations become hollow, implausible, and presumptuous.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“they are eventually silenced and they're silenced for two reasons one because they have not managed to convince job that he is somehow sinful that he is somehow author of his own evil and that god is just requiting job's evils in an appropriate and just way job continues to believe he's blameless”

0.74

God's message to Job is: 'I am God and you are not; complete acceptance of my will is the only virtue; all arguments with me are essentially satanic pride; you always lose arguments with God, so why continue disputing?'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“in other words no more insubordination from you this is the way things are i'm god you're not i speak to you out of the flux and chaos of the universe because i'm trying to make a point to the to the world complete acceptance of my will is the only virtue all arguments with me are essentially satanic pride you know who argues with me remember the guy from the beginning of the book satan right that's the kind of person that argues with me”

0.74

Job is thoroughly humbled by God's speech from the whirlwind and submits, saying he will no longer dispute with God; God accepts his submission and tells him not to worry, and notably God does not address the theological questions about why Satan was in heaven or why God meets with Satan.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and job is thoroughly humbled i mean we've been quieted down and forced to seriously reconsider his view of the world by elijah but god he's a real convincing guy especially when he's talking to you out of the world when he straightens him right out he says look i'm god you're not that's the end of all discussion don't dispute me and job says you know you got a point i'm not going to dispute this anymore sorry and god says all right don't worry about it it's no big deal i'm just trying to make a point notice he doesn't come and ask you know why was satan up in heaven why were you talking to him why'd you ever met with them all says forget it i don't ask any questions satan asks questions and that's what makes him satan”

0.74

Job's three friends offer various theological explanations for his suffering: that Job himself is secretly sinful, that collective family guilt is being punished, or that Job has sinned unknowingly; Job consistently refutes each explanation, maintaining his innocence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“part of the explanation or one explanation that they offer is that job you really are an evil man you've committed some some hidden sin which you have which no one has caught you in and that god has sent you righteous retribution for this and job says no hold it you know me and you've known me all my life i've been a righteous man”

0.74

Elihu accuses Job of latent satanic pride and blasphemy: Job defends his own righteousness against God, which is paradoxically unjustified given God's absolute authority and knowledge, and betrays a fundamental lack of submission.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“if you had believed that god was blameworthy if you had believed that god really was arbitrary when you get right down to it you would have blasphemed you would have taken the route suggested by your wife who's become in some ways a byword for lack of religious fidelity she said curse god and die well job you're going to die anyway in the long run we all die but the fact of the matter is that if you do anything except completely submit to the will of god and accept all that he sends you both for good and evil then you are a blasphemer and ultimately you are not a faithful man you are not god's faithful servant”

0.73

In ontological terms (the study of being and the hierarchy of existence), humans occupy a position much closer to worms and insects than to God; we are fundamentally limited, finite creatures with no standing to judge the infinite divine being.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“think of it this way if we had a an insect here a caterpillar or a worm or a maggot and we had god on the other end and we had man in between how would we parse these things i mean in other words think of it like in sesame street what is it big bird says or one of these things is not like the other one of these things just doesn't belong well which of these things is not like the other is god and job or a god and job very similar or are god and or are job and the maggot very similar in other words are we more like insects or are we more like the divinity well god made both insects and us whereas we're and insects in us are both finite and we're both limited and we both really can't presume to judge god”

0.70

God questions Job about whether he can make mountains, birds, and fish, establishing that God creates everything—mountains, stars, planets, the entire universe—and has been present from the beginning, whereas humans are finite, limited, and arrogant.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and he says i have some questions here's a pop quiz job how do you make mountains can you make mountains i make mountains all the time piece of cake what's the recipe for mountains do you understand mountains job and the fact of the matter is job doesn't know how to make mountains because he's a regular human being like us we don't want to make mountains and he says how about the birds of the air can you make ducks i make ducks all the time i know where they are i know what they do and all about ducks fish fish are the sea how do you make mackerel job do you understand that no of course you don't why because you're job you're a regular finite limited arrogant prideful human being”

0.68

At the end of Job, God miraculously restores Job to twice his former prosperity—twice the money, twice the flocks, a new family, a new house—which appears to be a happy ending but may actually be appended to the original narrative.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“at the end of the the story this is kind of a of a funny ending i don't know quite how to account for this god shows that he's really kind of a nice fellow or god shows that he's really in really inscrutable parts of the most incredible part of the book is that after god appears to job in the world when job humbles himself and submits to the word of god and says okay i understand that i'm a worm that i'm a maggot that i don't presume to judge you i get the idea i won't do that anymore i'm sorry and he says okay well since you're sorry i'm going to send you back twice as much money as you had before and twice as many flocks and a new family and a new house and all kinds of great stuff”

0.56

We should not seek after self-justification; we should learn to patiently submit to God's will; even a worm, in not presuming to judge God, is more virtuous than a human who argues with the Almighty.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the whole idea of any of his creatures presuming to justif to to justify themselves at the expense of the deity is wrong and that means that we should not seek aft out after self-justification we should learn how to patiently submit to the will of god in some respects the worm is more virtuous than we are at least the worm doesn't tell god how to run the universe the worm in fact even if it's not conscious doesn't try and be something that it's not whereas we would presume to judge the almighty the inscrutable deity how foolish how presumptuous how sinful”

0.56

Job may have harbored a secret sin all along: latent pride that he thought himself justified and deserved good things from God, leading to the realization that we get good things as acts of free grace, not because we deserve them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job has had a secret sin all along perhaps there's always been a sort of latent pride in which he thought himself justified and he thought that he deserved good things from god maybe the message here is that when we get good things from god we get them as an act of free grace and we don't deserve anything hell we don't even deserve to be alive we don't deserve to exist nothing deserves to exist”

0.56

God appears to Job out of a whirlwind, which is a beautiful image for the chaos and incomprehensibility of the world, and represents God speaking to us through the limitations of our understanding and knowledge.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“after this colloquy with elihu job is alone and god comes and speaks to job out of the whirlwind and that's a beautiful image for the chaos of the world think of a tornado god comes and it's not a deus ex machina the way we see in certain very inautistic plays or novels it's not god from a machine rather it's a deus ex natura it's god out of nature somehow out of the chaos the incomprehensibility the swirling flux of the world god speaks directly to job it's a beautiful image for god speaking to us through the limitations in our understanding and knowledge”

0.56

The restoration of Job may serve to show that God is truly inscrutable—sending and taking away for reasons beyond human comprehension—or to boost human morale; but the core point of Job's learning is that love of God must be autonomous, independent of external rewards.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“perhaps as a kind of way of flagging our sagging spirit of boosting our sagging spirits or job-sagging spirits perhaps showing that he truly is inscrutable that he sends and takes away for reasons that we don't entirely comprehend and that if we are wise and if we are virtuous and if we are good we will give up on all questions that are beyond our human capacity to understand now two things i'd like to conclude with”

0.56

Since we don't even deserve to exist and nothing deserves to exist, the fact that anything exists at all is testimony to God's righteousness, power, and goodness; we should accept patiently and with fidelity whatever God sends without complaint.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the fact that anything exists at all is testimony to god's righteousness to his power and to his goodness towards us the fact that we believe we deserve a continued series of good things is both foolish and ridiculous and since we don't even deserve to exist from the very beginning we have no claim to make on the almighty whatever he sends us we ought to accept patiently and with great fidelity we should not be a presumptuous worm”

0.56

Job has not fully worked out the implications of his own stance of complete submission; he continues to maintain his own righteousness, which makes God seem evil, though God cannot actually be evil by definition if one believes in the God of biblical religion.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the problem with job is that although he has adopted this stance he hasn't fully worked out the implications of this he continues to maintain his own righteousness which makes god seem evil for want of a better word now the idea that god seems evil means we have to stress very much perhaps italicize the word seems because for god to be evil is a contradiction in terms it doesn't make any sense if you believe in god it doesn't make any sense to have him be good some of the time and bad some of the time that's not the nature of the deity”

0.56

The Book of Job is part of the wisdom literature of the Old Testament and is universal rather than restricted to Hebrews, Christians, or Muslims, because it addresses a universal fact of the human condition: the inexplicability of suffering.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“that's one of the reasons why this is part of what's called the wisdom literature of the old testament and why it's not just restricted to the hebrews or to the christians or to the muslims rather it's a universal fact or a universal fact which is organized in this universal religious and literary text”

0.56

The marrow of religious faith—complete submission to God's will—is not restricted to any one religion but is foundational to Old Testament religiosity and also to New Testament and Islamic religiosity.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and i think this marrow of religious faith this complete submission to the will of god is not restricted to any one religion it's i think the marrow of old testament religiosity but i think it also has a lot to do with the religiosity of the new testament or the quran in other words if you believe in god and you believe that he has a providence which governs the world then whether you understand that providence or not the appropriate response is god gives this to us well and i will accept it i do not blaspheme god i do not presume to judge him”

0.56

The question 'why does God let evil happen?' is comparable to a child asking 'why did God let the goldfish die?'—naive and based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of the world; the proper response is acceptance that 'that's just the way the world is.'

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“represents the level of intellectual sophistication that we see i mean if you think of your six-year-old coming to you and saying mommy daddy how come god let the goldfish die well we kind of chuckle at that and say oh you know don't worry about a kid you know that's just the way the world is well when you extrapolate from that on a larger scale why does god let children die why does god let nations die why does god let the evil sometimes prosper and the good do badly don't ask it's like why does god let the goldfish die that's just the way the world is”

0.56

Every philosophy—religious and atheistic—has some foundational bedrock or stance toward the basic facts of human life; suffering is one of these basic facts, and all humans must at some point ask 'why me?' when facing intense suffering.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job represents a certain kind of what i'll call a stance towards being every philosophy not just religious philosophies but also atheistic philosophies uh general approaches to the world have some sort of foundational bedrock some foundational approach to the the facts of human life and suffering is one of those facts of human life all humans will experience suffering and if the suffering is intense enough they will at some point in time say why me god or if they're not religious believers why me universe but in any case they have to ask why me or why my child or why my parents or why my brother a sister we're all forced to ask that question simply by the nature of the human condition”

0.56

Other biblical texts present gentler and more gracious faces of God: the Song of Solomon shows the gracious face of God, and the New Testament Beatitudes show the generous and kindly face of God rather than the awesome law-giver.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and i would say that that's one of the reasons why other faces of the deity are shown to us in other books of the bible within judaism if you go and read something like the song of solomon you'll see the kind of gentle kind gracious face of god if you look at the new testament and read something like the beatitudes right you'll again see the gracious kindly um generous face of god rather than the awesome almighty law giver”

0.55

Real religious faith is beyond theodicy and beyond theology; theology is a sort of disguised blasphemy that claims to plumb the depths of an infinite ocean with finite cords, which is beyond human capacity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“what i'm suggesting is that job is the most anti-theological book ever written and surprisingly enough it ends up in the bible it says that real religious faith is beyond theodicy is beyond theology it perhaps it turns out that theology is really a sort of disguised blasphemy that we would claim to plumb the depths of an infinite ocean with our finite cords really beyond human capacity”

0.55

The Book of Job is the most anti-theological book ever written: it argues that the attempt to provide rational explanations for God's ways is itself presumptuous and amounts to a form of disguised blasphemy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“we might say that the book of job is the most anti-theological book ever written now anti-theological is not the same thing as atheistic in other words it's one thing to believe in god and another thing to believe that you understand what he's doing with the world”

0.54

The Book of Job is an indispensable tonic to self-pity and whining; without it, understanding of God's will and world would be incomplete; it is one of the great contributions to the wisdom literature of the world.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“and as a consequence of that it seems to me that the book of job is important and could never be left out of biblical literature because it is an indispensable tonic to a certain kind of whining to a certain kind of self-pity and for that reason it is one of the great contributions to the wisdom literature of the world and if in fact it's not the only face of the deity it is one of those faces of the deity without which our understanding of god's will and god's world would be incomplete”

0.52

Job's friends hold their faith by concocting pseudo-rational explanations for God's ways, fitting God into preconceived rational molds, claiming to have discerned deep secrets about divine justice; this allows them to reconcile belief in an all-good God with apparent injustice.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job's friends the theological wannabes the would-be practitioners of theodicy are those who are only able to hold on to their religious faith by concocting some sort of pseudo-rational explanation for the ways of god in other words they fit god into some preconceived mold that is consistent with the canons of human rationality and by doing so they reconcile themselves to the apparently promiscuous giving of rewards and punishments by saying that it's really not promiscuous it's really not arbitrary in fact there's some deep secret about these rewards and punishments which i have discerned and that means essentially that i have finally understood god's purposes in the world”

0.52

Job's stance toward being is one of absolute fidelity to God's word; he will not blaspheme under any circumstances, even the most trying to the human soul, and this represents the marrow or essence of religious faith.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job's stance towards being is one of absolute fidelity to the word of god he is god's faithful servant who will not blaspheme under any circumstances even those which are most trying to the human soul this i would say is in some respects the marrow of religious faith”

0.52

While the Book of Job depicts an indispensable aspect of God (awesome, inscrutable, demanding absolute submission), it is not by itself sufficient; if Job were the only biblical book, God would appear only as an intimidating, frightening, and law-giving figure without offering consolation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“while the book of job or the kind of deity that we see in the book of job is an indispensable aspect of almighty god it is not by itself sufficient in other words if this if all the other books of the bible were left out and we only had this well i mean i guess we would have to worship him since he comes out of the whirlwind and runs everything and all but he would be an intimidating awesome frightening kind of horrifying god because he does things for reasons we don't understand he creates a moral order to the world which really amounts to shut up and take it and it doesn't give us that consolation which is one of the important elements in religion”

0.48

Job's three friends are theological wannabes who claim to be wise enough to understand God's providence and purposes, and believe they can justify God's ways to man, offering various rational explanations for Job's suffering.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“he also has three friends who come and help him during or come and try and commiserate with him during his sufferings and they i would say are theological wannabes job's three friends are those people who claim to be wise enough to understand god's providence be able to comprehend his mysteries and comprehend his purposes particularly job's friends are the sort of people that think they understand the ways of god and believe that they can justify these ways to man”

0.48

Elihu is a mysterious, possibly angelic figure representing real theological wisdom, which understands that there is a limit to human comprehension of God and that submission to God's inscrutable will is the appropriate stance.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“finally there is elihu kind of a mysterious figure perhaps an angelic figure who represents kind of real wisdom with regard to the divinity real theological wisdom which says there's only so much you can understand about god at a certain point you have to say i submit to the will of the almighty i'm not in a position to understand such things and elijah forces job to the point where he is willing to acknowledge the fact that we cannot entirely comprehend god's ways”

0.48

The speaker argues that gratitude is often cynically motivated by expectation of future rewards ('gratitude is the expectation of future rewards'), and Satan applies this principle to Job's religious devotion.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“a very cynical saying once someone once said that gratitude is the expectation of future rewards well okay what satan is essentially saying is that you've given him all this great stuff so naturally he praises you hope he hopes you're going to give him some more good stuff a very cynical interpretation of religious devotion”

0.37

The problem of theodicy—justifying God's ways to man—is illustrated in works like Milton's Paradise Lost, and the Book of Job inquires into whether it is possible to justify God's ways to man and what would count as such a justification.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“just by the very nature of the human condition people have been asking this for centuries if you look back say oh to something like milton's paradise lost the whole point of paradise lost is what we call theodicy the justification of god's ways to man and the book of job inquires into the problem of whether it's possible to justify god's ways to man and what would count as such a justification”

0.33

Satan argues a second time that Job's continued fidelity is because he does not truly value his external possessions, but rather his own physical body; if afflicted personally with pain and sickness, Job will blaspheme.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“satan says look the reason why he is not blaspheming now the reason why satan is not cursing god or why he maintains his religious fidelity is because he really didn't care about his family and wealth isn't all that important what he really cares about is his own hide if i were to go down there and send all kinds of afflictions to him personally physical misery pain wretchedness then he would blaspheme before he expired”

0.33

Job, despite losing his family, house, and flocks, refuses to curse God or blaspheme, maintaining his religious fidelity even in extreme misery, which validates God's claim that Job's faith is not mercenary.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“well up he comes to heaven and they both look down and we see job a miserable man who's found that he's facing all sorts of calamities he's lost his family and he weeps for it he's lost his house he's lost his flocks he's a wretched he used to be a man who was very well off and now he's down in the depths of poverty and misery and he's lost a great many emotional ties but he refuses to curse god he refuses to blaspheme”

0.33

Job's wife is depicted as a religious skeptic who, when faced with Job's suffering, suggests he curse God and die, representing the position of ultimate religious skepticism and a cynical negation of religious devotion under adversity.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“his wife something of a religious skeptic plays a small but important part in the story of job and he also has three friends who come and help him during or come and try and commiserate with him during his sufferings”

0.33

Job is silenced by Elihu's rebuke and forced to seriously reconsider his worldview; he recognizes the force of Elihu's argument that God is God and humans are not, and that disputing with God is futile.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“so elihu who has wisdom far beyond his years and who has many of the qualities apart from being described as an angel sounds an awful lot like one of god's mouthpieces right he has a great religious wisdom here straightens job out about this and after thinking about he says you know you're right i mean there's no back and forth here elijah just comes down and lays the you know the real theological facts on him he says look god is god and we are not”

0.32

The Book of Job was written into the Hebrew Bible roughly a thousand or eight hundred years before the time of Christ, but it harks back to an ancient Near Eastern wisdom tradition that predates the organization of the Hebrew Bible by many centuries.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“the book of job was written into the hebrew bible at the time that the bible was that the hebrew bible was formed roughly a thousand or eight hundred years before the time of christ it took a number of generations to actually codify it and in fact the book of job harks back to an ancient tradition in the near east that goes back from many centuries prior to the organization of the hebrew bible”

0.29

God in the Old Testament is characterized as omniscient, omnipotent, all-good, and governing all of history such that not a sparrow falls without his consent.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“we have god who has the qualities of being the old testament deity he's omniscient he's omnipotent he's all good he's running all of history not a sparrow falls without his consent the usual attributes of the creator”

0.29

Job is described as a righteous man who shows appropriate respect to the deity and, as a consequence of his goodness, has been blessed by God with health, wealth, family, and all good things.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“job is described as a righteous man he is righteous to those around him he shows appropriate respect to the deity he and as a consequence of his goodness and his righteousness he's been blessed by god with health and wealth and family and all the good things that life offers a human being in this world”

0.29

God grants Satan permission to afflict Job by taking away his family, health, wealth, and all his possessions, but stipulates that Satan must not touch Job's body—a test of whether Job's faith depends on external goods.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“god says okay go ahead do whatever bad stuff you want to him but don't touch his body in particular just take away from him the things that i've given him so down goes satan into the world of space and time among us goes to job's family kills the family sends in invaders to kill his flocks kill his sons kill his daughters destroy his house make him wretched and miserable take away the many good things that god has given him”

0.29

God allows Satan to inflict terrible boils and sores on Job from head to toe, covering him with loathsome afflictions, depriving him of all comfort and health while he sits among ashes.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“down comes satan all right regardless of why god sends him in he's calling the plays and down he comes and he covers job with terrible boils and sores from the tip of his toe to the top of his head he's covered with these loathsome sores and remember of course as we're talking about the ancient near east medical science is not very far advanced and even today medical science can't solve all the afflictions that hit the human body and job is just forced to sit there and suffer”

0.25

Job only suffers impersonal evils (natural calamities, disease, loss of possessions and family) rather than personal evils inflicted by other humans; however, the narrative structure suggests Job would accept human-inflicted suffering with the same faithful submission.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition - The Book … [2ZH9X_1X9eA]

“first of all we should consider the fact that job only suffers throughout this impersonal evil he never suffers the evil at the hands of people who are close to him which is a different kind of suffering but i assume that the the nature of the story of job he would accept that that kind of chastisement in the same kind of uh faithful way that he accepted the others”